Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
TheChip · 24/01/2022 07:34

@CynsterBitch

YABU - there is a choice, get vaccinated and continue in your job, don’t Get vaccinated and Find a job that doesn’t require it. I absolutely think there should be restrictions for people whibhave not Been vaccinated not just in the work place but elsewhere too. That being said I don’t agree with the Austrian policy of legally mandating it for everyone, people need to be allowed to choose, but those choices should have consequences
Like people being unable to get shopping for their families? Because that's the kind if slippery slope you're agreeing to
CynsterBitch · 24/01/2022 07:32

YABU - there is a choice, get vaccinated and continue in your job, don’t Get vaccinated and Find a job that doesn’t require it. I absolutely think there should be restrictions for people whibhave not Been vaccinated not just in the work place but elsewhere too. That being said I don’t agree with the Austrian policy of legally mandating it for everyone, people need to be allowed to choose, but those choices should have consequences

Jinglebellsoncake · 24/01/2022 07:30

You are 100% right.
I'm vaccinated (although regret having it now due to side effects).
It should the person's decision.

Fimofriend · 24/01/2022 07:17

Abortions have nothing to do with vaccines. This is the equivalent of the people who used to say "Then move to the Soviet Union" whenever anybody criticized USA for anything.

Just because people should have bodily autonomy it doesn't mean that their right to bodily autonomy can be allowed to infringe on other people's bodily autonomy. Smoking can also be considered a question of bodily autonomy but it affects others badly so you can't do it near others. If you choose to remain unvaccinated you can't do it near others.

I can't see why it is so difficult to understand that if you have a job where you are meant to care for patients you cannot keep the job if you choose intentionally to do something that will put the patients at risk. ...But then again I did know a carer who moaned and moaned and moaned about not being allowed to smoke when she went to people's private homes to supply care so I really shouldn't be surprised.

Konstantine8364 · 24/01/2022 06:52

I am pro choice for abortion. The only option other than having an abortion is having a baby and it's not acceptable to force anyone to carry and birth a baby they do not want.

I think certain jobs having certain requirements is fine, you still have a choice, get the vaccine or get a new job. I see it as similar to the requirements to have certain vaccinations to travel.

However I am against true mandatory vaccines which other countries are bringing in, when you can be fined/imprisoned for not having the vaccine.

sashh · 24/01/2022 05:44

Well..that didn't happen to me shrug

It happened to me, the occ health, not the hold up, and it happened every time I changed hospital.

mikulkin · 24/01/2022 01:13

You are not getting exemption from your GP because blood clot risk is only relevant for Astra Zeneca. There are no blood clot risks from Pfizer or Moderna. Your GP understands it and hence refusing to give you exemption.
And your pro-choice comparison is completely ridiculous. COVID vaccines are needed to protect others, termination of pregnancy is about you only.

You keep talking about your specialist training but what about patients who will be unsafe in your presence because of your choice.

OhWhyNot · 23/01/2022 23:00

Are you working for the NHS now ?

It’s very clear in your contract what vaccines you are expected to have before face to face contact. If OH haven’t chased you up surely that is still for you to arrange this. We have had delays until staff have the correct paperwork (which is a pita as everything is taking longer)

Still confused how you know people who have had dismissal letters when the policy is not in place as of yet the date is set when it will become policy. I work managing a unit I know who is expected to get their letter unless they provide proof or appointment confirmation

secular39 · 23/01/2022 22:40

@BelieveInPeople

Not necessarily, you typically apply, interview, get the job (I have applied to NHS jobs in the past and no where did it ask whether I had received certain vaccinations) and then Occupational Health Contact you. If you don't book onto Occupational Health, the most likely scenario is that your manager will not be hounding you down to go to OH.

This is not accurate. The most likely scenario is that you won’t be able to start work until Occ Health clear you. I have had a contract held up because there was a query about my Hep B status and I needed to get a booster before I was able to work on the wards.

Well..that didn't happen to me shrug
OP posts:
Focus126 · 23/01/2022 22:36

YABU
"Pro-choice" is about pregnancy termination, not about any random thing Confused

BelieveInPeople · 23/01/2022 22:28

Not necessarily, you typically apply, interview, get the job (I have applied to NHS jobs in the past and no where did it ask whether I had received certain vaccinations) and then Occupational Health Contact you. If you don't book onto Occupational Health, the most likely scenario is that your manager will not be hounding you down to go to OH.

This is not accurate. The most likely scenario is that you won’t be able to start work until Occ Health clear you. I have had a contract held up because there was a query about my Hep B status and I needed to get a booster before I was able to work on the wards.

TheChip · 23/01/2022 22:08

But aren't the vaccines still under emergency authorisation? Or do they have full approval now. Surely if they are still under EUA, no job should be able to use it against their employees. What if, God forbid, they failed full auth?

secular39 · 23/01/2022 22:01
  • I don't believe the NHS insists on a TB vaccine as a condition of employment. They test new staff that have come from known areas with TB & vaccinate accordingly. I believe the UK stopped routinely immunising children for TB a good while back too.

Measles, Mumps & Rubella along with Chicken Pox are not routinely immunised against in the UK among health workers. Either history of childhood immunisation or history of having been in contact and created self immunity are considered good enough.

Likewise the only hepatic disease immunised against is Hep B.

I can't think of anything other than Hep B that staff are forced to take to carry on employment. And as already said, this only applied to new employees.

If only Mumsnet had a like button. I am even overdue on my doses for the Hep B vaccine.

OP posts:
pointythings · 23/01/2022 21:56

The vaccine for Covid 19 is an entirely new vaccine made for an entirely new Virus, Given under a special license that protects the producers from any fallout from it.

Are we still peddling that bollocks? The COVID 19 vaccines did not come out of nowhere. Work was ongoing on vaccines for SARS and MERS (both coronaviruses) - this was mothballed when those viruses subsided into insignificance, but that work was a platform to work from.

The technology isn't new either - mRNA vaccines have been in use for around a decade.

And the vaccines went through all the usual stages of clinical trial just like any other new treatment.

Stop it with the lies and misinformation already.

Youarefakenews · 23/01/2022 21:49

@Eleganz

NHS trusts have clear immunisation policies for a range of diseases such as hepatitis and tuberculosis. They all state that employees are expect to comply with these policies unless there are medical contraindications otherwise. This has been the case for years. It is not controversial, it is based on risk.

Add COVID vaccines onto the list of a very well established policy and everyone suddenly loses their shit like this is the first time anyone has ever required vaccinations as a condition of employment.

It just shows you what kind of a society we live in really. Full of people who think they know best even though they know nothing.

I don't believe the NHS insists on a TB vaccine as a condition of employment. They test new staff that have come from known areas with TB & vaccinate accordingly. I believe the UK stopped routinely immunising children for TB a good while back too.

Measles, Mumps & Rubella along with Chicken Pox are not routinely immunised against in the UK among health workers. Either history of childhood immunisation or history of having been in contact and created self immunity are considered good enough.

Likewise the only hepatic disease immunised against is Hep B.

I can't think of anything other than Hep B that staff are forced to take to carry on employment. And as already said, this only applied to new employees.

All the other things I describe above like MMR have well road tested vaccines. The vaccine for Covid 19 is an entirely new vaccine made for an entirely new Virus, Given under a special license that protects the producers from any fallout from it. With that in mind, is it right to force people to take it just to carry on doing the same job they have been doing for two Years.

Thinkbiglittleone · 23/01/2022 20:36

It's blackmail, pure and simple.

So OP it's not about body autonomy then, it's about blackmail ??

They are different so choose your argument, the body autonomy is absolutely tripe and does not have an ounce of truth to it.

So addressing it as blackmail is also incorrect. It is a consequence to a negative action or an action that could put others ,particularly the vulnerable, at risk.

We have many laws that mean a person needs to do something In order to potentially keep others safe.

You can choose what you do or put into your own body, that right is refused when that action poses a risk to others.

You may be angry and feel that this is unfair, which is absolutely fine, but you can't justify those feelings with nonsense.

Eleganz · 23/01/2022 19:42

NHS trusts have clear immunisation policies for a range of diseases such as hepatitis and tuberculosis. They all state that employees are expect to comply with these policies unless there are medical contraindications otherwise. This has been the case for years. It is not controversial, it is based on risk.

Add COVID vaccines onto the list of a very well established policy and everyone suddenly loses their shit like this is the first time anyone has ever required vaccinations as a condition of employment.

It just shows you what kind of a society we live in really. Full of people who think they know best even though they know nothing.

User72614643 · 23/01/2022 19:24

@Youarefakenews oh jeez

  • You are not allowed to smoke in pubs in the UK
  • You are not allowed to walk naked in city centres in the UK
  • You are not allowed to have sex in city centres in the UK
  • You are not allowed to solicit sex on the street
-You are not allowed to be a pimp -You are not allowed to choose to take a shit on the street and then not clean it up
Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 19:17

Youarefakenews

Not talking nonesense. A fat person goes for medical help. Gets diagnosed with fat (apparently that is an illness) then gets told it is because of this fat and turned away without help. Repeat 3 or 4 times before finally being allowed treatment.

Yes I can I have been refused sterilisation because I am female for the past 20 years, while all my friend's husbands get theirs as soon as they ask. Same GP just different sex asking.

Youarefakenews · 23/01/2022 19:04

@Awalkintime

You are too fat/thin to get treatment

Already happens, also you're a female so not entitled to treatment.

You are now frankly talking nonsense. The obese/underweight always get emergency treatment. An operation may be refused if eg obesity is considered too high a comorbidity and creates too large a risk of death.

In these cases if not getting an operation will result in death, then paliative care is put in place.

As for being refused treatment due to sex, Can you give an example.

Youarefakenews · 23/01/2022 19:00

@UniversalAunt

Some things are in the NHS contract, but not mandatory ongoing prophylactic vaccination.

Every year, NHS management undertake a campaign to persuade all staff to have the seasonal flu job, it has to be an annual campaign to account for new strains & variants. Every year loads of NHS staff elect to not have the flu jab. Flu kills the elderly & vulnerable every year, Flu incapacitates many healthy people every year. Every year seasonal flu puts the NHS under considerable operational pressure.

Every year, we all accept treatment from an NHS where many staff are not vaccinated for flu. Has this stopped you having NHS treatment in the past?

During the worst of the pandemic in the past two years, many NHS & social care staff held the front line with little protection or vaccination, they did their best & relied upon basic infection protocols to do their duty.

Me, I am first in the queue for the seasonal flu jab as it offers me some protection, but I know it is just to shorten the odds of being very unwell. I don’t do it to protect the wellbeing of those I live & work with in close proximity. It is unethical to coerce medical treatment on people to protect others - a reasonable argument can be made, but it cannot be mandatory or coerced.

Totally agree. Also if these members of staff are so dangerous to everyone, Then the NHS must remove them from all front line duties NOW.
Awalkintime · 23/01/2022 19:00

You are too fat/thin to get treatment

Already happens, also you're a female so not entitled to treatment.

UniversalAunt · 23/01/2022 18:55

Some things are in the NHS contract, but not mandatory ongoing prophylactic vaccination.

Every year, NHS management undertake a campaign to persuade all staff to have the seasonal flu job, it has to be an annual campaign to account for new strains & variants. Every year loads of NHS staff elect to not have the flu jab. Flu kills the elderly & vulnerable every year, Flu incapacitates many healthy people every year. Every year seasonal flu puts the NHS under considerable operational pressure.

Every year, we all accept treatment from an NHS where many staff are not vaccinated for flu. Has this stopped you having NHS treatment in the past?

During the worst of the pandemic in the past two years, many NHS & social care staff held the front line with little protection or vaccination, they did their best & relied upon basic infection protocols to do their duty.

Me, I am first in the queue for the seasonal flu jab as it offers me some protection, but I know it is just to shorten the odds of being very unwell. I don’t do it to protect the wellbeing of those I live & work with in close proximity. It is unethical to coerce medical treatment on people to protect others - a reasonable argument can be made, but it cannot be mandatory or coerced.

Youarefakenews · 23/01/2022 18:55

@Technonan

I haven't had time to read the whole thread, so apologies if someone has already said this. If you have a pregnancy terminated, you are not going to cause spontaneous abortion in people you come into contact with, similarly, pregnancy is not catching. Abortion is an individual choice that affects the pregnant woman only.

If you work with people, especially sick and potentially vulnerable people, you should get vaccinated because it reduces the risk to them.

The two situations are not the same.

The choice to carry on with a pregnancy affects three people directly. Mum, Dad & unborn child. It is an argument for a different day. But really the potential Fathers opinion should be taken into consideration also.

Awalkintime. The Hep B mandatory vaccine came in around early noughties if I remember correctly.

AlizeeEasy A lot of what you quote is incorrect. You can smoke inside a number of places, including your own home.

You can walk around naked in public. Some places have designated permissions for nudism. Others have a tolerance approach eg know nudist beaches. Incidentally being naked in public is not a crime. An officer could charge you with outraging public decency, It could be argued in court that was not the case depending on circumstances.

You can become a sex worker, it is entirely legal and you can become properly self employed and declare tax etc.

I imagine you could theoretically take a shit on the pavement, If you could prove you had a sudden onset of the shits. It would be your actions after that would be in question. Eg did you try and clean it up etc.

UniversalAunt · 23/01/2022 18:40

YANBU.

If NHS staff are mandated - not encouraged or persuaded - to have a prophylactic treatment imposed upon them, then the principle of body autonomy as a human right is torn up for everyone.

Do it or loose your job is not choice, it is coercion.

I am vaxxed to the hilt for every condition relevant to my health, my choice in light of my own risk factors. I elect (& pay to have) preventative medication to protect my own health - my body, my choice.

What next? You are too fat/thin to get treatment as resources are too scarce…oh, now you mention it, that might help with minimising the viral factor behaviours as one of the highest risk factors of serious Covid is obesity. Hey everyone, loose weight now, protect the NHS…or else.

Body autonomy - this is a fundamental principle that the NHS cannot afford to trash.. In light of existing staff resourcing challenges, NHS staff mandatory vaccination is not a hill to die on, particularly as reconfirming that NHS structure is long overdue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread