Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Youngest Daughter in bits on phone - advice please

463 replies

Icecreamlover63 · 22/01/2022 14:54

My Youngest Daughter has just been on the phone and is extremely upset. I have seen this coming for some time but i cannot say anything about peoples relationships however i would appreciate some advice.
In 2019 my daughter was engaged and found out that her then fiancée had spent £3 on gambling in six months. He promised he would not do this again was so very repentant and she forgave hi.
In very early 2020 they got married. They moved into military housing about 8 miles away and appeared very happy.
Then they got transferred to Wiltshire and my daughter got a job at a local hospital and promptly made lots of friends and loved her new job. She joined a gym and lost some weight and was looking amazing.
Her husband's, Mother came over in October 2021 and was furious as she had just had a phone call completely out of the blue. It was the bank informing her that her sons account was overdrawn by £600. (when her son went to Afghanistan she had to have access to his accounts in case he died) and she had forgotten all about it.
The account was overdrawn because of 2 large bets of £500 each.
My daughter again lost her temper and he promised never to do it again.
Just before Christmas he took £500 out of their joint account to pay his friend as apparently he had bailiffs at the door. Then he took another £250 out a one of his friends could not see his children. My daughter said can you give those two friends the account number for our joint account so they can pay it back into the account it came out of. Guess what he said he wouldn't and said they money was going back into his sole account.
He has not spoken to my daughter most evenings and only watches football on sky. He refuses to go out at all in January and has ben very rude to her on lots of occasions.
Basically she has had enough of the gambling and the lies and just basically being ignored.

Fast forward to today!! She has just gone back to collect some of her bits and he started screaming at her and saying she was sneaky moving half of the money into her savings account before she had even spoken to him. She moved it this morning as she did not want him to be reckless and bet it away. He then started to blame her for having mental health problems and that when she was at home she was unhappy (not true) and that he had to speak to welfare in the Army to get married quarters early. They got their married quarters 3 weeks before they got married (which is the normal time line).
He has told her she always runs back to London when she is upset. Again not true she has been to us 4 times in 4 months and two of those times he was with her.

She is so upset and so distraught I honestly don't know what to do and she is driving back home now. I wish i could say she was right but I feel it would be wrong for me to say so. Please can you advise me what to do and also if you think she has made the right decision.
I do understand there is 2 sides to the story but my daughter has moved half way across the country and has not lied, she is devestated.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 07/03/2022 14:19

Wow. Well, I'll start by saying I'm very much 'once bitten twice shy' and I find it almost impossible to give a second chance to someone who has betrayed my faith in them. I can forgive, but I don't forget. He's broken DD's faith. She needs to decide if she can fully trust him again or if she'll be content to live with that little niggling doubt in the years to come. And living that way can be so destructive to one's 'self'.

Showing bank statements is all well and good. But most addicts can and will stay 'sober', sometimes for great lengths of time, when there is something they want. And he wants her back so right now he has great incentive to not gamble. Also, there are other ways of getting money than taking it out of one's bank, as your lovely DD knows. Pawn shops, loans, credit cards, etc are all tricks to conceal habits. So he's shown her a 'snapshot' by showing her his bank account. But is he also willing to show her his credit reports? His bank statements for the last, say, 6 months? That will give a better picture of his past, and possibly his future.

It's very tricky for us as parents to give our 'opinion'. We aren't experts and we speak from our hearts with our 1st priority being to protect our child. Also, you love(d) your SiL so you want to have faith in him. Add in that you don't want to unwittingly influence DD and have it all blow up in her face. It's almost impossible to see a situation like this with cool logic. All I can suggest is that DD needs to speak to a counselor, preferably one who has experience with addiction. She needs to speak to someone who will respond with their 'head', not their 'heart'.

But I will also say that IMHO if she does decide to 'give it a go' she should NOT move back in with him. It needs to be 'prove yourself to me, then I'll decide' situation. Right now it's a 'one swallow does not a summer make' situation. He needs to prove himself to her 'from a distance' and for months, not knowing for certain whether or not she'll come back. He needs to want to stop his addiction for himself not because he's motivated by 'keeping her'. Because someone who stops 'using' (gambling) for/to keep another person invariably fails.

It's a different situation, but I have a brother who is a recovering alcoholic, sober now for almost 7 years. He tried stopping for every reason under the sun but until he really, really did it completely and only for himself he failed, every time.

Icecreamlover63 · 07/03/2022 13:01

What w weekend!!
My dd met SIL for breakfast yesterday. She wanted to meet him. She wanted to tell him how she felt. She was in for a huge shock.
SIL has not bet for 50 days he sat down showed her his bank statements and explained he is attending counselling, showed her the emails with appointments confirmation.
She sat and listened and felt sad she feels so bad. She now feels confused to the point where she has asked me what I think!
SIL does not want to split up he wants to give things a go he has given her full access to his bank accounts and has told her he will do anything to give it another chance. He has taken full responsibility for his actions and has written to dh and myself apologising for his actions and for any hurt he has caused us and also our dd.
He said his dad is not taking to him and blames him for everything saying that SIL has destroyed everything!

I feel I should give my dd an opinion because she has asked for one but I’m confused too. I have never been in this Poland I really want some advice myself. I’m going home after work and would appreciate if you could help me before then.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 05/03/2022 14:03

@Icecreamlover63

SIL is phoning her tomorrow. I’m not sure why and neither is she. I know that counselling is being arranged by the Army for her and I believe and know this will help her. The money aspect is being sorted out by them too. He is in our area tomorrow as he is up to watch a match and dd is making it clear she doesn’t want to meet up with him. I’m just concerned in case he tried to talk her into meeting him. He is an accomplished liar so goodness only knows what he will say
I'd assume that's why he's calling her tomorrow, to try and get her to meet up with him before she has a chance to think about it. Sort of "I'm at X place, come meet me right now", or worse "I'm outside the house". She really, really needs to NOT do that! In fact, she needs to not answer the phone.

Is there a reason she won't block communications with him? At this point she'd be better off not making herself so vulnerable to his sob stories and lies. If she insists there is some form of open channel, she'd be better off using email. That way she can read at her leisure, when she's feeling strong and calm, rather than a jarring phone call or text message popping up on her screen. She could even have you or her dad 'screen' the emails and only tell her what she needs to know in unemotional terms, without mentioning any emotional blackmail.

Icecreamlover63 · 05/03/2022 12:53

SIL is phoning her tomorrow. I’m not sure why and neither is she.

I know that counselling is being arranged by the Army for her and I believe and know this will help her.

The money aspect is being sorted out by them too.

He is in our area tomorrow as he is up to watch a match and dd is making it clear she doesn’t want to meet up with him. I’m just concerned in case he tried to talk her into meeting him. He is an accomplished liar so goodness only knows what he will say

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 04/03/2022 20:00

You're right, she shouldn't phone him. I'd ask her gently what she would expect to accomplish by doing so. Does she think he will listen to her with an open mind as to the reason she left? Does she think it's going to change him into someone who doesn't lie, someone she can trust? I'd ask her to please give herself at least 48 hours to really, really think it through before doing anything.

As far as her feeling sad or upset, there is nothing 'wrong' with being upset that the marriage didn't work out. We get a notion into our heads that when we're married to a 'bad' un' we should be 100% joyful when we get 'out'. But that's wrong. Yes, it's right to feel good about that person no longer creating havoc in our lives. But it's also the 'death of the dream'. Your DD had a dream of how her life was going to be with him. She 'saw' herself as wife, mother, all stretched out before her, rosy and 'real'. But now she's facing the death of that dream. It's only natural for her to mourn that deeply! Right now she has nothing to replace it with. But she will, in time.

She doesn't feel she's 'good enough' now because she wasn't 'good enough' for her STBX to want to change for her. She's taking all the blame for the failure on herself, because she wasn't 'enough'. She isn't in the mental place to believe that it was HIM, not her. We all like to believe that we can control our destiny, our 'world'. And that when we can't, it's our own fault. It's a very painful (and gradual) realization that we are just a little cog in a great big world and that our control over things and people around us is pretty limited. We have to learn to be happy that we can only control ourselves and our reactions to the people/places/events around us.

Bottom line is, her feelings are completely natural. And best 'picked apart' and put to rest with a qualified counselor. As mums of adult children, they only listen to us so far before "It was different when you were my age, it's not the same for me/my generation" kicks in.

I have been exactly where she is. And exactly where you are. I wish I could give you both a very unmumsnetty hug.

Shoxfordian · 04/03/2022 07:01

Advise her not to phone him and that she’ll be ok without him; she will be much happier without him

Sounds like such a difficult time for you all but you’ll get through it

Icecreamlover63 · 04/03/2022 06:48

Many of you have been following this thread and some of you were even extremely kind enough to privately message me.
Dd had a very bad night extremely upset. Doesn’t think she is good enough for anyone. Is now saying she is sad everything turned out this way. She is even thinking of phoning SIL!!!’ I’ve told her how she feels is to be expected and just to take one day at a time. But what I haven’t told her is this, I don’t think she should phone SIL. I’m not actually sure what it will achieve I think it would just extend her period of get over him. Am I right or wrong? Again I can’t tell a grown woman what to do but she has asked me what I think.

OP posts:
Icecreamlover63 · 21/02/2022 23:00

@billy1966

Don't be sad, be delighted.

She is showing resilience which is fantastic.

She is accepting that what has happened was awful.

That he was not a good husband.

That she will not be defined by this.

Be delighted that it is highly unlikely she is going to ages to heal and move on.

This is so positive.

You sound utterly worn out, which is to be expected.

A tonic with iron is a great idea.
Plenty of sleep too.

Mind yourself Flowers

I am exhausted it’s been a long month. But onwards and upwards x
OP posts:
billy1966 · 21/02/2022 22:44

Don't be sad, be delighted.

She is showing resilience which is fantastic.

She is accepting that what has happened was awful.

That he was not a good husband.

That she will not be defined by this.

Be delighted that it is highly unlikely she is going to ages to heal and move on.

This is so positive.

You sound utterly worn out, which is to be expected.

A tonic with iron is a great idea.
Plenty of sleep too.

Mind yourself Flowers

Grrrpredictivetex · 21/02/2022 22:02

@Icecreamlover63 I'm so pleased for you all that she's home. She's bound to have dips in mood after all she's been through. Good luck to you all.

Icecreamlover63 · 21/02/2022 18:33

[quote Grrrpredictivetex]@Icecreamlover63 how many weeks before your DD can come back? [/quote]
She is back home now.
She saw lots of friends at the weekend and had a great time. She is very tired and I expected that as she has been staying at her friends houses for the past three weeks. It’s been good so far. Honestly I can’t believe our year started like this. I have an ear infection now and I feel so run down. I’ve gone off and bought an iron tonic so hopefully that will
Perk me up.

I just hope the Army stick to their word and sort out this financial mediation that’s all. It would make a wealth of difference to her. Anyway she is out tonight with a school friend and is looking forward to it. Her friends are just so pleased she is home they were so worried about her. Her best two friends were at the point that when they last visited they cried in the car on the way home. They spoke to us as SIL was on a course and that’s when dh went to see her. It all stemmed from then. But I think she will be ok. I really do she told me tonight there is literally not one thing she misses about him not one. I just thought that was really sad 😢

OP posts:
Grrrpredictivetex · 21/02/2022 16:12

@Icecreamlover63 how many weeks before your DD can come back?

AcrossthePond55 · 21/02/2022 15:51

@ESGdance

Excellent suggestions!!

I was the 'email monitor' for a friend back in the day. I'd go through her exH's emails and tell her only the 'relevant details and leave out the abuse. Threats were reported to the police. Eventually his vitriol didn't phase her she was able to deal with his emails herself.

I also agree with not talking to him, she needs to block his number. I know that most of the time they can still text or leave a voice message but that can be easily monitored by a third party, too.

Letting him know he's 'on speaker with witnesses' if she does have to speak to him is brilliant!!!

ESGdance · 21/02/2022 13:28

She needs a safety strategy.

Maybe don’t answer his calls.

Tell him that she is only contactable by email and that all his emails are diverted to a folder that she will respond to once a week if they are relevant to their divorce proceedings - and after they have been filtered for abuse by someone else.

She needs to get ahead of any nastiness.

She could also agree to call him back - only when she is in loudspeaker with someone present - that the calls are for divorce negotiations only and will be recorded and any harassment reported.

Really though she doesn’t need to speak to this nasty, lying, manipulative, thieving, bullying, erratic, volatile thug ever again. She doesn’t need to be exposed to his rage - you and your DH have experienced a small part of it - her recovery of her self esteem needs her to be physically distant and emotionally detached. Every single communication will just damage her, set her back and knock back any progress. She doesn’t have time or obligation to indulge this dysfunctional character - she has endured too much for too long.

Icecreamlover63 · 21/02/2022 12:48

@ESGdance

Well done.

Shine a light on it with the authorities and then cut all contact.

Then up all your security and keep your wits about you.

He’s nasty.

Don’t give him air time or access.

We have a ring doorbell and the Army have given us a hotline number.

I’m more concerned if he rings dd and is abusive to her x

OP posts:
ESGdance · 20/02/2022 20:54

Well done.

Shine a light on it with the authorities and then cut all contact.

Then up all your security and keep your wits about you.

He’s nasty.

Don’t give him air time or access.

AcrossthePond55 · 19/02/2022 18:30

Whew!! That's quite an update! And a good one. I'm glad DD is getting such good support from the military.

I think just about everything that can be done has now been done. SiL has been found out and dealt with by his superiors. DD is getting support. SiL's parents have been told the truth. Now all that remains is for DD to get a solicitor. But in the meantime it's definitely time for all of you to cut communications with SiL and his family. Time for all three of you to move forward in peace and unity.

billy1966 · 19/02/2022 18:10

Great update OP, thank you.

She is so lucky that you have had her back so comprehensively, that the MOD have taken it so seriously and that he will not be able to bullshit any of you again.

The mediation will be great to finalise things.

Your husband's letter was a good idea as was expression of distaste for him.

Your daughter will thrive and move forward.

Mind yourself and your health.

A good vitamin B complex is a great supplement to help manage stress and support your nervous system during difficult times.

Flowers
Icecreamlover63 · 19/02/2022 17:24

So here is the update i promised.

The army welfare have rung my dd and they know the truth. They are making lots of referrals for SIL. I don’t know what for but nevertheless it’s four.

He will be moving back into barracks in the next 93 days. He will be staying in the countryside posting he has got for the next 4 years! (Something he will hate).

They are going to organise counselling for my dd and they are also going to book a financial mediator for them to sort out the money he owes on the credit card that he photographed and used fraudulently.

All in all he has been found out by the Army. I’m sure this will not look good on his records!

My DH has written to his parents and told them all of the facts that can be backed up.
How much SIL has taken out of their joint savings
How he threw my dd out and we had to pay for a hotel.
How he faked a break in !
How he shouted at my dd so much she get like she had to film herself cleaning.
He also explained how SIL had lied to senior Army officers, again a fact.

All in all this has been a horrible experience. I feel betrayed and hurt. My dh is disgusted with SIL and he has made this know to the army as well. My dd however is strong she knew it was wrong and has held her head up high and I just know she will be happy.

Coming onto Mumsnet was a good decision I have learnt a lot. So now hopefully after this mediation we can all move forward my dd can have the money she is owed paid back and we can just get in with our lives!
Thank you

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 17/02/2022 13:58

Not at all surprising, really. If there's one thing a gambler is good at it's 'bluffing'.

Icecreamlover63 · 16/02/2022 23:06

@FelicityPike

Ugh he’s such a shit bag.
Indeed he is. Over the past month I have witnessed things I thought I never expected.
OP posts:
nancynoname · 16/02/2022 22:48

Your poor daughter. Obviously let down by her husband, for all the reasons here. But equally as let down by her own father. I'd consider going NC with my father (or mother) if they continued to stay in contact with my abuser. What your husband did (with the phone calls) is inexcusable. He should have blocked SIL the second your daughter opened up about the abuse. So should you.

FelicityPike · 16/02/2022 22:19

Ugh he’s such a shit bag.

ChargingBuck · 16/02/2022 21:42

No surprise about the latest update OP.
Remember - he only rang to manipulate you.

In DH's hour-long phone call with him, DH was treating him, & reacting to him, as one reasonable man to another. DH needs to be disabused of that notion immediately, & I hope this latest bombshell (no surprise to us who've been through similar & know "the script" - shocking to people who believe they are dealing with a 'normal' person) will do the trick.

A wise & excellent poster round these parts. @TheFoundations, posted an analogy about how reasonable people get bamboozled & confounded by unreasonable people. The analogy is based on Cluster-B personality disorders (eg narcissism) but works for addicted & disordered personalities too:

As a definition of a cluster b personality disorder, I found it helpful to see it as a slightly different species. They look like us and can act like us, but they respond to different triggers. I heard a fox described as dog hardware with cat software, and that's what narcissists/psychopaths are like; they're programmed differently to the rest of us; a different human species. Once you learn about their behaviour patterns, you'll see that they're all the same, and very predictable. I found that disturbing until I realised that we all are. Respect us, we will respect you. Love us, we will have a soft spot for you. Swear at us, we will become defensive and upset. Cluster bs just have different responses. Love them, they will see that you can be used as a tool. Offend them, they will destroy you. If someone more useful loves them, they will walk away without a second glance. Stay on their side, they will eternally see you as a tool, and leave you in the toolshed, picking you up and putting you down whenever suits them.

I hope this helps your family 'gird your loins' - & thanks again, Foundations.

billy1966 · 16/02/2022 21:28

Thanks goodness.
Great news.
That is so positive.

Thank you for updating OP.

Mind yourself too as you mind your daughter.

Hopefully this will speed up her freedom from him.

Gamblers are such liars unfortunately, it is not the least bit surprising.

So pleased for you all.Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread