Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 22/01/2022 21:34

YANBU, this doesn't sit well with me, FWIW I'm double backed, but your body your choice. Bodily Autonomy matters.

Buzzinwithbez · 22/01/2022 21:30

So I learned about informed consent and body autonomy when I had my babies. I experienced the difference between midwives that understand consent and those that either think they do or simply don't care... And of doctors that definitely had a funny idea of consent.

I worry that medics who will not support their colleagues are unlikely to be able to obtain consent from their patients either.

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 22/01/2022 21:24

YANBU either you support bodily autonomy or you believe people should be forced into something (vaccine/pregnancy) for the benefit of others (that old man down the street/ your unborn child).

user1745 · 22/01/2022 21:21

@TeenPlusCat

Depends what you mean by 'mandatory'. If literally the police are locking people up for not being vaccinated, regardless of other behaviour, then YANBU. If you mean people in a pandemic are more restricted if they choose not to have a vaccine that is proven to reduce transmission and severity, then YABU. Ditto if people want to work with vulnerable people.
What if abortion is not illegal, but we were to heavily discourage by means of restrictions and deterrents for women who choose it? Do you think a person could support that and still be pro-choice?

For example, requiring women to pay for abortions, and for treatment for any complications afterwards, while pregnancy care and births are still free. Would that be fair? I would argue that when you disincentivise a choice in that way, for many people it becomes not really a choice (i.e a woman on the poverty line will opt against abortion because she cannot afford it), and thus it's not consistent to call yourself pro-choice and yet support it. This is obvious to anyone when it comes to the abortion debate but apparently not when it comes to the vaccination debate. This example is roughly similar to what many are advocating with regard to making the unvaccinated pay for any Covid medical treatment they need.

There is a point at which restrictions and disincentives edge into the territory of coercion, and society has generally agreed that medical coercion is unethical.

The vaccine also is not proven to reduce transmission, certainly not any more than alternatives such as regular testing would.

StanleyGreen · 22/01/2022 21:19

@gettingmylifetogether

No. YABU. I'm pro-choice when it comes to pregnancy, because whether or not to have a baby has a massive physical and mental impact on the woman. I will go to my grave defending female freedoms to decide whether or not they want to give birth or not.

Covid vaccines aren't just about you. They're about the people you come into contact with.

Deciding not to have a Covid vaccine is only acceptable if your medical history suggests it's a bad idea and/or you intend to live in a cave. If you want to participate in society and your doctor sees no reason why you can't have the vaccine, yes, you're being selfish.

Firstly I'll begin with saying I'm pro choice for both abortion and Vaccines. But you are saying it's more important to protect other people by having a vaccine than it is to end an unborn childs life. Because no matter how you want to dress it up, you're ending a life having an abortion.
Broblem · 22/01/2022 21:13

OP, are you going to support my right to smoke in public buildings? If not, why not?

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 21:13

Body autonomy is about having a personal choice about what someone wants to do with their own body.

So what do the nurses do when they have an unconscious patient in front of them? Do they respect their body autonomy?

JigglyPiggly · 22/01/2022 21:03

@secular39

You've demonstrated most of those comments in your posts on this thread

You clearly are uneducated based on some of the arguments you are trying (and failing) to make

You have a fundamental lack of understanding of how vaccines work, how many healthcare workers have to have others to work as well and the very fact you're trying to compare a vaccine to an abortion is woo in it's finest

YeOldeTrout · 22/01/2022 21:01

My husband is a doctor, he has hepatitis jabs each year

I'm just so surprised when I read that I thought the Hep jabs were just a few doses in life, not annual. Also thought the Hep Jabs were to protect the health care workers from germs in patient bodily fluids who knew that so many health care workers were exposing their bodily fluids to colleagues & patients?

secular39 · 22/01/2022 21:01

@Justenuff

YANBU. Mumsnet is generally very pro-choice, advocating bodily autonomy so I've been absolutely aghast at the endless "Get vaxxed or go to hell" threads. Thread after thread after thread for months.
Exactly- and the venom is not only towards NHS workers. Mumsnet throws venom towards normal folks, who have normal jobs, who have decided to not get the vaccine. Calling them anti-vaxers, uneducated, stupid, woo, odd and selfish.
OP posts:
secular39 · 22/01/2022 20:59

@Theunamedcat

So, we should have the right to abortion

The right not to be forced into being vaccinated

What about the right to die? Its something many people want they can do it in other countries why can't we do that here?

What about the right to kill someone? A murderer obviously not just anyone on the streets but why not?

Why not mix every single right that people want in a big ball under PRO-CHOICE just to prove a point that no one is even sure of

Has anyone asked WHY? why don't they want the vaccine none of that "untested bollocks" because they modified one they were already working on its not like they started from scratch they literally turned a Victoria sponge into chocolate cake yes its a bit rough around the edges not as refined as we would normally get but still a working vaccine it the timeline is fantastic work why do all these people who work for the NHS not want to take it

Not everyone agree will with your choices though. Taking ones life is completely different and you know this.

Body autonomy is about having a personal choice about what someone wants to do with their own body. Killing someone is an infliction towards someone else to cause harm- same as if a man abuses a woman. Linking body autonomy akin to murderers is stupid and completely dangerous.

OP posts:
Justenuff · 22/01/2022 20:50

YANBU. Mumsnet is generally very pro-choice, advocating bodily autonomy so I've been absolutely aghast at the endless "Get vaxxed or go to hell" threads. Thread after thread after thread for months.

Crunchymum · 22/01/2022 20:34

I have always been ardently pro choice, my stance doesn't waver with regards to the Covid vaccine.

It's a very interesting way to look at it actually.

I've got to be honest though in my circle of family and friends, no-one is pro mandatory vaccination (most, who can be, are vaccinated)

StrongSunglasses · 22/01/2022 20:30

Yanbu

CoastalWave · 22/01/2022 20:29

I agree with you OP. And I've said it before.

You can't go around supporting women for aborting babies (basically killing another human life) because it's 'their body and their choice' and then in the next breath forcibly inject people with a concoction of drugs into their body.

Problem is though, women want it all!

Theunamedcat · 22/01/2022 20:21

So, we should have the right to abortion

The right not to be forced into being vaccinated

What about the right to die? Its something many people want they can do it in other countries why can't we do that here?

What about the right to kill someone? A murderer obviously not just anyone on the streets but why not?

Why not mix every single right that people want in a big ball under PRO-CHOICE just to prove a point that no one is even sure of

Has anyone asked WHY? why don't they want the vaccine none of that "untested bollocks" because they modified one they were already working on its not like they started from scratch they literally turned a Victoria sponge into chocolate cake yes its a bit rough around the edges not as refined as we would normally get but still a working vaccine it the timeline is fantastic work why do all these people who work for the NHS not want to take it

SoftSheen · 22/01/2022 20:17

The two issues are entirely separate.

Theunamedcat · 22/01/2022 20:14

@Broblem

“You’re pro choice? A-ha! Then you must support my right to smoke cigarettes in pubs and restaurants. My body my choice!”

This thread is dumb.

True
ladygindiva · 22/01/2022 20:05

Yes, I agree with you op. I'm pro choice and the concept of mandatory vaccinations makes me very uncomfortable.

bozzabollix · 22/01/2022 19:59

I don’t get the hysteria about this vaccine. My husband is a doctor, he has hepatitis jabs each year which are mandatory too, because obviously it’s not fair to pass on a condition like that to patients. Are you ok with doctors passing on hepatitis? You must be, being ‘pro choice’? Have we anything to say about the choice of patients whilst putting their trust in medics, that the medics should have a duty of care in protecting their patients choice to stay well?

There’s no difference between this and the other mandatory vaccinations necessary for medics.

Incidentally my husband isn’t supportive of the mandatory vaccinations but this is to do with not losing staff at a time when the NHS most needs them. It’s nothing to do with the safety of the vaccine or the need to have it.

As someone who has treated many Covid patients some of whom have died he’s got very limited understanding of why someone wants to have the freedom to get critically ill.

Njbrookes · 22/01/2022 19:44

In regards to the covid vaccine I can see both pros and cons to it being mandatory.
I myself chose to have my vaccines before there was talk about them becoming mandatory for nhs workers.

I am pro choice and hate to see people being forced to have a vaccine or lose their job because of their choice, for context I’m a second year student paramedic and have seen multiple people on my course being forced to either have the vaccine or leave the course if they don’t.

They have all had valid reasons to why they don’t want it mostly due to the lack of evidence of the long term affects including potential infertility.

But I also see why it is being made mandatory as we are closely working with a lot of vulnerable and very unwell patients who could become extremely I’ll or die from catching covid from someone who is there to help and make them better.

Broblem · 22/01/2022 19:42

“You’re pro choice? A-ha! Then you must support my right to smoke cigarettes in pubs and restaurants. My body my choice!”

This thread is dumb.

PAFMO · 22/01/2022 19:41

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

There are exemptions for those with a medical reason.

Yes, I understand that but what if you wanted to travel, would you still be exempt? Would they allow you to travel if you had medical reason for not being vaccinated?

Yes.
KeepingAnOpenMind · 22/01/2022 19:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TooOldForButterflies · 22/01/2022 19:05

I totally agree and have thought this from the start.

Swipe left for the next trending thread