Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want DH to take 6months paternity leave

241 replies

Beeswax2022 · 22/01/2022 15:43

AIBU to not want DH at home with me for SIX consecutive months?
He has the option to spread it over a year so could do 2months at home, 2months at work etc which is a much better option IMO. Baby will benefit from some quality time with him when he/she is a little bit older and probably partly bottle fed by then etc.
Surely I can’t be the only person who would hate their DH to be home for a full 6months, especially after giving birth!?
Of course, I want him to have a good amount of time at the beginning to bond with our newborn but not a whole 6months in one go.
I probably sound selfish but he’s not an easy, chilled person to be around. He is in your face, loud, needy and constantly needs tv/iPad on. Baby and I will need peace and quiet a lot of the time Smile

I can handle all this for the evenings and weekends but not for that many months and for 24/7 (he doesn’t go out much)
This will be our 4th baby and he has never been in the position to take more than 2 weeks paternity for the others…. Maybe I just need to accept his choice and how he wants to take his paternity leave…

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/01/2022 17:44

I wasn’t saying you were necessarily wrong that he shouldn’t have all the leave straight away. I was just saying he sounded absolutely awful from your description and not someone you’d want to be married to.

It’s a joint decision, and you need to work out together what’s best for the family. He obviously should be using it to be the most use he can, not just to have a long break. If he can’t do much with the baby in the first few months, it could be better taking ot later. But will he be taking nearly sole charge of the older children, for example?

RaginaPhalange · 22/01/2022 17:43

Wow. If you don't like spending time with your dh then why marry him, have kids with him etc?
My dh is a very loud person and he has a fair bit of time off work and if he did have to work he worked from home. Me and ds loved having him around and he loved being able to bond with baby and spend some time together as a family. If he wants to take it in one go there's nothing you can do about that surely, it's his choice what he does with it.

JigglyPiggly · 22/01/2022 17:38

@Maryann1975

Doesn't he ever leave the house other than to go to work? No hobbies, friends or family to see, errands to run? This is really not the idea of paternity leave. It isn’t an extended, paid for holiday. It’s to benefit the parent/child relationship and to help the mother/family unit when the family have another child. i can’t believe you think this is an appropriate use of paternity leave. If a friend told me her partner was spending his paternity leave doing these things I’d be quite concerned about how unsupportive he was being.
So women don't go out and see friends whilst on maternity leave? Hmm
Mumof3girlygirls · 22/01/2022 17:37

Not an easy person to be around 🤣🤣🤣 sounds like a sperm donor to me!!

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2022 17:31

I guess it depends on the man.

Him wanting two months off before the baby (why would his work permit that??) seems quite questionable unless it was to get something significant done in the house, lift the burden of child and house care from his partner.

Three months at the start then three months at end sounds reasonable, but might be a pita for work. Certainly two months on and off work would be a nightmare logistically.

But it does just sound like you don't overly like spending time with him - needy, loud, needs constant noise when you just want to sit silently etc.

The only good thing about the pandemic was DH working from when I had 3 month old twins for 14 months

Maryann1975 · 22/01/2022 17:29

Doesn't he ever leave the house other than to go to work? No hobbies, friends or family to see, errands to run?
This is really not the idea of paternity leave. It isn’t an extended, paid for holiday. It’s to benefit the parent/child relationship and to help the mother/family unit when the family have another child. i can’t believe you think this is an appropriate use of paternity leave. If a friend told me her partner was spending his paternity leave doing these things I’d be quite concerned about how unsupportive he was being.

Twitterwhooooo · 22/01/2022 17:27

Just noticed that he wants to start his paternity leave two months before the baby is due.

It sounds like he might not quite be planning to take over management of the household and looking after of the other children while you rest.

Sounds like that's the problem, regardless of when he takes his paternity leave.

Twitterwhooooo · 22/01/2022 17:25

I'm going against the grain I think, by saying that in a family with soon-to-be four children, when to take paternity leave needs to be worked out so that all of the family benefit as much as possible from it.

It would probably be lovely for your other children to have him doing the bulk of the school runs, taking to activities, cooking, cleaning and laundry etc while you get breast feeding established, fit baby into family routine etc for the first couple of months.

Ditto school holidays.

But that would rely on the person being on paternity leave using it to increase his paternal input into the home and children, which isn't quite what you're envisioning by the sounds of it...

Dullrugby · 22/01/2022 17:19

Don't you need the money? I thought having the extra leave was in part a policy to get women back to the workforce so you don't need to take the full year. So he should take a bit right at the start and then 5 months or whatever where he is the SAHP.

Maryann1975 · 22/01/2022 17:19

I’d have hated having dh at home for 6 months of my maternity leave! He worked shifts and did a sleeping night shift so was about a lot but we didn’t need him at home all the time. Surely it would be better for him to take time off after your maternity leave so you can have a SAHP for longer, but then he won’t have the same amount of time for hobbies and doing what ever he wants to do.
As for this comment Because his life is about to change massively and it might be nice to spend time with his wife, enjoying being at home without a screeching baby? OK for you to do that and not him though. Got it
Have you forgotten that it is the mother that is growing a baby inside of her (and her forth baby - ime pregnancy got harder with each baby). If the Mother feels like she needs to have her maternity leave before the baby comes along, so she can rest I would fully support that, but want on Earth is the father going to do for 2 months off while waiting for the baby to arrive. He doesn’t need extra rest because his body Is supporting a new life. Life doesn’t really change a massive amount once you get on to subsequent children, yes there is an extra child to think of but it is in way comparable to having your first child and the way life changes then.

Croissantly · 22/01/2022 17:14

A few months on and a few months off is really disruptive at work, people I know who have done it have hated it and wished they'd done it in one. Odd that he's starting it 2 months before your due date though, usually paternity is firmly on and after that date.

Chailatteplease · 22/01/2022 17:13

@JigglyPiggly

YABU

If he isn't an easy person to be around you shouldn't have tethered yourself to him for 18+ years

You put it much more succinctly than I did. But yes, this!
FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 22/01/2022 17:12

I divorced him instead (he was abusive, though that was not clear at the baby stage).

I couldn't have coped with having anyone hanging around while I was at home with the DC. More practically, though, if the OP is going back to work, it makes far more sense for her DH to take extended paternity leave at that point, so the baby doesn't need to be looked after by anyone else until absolutely necessary.

theleafandnotthetree · 22/01/2022 17:12

OP, the thought of my ex husband being at home for 6 months makes me feel like I can't breathe so I sympathise! I guess the difference is that I only had two children with him and left him. It does sound from your updates like it is more about him getting 6 months off than making the most judicious use of the leave from everyone elses point of view. You are very very lucky to have this time, I would stringly urge him to make the best use of it

Chailatteplease · 22/01/2022 17:12

Whenever I read posts like this, I always feel like the couples just aren’t a good match.
It was the same in lockdown, people getting frustrated with each other.
I’m an introvert and the only person I can stand to be around for long periods of time is my DH.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 22/01/2022 17:10

@FOTTFSOFTFOASM

OP, I would have killed my husband after six consecutive days, never mind six consecutive months. It's all very well, even if his company is fine - but having him there will spoil all your existing routines and ways of doing things. He will be an extra and unwelcome body in the house, and the mere presence of another adult all the time is oppressive. Though I know others think differently.
The baby's other parent is an extra and unwelcome body in the house?

Wtf? Why didn't you just go to a sperm bank if that's how you feel about the man you chose to father your kids?

AnyBenny · 22/01/2022 17:08

Does his work not have any rules about paternity leave? Why should a father be allowed to take paternity leave 2 months before the birth? He’s not carrying the baby so the paternity element is necessarily limited. Also they may have rules about taking it in several chunks - it’s a while since my maternity leave days but from memory once you were back, you were back.
I agree with all those saying that he should be looking for his 6 months to happen from 6m to a year, or even later if his work allows.

realchaplin · 22/01/2022 16:58

DH will be taking 6 months paternity (on full pay). I'm definitely looking forward to it, we had a shorter paternity leave of 3 months with older DD and it was lovely spending our days just bonding, taking her out to parent and baby films, galleries and wandering around town. It was the longest time we'd ever spent continously in each other's company (because normally we'd have been at work, except for holidays of up to 2 weeks) and it was nice doing things together on quieter weekdays and not just having to do everything on weekends when everything is more crowded.

I needed a c-section as well (and will with this birth) so he'll be invaluable in the first few weeks. Life will be a bit busier this time with an older child, but she's at nursery and will start school when baby is 5 months, so we'll still get lots of couple+baby time together. We might take a short break in the middle so he can spend a bit longer helping out once DD starts school, as the school is a short commute away. We're also planning to move house within the next year, so it will be really useful having him around for dealing with that.

LeifSan · 22/01/2022 16:57

Wanting to take two months before the baby is even born is a pisstake, unless you are having a very difficult pregnancy and he plans to use that time to take care of the three kids and house while you rest.

Wanting to take 6 months in one go seems to make more sense to me as it provides focused time for your family and also it’s a lot easier to have six months off work and then return than it is to do two months on and two months off. However, it doesn’t sound like he’s really wanting this to be an engaged family man and more like he wants six months off work. I’d be less than impressed if my partner wanted to take two months off before the baby was even there.

teezletangler · 22/01/2022 16:55

I don't know why the OP is getting such a hard time. This isn't the most sensible plan. I also wouldn't want to be home with someone else (anyone else!) day in, day out for 6 months straight. I'm introverted and like my own time and routine.

The suggestion to just give the baby formula so the dad can give some feeds is ridiculous and unnecessary, when the OP clearly intends to BF.

ladycarlotta · 22/01/2022 16:55

My partner took almost all the parental leave because I was self employed and it made more sense. He was home for a YEAR. I loved it - it was wonderful for us as a family and for his relationship with our child. It established her as our joint responsibility rather than cementing me as the default primary carer. There are plenty of things he can do besides breastfeed. I think it makes for a really good long-term dynamic for him to be off while the baby's tiny.

girlmom21 · 22/01/2022 16:52

@BrambleRoses

Oh God, YANBU! I had a WFH husband for my maternity leave and that was bad enough!
Oh I'm loving having DP work from home!
FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 22/01/2022 16:52

OP, I would have killed my husband after six consecutive days, never mind six consecutive months. It's all very well, even if his company is fine - but having him there will spoil all your existing routines and ways of doing things. He will be an extra and unwelcome body in the house, and the mere presence of another adult all the time is oppressive. Though I know others think differently.

Krakenchorus · 22/01/2022 16:50

@HardbackWriter

I actually agree with OP that I don't think it's the best way to take the leave. With my first baby DH had 8 weeks off when he arrived and then four months off at home when I went back to work (and baby was 6 months). Those first 8 weeks were nice but, contrary to my expectations, we couldn't split things 50-50 with an EBF baby and it didn't feel like it make that much difference overall. Those final four months when he was home alone with the baby, on the other hand, were absolutely transformative and I think it's why we still, three years on, have the most genuine equal parenting of any couple I know. I'm not sure about him going back and forth in the way OP suggests but I don't think it's at all unreasonable to want him to take some of it alone at the end of the baby's first year rather than taking it in one block at the beginning. It would also make much more financial sense for most couples to do it that way.
^^ This. We did similar with all of ours, and dh has a knowledge and confidence with the dc that comes from being solely responsible for them as babies. It also made going back to work much easier for me.
curlydiamond · 22/01/2022 16:48

I'm with you OP, 6 months parental leave for DH would be better spent when baby is 6 months (am assuming you go back to work then?). DH can have the main responsibility for weaning and can enjoy the baby groups that are more interesting once baby can sit, crawl, walk etc (actually - I'd probably be a little resentful that he gets to enjoy the fun bit after 6 months of hard work feeding and hoping baby starts to sleep). It also makes sense from a financial perspective.
As for him wanting to start 2 months before o
your baby's arrival? He's having a laugh. It's baby 4, you don't need weeks to 'prepare yourselves' - if you're starting mat leave early because pregnancy is hard you're hardly going to be in a position to 'enjoy eachother' before the baby is born either.
It's indulgent; he wants time off work (which I dont blame him for) that is of no particular use to anyone but himself before the baby even arrives- I would be annoyed as the baby wouldn't get any benefit from those two months at all.

DH is hoping for an extended holiday - we'd all like that, but in terms of family life it is pretty selfish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread