Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Building surveyor damaged property

287 replies

Iamthedom · 22/01/2022 13:34

My buyers arranged for a building survey yesterday
I’ve just gone to the property to collect any mail and he’s done the following
Tried to remove a period tile and had broken it in half
Didn’t leave the tile anywhere
Ripped up laminate flooring under the bay window - obviously to check for damp but the flooring can’t be replaced
Removed a kicker and not replaced it
Ripped wallpaper of the bedroom wall to check a crack
Removed a floorboard didn’t put it back and left nails sticking up
No idea if he has done in
I’m furious and upset .Yes the house is old and is a dooer upper but it’s being sold as such

The period tile in the entrance hall can’t be replaced its been there since 1870s so can’t exactly get it from B & Q
What do I do
Im sending a email to my estate agent with photos and I have spoken to them and they were really shocked and said this should not have done this

OP posts:
Pluvia · 25/01/2022 13:49

FWIW, I just showed your photos on this thread to a colleague who develops properties and his comment was that whatever you do, don't try to repair the laminate. Even if this purchaser falls through, the next one will want to take it up to see what's going on in that bay. Refusing to let anyone inspect could well make people suspicious and lose you a sale.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 25/01/2022 13:46

Maybe @Pluvia isn't necessarily saying @Iamthedom's has to replace the tile, but is simply pointing out that there are places where a replacement tile should be available, so she can insist on the surveyor getting an authentic replacement?

bcc89 · 25/01/2022 13:42

@Pluvia

You're completely missing the point, but here you go:

uk-heritage.co.uk/shop/category/flooring-tiles/

Just one of hundreds, thousands, of reclamation yards and sites where you can buy tiles and other items for your period house. All the OP needs to do is photo the broken tile and send the pic and someone'll have a match for it. The property in the pictures isn't so exceptional it'll have been tiled with something bespoke.

The house is being sold for renovation and anyone looking to buy a house requiring renovation won't be squealing about a broken tile. Or about a bit of 15-year-old laminate being broken. To you these may seem major problems, to me I'd be far, far more concerned about the state of all the skirting which from the photos are sending a strong damp warning. If there's a timber floor underneath I'd be concerned about its state, and the state of the joists.

Why should the OP have to pay for a new tile? The whole thread is about external people damaging the property. What a silly comment.
Honeyroar · 25/01/2022 13:41

[quote Hrpuffnstuff1]@bcc89

Your experience in the house renovations industry is what?
Zero/limited at a guess.

The house is quite clearly dilapidated.
He's carried out an intensive survey. The op is emotionally attached to the house, the buyers are not. Hence the hue and cry whilst selling.

Imagine being on the other end as a buyer in this chain. Nightmare.[/quote]
None of this is any reason why a surveyor should damage the house. Whatever your opinion of the house it’s someone else’s property… Anyone touting themselves as experienced in the property market would know that. Or anyone with half a brain!

bcc89 · 25/01/2022 13:39

[quote Hrpuffnstuff1]@bcc89

Your experience in the house renovations industry is what?
Zero/limited at a guess.

The house is quite clearly dilapidated.
He's carried out an intensive survey. The op is emotionally attached to the house, the buyers are not. Hence the hue and cry whilst selling.

Imagine being on the other end as a buyer in this chain. Nightmare.[/quote]
I've actually just renovated a 5 bed house... and the guy doing the survey didn't steal a tile before the house was legally mine Grin

CaptaNoctem · 25/01/2022 13:36

@Pluvia

You're completely missing the point, but here you go:

uk-heritage.co.uk/shop/category/flooring-tiles/

Just one of hundreds, thousands, of reclamation yards and sites where you can buy tiles and other items for your period house. All the OP needs to do is photo the broken tile and send the pic and someone'll have a match for it. The property in the pictures isn't so exceptional it'll have been tiled with something bespoke.

The house is being sold for renovation and anyone looking to buy a house requiring renovation won't be squealing about a broken tile. Or about a bit of 15-year-old laminate being broken. To you these may seem major problems, to me I'd be far, far more concerned about the state of all the skirting which from the photos are sending a strong damp warning. If there's a timber floor underneath I'd be concerned about its state, and the state of the joists.

Why should the OP have to do that? SHE didn't cause the damage! The damage to the floor is an easy fix but many people buy period properties FOR the original features. The buyers may or may not be planning to retain the original tiles - I would be and I'd be livid as the buyer as well.

If the sale falls through then the surveyor's employer will have to foot the bill for the replacement.

The house will also look worse than it did if it has to go back on the market which impacts it's saleability even as a doer upper.

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 13:06

You're completely missing the point, but here you go:

uk-heritage.co.uk/shop/category/flooring-tiles/

Just one of hundreds, thousands, of reclamation yards and sites where you can buy tiles and other items for your period house. All the OP needs to do is photo the broken tile and send the pic and someone'll have a match for it. The property in the pictures isn't so exceptional it'll have been tiled with something bespoke.

The house is being sold for renovation and anyone looking to buy a house requiring renovation won't be squealing about a broken tile. Or about a bit of 15-year-old laminate being broken. To you these may seem major problems, to me I'd be far, far more concerned about the state of all the skirting which from the photos are sending a strong damp warning. If there's a timber floor underneath I'd be concerned about its state, and the state of the joists.

Whattochoosenow · 25/01/2022 12:57

The surveyor should have asked your permission to lift floors and remove tiles. That’s the issue here.
If he have come to you first and said he needed to check for damp under the laminate then I suspect that would have been ok, but the removal of the tile would not.
It doesn’t matter that the whole house needs to be renovated, it’s the fact he went ahead without asking first.

milkyaqua · 25/01/2022 12:51

but you've lost nothing by him doing what he did

Hello! A historical tile has been broken and its other half removed so it cannot even be mended! The entryway to the property is blemished, for starters. I'd like to see anyone on this thread who is downplaying this behaviour and the lies about it, source a tile from 1870 to replace it.

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 12:48

[quote Iamthedom]@Pluvia I didn’t put down the laminate it’s not my house it’s my late parents house
That laminate has been down for about maybe 15 years I’m not sure

There isn’t a chain I’m not buying anything I have my own house that I live in I’m in no rush for a sell .
The buyers are also chain free
So it’s just us in the chain . No one else .

I’ve allowed them as many visits as they need to check the property. I’ve not been obstructive in any way . They have had builders in giving them prices .

Honestly it’s not about emotions Im really not attached to the house I haven’t lived there for around 25 years 😂 I had no issues in clearing the house out and getting rid of my parents stuff as soon as my dad passed away . Im quite hard nosed and I don’t care if this sell goes through or not as the property will sale easily again.

It’s about the surveyor going in and doing stuff he had no permission to do and then lying to me . That lying is what is fucking annoying me more than anything. I really should let that go 😂[/quote]
Yeah, it's annoying, he shouldn't have done it. Tell him that, put it in writing but you've lost nothing by him doing what he did and just waving your finger and clucking 'You shouldn't done that' looks a bit ridiculous.

If these buyers fall out, it sounds like there'll be a queue of others behind them. If they're trying to raise a mortgage rather than being cash buyers they're probably under a lot of pressure from the lender to prove that the house is worth what they're paying for it and isn't likely to need far greater renovation than is superficially obvious.

Be hard nosed. Tell the surveyor he's gone beyond his remit and then just get on with the business of selling the house instead of getting precious about a laminate floor in a house that may well have to be stripped back to the brick.

DingleyDel · 25/01/2022 12:37

And the Op has stated several times that the property was priced considerably below market value due to the condition of it and the fact that significant work needed doing

But there’s a big difference between full renovation (electrics/plaster/ decorate) required and replacing every bit of woodwork/beams if a house is riddled with dry rot. Any perspective buyers will want to know the state of the woodwork. What’s the point of a full structural survey otherwise?

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 12:33

No one's going to pay for the damage because whoever buys the house is going to have to rip off the skirtings, sort the damp problem out and dispose of the floor. This is a house being sold for total renovation/ makeover. The purchasers are buying it for location, size, potential, not for its beautiful interiors.

I'm taking it you've never developed a dilapidated house that needs major works?

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 25/01/2022 12:28

@Pluvia

Just managed to read on to the end. If the house was in good condition and wasn't due for complete refurbishment you'd have a point, but as you know the whole place is going to be stripped out I think you ABU. Presumably the purchasers told the surveyor that they were going to take up that laminate and the original tiles and they wanted to know what was going on under the floors. In these circumstances I can see how it happened.

You need to remove emotion from the situation which is hard when it's your family home. They've offered more than you wanted for the property. If they start messing you about you can put it back on the market and expect to get a similar offer because from the sound of it the location is good and, whatever its condition, the house will appeal to another buyer.

I had to sell my mother's house and it was an upsetting experience. I can see how tempting it could be to channel difficult feelings into retribution against the surveyor but it's really not worth it. Sell quickly, put this behind you, enjoy the proceeds, remember good things about you parents, get on with your lives.

Pluvia, Im not sure where you are coming from. Nobody has the right to damage property THAT ISNT OWNED BY THEM (without permission). What if they decide not to purchase? Who is going to pay for the damage?
Pegasushaswings · 25/01/2022 11:48

The estate agents should be dealing with this! They are meant to be coordinating the sale, not you. I’d put that complaint in but also your earlier idea of the buyers paying some money in now in case they pull out is a good, fair solution. If they then complete it’ll be their problem.

I’d also double check the rest of the house thoroughly because you can’t trust that surveyor!

iwannascream · 25/01/2022 11:43

Hi I've read the full thread and am appalled at what the Surveyor has done. I work for a firm of Structural Engineers and we do full structural surveys and we always make sure to tell the clients that we do not lift any floors, tiles etc. We don't even move furniture we note in our reports that there were items obscuring our visibility. I would be making the managing director of his company aware of what he has done and also that he lied, and ask them what they are going to do to sort the situation.

I hope you manage to simmer down slightly (I would be as angry as you were/are) so I do understand.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/01/2022 11:34

Op it's not you.

SexPeopleLynn · 25/01/2022 11:33

So many people missing the point of this and shrugging with views that the house needs work.

As a helpful PP pointed out, the surveyor has breached several codes of conduct and damaged property he did not have permission to interfere with. Several knowledgable posters have pointed out that nothing needed lifting or removing to identify things such as damp-an experienced surveyor would use instruments of the trade to do this without damage.

And the Op has stated several times that the property was priced considerably below market value due to the condition of it and the fact that significant work needed doing.

So Op is now left with a property in worse condition than before his visit and has not sold it yet. If the buyers pull out, who will pay for this damage or any impact on future saleability?

TakeYourFinalPosition · 25/01/2022 11:30

Have you heard from the estate agent at all, @Iamthedom?

Having just sold, I'm baffled as to how this happened... Our buyer arranged his survey through our estate agent, who basically just passed on the surveyor's available times and asked us to confirm which one we wanted. Our buyer then cancelled the day before; they didn't want a survey anymore.

For the house we bought, the surveyors contacted the estate agent for the seller directly and then told us what time had been booked, and when the report would be due. The seller was home for it - we came round to measure up just afterwards, and the seller was chatting to us about the surveyor being very short, and constantly running up and downstairs to ask for permission to look at things (it's a four-storey house).

I'm not sure if that's the norm; or if you should have been asked in advance... Have you contracted the estate agent to do viewings? Were you expecting them to accompany the surveyor?

It seems a colossal error from a surveyor to not have tried getting permission, so I wonder who he thought he had it from.

Iamthedom · 25/01/2022 11:23

@Pluvia I didn’t put down the laminate it’s not my house it’s my late parents house
That laminate has been down for about maybe 15 years I’m not sure

There isn’t a chain I’m not buying anything I have my own house that I live in I’m in no rush for a sell .
The buyers are also chain free
So it’s just us in the chain . No one else .

I’ve allowed them as many visits as they need to check the property. I’ve not been obstructive in any way . They have had builders in giving them prices .

Honestly it’s not about emotions Im really not attached to the house I haven’t lived there for around 25 years 😂 I had no issues in clearing the house out and getting rid of my parents stuff as soon as my dad passed away . Im quite hard nosed and I don’t care if this sell goes through or not as the property will sale easily again.

It’s about the surveyor going in and doing stuff he had no permission to do and then lying to me . That lying is what is fucking annoying me more than anything. I really should let that go 😂

OP posts:
givemepiece · 25/01/2022 11:18

Presumably the purchasers told the surveyor that they were going to take up that laminate and the original tiles and they wanted to know what was going on under the floors

Omg. It is NOT the purchasers house (yet)!
The surveyor should have sought permission from OP. How is this difficult to understand?!

MaxNormal · 25/01/2022 11:16

It wasn't the buyers property to damage though. That's the point. It doesn't belong to them.

Did you put down laminate to hide what was going on underneath?

OP has clearly stated that this is a probate sale and the house was occupied by her elderly unwell parents previously. She knows it's not in perfect condition and has been honest with the seller about that. That does not give them the right to damage her property.

ThePurpleOctopus · 25/01/2022 11:13

So @Pluvia, in this business transaction, will the buyers remedy this damage if they pull out or the sale doesn't go ahead? If one of them is made redundant and they revisit their finances and need to pull out of the sale, what happens to Op's now damaged house?

I don't think anyone is saying these investigations don't need to be done at all. But I'm so surprised anyone think it's ok for them to be done a) without the owner of the house's permission, and b) without any plan for remedy/replacement if the sale doesn't go through.

If the buyers thinks these investigations are so important, why didn't they ask for permission and get them done in a way that the property could be put back to its original state afterwards? Why has the Op now got to worry about what to do with a damaged house if the sale falls through?

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 11:05

[quote Hrpuffnstuff1]@bcc89

Your experience in the house renovations industry is what?
Zero/limited at a guess.

The house is quite clearly dilapidated.
He's carried out an intensive survey. The op is emotionally attached to the house, the buyers are not. Hence the hue and cry whilst selling.

Imagine being on the other end as a buyer in this chain. Nightmare.[/quote]
This is essentially a business transaction. The buyers are making an investment and they want to be sure that there's nothing going on that they can't see from the surface dilapidation. The seller is emotionally attached to the house and didn't think to mention it in the OP).

I work in the construction sector and when people discover a serious dry rot or similar issue in their homes they often put down laminate, do superficial work to disguise the problem and sell on. Hrpuffnstuff1 is right: this hue and cry is about emotions, not about business.

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 10:57

Just managed to read on to the end. If the house was in good condition and wasn't due for complete refurbishment you'd have a point, but as you know the whole place is going to be stripped out I think you ABU. Presumably the purchasers told the surveyor that they were going to take up that laminate and the original tiles and they wanted to know what was going on under the floors. In these circumstances I can see how it happened.

You need to remove emotion from the situation which is hard when it's your family home. They've offered more than you wanted for the property. If they start messing you about you can put it back on the market and expect to get a similar offer because from the sound of it the location is good and, whatever its condition, the house will appeal to another buyer.

I had to sell my mother's house and it was an upsetting experience. I can see how tempting it could be to channel difficult feelings into retribution against the surveyor but it's really not worth it. Sell quickly, put this behind you, enjoy the proceeds, remember good things about you parents, get on with your lives.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/01/2022 10:55

[quote Hrpuffnstuff1]@bcc89

Your experience in the house renovations industry is what?
Zero/limited at a guess.

The house is quite clearly dilapidated.
He's carried out an intensive survey. The op is emotionally attached to the house, the buyers are not. Hence the hue and cry whilst selling.

Imagine being on the other end as a buyer in this chain. Nightmare.[/quote]
Ridiculous.

Just because a house needs work isn't automatic open season on ripping up floors etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread