Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
OhWhyNot · 23/01/2022 14:15

Again it’s based on risk

There is more risk having non vaccinated staff

On wards/community setting risk management is a huge part of the treatment/care

Are we meant to suddenly ignore risk. And put extra pressure of other staff

lljkk · 23/01/2022 14:01

It is not coercion or blackmail, Grow up. ...Actions have consequences.

I've been listening to that argument for > 1 year and it's not convinced me, yet.

Can't enrol in school in some US states without vaccines = "consequences"

USA tried to mandate that ALL employers must get proof of negative Covid test or Covid jab from their employees and many employers adopted jab requirement or lose your job = "consequences"

English Care home staff, get Covid jab or lose your job = "consequences"

Israel, large public events = get jab or you aren't allowed in = "consequences"

Austria proposed policy for everyone, "get jab or pay a fine" = "consequence"

How extreme does the "consequence" have to be before we call it coercion? I don't understand what the threshold is between "consequence" and "coercion". Does someone have to point a gun before we call it coercion?

In which case why does the offence of coercive control exist in English law -- is humiliating abuse the actual threshold?

I'm waiting for the country that publishes, names & shames, people who haven't had a covid vaccine.

PAFMO · 23/01/2022 13:08

@strivingtosucceed

It's easier to say "get another job" when there is that alternative. Assuming we were living in Israel where EVERY job requires an up-to-date Covid vaccine, would you be so understanding?

The problem with these things is it's a slippery slope. Today it's NHS, tomorrow it's teachers, the next day its all public servants, all the way until you can't enter shops or you have to pay for any treatment in an otherwise free healthcare system.

You can't use the excuse of "covid affects many people" either. At the end of the day, it's something you are doing with your own body, so either you support bodily autonomy or you don't. Otherswise you can use that argument for forced sterilisation etc.

The OP was happy to say those exact words "get another job" last summer when posters working in the childcare sector were talking about low wages.

In the same way she (?) told a poster who said that under certain circumstances she'd have a termination that she would be committing infanticide.

And saying blatantly false and untrue things about vaccinating teenagers.

Yes, OP, YOU told us to look at your previous threads.

You should be careful what you wish for.

hedwigismyowl · 23/01/2022 12:59

[quote niccyb]@gettingmylifetogether. The vaccine doesn’t stop you getting the virus or does it stop you passing it on.

Against the Covid-19 virus there was 80% effectiveness against infecting someone else but in the trials for the effectiveness against the DELtA and on ice on virus there was actually very little protection.
Not to mention, you do realise that it is only NHS front line employed staff and carers who have been ordered to have the vaccine? GP’s and dentists are not employed by the NHS and therefore it will remain their choice whether they have it.
Also when the NHS nurse leave the NHS and decides to work for a private company because they don’t want the vaccine. The NHS will look to that nurse and private company to work in her old role for more pay and without needing the vaccine because there will be a shortage of staff![/quote]
It's not just the nhs though, it also affects independent sectors like private hospitals, agency staff. The actually wording is 'CQC regulated activity' not 'NHS only'.

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 23/01/2022 12:20

Well it's clearly a false equivalency. And there are philosophical contradictions unless one concurrently believes that abortion does have wider ranging affects on society such as a pandemic does.

Nevertheless I do absolutely believe in bodily autonomy and do not believe in mandatory vaccines.
I do however also believe that if people want to be fully functioning members of a society in which our children are safe, such as our kids having mandatory MMRs then I support people abstaining from it, not being allowed to have their kids in the same school system. For instance.

thecatsthecats · 23/01/2022 12:20

Choice and consent apply to everything.

My employer doesn't have to consent to pay me if I choose not to show up to work. I only consent to do the work on the grounds that they pay me, and give me leave. I have the choice to leave if I don't like the work, but I don't have the choice to tell them that they must now give me a role in consumer research.

It's nothing to do with bodily autonomy.

Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 12:19

@strivingtosucceed

It's easier to say "get another job" when there is that alternative. Assuming we were living in Israel where EVERY job requires an up-to-date Covid vaccine, would you be so understanding?

The problem with these things is it's a slippery slope. Today it's NHS, tomorrow it's teachers, the next day its all public servants, all the way until you can't enter shops or you have to pay for any treatment in an otherwise free healthcare system.

You can't use the excuse of "covid affects many people" either. At the end of the day, it's something you are doing with your own body, so either you support bodily autonomy or you don't. Otherswise you can use that argument for forced sterilisation etc.

So if you support autonomy then you support patients freedom of choice in deciding who treats them and give them a choice of vaccinated nurses or unvaccinated nurses? Freedom of choice goes both ways, right?
Beowulfthethird · 23/01/2022 12:14

You can't use the excuse of "covid affects many people" either

Watch me.

Energysaver · 23/01/2022 12:13

@secular39

Yes. Exactly. I have seen many posts citing that NHS workers are selfish/inconsiderate/ anti-vaxers if they do not get the vaccinations. Many of my friends who are working in the NHS are flabbergasted that some of their colleagues have been given dismal letters for not having the vaccine.

Mandating the vaccine is basically a fuck you to body autonomy. As a woman, no one can tell me what I should or should do not do with my body and I should not be penalised over my decisions.

Many Mumsnetters on here are pro choice (thankfully) but time and time again I'm seeing collectively views of people refusing to take the vaccine as 'scum' it's ridiculous.

I agree, people have the right to refuse the vaccine. I, however, should also have the choice not to be treated or cared for by someone unvaccinated. When DH was working with human blood products as part of his research, he had to have a hepatitis jab. No jab, no access to the products he needed for his research. This is not new, there s a precedent for needing specific jabs in certain situations.
OhWhyNot · 23/01/2022 12:13

bluebeach it’s not yet known how long the vaccine will start to wane hut I don’t know anyone who thinks it’s a one off vaccine

Of course there is trials for the booster vaccine and the side effects (we all have the option to report in the Yellow Card site/app)

We are told of possible side effects this may change as the vaccines are having to be tweaked as the virus is still mutating

This happens with the flu jab too

I am a HCP I know it’s likely I shall have to have another vaccine this year (it’s past three months now) I rathe tit wasn’t that way but it is as we are still in the pandemic

strivingtosucceed · 23/01/2022 12:12

It's easier to say "get another job" when there is that alternative. Assuming we were living in Israel where EVERY job requires an up-to-date Covid vaccine, would you be so understanding?

The problem with these things is it's a slippery slope. Today it's NHS, tomorrow it's teachers, the next day its all public servants, all the way until you can't enter shops or you have to pay for any treatment in an otherwise free healthcare system.

You can't use the excuse of "covid affects many people" either. At the end of the day, it's something you are doing with your own body, so either you support bodily autonomy or you don't. Otherswise you can use that argument for forced sterilisation etc.

Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 12:02

secular39
So you have a family history of blood clotting and yet you still gave your child the MMR even though you know there was a risk and without getting their consent?

MissTrip82 · 23/01/2022 11:58

Goodness me you must feel very strongly indeed about mandatory seatbelts.

MogsBestestFurball · 23/01/2022 11:41

Another misogynist troll cruising Mumsnet and trying to push women's buttons {yawn}.

Yeah, being forced to have a vaccine totally equates with being forced to bear an unwanted child for 9 months, undergo the extreme risks of birth and raise another human being for the next 18 years...

Beowulfthethird · 23/01/2022 11:35

You can still have the vaccine and pass on Covid.... You can still have the vaccine and have Covid....

So? You can still get TB if you get a TB vaccine but there are much lower risks. Why do all these hcps suddenly not understand the concept of reduced risk? Why all this in for a penny in for a pound nonsense? Florence Nightingale would have a heart attack.

amusedbush · 23/01/2022 10:56

@secular39

You can still have the vaccine and pass on Covid....

You can still have the vaccine and have Covid....

Yes. And in other news, both Serena Williams and I can play tennis Hmm
amusedbush · 23/01/2022 10:54

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations. It does not work like that.

Tell that to the pro-life campaigners in the US who scream scripture at women trying to use family planning clinics, but who are also against gun control and support the death penalty. That also does not work like that.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 23/01/2022 10:54

@LadyFlumpalot

Way I see it is that no one is being forced to have the vaccine, only that if they don't have the vaccine they will be unable to work in certain fields.

If I wanted to work in the defence industry I would need to have a SC check, I'm within my rights to refuse that, but then my employer has equal rights to refuse to employ me, or to terminate my employment if I refuse to have it renewed.

If I want to legally drive I have to take a driving test. I don't have to take a driving test, but then I can't drive on a road.

If I want to work in childcare I need to be screened, I could refuse to be screened but then I couldn't work in childcare.

If you don't want to take the vaccine that's your choice, but your employer is perfectly entitled to decide your views no longer match their requirements and terminate your employment.

Well said.
LadyFlumpalot · 23/01/2022 10:48

Way I see it is that no one is being forced to have the vaccine, only that if they don't have the vaccine they will be unable to work in certain fields.

If I wanted to work in the defence industry I would need to have a SC check, I'm within my rights to refuse that, but then my employer has equal rights to refuse to employ me, or to terminate my employment if I refuse to have it renewed.

If I want to legally drive I have to take a driving test. I don't have to take a driving test, but then I can't drive on a road.

If I want to work in childcare I need to be screened, I could refuse to be screened but then I couldn't work in childcare.

If you don't want to take the vaccine that's your choice, but your employer is perfectly entitled to decide your views no longer match their requirements and terminate your employment.

DolphinFC · 23/01/2022 10:46

@secular39

You can still have the vaccine and pass on Covid....

You can still have the vaccine and have Covid....

For the love of God, can you please reassure me that you're not a doctor or a nurse.
secular39 · 23/01/2022 10:29

@DontTellThemYourNamePike

Your own circumstances with regard to potential blood clots *@secular39 are irrelevant to the thread you started. Surely you have a good case for exemption, so your 'choice' is effectively taken away for that reason. Your choice to have* the vaccine is removed. If you want to argue about bodily autonomy, then surely you should accept that your situation is exceptional and making reference to it is not useful in a discussion like this.
I don't qualify for an exemption, according to my GP. Even despite going through tests to determine whether I have the same blood clotting disorder.
OP posts:
secular39 · 23/01/2022 10:27

@DontTellThemYourNamePike

Your own circumstances with regard to potential blood clots *@secular39 are irrelevant to the thread you started. Surely you have a good case for exemption, so your 'choice' is effectively taken away for that reason. Your choice to have* the vaccine is removed. If you want to argue about bodily autonomy, then surely you should accept that your situation is exceptional and making reference to it is not useful in a discussion like this.
Exactly. It is not relevant. Which was why I didn't state it in my opening post.
OP posts:
milkyaqua · 23/01/2022 10:27

OP: Please see past threads that I have a strong family history of blood clots.

Another poster checks past threads, as instructed!

OP: Do you not have a life? Who has the time to go through my past threads. FYI, why would I voluntary share my personal health needs on a public forum?

secular39 · 23/01/2022 10:26

[quote PAFMO]@secular39

"Please see past threads that I have a strong family history of blood clots"

You are the one saying you have a history of blood clots, and telling others to refer to your past threads to see that.[/quote]
I meant previous posts on this thread.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 23/01/2022 10:24

Sorry- meant to tag @DontTellThemYourNamePike, not @JigglyPiggly

Swipe left for the next trending thread