Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 22/01/2022 23:57

YANBU

RoomOfRequirement · 22/01/2022 23:55

Such an offensive thread. You have no idea.

No one is forcing you to get the vaccine. You have the option of choosing another job. Your employer has the right to make requirements for your job and you have the right to refuse them and work for a different employer. Vaccines have been required for NHS worked for years.

Comparing that to women actually being forced into pregnancy, vaginal examinations, painful labors and possible death is not even remotely the same thing.

SpeedRunParent · 22/01/2022 23:53

I think you that by conflating the two issues you damage the credibility of what clearly is a far bigger issue than this fleeting pandemic. I am not for vaccine mandates either but I don't agree that we should be bringing the two matters together.

Sometimeswinning · 22/01/2022 23:43

Well you can say no and find another job. Sorry but women being downtrodden and forced into backstreet abortions are being compared to people who choose not to have a vaccine which helps protect the vulnerable? I'm anti forced pregnancy if that makes it more clear.

It's your choice whether you have the vaccine but I'm free to think your selfish.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 23:21

@Seraphina1993

YANBU

This 'otherising' of people in society is just plain wrong. We've seen it before with brexit, one group think they're virtuous and good and look down their nose at the 'others' who don't make the same choice as them.

Im vaxxed but believe that we should be treating people with dignity to make the choice to have any medical procedure performed on them.

Just really hate the extreme and nasty attitudes I'm seeing from people it's something we've seen in history time and time again.

It's like the whole 'be kind' movement. People only seem to be kind to people as long as you think the way they think and when you disagree on a topic you're branded as scum.

I agree but it is both sides doing this. Name calling and threats from both sides.
Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 23:16

You do have a say, you can say no as can everyone else.

secular39 · 22/01/2022 23:14

I'm sure if there was a mandate that every adult (children? Why not) is required to have the Covid vaccine, there would be an uproar.
Being blackmailed to have a vaccine or lose my job makes me feel sick and anxious. I have no say, as an individual, what medication I can/cannot put into my body. If I give a patient medication without consent, I will be preferred. No matter what argument. This is wrong pure and simple.

OP posts:
Seraphina1993 · 22/01/2022 23:10

YANBU

This 'otherising' of people in society is just plain wrong. We've seen it before with brexit, one group think they're virtuous and good and look down their nose at the 'others' who don't make the same choice as them.

Im vaxxed but believe that we should be treating people with dignity to make the choice to have any medical procedure performed on them.

Just really hate the extreme and nasty attitudes I'm seeing from people it's something we've seen in history time and time again.

It's like the whole 'be kind' movement. People only seem to be kind to people as long as you think the way they think and when you disagree on a topic you're branded as scum.

secular39 · 22/01/2022 23:09

@Thinkbiglittleone

I am pro choice.

Mandating vaccines for job roles does not effect body autonomy, it is a consequence to a choice. Nobody is making them have vaccines, just if they want to be in a role that is dealing with vulnerable people.

It's blackmail, pure and simple.

No vaccine, no job (really? The NS workers, particularly the ones who have been working in the sector for 10 years plus, who 22 months ago, were working face to face with Covid patients, putting their lives at risk during the face of a pandemic, and now the government says that by the 1st April, NHS workers have not had the vaccine lose their jobs.

Despite strong family history of blood clots and undergoing tests for a blood clotting disorder, my GP would not give me a medical exemption certificate and no way would I get my test results before February 1st- it's ludicrous.

OP posts:
Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 23:08

@Theluggage15

YANBU. Bodily autonomy is bodily autonomy. You don’t pick and choose. The transmission effects of this vaccine last only a few weeks with omicron so waste of time anyway unless they’re suggesting vaccinating staff every few weeks!

Looks like they’re going to push this ridiculous policy into the long grass anyway.

But they have autonomy - they have a choice, no one is being forced to have a vaccine.
Theluggage15 · 22/01/2022 22:55

YANBU. Bodily autonomy is bodily autonomy. You don’t pick and choose. The transmission effects of this vaccine last only a few weeks with omicron so waste of time anyway unless they’re suggesting vaccinating staff every few weeks!

Looks like they’re going to push this ridiculous policy into the long grass anyway.

niccyb · 22/01/2022 22:44

@gettingmylifetogether. The vaccine doesn’t stop you getting the virus or does it stop you passing it on.

Against the Covid-19 virus there was 80% effectiveness against infecting someone else but in the trials for the effectiveness against the DELtA and on ice on virus there was actually very little protection.
Not to mention, you do realise that it is only NHS front line employed staff and carers who have been ordered to have the vaccine? GP’s and dentists are not employed by the NHS and therefore it will remain their choice whether they have it.
Also when the NHS nurse leave the NHS and decides to work for a private company because they don’t want the vaccine. The NHS will look to that nurse and private company to work in her old role for more pay and without needing the vaccine because there will be a shortage of staff!

Shadedog · 22/01/2022 22:05

Ludicrous comparison. Believing women should have access to safe and legal abortion isn’t the same thing as thinking people with high risk of transmitting a virus should have unfettered access to elderly/sick/vulnerable people receiving care. Nor do they have a human right to compete in the Australian Open or go to an event where a vaccine passport is required. There was none of this “you must want to force women to give birth against their will if you think HCPs shouldn’t perform EPPs when infected with a BBV” nonsense when health clearance for HIV/hep/TB was brought in.

Thinkbiglittleone · 22/01/2022 22:05

I am pro choice.

Mandating vaccines for job roles does not effect body autonomy, it is a consequence to a choice. Nobody is making them have vaccines, just if they want to be in a role that is dealing with vulnerable people.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 22:05

@FriedTomatoe

I'm fed up of how awful people are being about this. I'm having issues at the lack of information about the vaccine with regards to adolescents and fertility in later life. I'm past reproductive age - having the vaccine has no downside for me. However, if I was 17 years old I might feel differently about it. Although there are loads of scientists saying how safe it is - how can anyone say with any degree of confidence that there aren't long term effects? In this regard, maybe there is a case for pro-choice.
Just look at the birth rate. Has it fallen drastically since vaccines were introduced?
JigglyPiggly · 22/01/2022 22:04

@FriedTomatoe

I'm fed up of how awful people are being about this. I'm having issues at the lack of information about the vaccine with regards to adolescents and fertility in later life. I'm past reproductive age - having the vaccine has no downside for me. However, if I was 17 years old I might feel differently about it. Although there are loads of scientists saying how safe it is - how can anyone say with any degree of confidence that there aren't long term effects? In this regard, maybe there is a case for pro-choice.
Someone else demonstrating their ignorance

The entire point is vaccine side effects are seen quickly, there are no 'long term effects' as that's not how they work

Do you know the long term impact on fertility of the childhood vaccinations?

milkyaqua · 22/01/2022 22:03

Oh my god. You can't just say 'bodily autonomy!' several times and there's your argument. They are two very different situations.

FriedTomatoe · 22/01/2022 22:01

I'm fed up of how awful people are being about this. I'm having issues at the lack of information about the vaccine with regards to adolescents and fertility in later life. I'm past reproductive age - having the vaccine has no downside for me. However, if I was 17 years old I might feel differently about it. Although there are loads of scientists saying how safe it is - how can anyone say with any degree of confidence that there aren't long term effects? In this regard, maybe there is a case for pro-choice.

DropYourSword · 22/01/2022 21:55

@secular39

There. I said it.
There were mandated vaccinations for healthcare workers before COVID-19. Were we not pro-choice back then too then?
user1471453601 · 22/01/2022 21:50

What absolute bollocks.

If you have a abortion or not, it's not going to kill me or other cev people. Not being vaccinated may kill us.

echt · 22/01/2022 21:45

@secular39

There. I said it.
YABU.

Pro-choice is one person and doesn't affect others.

Vaxxing does affect others.

ldontWanna · 22/01/2022 21:42

YANBU. Whether I agree with someone's choice to vaccinate or not , is irrelevant. I do however believe they have the right to (freely) choose and support that.

Beowulfthethird · 22/01/2022 21:40

What if abortion is not illegal, but we were to heavily discourage by means of restrictions and deterrents for women who choose it? Do you think a person could support that and still be pro-choice?

How hysterical. Having an abortion to work in your job and having and a very safe vaccine are hardly comparable. I remember trotting along for various extra vaccinations as a prospective medical student and accepting this was necessary to work with vulnerable people. It would have been a very different experience to be asked to terminate my pregnancy. Something of a straw man there.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 21:36

I worry that medics who will not support their colleagues are unlikely to be able to obtain consent from their patients either.

But the very nurses protesting about autonomy do not obtain consent themselves some of the time which is ironic.

Beowulfthethird · 22/01/2022 21:36

No I don't agree with you. They're entirely different issues for me.

If you were giving patients, pregnant women and care home residents the choice of vaccinated or unvaccinated HCP, or if you were not giving HCP the choice to leave the profession if they weren't prepared to take a safe vaccine (and vaccines have always been mandated for medics-you can't go to medical school without them) there might be more of a conversation to be had.

Swipe left for the next trending thread