Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
heldinadream · 22/01/2022 17:34

For all the reasons other people have given and it's too tedious to repeat, OP, you are talking utter bollocks.
I've seem so much nonsense spouted about vaccines but this is right up there with the most stupid and illogical arguments around.

Krakenchorus · 22/01/2022 17:33

Abortion is not a decision that impacts public health. It impacts the health of only one viable human: the mother. The only counter-argument is that it also impacts the fetus and that the rights of the fetus outweigh the right of the mother to end her pregnancy.

A 'pro-choice' stance isn't about the inalienable right of choice in all matters (this is a severely hard-of-thinking interpretation). It's that only one person is impacted, and that person should be entitled to an abortion.

Being pro-choice about abortion isn't about being thinking that choice is a a virtue that should be defended in every possible situation. I can think of a lot of situations in which I would not support a person's right to choose an action that harms others.

You aren't pro-choice either, OP. No one is, unless they're sociopaths. It's all very situation-dependent.

What's your stance on mandatory seatbelt use? No-smoking legislation? Helmet laws? Court intervention when parents have refused life-saving medical care to a child due to religious beliefs? Really, it goes on and on.

oncemoreunto · 22/01/2022 17:30

I am pro-choice, I am also pro accepting the consequences of choice.

I wouldn't accept forced vaccinations but having a consequence following on the choice of not getting vaccinated is just a natural consequence.

In the same way that there are consequences to continuing or not continuing with a pregnancy.

Adult should be able to choose and accept the consequences that stem from their choice.

WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 17:28

And given these rules already existed before covid for other vaccines then you would already have needed vaccinations for some countries already so surely you had an issue with this pre-covid and would've been up in arms about it before now.

What other vaccines? I know if you want to go to certain countries it is advised that you have a vaccine but I didn't think it was mandatory?

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 17:22

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

There are exemptions for those with a medical reason.

Yes, I understand that but what if you wanted to travel, would you still be exempt? Would they allow you to travel if you had medical reason for not being vaccinated?

Other countries, other rules. And given these rules already existed before covid for other vaccines then you would already have needed vaccinations for some countries already so surely you had an issue with this pre-covid and would've been up in arms about it before now. Not sure why people never whinged about other countries rules about vaccines before covid and now it is a big issue.

Still a choice not to go to that country. Choose another country instead.

secular39 · 22/01/2022 17:21

Even if I wanted to. I'm not able to get a medical exemption, my GP made that very clear unless the tests say otherwise.

OP posts:
Distant01 · 22/01/2022 17:21

YANBU

WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 17:20

There are exemptions for those with a medical reason.

Yes, I understand that but what if you wanted to travel, would you still be exempt? Would they allow you to travel if you had medical reason for not being vaccinated?

titchy · 22/01/2022 17:15

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

It is still a choice. A choice means there is more than one option or possibility. Is there more than one option? Yes.

But what if you can't get vaccinated for medical reasons, what then?

There are exemptions for those with a medical reason.
NoRaceInThisHorse · 22/01/2022 17:15

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

You dont if you want to travel and what about NHS workers losing their jobs? That doesn't sound like a choice.
Of course it's a choice. Other countries are free to impose whatever entry requirements they like, and you can choose if you agree to those requirements/terms or not. If you don't, then you accept you can't travel to that place.

NHS front line- face to face- workers will be required to be vaccinated, and may be redeployed (not sacked) if they choose not to be vaccinated: www.england.nhs.uk/coronavirus/wp-content/uploads/sites/52/2022/01/C1545-update-vcod-for-healthcare-workers-phase-2-implementation.pdf

WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 17:11

You'd already be exempt from the others on your contract and the current rules allow for exemptions. I'm sure you already knew that.

So if you wanted to travel to another country you would be exempt if you couldn't be vaccinated due to medical issue's? Not trying to be argumentative, this is a genuine concern. Do you think they would care?

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 17:09

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

It is still a choice. A choice means there is more than one option or possibility. Is there more than one option? Yes.

But what if you can't get vaccinated for medical reasons, what then?

You'd already be exempt from the others on your contract and the current rules allow for exemptions. I'm sure you already knew that.
withgraceinmyheart · 22/01/2022 17:08

Yabu

Of course you can be ‘pro choice’ in the sense of pregnancy choices without believing that everyone, in any situation can make any choice they like without facing any consequences whatsoever, regardless of the consequences to others.

They’re totally separate issues.

WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 17:04

It is still a choice. A choice means there is more than one option or possibility. Is there more than one option? Yes.

But what if you can't get vaccinated for medical reasons, what then?

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 17:01

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

You dont if you want to travel and what about NHS workers losing their jobs? That doesn't sound like a choice.
It is still a choice. A choice means there is more than one option or possibility. Is there more than one option? Yes.
MintJulia · 22/01/2022 16:58

@littlejalapeno

It’s a completely different issue.

The impact of being forced to carry a foetus to term and risk your life in child birth with no choice, vs. Everybody taking a vaccine that protects vulnerable people and reduces the risk of dying of a disease, are completely different scenarios with completely different implications.

You’re conflating them to muddy the waters and promote outrage and confusion.

I’m so over people being precious about the vaccine because of something they read on Facebook and then equating it with the struggle for woman's rights and autonomy. We’re so lucky to have modern medicine. It’s actually insulting to anyone with a uterus and especially insulting to rape survivors and those who have had to have abortions for medical necessity.

This post is a “fuck you” to common sense!

This !
ghostyslovesheets · 22/01/2022 16:58

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

You dont if you want to travel and what about NHS workers losing their jobs? That doesn't sound like a choice.
it's totally a choice - if other countries want people who visit to be vaccinated that's their right - ditto the NHS - you still have a CHOICE - be vaccinated or travel/work elsewhere
OniferousWasp · 22/01/2022 16:56

@daisy46

YANBU. bodily autonomy.
This!
WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 16:55

You dont if you want to travel and what about NHS workers losing their jobs? That doesn't sound like a choice.

NoRaceInThisHorse · 22/01/2022 16:53

Self absorbed colleagues? These same colleagues who were clapped for, worshipped and called heroes not too long ago?

A lot of people, and a lot of NHS staff found that daft, patronising and embarrassing, so I doubt they particularly consider it.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 16:52

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

Mandatory vaccinations should never happen and I'm very pro vaccine. It's scary. Everyone should have a choice.
Everyone does have a choice.
WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 16:49

Mandatory vaccinations should never happen and I'm very pro vaccine. It's scary. Everyone should have a choice.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 16:47

You can't be pro choice when it comes to specific circumstances and not be pro choice in certain situations. It does not work like that. Pro choice is primarily body autonomy.

So how does the pro-choice nurse deal with the unconscious patient?

pointythings · 22/01/2022 16:44

When the consequences on your choice have a negative effect on another living human being, you've reached the border where personal freedom and social responsibility intersect.

Your argument is completely spurious, OP.

ahcmonnow · 22/01/2022 16:39

YANBU