Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
Forgotthebins · 22/01/2022 16:38

Absurd analogy OP. Unwanted pregnancy is not like a vaccine.

ghostyslovesheets · 22/01/2022 16:37

I assume you will have no problem if an employer refuses to employ the vaccinated over blood clot fears

I'll keep my mask on thanks rather then travel around the world like a arrogant sod thinking I'm immune because I got jabbed

erm well I doubt any employers would do that since it's a minimal risk and actually not a thing - so careful you don't pull a muscle with that over reaching!

Not sure who you are calling an arrogant sod - myself - I have had both doses and my booster, still work from home and will continue to wear a mask - so erm yeah Grin

Duetorain · 22/01/2022 16:32

I am pro- choice as regards abortion. These are two completely different things. I do not advocate mandatory vaccines for the whole population.

I’m not sure how I feel about the current NHS mandate as I have not looked into the science and potential lives lost through staff leaving.

Neither of these come without consequences though -
A mandate for health care staff does not mean they are strapped down, it means finding a different job

Pro choice also has an implication for others. A HCP who works at an organisation that provides abortion can have a conscientious objection to abortion. However if a woman needs or wants an abortion and the HCP is the only one trained and available they should carry it out. If a person would never assist at abortion certain jobs are out.

Thelnebriati · 22/01/2022 16:29

YABU, and I think the argument is similar to 'you can't love animals if you eat meat'.

If you want to make a case start by defining your terms; what do you mean by 'vaccine mandate'?
a) the State has the right to force everyone to have the vaccine, or
b) you will be restricted from certain occupations or activities if you have not been vaccinated.

trunktoes · 22/01/2022 16:26

I am absolutely pro choice when it comes to pregnancy - strongly so. I also believe you have a choice about the vaccine - but that choice has consequences and not being allowed to work in an environment with very sick people or being paid for having to quarantine is fair imo

LuchiMangsho · 22/01/2022 16:25

The definition of pro choice is NOT pro bodily autonomy in all circumstances.
I don’t think a healthy person should have the right to amputate a leg.

Pro choice means that I should not have to carry a pregnancy to term and should have the right to abortion.

There is literally no link between the two because pro choice does NOT mean people can do what they want to their bodies.

And using women and their bodies for this argument is the lowest of the low esp when abortion rights are under threat.

110APiccadilly · 22/01/2022 16:24

A pregnancy affects you and your partner and NO-ONE else.

This is not true. Demographics affect all of us. Why do you think governments sometimes incentivise/ de-incentivise having children?

VodselForDinner · 22/01/2022 16:23

I don’t think you can be “pro-life” if you refuse a vaccine that will save the lives of many actual already-born people.

FrankieBoyleSezLoveOneAnother · 22/01/2022 16:21

You are free to do whatever you want. You need only face the consequences.

  • Sheldon Kopp
PAFMO · 22/01/2022 16:21

[quote littlejalapeno]@PAFMO the point is that children are not afforded the autonomy to decide what vaccines they put in their body, because the benefit to society outweighs the cost to their autonomy, so the OPs argument for choice is impossible to implement and inconsistent.[/quote]
Don't know I'm tagged there.
I've only looked at some of the Op's rather eclectic ideas on MN.

An interesting dripfeed from them following my post though.

Loopytiles · 22/01/2022 16:21

‘ You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances [abortion] and not be pro choice about [other circumstances - vaccines]’

Yes we can!

OhWhyNot · 22/01/2022 16:20

They are not being blackmailed

The reason behind this becoming mandatory is based on risk. We are being clearly informed of this

littlejalapeno · 22/01/2022 16:19

@PAFMO the point is that children are not afforded the autonomy to decide what vaccines they put in their body, because the benefit to society outweighs the cost to their autonomy, so the OPs argument for choice is impossible to implement and inconsistent.

bogie · 22/01/2022 16:19

Yanbu

anon12345678901 · 22/01/2022 16:18

Well they aren't the same and you should be able to understand the difference. No one is being forced to have the vaccine, simply being told it is a requirement of their job. The vaccine is to add a barrier of protection from a virus that affects everyone. Pregnancy and abortion only affect the pregnant woman. I'm still pro choice if I believe a job has the right to ask individuals to get the vaccine to continue their role, because they have the right to say no and leave. If they were saying they would hold them down and force them to have it with no way to say no, then I would be against that. If it was like that, then you could compare it to abortion, but it's not so you can't.

secular39 · 22/01/2022 16:17

[quote littlejalapeno]@secular39 so you won’t be vaccinating your children with the mmr either then?[/quote]
What? Confused My kids have had the Mmr.

OP posts:
secular39 · 22/01/2022 16:17

No one is forcing NHS workers to have the vaccine. But they are practically being blackmailed to get the vaccine or risk losing their jobs.

I will happily get the vaccine. But I have a family history of blood clots, recently diagnose lost a very close relative to a blood clot and have for many years been recommended by DRs to not get medication that may be at risk for triggering a blood clot. Since the vaccine came into play, I have had numerous appointments with my GP voicing my concerns as I wanted to get vaccine. All said it was fine and then AstraZeneca was scrapped. I'm currently going through investigations whether I have the blood clot disorder as my mum. But keep getting "oh it's fine" and just bugger off. I'm not going to "sacrifice" my health for no one.

OP posts:
ABCeasyasdohrayme · 22/01/2022 16:15

If you belive drink driving should be illegal then you're clearly not pro choice.

It doesn't matter if the drunk driver impacts others as long as they are doing what they want.

That's how stupid you sound op.

DoubleDeckerSwimmer · 22/01/2022 16:15

@DoubleDeckerSwimmer

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations.

You have set up the link between the two and you have created your own definition of "pro choice". We don't all have to sign up to your link or your definition. (I don't)

My definition is, "advocating the legal right of a woman to choose whether or not she will have an abortion."

I don't see that much overlap with that and my opinion on whether unvaccinated people should be allowed to potentially spread infection to vulnerable people (especially those in jobs that have traditionally had other mandatory vaccines).

To be clear, I am - I think - uncomfortable with mandatory vaccinations.

I am not uncomfortable with preventing people who have not had certain vaccinations from being in certain situations where the others involved have no choice and would be at increased risk.

I can believe that at the same time as being pro-choice. Indeed, I think both positions have the protection of the vulnerable at heart.

I can also believe that at the same time as recognising the vaccine is not 100% effective.

titchy · 22/01/2022 16:13

That’s exactly why I’m anti-mandate. Because I’m pro-choice. For every body. Not just pregnant bodies. Not just female bodies. Every single body should have the right to decide what goes in and what can be taken out.

Which everyone does have. Even if they work for the NHS. Hmm

Porcupineintherough · 22/01/2022 16:12

@BritWifeInUSA so you believe in people being able to buy and sell human organs?

DoubleDeckerSwimmer · 22/01/2022 16:12

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations.

You have set up the link between the two and you have created your own definition of "pro choice". We don't all have to sign up to your link or your definition. (I don't)

My definition is, "advocating the legal right of a woman to choose whether or not she will have an abortion."

I don't see that much overlap with that and my opinion on whether unvaccinated people should be allowed to potentially spread infection to vulnerable people (especially those in jobs that have traditionally had other mandatory vaccines).

PAFMO · 22/01/2022 16:10

[quote littlejalapeno]@secular39 so you won’t be vaccinating your children with the mmr either then?[/quote]
An AS shows a fair few "interesting" ideas regarding health and medicine. As well as comments along the lines of "well, just hope your (sic) not in that percentage then" said to posters who had received the AZ vaccine and were fine and not dead from blood clots. Which was clearly quite a disappointment to our tricoteuse.

Luredbyapomegranate · 22/01/2022 16:10

So if I’m pro mandatory seatbelts, I can’t be pro life??

I’m not pro mandatory vaccines, in general, but you are talking inflammatory bullshit OP. And the world really doesn’t need more of that.

Snowiscold · 22/01/2022 16:07

Every single body should have the right to decide what goes in and what can be taken out.

Every single body does have the right to decide that. There are no compulsory vaccines.