Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be 'Pro choice' if you agree in mandate vaccinations?

362 replies

secular39 · 22/01/2022 15:13

There. I said it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Youarefakenews · 25/01/2022 14:55

@Claymorekick

But it is not a change to an employment contract- the change is legislation coming into force that makes it illegal for your employer to continue to employ you in that role. Employers are not changing anyone's contract, they are having to dismiss people so they do not breach the legislation.
I can see some decent pay-outs for unfair dismissal if this does go a head-I think it unlikely it will.

The most likely scenario is that affected staff will be furloughed on full pay. From what I can see most of the unions appear to be against forcing people to have it and will fight for the rights of their members.

Thelnebriati · 25/01/2022 11:43

I don't think DarkStar is objecting to the hep vaccine, she's pointing out the double standards. Covid is not the first vaccine thats mandatory for certain roles.

PAFMO · 25/01/2022 07:31

@Darkstar4855

I love how everyone is up in arms about covid vaccination being mandatory for me to do my job but nobody cared when it was just stuff like hepatitis vaccination. Such a double standard.

We have a choice: get vaccinated or do a different job. It’s not remotely comparable to abortion.

Has hepatitis caused thousands of excess deaths in the UK over the last two years?
Darkstar4855 · 24/01/2022 23:01

I love how everyone is up in arms about covid vaccination being mandatory for me to do my job but nobody cared when it was just stuff like hepatitis vaccination. Such a double standard.

We have a choice: get vaccinated or do a different job. It’s not remotely comparable to abortion.

secular39 · 24/01/2022 22:26

Indonesia was the first country to introduce a Covid vaccine mandate, in February 2021. It is extensive, allowing local government or regional health agencies to fine or refuse social assistance and government services to people who do not get vaccinated.[1]

If this is not coercion. Then I don't know what it is. This is what it's going to come to anyway.

OP posts:
Claymorekick · 24/01/2022 15:22

But it is not a change to an employment contract- the change is legislation coming into force that makes it illegal for your employer to continue to employ you in that role. Employers are not changing anyone's contract, they are having to dismiss people so they do not breach the legislation.

Risibisi · 24/01/2022 14:11

The quality of discourse from op and some of her supporters on this thread is DIRE; it’s Facebook levels of intellect. The pros and cons of mandatory vaccination is an interesting topic for discussion but op’s arguments are so vapid and so lacking in any sort of rigorous investigation, as well as being presented in a ‘gotcha’ sort of way, one soundbite or cliché after the other. And people just grab onto these phrases and keep repeating them - ooh, bodily autonomy / sleepwalking towards tyranny/disaster/decline - but refusing to engage with any counter arguments.

For God’s sake, say something with some substance; support your arguments with evidence, tell us something, show us your thought processes. I’m open to interesting perspectives but just can’t stand reading this wretched, naive drivel over and over again.

pointythings · 24/01/2022 13:30

Imagine any other major change to your contract being implemented and the threat of sacking being the result if you do not agree.

You mean like the registrar who didn't want to officiate at same sex civil ceremonies.... and was sacked?

You mean like the massive changes to public sector pensions, which made them significantly less good, which nevertheless happened?

Change is inevitable. You can't go into a job and expect things never to change. And let's face it, NHS staff have had substantial notice that this was going to happen.

These are unprecedented times, we're living through a global pandemic and anyone bleating that 'they can't change my job' is being feeble. If you can't handle change in your life, be a hermit. Frankly, this is a pathetic argument.

Youarefakenews · 24/01/2022 13:08

@pointythings

Youarefakenews and what point are you making with that link? It states quite clearly that staff who are not immune to Measles, Chicken Pox etc. must receive appropriate vaccinations. So summed up - you either bring your childhood vaccination record as proof (and who knows there might be a blood test involved, there is at our Trust), or if you can't, you get vaccinated. If you don't, you can't take up your post.

I had a colleague whose test came back with no immunity against Measles, Mumps and Rubella - she had to have the MMR before she could undertake patient facing work.

The largest difference is that any person applying for the job can make that decision before doing so. Don't want the above vaccines, don't apply for the job The Covid vaccine is being applied retrospectively.

Imagine any other major change to your contract being implemented and the threat of sacking being the result if you do not agree.

2Gen · 24/01/2022 13:07

YA Definitely NBU!

pointythings · 24/01/2022 12:54

Youarefakenews and what point are you making with that link? It states quite clearly that staff who are not immune to Measles, Chicken Pox etc. must receive appropriate vaccinations. So summed up - you either bring your childhood vaccination record as proof (and who knows there might be a blood test involved, there is at our Trust), or if you can't, you get vaccinated. If you don't, you can't take up your post.

I had a colleague whose test came back with no immunity against Measles, Mumps and Rubella - she had to have the MMR before she could undertake patient facing work.

Youarefakenews · 24/01/2022 12:37

[quote Eleganz]@youarefakenews

You can believe what you like.

The written policies on Trust websites are pretty clear. Trying to argue that the NHS doesn't expect staff to be immunised against a range of conditions because they have already been immunised as children is a bizarre argument. They are already immunised, if they weren't they would be expected to get immunised. Likewise the TB argument where again staff are tested and those without immunity are vaccinated. All risk based.

As for the bollocks about COVID vaccines not going through proper checks. Show your evidence for this and no, a speeded up process is not evidence given that most drugs take a long time approve because of securing funding for trials the not the science.

It seems that lots of people are just making up what they want to be the case and lack the knowledge to even see the basic flaws in what they are saying.[/quote]
Here ya go! Grin
www.solent.nhs.uk/media/1257/healthcare-workers-screening-and-immunisation-policy.pdf

Belladonna12 · 24/01/2022 10:56

If you genuinely feel that you should be exempt, why are you waiting for an investigation to be done? Surely it just involves a blood test which wouldn’t take more than a couple of weeks. If I was in your position I would be making a private appointment to chat to a haematologist or consultant in a relevant speciality rather than asking a GP whose opinion you obviously don't trust. They will either reassure you or they will confirm that you should be exempt. You've had months to sort this out and your inertia is a bit pathetic.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 24/01/2022 09:16

YABVU.
You cannot seriously think that abortion and a vaccine are in any way equal.
Working in healthcare requires certain sacrifices for the good of the sick people you're caring for, don't like it, get a different job.

Ipadflowers · 24/01/2022 09:11

To add to that op, I’d speak to your management about taking a short break where you wait for the test results, if you don’t have the disorder you can then get your vaccines and stay employed. You can show evidence you’re going through clotting disorder tests. Hopefully they are negative and you can then be vaccinated, if not then you’d get an exemption certificate and also stay employed.

Eleganz · 24/01/2022 09:09

@youarefakenews

You can believe what you like.

The written policies on Trust websites are pretty clear. Trying to argue that the NHS doesn't expect staff to be immunised against a range of conditions because they have already been immunised as children is a bizarre argument. They are already immunised, if they weren't they would be expected to get immunised. Likewise the TB argument where again staff are tested and those without immunity are vaccinated. All risk based.

As for the bollocks about COVID vaccines not going through proper checks. Show your evidence for this and no, a speeded up process is not evidence given that most drugs take a long time approve because of securing funding for trials the not the science.

It seems that lots of people are just making up what they want to be the case and lack the knowledge to even see the basic flaws in what they are saying.

Ipadflowers · 24/01/2022 09:04

I think op you’re clearly very angry about the situation you’re in. And understandably so. But you do have choice. A terribly hard choice, but it’s a choice you’re making all the same.

Trying to start an argument and lash out at randoms on the internet though is not going to do anything, no one really cares if you think they meet the definition of pro choice or not.

As said though, it’s an awful situation to find yourself in, to loose the job you trained for years to do because of Covid.

CynsterBitch · 24/01/2022 09:03

@TheChip that is certainly one option, or they could get vaccinated, might be the better solution

lljkk · 24/01/2022 08:50

Having the vaccine... might give you a sore arm for a bit.

There are Lot of MNers hysterically reporting stronger reactions than that.

Thing is, that argument isn't about bodily autonomy... it's about harms & benefits. Most of the counter-arguments given here against vacc mandates are not addressing bodily autonomy. Instead they are insisting that other principles are more important than bodily autonomy.

That is pretty much what the pro-life brigade say about abortion. That bodily autonomy is secondary to other moral principles, and that the most sacred of these is Right to Life (of the embryo/fetus). So you agree that other things matter more than bodily autonomy.

Nearly All of you saying "It's not the same" are agreeing with OP -- you may not realise it. You don't support bodily autonomy when it comes to Covid vaccines, you are arguing that other things matter more than bodily autonomy.

I dunno if bodily autonomy is "the most important principle" but once you start downgrading it you should not be surprised how much others downgrade it, too.

TheChip · 24/01/2022 08:21

[quote CynsterBitch]@TheChip Online shopping in a wonderful new invention. But yes actions have consequences, don’t get vaxxed, expect to be barred from certain places.
I actually don’t think that will be an issue this time around though, the strains are getting milder and we’ll be back to normal life soon enough. Before the next back mutation hits in 5-10 years if course[/quote]
I guess those who can't afford the internet would just have to starve.

DockOTheBay · 24/01/2022 08:18

Continuing an unwanted pregnancy has a 100% chance of causing lifelong physical, emotional and financial impact.

Having the vaccine... might give you a sore arm for a bit.

Hardly comparable

CynsterBitch · 24/01/2022 07:57

@TheChip Online shopping in a wonderful new invention. But yes actions have consequences, don’t get vaxxed, expect to be barred from certain places.
I actually don’t think that will be an issue this time around though, the strains are getting milder and we’ll be back to normal life soon enough. Before the next back mutation hits in 5-10 years if course

OhWhyNot · 24/01/2022 07:47

It’s not about our POV

It’s about risk management of vulnerable patients

My POV is irrelevant. This applies to many areas of work.

MaxNormal · 24/01/2022 07:38

You either agree with bodily autonomy or you don't. It's not just for when it suits your POV.

Claymorekick · 24/01/2022 07:36

You can moan and conplain about the situation as much as you like, you can have your own views about whether it is blackmail, coercion whatever and you could have everyone on here agreeing with you.

But that will not change the fact that from 1 April, it will be illegal for your Trust to continue to employ you in your role so they have no other option but to redeploy or dismiss you. The managers cannot turn a blind eye, they cannot decide to take no action because they agree with you/feel sorry for you (which they may well do). They have to take action to remove you from your role because they have no choice due to the legislation changes.