Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Building surveyor damaged property

287 replies

Iamthedom · 22/01/2022 13:34

My buyers arranged for a building survey yesterday
I’ve just gone to the property to collect any mail and he’s done the following
Tried to remove a period tile and had broken it in half
Didn’t leave the tile anywhere
Ripped up laminate flooring under the bay window - obviously to check for damp but the flooring can’t be replaced
Removed a kicker and not replaced it
Ripped wallpaper of the bedroom wall to check a crack
Removed a floorboard didn’t put it back and left nails sticking up
No idea if he has done in
I’m furious and upset .Yes the house is old and is a dooer upper but it’s being sold as such

The period tile in the entrance hall can’t be replaced its been there since 1870s so can’t exactly get it from B & Q
What do I do
Im sending a email to my estate agent with photos and I have spoken to them and they were really shocked and said this should not have done this

OP posts:
FurbleSocks · 24/01/2022 14:48

Oh wow. I was not expecting it to be the surveyor. And he admitted to it. For the RICS complaint you might want to ask on the Property/DIY section as the specialists are there.

FreddieRocks · 24/01/2022 14:41

The firm the surveyor works for should have a complaints handling procedure on their website. It’s a RICS requirement. That should tell you who to complain to, and the timescales in which they must reply etc. If it’s not clear on their website, then call them and ask for it. If they don’t have one then report them to RICS. The surveyor sounds a complete liability.

Legodout · 24/01/2022 14:32

So he's actually a RICS surveyor then? I'm astonished!

Iamthedom · 24/01/2022 14:27

@DingleyDel the buyers are aware that there is a huge amount of work that needs doing to the property
Its empty so they were able to see everything
The damp is obvious and not hidden behind anything

The house was priced accordingly house in the area that have been refurbished sale for sale 100k - 120 k more
Plus seeing as he’s obviously lied and did damage to the property how am I supposed to believe anything in the survey should the buyers try to negotiate

OP posts:
Clymene · 24/01/2022 14:14

@DingleyDel

Ouch. Sounds like they will more than likely use the survey to negotiate on price. To be fair to the surveyor I absolutely would want to have seen the state of the floorboards underneath, and I think any prospective buyers will. It looks like the perfect environment for dry rot. I’ve never understood the point of surveys if they come with so many caveats that they ‘couldn’t inspect this or that’. Breaking the tiles though, how unnecessary.
There is nothing about being fair to the surveyor. He has blatantly ignored the professional standards he's supposed to adhere to
RelentlessForwardProgress · 24/01/2022 14:01

I would send the company a copy of the pictures the estate agent used, and the pictures of the damage, plus a brief description of the phone call where he lied about the damage (unless you happened to have recorded it, if so send a copy) along with a deadline of when you expect to hear back, and what you want done, plus I would state clearly that if you do not feel satisfied you will complain to the RICS.

I help at a sort of drop in and we have a serial complainer who comes, and who is always in the middle of a massive complaint about some company or other. A couple of years ago he complained to the RICS about a surveyor. His problem was that someone else had paid for a survey years previously on a property next door do to him, the results of which did not effect his property at all and the surveyor did not at the time give him a copyConfused. The surveyor very politely explained several times in writing that he was not a party to the survey and then ignored him. He then made a formal complaint to RICS about how being ignored was unprofessional...and this went on for MONTHS! Rather than the RICS saying, look you are completely batshit, go away, they allowed him to send in reams of documents and angst ridden letters and they then convened a group of 3 people to oversee the complaint.....He was clearly bonkers and the surveyor had done nothing wrong, so I should imagine they would take this very seriously indeed.

SituationCritical · 24/01/2022 14:00

Well he clearly took up the tile...it didn't magically remove itself with that huge accompanying chisel gouge did it. I'm actually embarrassed for him on the basis of that phone call.

DingleyDel · 24/01/2022 14:00

Ouch. Sounds like they will more than likely use the survey to negotiate on price. To be fair to the surveyor I absolutely would want to have seen the state of the floorboards underneath, and I think any prospective buyers will. It looks like the perfect environment for dry rot. I’ve never understood the point of surveys if they come with so many caveats that they ‘couldn’t inspect this or that’. Breaking the tiles though, how unnecessary.

Clymene · 24/01/2022 13:51

@Iamthedom

Update Spoke to the surveyor initially he lied said there was no flooring Then he denied ripped up any flooring Then he did admit to taking up the laminate flooring to gain access to the floorboards underneath . When I asked him who gave him permission to remove my floor covering He was extremely evasive saying he “ kind of had permission “ to do that Then he did admit to not having my permission to do this. He denied removing the tile but obviously if he lied about the removing the flooring then I have to assume that he lied about the tile

Tried to bluster me about upstairs and how much work needs doing but I just kept asking him who gave him permission to remove the flooring
I now have to put in a complaint to his company and take it from there
Any advice on what to put in my complaint

I would refer back to that RICS guidance, say that he has contravened sections 2.1, 2.5, and 3.2 or whatever, enclose photographic evidence and also send it to RICS

He did not have your permission to do any of that. He has damaged your property and I would say you want it repaired and compensation

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 24/01/2022 13:44

[quote Iamthedom]@Kshhuxnxk
There is damp in the bay window it’s easily identified and it wasn’t hidden
I think he ripped up the laminate to check if the floorboards underneath were damaged by the damp - they aren’t
But even so he had absolutely no right to do that -he didn’t have my permission[/quote]
The surveyor should've used a damp meter, although it looks like a physical visual inspection has been carried out instead.

Tbf that bay window damp looks shocking.

Iamthedom · 24/01/2022 13:38

Update

Spoke to the surveyor initially he lied said there was no flooring
Then he denied ripped up any flooring
Then he did admit to taking up the laminate flooring to gain access to the floorboards underneath .
When I asked him who gave him permission to remove my floor covering
He was extremely evasive saying he “ kind of had permission “ to do that
Then he did admit to not having my permission to do this.

He denied removing the tile but obviously if he lied about the removing the flooring then I have to assume that he lied about the tile

Tried to bluster me about upstairs and how much work needs doing but I just kept asking him who gave him permission to remove the flooring
I now have to put in a complaint to his company and take it from there
Any advice on what to put in my complaint

OP posts:
billy1966 · 23/01/2022 17:53

I am just beyond gobsmacked at the actions of a professional surveyor.

Classic MN, I have never heard the like of it.

I would be so upset at tiles that age being randomly damaged.

Pure vandalism.

Irrespective of whether the sale goes through, his vandalism of your property is disgraceful.

I would want clarification from the buyers as to EXACTLY what he was told as to the status of the purchase, BEFORE you contact the company he works for and his professional body.

Flowers
Iamthedom · 23/01/2022 17:34

@Kshhuxnxk
There is damp in the bay window it’s easily identified and it wasn’t hidden
I think he ripped up the laminate to check if the floorboards underneath were damaged by the damp - they aren’t
But even so he had absolutely no right to do that -he didn’t have my permission

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 23/01/2022 17:02

Kshhuxnxk

I reckon you could snap the laminate in my flat easily, it's 20 year old cheap laminate, I think.

But that's not for OP to worry about anyway.

Kshhuxnxk · 23/01/2022 16:59

@Iamthedom

He lifted one floorboard in the bedroom didn’t put it back

He ripped up laminate flooring in the front room under the bay window
I’ve attached a photo

Crikey given the state of the skirtings and the fact he was able to snap the laminate so easily I think you've got bigger issues on your hands - your house looks riddled with damp!
JSL52 · 23/01/2022 16:46

@Iamthedom

Well I’ve spoken to the buyers as they live local and I really wanted to get information direct from them And they have assured me it’s a RICS surveyor and that they paid for a full structural building survey It’s a well known company so I’m at a complete loss as to why a professional surveyor would do this
What did they say about the damage ?
WinterDeWinter · 23/01/2022 16:35

I agree - the buyer is responsible. Hand it to them (especially 'where is the fucking tile?!) and tell them that you very much hope this would never happen but if the sale fails for any reason you will have to pursue them for the damage, you're sure they understand.

ChicCroissant · 23/01/2022 16:06

Regardless of who did the damage, I'd be holding the (potential) buyers responsible as they ordered it. I would get your solicitor to send a letter saying they will be responsible for the costs of repairing the damage if they do not buy the property. If they (the buyers) want to claim off the surveyor then they can, but I'd be putting them firmly in the frame now.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 23/01/2022 15:21

@lamthedom - even if it is about the principle rather than the cash, if they have damaged your property they should pay for it - since it is a sale, you probably wont need to take the money from them. But if anything happens with the sale, why should you be out of pocket? That was my point.

MrsTrumpton · 23/01/2022 15:21

Are the buyers sorry for what he did? Are they upset he's ruined the hallway? I'd be very interested to hear the instructions they gave him and whether they said they had permission from you for him to pull things up.

sueelleker · 23/01/2022 15:13

Check how long the "surveyor" has been working for his firm; if he's new, he may have lied about his qualifications to them.

positivevibesonly22 · 23/01/2022 15:02

It really is the tiles that are such a shame. With minimalistic and freshly decorated, new flooring and door I would 100% want to keep them as an original feature. I love things like that and can't believe people would rip them out 😯 it's a bit like 30's tiled fireplaces when people rip them out. With everything else around simply decorated they look lovely and retain the original details of the house.

driftcompatible · 23/01/2022 14:18

My jaw dropped (comically so) looking at those pictures. That's absolutely reckless damage. I can't even fathom it. The buyers don't own this property yet! So someone has come into your house and caused damage and left like it's nothing.

The tiles are really sad. 1870 :(

Iamthedom · 23/01/2022 14:18

I know that the surveyor was in the property for around 2hrs
I have a lovely neighbour who tells me everything 😂 and she saw him arrive and leave the property .
I wouldn’t have thought 2 hrs was enough time for a level 3 survey

OP posts:
BFPDec21 · 23/01/2022 14:04

You need to complain to the EA and your solicitor. Make sure this damage is well noted by all parties in writing as the buyers may play dumb/disbelieve you and try and knock the price down. It's nice to keep it up your sleeve but not in this situation.

I'd also complain to the company directly if you have their details or can get them.

Could the EA have allowed anyone else access generally or at the same time? Perhaps the buyers have gone with and ripped up things to show the surveyor. It may be that these are things they'd change anyway but regardless, it's still not on as they could still pull out!

Swipe left for the next trending thread