Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
GrumpyPanda · 22/01/2022 15:48

Using more precise language might help. "Selfishness" is a sloppy concept. The fact of the matter is that a global pandemic is a collective action problem, in which individual actions - restricting one's interactions, masking, getting vaxxed - contribute to the public good of containing the pandemic. Antivaxxers are freeriding on these efforts - they are benefitting from the public good while refusing to contribute to it. A meaningful comparison would be crossing a picket line while still happily accepting wage raises as a result of the sacrifices made by others.

In contrast, forced birtherism/opposing forced birtherism doesn't involve collective goods, it's all about a multitude of individual conflicts and decisions, unless you're talking about legislation in and of itself. I suppose the only remote parallel would be if you'd spent your whole life campaigning for forced birth only then to turn around and avail yourself of the option to have a termination for yourself or your partner.

UthredofBattenberg · 22/01/2022 15:47

Well, pregnancy isnt infectious, or killi
or incapacitating other people. So someones choice to terminate or continue a pregnancy isnt a parallel you can draw in being vaccinated IMHO

goodwinter · 22/01/2022 15:47

@OneTC

I'm not sure it's that clear cut because I think there's a valid argument to be made about one's choice negatively impacting others - which doesn't apply to abortion in the same way. BUT on balance I am against mandatory vaccination and think yanbu

So if you could demonstrate or argue a negative impact to others you could apply the same thinking to abortion?

You mean like if getting an abortion could put other people's lives at risk? Possibly, I guess, but of course it doesn't.

(Although thinking about it - I suppose that's why people who ascribe personhood to foetuses are anti-abortion. So I suppose many people do in fact apply that same thinking to abortion, as much as I disagree with it)

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:46

@TeenPlusCat

A few vaccinations are mandatory under the NHS but one; we are not at risk of losing our jobs if we do not receive those vaccines.

If vaccinations are mandatory, presumably you wouldn't have been given the job in the first place if you hadn't had them. There has been ample time to get vaccinated by now.

(To be honest I have partly wondered whether making them mandatory was a 'stick' approach to get levels up (similarly vaccine passports), and then when high enough the requirement would be dropped.)

Not necessarily, you typically apply, interview, get the job (I have applied to NHS jobs in the past and no where did it ask whether I had received certain vaccinations) and then Occupational Health Contact you. If you don't book onto Occupational Health, the most likely scenario is that your manager will not be hounding you down to go to OH.
OP posts:
Snowiscold · 22/01/2022 15:46

No-one is telling you what you can or cannot put in your body, though. Interested in the wording of the dismal letter, though.

TeenPlusCat · 22/01/2022 15:46

secular You do have a choice though, in theory at least. The practice I accept might well be harder. Get vaccinated or move jobs?

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 15:45

Surely you can't then say you are pro choice about vaccines now if you never said a peep about mandates before covid.

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:44

@PerkingFaintly

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations.

I can and I am.

HTH.

Then your not pro choice Wink
OP posts:
TeenPlusCat · 22/01/2022 15:44

A few vaccinations are mandatory under the NHS but one; we are not at risk of losing our jobs if we do not receive those vaccines.

If vaccinations are mandatory, presumably you wouldn't have been given the job in the first place if you hadn't had them. There has been ample time to get vaccinated by now.

(To be honest I have partly wondered whether making them mandatory was a 'stick' approach to get levels up (similarly vaccine passports), and then when high enough the requirement would be dropped.)

PerkingFaintly · 22/01/2022 15:43

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations.

I can and I am.

HTH.

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:43

Not sure how they have received dismissal letters yet it isn’t mandatory now

Yes, those who have not declared the vaccine status or have shared that they are not going to take the vaccines (the latter) have received dismal letters from their managers.

OP posts:
JigglyPiggly · 22/01/2022 15:43

You can have the stupidest post of the day award

How you've even tried to conflate the two is mind boggling

Other peoples pregnancies don't impact the general populations health and well-being

stuntbubbles · 22/01/2022 15:42
Biscuit
TheChip · 22/01/2022 15:41

@OhWhyNot

They have until the first week of February to have their first dose

Not sure how they have received dismissal letters yet Confused it isn’t mandatory now

I don’t know anyone unless unvaccinated who isn’t supportive of there measures everyone is fed up with these whining self absorbed colleagues

Self absorbed colleagues? These same colleagues who were clapped for, worshipped and called heroes not too long ago?
OhWhyNot · 22/01/2022 15:40

They have until the first week of February to have their first dose

Not sure how they have received dismissal letters yet Confused it isn’t mandatory now

I don’t know anyone unless unvaccinated who isn’t supportive of there measures everyone is fed up with these whining self absorbed colleagues

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:39

@gettingmylifetogether

No. YABU. I'm pro-choice when it comes to pregnancy, because whether or not to have a baby has a massive physical and mental impact on the woman. I will go to my grave defending female freedoms to decide whether or not they want to give birth or not.

Covid vaccines aren't just about you. They're about the people you come into contact with.

Deciding not to have a Covid vaccine is only acceptable if your medical history suggests it's a bad idea and/or you intend to live in a cave. If you want to participate in society and your doctor sees no reason why you can't have the vaccine, yes, you're being selfish.

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations. It does not work like that. Pro choice is primarily body autonomy.

Depending on upbringing, relationships, social circle and in certain countries. Women who have had abortions are at risk of alienation from certain communities, relationship breakdowns, and are basically shunned. The impact is more social/emotional and mental.

A few vaccinations are mandatory under the NHS but one; we are not at risk of losing our jobs if we do not receive those vaccines.

OP posts:
ghostyslovesheets · 22/01/2022 15:39

This post is a “fuck you” to common sense

this! also I believe in choice over vaccines but those choices have consequences - just like any other choice - don;t have it by all means - your choice - but then expect to find access to some jobs/venues/countries barred to you.

ThreeRingCircus · 22/01/2022 15:38

Personally I see them as two separate issues. I am pro choice regarding women having the freedom to choose to have an abortion if they feel that is the best thing for them/their family.

I don't think people who choose not to have the Covid vaccination should be prosecuted, but I think it's totally fair enough that front line NHS workers, care sector workers or anyone else coming into contact with vulnerable people should be required to have all necessary vaccinations mandated by their employer, including the Covid vaccinations. Certain vaccinations being a requirement of certain jobs is nothing new.

Porcupineintherough · 22/01/2022 15:38

Can you be pro choice if you dont support surrogacy? What about if you dont support people being able to sell a kidney?

littlejalapeno · 22/01/2022 15:36

It’s a completely different issue.

The impact of being forced to carry a foetus to term and risk your life in child birth with no choice, vs. Everybody taking a vaccine that protects vulnerable people and reduces the risk of dying of a disease, are completely different scenarios with completely different implications.

You’re conflating them to muddy the waters and promote outrage and confusion.

I’m so over people being precious about the vaccine because of something they read on Facebook and then equating it with the struggle for woman's rights and autonomy. We’re so lucky to have modern medicine. It’s actually insulting to anyone with a uterus and especially insulting to rape survivors and those who have had to have abortions for medical necessity.

This post is a “fuck you” to common sense!

OhWhyNot · 22/01/2022 15:35

It’s been a nightmare having to cover for unvaccinated staff that are self isolating once again and having to consider their risk (while not changing their roles Hmm ) it puts more pressure on everyone else

They do still have a choice but not when choosing to work with vulnerable people as the impact isn’t on them it’s in everyone else too

The argument for mandatory for all adults is a different argument that is about body autonomy a job you choose to do isn’t

OneTC · 22/01/2022 15:34

I'm not sure it's that clear cut because I think there's a valid argument to be made about one's choice negatively impacting others - which doesn't apply to abortion in the same way. BUT on balance I am against mandatory vaccination and think yanbu

So if you could demonstrate or argue a negative impact to others you could apply the same thinking to abortion?

Freecuthbert · 22/01/2022 15:33

There's other vaccines that are mandatory for NHS workers. Do you propose we scrap them all in favour of bodily autonomy? Or do you recognise that if you're working on the frontline in healthcare that it's actually probably best to have certain vaccines?

3scape · 22/01/2022 15:31

*mandatory.

Being anti Vax though.... That's not the same is it. So tired of this bs.

If you can get vaccinated and have a sense of responsibility towards your community/ society then you do and have done. It's fairly straightforward. If you can't you can't. , No big deal. It's the chunk of society that don't wish to support the needs of others who won't get vaccinated that means, unfortunately, this is becoming a situation of coercion. It wouldn't be necessary if enough people hadn't been allowed to spread the lies. Where I live are a HUGE number of anti vaxxers and from the local forum it's clear they think killing off the vulnerable is humanities best hope. Depressing. There you have it. The bodily autonomy bunch are apparently modern eugenicists. Hmm

TeenPlusCat · 22/01/2022 15:31

secular Your view is all very well, but if one of my vulnerable parents had to go into hospital or a care home, should not the people caring have 'duty of care' to reduce their likelihood of passing covid onto them?

Mandatory vaccinations for certain jabs aren't a new thing.

The biggest issue in healthcare provision doing this is we don't have sufficient people doing some of the jobs anyway. So losing people due to them being vaccinated potentially is a bigger risk to quality of care than them being unvaccinated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread