Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 22/01/2022 19:03

I dont see the connection.

One decision is just about the woman and her life.

One decision is about the woman and her life and all the people she may infect with a virus that could kill them

Plus mandated vaccinations isnt forcing people to have vaccinations, its usually done though a 'if you want to mix with others in a school/ cinema/ restaurant then you must... so not not really the same

Liesovertheocean · 22/01/2022 19:00

Pro lifers want to make abortion illegal. Punishable by law. A criminal act. Unless I’m mistaken the vaccine mandate doesn’t make it illegal for a person to be unvaccinated. ‘Pro choice’ is a smoke and mirrors argument. That’s not to say there aren’t potentially good arguments against it just that I don’t believe that this one is it.

christmaslights4 · 22/01/2022 19:00

@secular39

There. I said it.
i just think the difference is vaccinations keep not just your safe but other people, and people who aren't vaccinated can harm others, but people who get an abortion aren't harming others
LuaDipa · 22/01/2022 18:55

@littlejalapeno

It’s a completely different issue.

The impact of being forced to carry a foetus to term and risk your life in child birth with no choice, vs. Everybody taking a vaccine that protects vulnerable people and reduces the risk of dying of a disease, are completely different scenarios with completely different implications.

You’re conflating them to muddy the waters and promote outrage and confusion.

I’m so over people being precious about the vaccine because of something they read on Facebook and then equating it with the struggle for woman's rights and autonomy. We’re so lucky to have modern medicine. It’s actually insulting to anyone with a uterus and especially insulting to rape survivors and those who have had to have abortions for medical necessity.

This post is a “fuck you” to common sense!

Sorry op, I agree.

I’m pro choice and opposed to mandatory vaccination but I think they are two clear and distinct issues with very different implications.

poetryandwine · 22/01/2022 18:45

YABU. I agree with PP’s who take a nuanced view of choice. OP, you are trying to make a new definition of ‘pro choice’.

Probably women would benefit from sticking with the one we’ve got and those who want to fight this battle should do so on other grounds.

My lovely neighbour contracted COVID in hospital and died, in the dark days before the vaccine, so I am all for the regulation for nonexempt NHS workers.

pointythings · 22/01/2022 18:41

@YeOldeTrout

When the consequences on your choice have a negative effect on another living human being, you've reached the border where personal freedom and social responsibility intersect.

According to the pro life people that's exactly why abortion should be illegal. Because the embryo / fetus is a life being squashed out. The pro-life brigade would also say that abortion is also very upsetting to the pregnant woman there is a high risk of chronic upset, even PTSD. Remember Norma McCorvey is a poster-girl for the pro-life campaign. So abortion is bad for the pregnant person, and bad for others (is their argument).

The issue with the abortion argument posited by the forced birth brigade is that they consider the foetus to be a living human being with equal personhood to the woman carrying it. Once you shoot that one down, their whole argument comes down with it.

The evidence that abortion is damaging to a woman's mental health on a large scale has been largely debunked. So it's a bollocks argument whichever way you turn it.

YeOldeTrout · 22/01/2022 18:40

The pro-life campaigners talk about other health harms to the woman who has the abortion, damage to her body or future fertility or cancer risks.

They also talk about moral harm to human conscience, morality, and how this harms all of society. Plus people who feel upset about the fact the abortion happened (such as relatives who might object to the abortion happening). This is why abortion is harmful to others, not just a private procedure (they argue).

If the logic is you must have vaccine to protect others, that protecting others is paramount , then you shouldn't have abortion because abortion damages others. It's the same general justification.

Saintandsophia · 22/01/2022 18:39

I would like to vote but no option?

BigYellowHat · 22/01/2022 18:36

YABU. You’re talking about two totally different things Biscuit Nice try though.

YeOldeTrout · 22/01/2022 18:33

When the consequences on your choice have a negative effect on another living human being, you've reached the border where personal freedom and social responsibility intersect.

According to the pro life people that's exactly why abortion should be illegal. Because the embryo / fetus is a life being squashed out. The pro-life brigade would also say that abortion is also very upsetting to the pregnant woman there is a high risk of chronic upset, even PTSD. Remember Norma McCorvey is a poster-girl for the pro-life campaign. So abortion is bad for the pregnant person, and bad for others (is their argument).

Liesovertheocean · 22/01/2022 18:28

Yeah. Definitely not the same thing I’m afraid. I can see how you might consider a reasonable argument on the surface but more than a momentary consideration makes it clear it’s just not remotely comparable.

ElenaCouch · 22/01/2022 18:22

@TeenPlusCat

Depends what you mean by 'mandatory'. If literally the police are locking people up for not being vaccinated, regardless of other behaviour, then YANBU. If you mean people in a pandemic are more restricted if they choose not to have a vaccine that is proven to reduce transmission and severity, then YABU. Ditto if people want to work with vulnerable people.
This.
AndAnotherNewOne · 22/01/2022 18:20

Logic by pass, OP?

Only the mince thick would think so.

TheGoldenWolfFleece · 22/01/2022 18:19

What health care workers who refuse the vaccine are basically saying is that they don't think the vulnerable people they are paid to look after should have any say over whether they are exposed to unvaccinated people.

My neighbor is refusing to get vaccinated. He works with elderly people in their homes. They should have the right to refuse him entry. He hasn't got any health concerns that mean he shouldn't get vaccinated. He just believes everything he reads on the internet.

OfstedOffred · 22/01/2022 18:15

They are completely different issues.

A woman's choice to abort her own pregnancy does not impact the wider population, other than positively due to there being one less unwanted child.

The decision to choose not to have a vaccine affects vulnerable people who medically cannot have it, by increasing transmission.

It's about how decisions affect others. Health care workers are regularly coming into contact with vulnerable and immunocompromised people, its seriously important that they are vaccinated and if they are unwilling, perhaps it's not a good choice of career.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 18:14

[quote Chocolatefreak]@Awalkintime presentation of vaccination certificates is mandatory at primary schools in many European countries, eg France and Switzerland. Everyone who wants their child to go to school just gets them. [/quote]
And in other non-European countries too. It makes me wonder why no one cared about this before covid. Maybe they weren't pro-choice before then!! ha!

LoveFall · 22/01/2022 18:11

A person's views on bodily autonomy are not a binary thing. A person does not believe in either complete "bodily autonomy" or no "bodily autonomy."

To me, believing it is a rigid yes/no question is very narrow-minded and frankly ridiculous.

There are many things we are required by societal norms and laws to do. There are also things where we have a choice.

Being pro choice and also believing in mandatory vaccination in order to do certain things are not mutually exclusive. No one is holding people down kicking and screaming in order to give them the vaccine. Same thing for abortion.

Chocolatefreak · 22/01/2022 18:09

@Awalkintime presentation of vaccination certificates is mandatory at primary schools in many European countries, eg France and Switzerland. Everyone who wants their child to go to school just gets them.

Chocolatefreak · 22/01/2022 18:06

It's a question of where your rights infringe on someone else's. Abortion = your right, does not impact on others; refusal to get vaccination will impact negatively on others.

DSGR · 22/01/2022 18:04

Yabu, ridiculously so.
If I don’t want a baby that only affects me and the cells.
If I don’t have a vaccine I can hugely impact other people.
The two are not comparable and you know that

jay55 · 22/01/2022 18:00

I'm happy to call myself anti forced birth instead of pro choice.

Mrssebastianstan · 22/01/2022 17:40

I don’t agree with mandatory vaccines eg everyone over 50 has to have it.

I do think it’s reasonable in some circumstances that an employer says you must have certain vaccinations if you want to work in these areas because of the risks to you (diseases) the client/patients/public (you are likely to spread it more easily) and the employer (being sued for your illness acquired from working).

If you want to work for them, eg NHS front line clinical areas you get hepatitis and tetanus jabs for example, why not covid - but I would say as usual, the NHS is getting the grief for a policy dreamt up by politicians at a drunken party/office meeting at no10.

It isn’t sensible to me to impose such a massive policy change to sack people already working there, it is possible to say there are restrictions on how/where you can work for example, which may in the long term mean people can’t get certain promotions but still giving them choice.

It is ok to mandate that anyone joining the NHS from April is vaccinated as then it’s an informed choice to apply.

Krakenchorus · 22/01/2022 17:39

A cholera vaccination is also mandatory in some countries.

WhateverHappenedToFayWray · 22/01/2022 17:37

Yellow fever is mandatory in some countries. You must produce a certificate for it or a medical waiver for exemptions.

You're right, I've just read that.

Awalkintime · 22/01/2022 17:34

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

And given these rules already existed before covid for other vaccines then you would already have needed vaccinations for some countries already so surely you had an issue with this pre-covid and would've been up in arms about it before now.

What other vaccines? I know if you want to go to certain countries it is advised that you have a vaccine but I didn't think it was mandatory?

Yellow fever is mandatory in some countries. You must produce a certificate for it or a medical waiver for exemptions.