Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SenexDelerius · 18/01/2023 16:44

Higher earners will have paid more in National Insurance, so why would you pay them a smaller benefit?

A flat rate pension already favours the poor because they receive the same amount for a lower cost. Seems like a fair deal to me.

FanGirlX · 29/01/2022 09:37

@Oldsu

Morningstarling appears to be of the "everyone else should pay to fund my lifestyle choices" ilk.

FanGirlX · 29/01/2022 09:34

Give it to everyone then tax income which includes pension

This is how it works now. Pensioners pay tax on all income above the threshold (about 12.5k), just like workers do.

CayrolBaaaskin · 25/01/2022 17:05

@Blossomtoes - alan sugar doesn’t immediately “hand back his state pension in tax”. The highest rate of tax is 45% so at the least he keeps 55%. Abs like other pensioners he pays no NI thus saving himself a fortune on his colossal income.

This is not about Alan Sugar though but a general point that no reason elderly should have a hugely favourable tax regime and universal benefits. They tend to be the wealthiest group in society both in respect of assets and household income.

State pension is hugely expensive and no reason it should go to those who don’t need it

Lockdownbear · 25/01/2022 13:31

@Grantanow I agree means testing can be very crude. I recall my Grandparents missing out on Income Support in their old age by 50p per week.
Which in turn cut them off from other help like prescription changes, glasses. Means testing can be very unfair to those just over the threshold.

Pension should remain universal.

Blossomtoes · 25/01/2022 12:36

@user1497787065

I'm reading the post that those, for example, Alan Sugar, who would automatically receive state pension and don't need it will not receive it.

It does seem absurd that he receives state pension and a winter fuel payment.

Which he immediately hands back in tax. Do you think the state pension is tax exempt? If only.
Grantanow · 25/01/2022 12:34

No. It must remain universal. Means testing may be appropriate to some benefits but it would be the thin end of the wedge: how about means testing at A&E? My parents were always bitterly against means testing having experienced life before the welfare state. And it is true that the UK old age pension is much worse than in France and other EU countries.

Lockdownbear · 25/01/2022 12:09

It might have less money but it will still have a choice in how it spends it. It might come down to a choice of UC vs Pension but the pot won't be empty.

There is an argument that with limited employment you are better to Pension old people off than to have younger people with children claiming benefits.

It will come down to choice. But the pot won't be empty.

user1497207191 · 25/01/2022 11:57

@Lockdownbear

How can the governments money run out. Two certainties in life Taxes and Death.

The Government will always collect tax and in turn decide how to spend it. That includes spending on defense, infrastructure, pensions, schools, welfare benefits and the NHS.

Whilst Govt money doesn't "run out" as such, the country's "wealth" depends on interest rates, balance of payments, exchange rates, etc., If the Govt "print" too much money, then it affects other things, like exchange rates and interest rates, which detrimentally affects us, i.e. makes imports more expensive so drives up inflation and reduces buying power, makes exports cheaper so reduces UK manufacturing profits (less tax revenue, more unemployment). If foreign investors (who've lent money to the UK increase interest rates, or refuse to lend, then the UK has less money to spend on public services, investment, etc. Higher interest rates also impact firms' ability to grow and invest. It's all a huge balancing act, and no where near as simple as "just print more money" due to the consequences.
Lockdownbear · 25/01/2022 11:51

How can the governments money run out. Two certainties in life Taxes and Death.

The Government will always collect tax and in turn decide how to spend it. That includes spending on defense, infrastructure, pensions, schools, welfare benefits and the NHS.

DGRossetti · 25/01/2022 09:52

Does it really matter if the money runs out, or government decides to stop handing it out? Same outcome.

Only if you rely on government money. Well your government money. A lot of countries (that admittedly I wouldn't like to live in) get by using someone elses money - US dollars usually. As do entire industries like drugs, trafficking, slavery, most of the oil industry.

Beyond that, of course, are cryptocurrencies. Not for me at the moment, but some are managing OK.

Even precious metals are of limited value in some respects. No matter how much gold you may have you can't eat it.

echt · 25/01/2022 08:35

@DGRossetti

For everyone getting offended, going on about how they have "paid in", what will we do when the money runs out?

Money can never "run out". It's a made up concept. Just print as much as you like.

Part of the problem with .... well everything today is the obsession with using money as a proxy for worth. It's why essential roles like carers are paid shit, while "high powered" roles are paid in multiples of tens if not hundreds of those roles.

And if the government doesn't want to print more money it can just revalue it while it's in your pocket. Which has happened.

See my post above.
roseky · 25/01/2022 08:34

@DGRossetti

For everyone getting offended, going on about how they have "paid in", what will we do when the money runs out?

Money can never "run out". It's a made up concept. Just print as much as you like.

Part of the problem with .... well everything today is the obsession with using money as a proxy for worth. It's why essential roles like carers are paid shit, while "high powered" roles are paid in multiples of tens if not hundreds of those roles.

And if the government doesn't want to print more money it can just revalue it while it's in your pocket. Which has happened.

Does it really matter if the money runs out, or government decides to stop handing it out? Same outcome. Unless we change something. For the record, I think its important to protect the state pension. I just dont see how its possible. Erosion of pensions, rising house prices, declining fertility, climate crisis. All a symptom of the same problem. Profit over people. But that doesnt change the fact that current status quo is unsustainable
ClumsyClaret · 25/01/2022 08:30

Give it to everyone then tax income which includes pension - scrap the NI - just call it income tax. So rich or poor? Working or not working - you receive tax on your income.

DGRossetti · 25/01/2022 08:25

For everyone getting offended, going on about how they have "paid in", what will we do when the money runs out?

Money can never "run out". It's a made up concept. Just print as much as you like.

Part of the problem with .... well everything today is the obsession with using money as a proxy for worth. It's why essential roles like carers are paid shit, while "high powered" roles are paid in multiples of tens if not hundreds of those roles.

And if the government doesn't want to print more money it can just revalue it while it's in your pocket. Which has happened.

echt · 25/01/2022 08:13

@roseky

For everyone getting offended, going on about how they have "paid in", what will we do when the money runs out? Because it will. Probably within your lifetimes. I'm working on the assumption that when I retire, I wont get a state pension. My parents are retiring soon, I think its ambitious to assume there will be a state pension for their entire retirement. NI isn't a saving account. That's not how it works. What you paid in, is long spent. Current retirees are funded by current workers. With an aging population, and rising cost of living it will be impossible to sustain.
They won't run out. Get past the Australian context, it's the same in the UK. And if that doesn't wash for you, consider how this government has just written off a £4.3b covid business loan fraud.

Clue: it's because they want to.

Enjoy:

roseky · 25/01/2022 08:06

For everyone getting offended, going on about how they have "paid in", what will we do when the money runs out? Because it will. Probably within your lifetimes. I'm working on the assumption that when I retire, I wont get a state pension. My parents are retiring soon, I think its ambitious to assume there will be a state pension for their entire retirement.
NI isn't a saving account. That's not how it works. What you paid in, is long spent. Current retirees are funded by current workers. With an aging population, and rising cost of living it will be impossible to sustain.

Lockdownbear · 25/01/2022 08:00

To the poster who wants to cap pensions. You do understand that when someone decides to start drawing down on their pension they have options like taking a lump sum, out too so by your suggestion they are as well to take the maximum lump sum and leave themselves with the minimum pension.
Intact it's not even worth saving for a pension if your not going to be any better of than the people who don't.

Think things through before making stupid suggestions.

Lockdownbear · 25/01/2022 07:54

@user1497787065

I'm reading the post that those, for example, Alan Sugar, who would automatically receive state pension and don't need it will not receive it.

It does seem absurd that he receives state pension and a winter fuel payment.

It might seem absurd but for the relatively few Alan Sugars it's not worth the cost of means testing everyone. But remember he'll be paying a hefty income tax on it so a huge chunk will be going straight back to HMRC. Think how much employment the Alan Sugars create for other people. Do you want them to disappear of to other countries?
user1497787065 · 25/01/2022 07:19

I'm reading the post that those, for example, Alan Sugar, who would automatically receive state pension and don't need it will not receive
it.

It does seem absurd that he receives state pension and a winter fuel payment.

AlDanvers · 25/01/2022 05:21

My preference would be to put a cap on private pensions and use that to fund a better state pension

Would you also put a cap on anyone saving money?

How on earth can you stop someone financial planning for their future?

How is it offensive for a pensioner who has saved and planned for retirement.....to have access to it? How do they become 'not entitled' to their own money once they hit a certain age?

Are you stopping investments as well? And sort of financial planning? For everyone?

Or do you just have a problem with the over 65s?

And then if you did this, who would pay into a private pension? Why would I put loads of money into my pension, as an example, if it was going to benefit me?

echt · 25/01/2022 04:11

My preference would be to put a cap on private pensions and use that to fund a better state pension

How would you do that?

Oldsu · 25/01/2022 02:30

meant to say putting my state pension into my savings account

Oldsu · 25/01/2022 02:29

@MorningStarling

My preference would be to put a cap on private pensions and use that to fund a better state pension. No pensioner should be raking in more than 20k per year. Any annuity or drawdown from a private pension above this should be confiscated.

Alternatively/also you could have a rule whereby state pensions are only provided to top up whatever someone has earned in a private pension. So if someone retires with a private pension which can buy an annuity of £100 per week, this gets topped up by the state to state pension levels. Again, it would be a good idea to have a maximum private pension level, it's offensive that a pensioner could have an income higher than the average working person after tax.

OFFENSIVE !!!!!!!!!! how DARE you say that - and to confiscate something that someone has paid in for maybe going without when they were working is a nasty mean thing to say, I am still working but when I stop my state and private pensions will be lower than 20k which is why I am putting my state pension (less the 200 a month I pay in extra tax on my wages that's £200 a month more than the tax and NI I paid when I was working age BTW in case you start whining that I don't pay NI anymore) so I have savings to top me up, want to take that away from me as well as its OFFENSIVE do you? seriously???? I really have no words that expresses my total and utter contempt for your views.
ancientgran · 24/01/2022 19:14

@DGRossetti

The English haven't had a revolution. The civil war was just a lot of posh boys arguing over who gets to stay up after lights out. Unfortunately it dragged in the rest of Britain (sorry about that).
I think Charles I found them revolting.
Swipe left for the next trending thread