Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
bluebeach · 23/01/2022 08:27

Agree, it’s impossible to keep testing antibodies. But vaccination induced antibodies can wane after 3 months. Are you suggesting all healthcare workers get vaccinated every three months? Where are the clinical trials to see how repeated vaccinations affect the body? Original trials only looked at effects of two injections.

RandomLondoner · 23/01/2022 08:13

No one is forcing NHS workers to have the vaccine. But they are practically being blackmailed to get the vaccine or risk losing their jobs.

This is the second misuse of the word "blackmail" I've seen in two days. (The other was a Conservative MP saying MPs had been "blackmailed" with a threat of funding being taken away from their constituencies.)

You need to look up the word "blackmail" in the dictionary, it does not mean the same thing as "threatened." NHS workers are being threatened, they are not being blackmailed.

I've looked it up for everyone, here is what google says "blackmail" means

the action, treated as a criminal offence, of demanding payment or another benefit from someone in return for not revealing compromising or damaging information about them

OhWhyNot · 23/01/2022 08:13

Oh that’s good then we can guess who has antibodies and who doesn’t

Many front line workers may have had Covid and been asymptomatic. Testing was slow for the first few months. And then there is the issue of some having no antibodies after six months after a positive result

How do you keep in top of testing for antibodies you can’t it’s impossible

Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 08:11

@bluebeach

Having the freedom to put things into or take things out of your own body should always remain your own choice.
It still is. No one is being forced.
bluebeach · 23/01/2022 08:06

Having the freedom to put things into or take things out of your own body should always remain your own choice.

bluebeach · 23/01/2022 07:59

Many frontline workers have antibodies from contracting covid early in the pandemic. They likely are no more threat to patients than vaccinated workers. alethonews.com/2021/12/14/a-huge-israeli-study-shows-natural-covid-immunity-is-far-superior-to-the-vaccine-generated-kind/

sashh · 23/01/2022 07:12

OP

You are wrong about OH when it comes to front line HCP. If OH don't pass you then you don't get the job.

Some vaccines are mandatory for certain jobs, there are the odd exceptions, I worked with one person who had been jabbed for Hep B 3 times, every time she was tested she had not seroconverted.

As a department she was never in contact with someone with known HepB.

In my day only girls were given rubella jabs, I was given no choice even though I knew I would never have children, but it was also to protect other people.

I can see the arguments with covid vax but if you refuse to have the jab then any time for isolation should be unpaid, you should have to wear full PPE at all times in the hospital / care setting.

Shadedog · 23/01/2022 06:56

We are not hounded by Occupational Health to receive vaccinations. If we don't want then, they don't bother

Bollocks. They don’t have to “hound” you because your vaccination status and health screening should be done before appointment. If your OH and HR are shite then it doesn’t mean it’s shite in every other trust. You only need one course of Hep B vaccine so of course OH/management don’t need to send weekly emails as most healthcare workers will have had it before appointment to their first ever post and eventually almost everyone will have had it as it’s now in the 6in1 baby vaccine. Frankly we are “hounded” about flu vaccines every year because our bastard management want to protect us from flu. Twats. Honestly. Caring for the most clinically vulnerable people in society is not some sort of human right. Absolutely sick of people thinking they are so special that their choices should be consequence free. Don’t have the vaccine if you don’t want but don’t expect to waltz onto an oncology ward either.

gettingmylifetogether · 23/01/2022 06:52

But you are saying it's more important to protect other people by having a vaccine than it is to end an unborn childs life. Because no matter how you want to dress it up, you're ending a life having an abortion.

@StanleyGreen I don't consider it ending a life at that stage, but you're getting off-topic.

Simply put, I support every woman's right to decide to continue with a pregnancy or not.

I do not support every person's right to refuse to get vaccinated and continue to participate fully in society. I also make a distinction between people who refuse to get vaccinated, and people who have been medically advised not to get the vaccination. For people in the latter category, they're part of the reason why I have been vaccinated and why I mask up, wash my hands and use hand sanitiser. I think everyone who can get vaccinated should, because there will always be some people who can't.

People who can and refuse are just selfish. It's like the people who were never exempt from wearing face masks and said they were. Ruined it for the people who were actually exempt and needed more protection and understanding.

I don't see why it's so controversial to give half a damn about the society around you.

LakieLady · 23/01/2022 06:02

False equivalence.

Mandatory vaccinations for staff working with vulnerable groups are to protect others, and not comparable with whether or not people are forced to continue with pregnancies that will only impact their own lives.

There's also a school of thought that care homes and healthcare providers could be exposed to liability if someone became unwell because they contracted Covid from staff in a care or healthcare setting, because the provider had failed to put in place effective infection control measures.

YABU.

DrSbaitso · 23/01/2022 05:43

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations.

Of course you can. It's called context.

DrSbaitso · 23/01/2022 05:41

Pregnancy is far more personal than a vaccination programme in a pandemic.

I'm not advocating for mandatory vaccination. But they aren't comparable.

milkyaqua · 23/01/2022 04:15

@secular39

There. I said it.
That's all right. There are lots of people making themselves known as dumbdumbs these days.
Theunamedcat · 23/01/2022 03:00

You talk about having your family around you do realise that's rare right now don't you? And it's going to be even more rare when we don't have the staff to run around trying to track a relative down

SerialNo · 23/01/2022 02:59

I don't think your analogy is a good one. A better one would be that if you are pro-choice re vaccines, does that mean you think manslaughter is OK as long as you didn't actually plan it?
I’d go for comparisons to seatbelt.

“If you are pro-choice re vaccines, shouldn’t you also be pro-choice re. wearing a seatbelt?”

After all, making it illegal for me to choose not to wear a seatbelt impedes my bodily autonomy (even if it makes me and other people safer).

MyDcAreMarvel · 23/01/2022 02:46

I don't think your analogy is a good one. A better one would be that if you are pro-choice re vaccines, does that mean you think manslaughter is OK as long as you didn't actually plan it?
Yes that’s a far better analogy.

Beowulfthethird · 23/01/2022 01:02

I can tell you now that there a few vaccinations that I'm overdue and no one gives a shit.

That's not true. They do give a shit and they've been trying to work out how to get NHS workers to stay up to date with their jabs for years because they're aware of how it's affecting patient outcomes.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 23/01/2022 01:02

I don't think your analogy is a good one. A better one would be that if you are pro-choice re vaccines, does that mean you think manslaughter is OK as long as you didn't actually plan it?

JustLyra · 23/01/2022 00:59

I stated other examples of blackmail. Stop getting excited and start something that isn't there. Not going to bother to entertain you,

The poster is right though - sex by coercion is rape and you were the one who made that connection.

secular39 · 23/01/2022 00:46

@Awalkintime

secular39 But you said there were no exceptions so surely that includes unconscious people? Or now are there exceptions because you have ignored autonomy yourself by treating someone without their consent.
Sigh.

If it was a life and death situation and my family knew of my wishes prior to my unconscious state and the advice and expertise of the doctors, I would hope they will make the best decisions on my behalf.

Same about dead relatives/friends having conditions over funeral arrangements.

OP posts:
Silverswirl · 23/01/2022 00:41

@3scape

*mandatory. Being anti Vax though.... That's not the same is it. So tired of this bs. If you can get vaccinated and have a sense of responsibility towards your community/ society then you do and have done. It's fairly straightforward. If you can't you can't. , No big deal. It's the chunk of society that don't wish to support the needs of others who won't get vaccinated that means, unfortunately, this is becoming a situation of coercion. It wouldn't be necessary if enough people hadn't been allowed to spread the lies. Where I live are a HUGE number of anti vaxxers and from the local forum it's clear they think killing off the vulnerable is humanities best hope. Depressing. There you have it. The bodily autonomy bunch are apparently modern eugenicists. Hmm
How strange. I’m anti abortion (not pro choice) but very pro choice of the vaccine. So totally reversal so most on here.
Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 00:40

No you just make stupid comparisons instead.

Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 00:39

secular39
But you said there were no exceptions so surely that includes unconscious people? Or now are there exceptions because you have ignored autonomy yourself by treating someone without their consent.

secular39 · 23/01/2022 00:37

@Awalkintime

Because you know you compared your work contract expectations to being raped. Also it is a handy time to say you're not engaging when I ask that difficult question you've ignored multiple times.
I don't answer stupid questions.
OP posts:
secular39 · 23/01/2022 00:37

@Awalkintime

You still haven't answered my question about what you do with an unconscious patient? How do you maintain autonomy when they are unresponsive?
That's a stupid question. I am not unconscious. If I was, I would hope that my family and the people who are treating me under their care would make the best decision for me.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread