Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Building surveyor damaged property

287 replies

Iamthedom · 22/01/2022 13:34

My buyers arranged for a building survey yesterday
I’ve just gone to the property to collect any mail and he’s done the following
Tried to remove a period tile and had broken it in half
Didn’t leave the tile anywhere
Ripped up laminate flooring under the bay window - obviously to check for damp but the flooring can’t be replaced
Removed a kicker and not replaced it
Ripped wallpaper of the bedroom wall to check a crack
Removed a floorboard didn’t put it back and left nails sticking up
No idea if he has done in
I’m furious and upset .Yes the house is old and is a dooer upper but it’s being sold as such

The period tile in the entrance hall can’t be replaced its been there since 1870s so can’t exactly get it from B & Q
What do I do
Im sending a email to my estate agent with photos and I have spoken to them and they were really shocked and said this should not have done this

OP posts:
Iamthedom · 25/01/2022 16:39

Exactly can you see why I’m so annoyed

This was after I sent them the photos
I sent them the link of the rightmove advert

When I spoke to the Surveyor he initially said there was no flooring or floor coverings just bare floorboards
As I was in the house at the time I asked him if that’s the case what am I standing on 😂
Then he blustered and I just kept asking him who gave him permission and could i see either a text or email with that permission
Then he said he kind of had permission

I asked who gave him kind of permission
Then he finally admitted that he didn’t have permission
Kept on about it being an old property and how bad it was and I just kept asking him who gave him permission
Stupidly I didn’t record
So you can see why I won’t take into account his survey - Boris Johnson’s more credible at the moment 😂

OP posts:
ifIwerenotanandroid · 25/01/2022 16:27

So we didn't do it, we couldn't have done it & who cares anyway? Nice.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 25/01/2022 16:26

I actually got an email from the company after I complained

OP was this before you sent them the photos of the damage? I can't believe their barefaced cheek.

And it doesn't matter what the purchasers intend to do since it's not their house yet.

EmmaH2022 · 25/01/2022 16:25

@Iamthedom

Thank you for those that understand why I am Annoyed If permission was asked I would have ensured I was at the property I actually got an email from the company after I complained

Email
Again just to confirm, we have not damaged the property and we do not carry any tools with. and I understand that the purchasers are looking to completely strip out the property and refurbish it.

They don't carry any tools and did that to the floor?

OP thank you for posting. If Hrpuff is correct, I will have to keep all this mind and make sure I'm present for any property surveys.

Iamthedom · 25/01/2022 16:19

Thank you for those that understand why I am
Annoyed
If permission was asked I would have ensured I was at the property
I actually got an email from the company after I complained

Email
Again just to confirm, we have not damaged the property and we do not carry any tools with. and I understand that the purchasers are looking to completely strip out the property and refurbish it.

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/01/2022 16:14

It's a Level 3/RPSA Building Survey.

The Surveyor will inspect the surfaces of exposed floors and will lift the corners of any loose and unfitted
carpets or other floor coverings where practicable. The surveyor will assess all floors for excessive deflection
by a “heel drop” test. For a more complete assessment, the magnitude of any identified deflection/slope
should be measured.
Where the sub-floor is inspected, an inverted “head and shoulders” inspection will be carried out at the
access point. If it is safe to do so, the surveyor will enter the under-floor area to carry out a more thorough
inspection.

No codes of conduct have been broken the Surveyor has been very thorough whilst undertaking his job.
I used the word, 'Chain', to describe the parties involved, the terminology was and still is correct.

GnomeDePlume · 25/01/2022 16:12

Of course the house is damp! All houses that age are damp and have woodworm until they have CH. What great discovery was the surveyor expecting to make?

If he wanted to pull back flooring then he should have asked @Iamthedom.

Looking at the picture of the tile damage it looks like he bashed something into it as there appears to be damage to the tiles lower down as well. As I said upthread, I think it is possible he bashed into the wall with something hard maybe like his ladder.

loislovesstewie · 25/01/2022 15:43

It is not necessary to pull up floorboards/ laminate to check for damp. There are tools that can be used to ascertain if there is damp/rising damp/penetrating damp etc. Neither did he have to pull tiles off the wall. He had no right to do so as he doesn't own the house, neither do the potential purchasers.

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 15:37

Hopefully the buyers will be so embarrassed about the whole thing, they'll just exchange ASAP with no haggling.

No, they'll be grateful to him for exposing those floors and checking them.

EmmaH2022 · 25/01/2022 15:25

Oh and I wouldn't trust his survey either!

EmmaH2022 · 25/01/2022 15:24

Some - thankfully few - odd attitudes here.

OP I had to do a lease extension and the first recommendation of surveyor turned out to be a charlatan - found out from googling his name. When my friend used him he was recommended by RICS. He had lost the accreditation later.

It is well worth letting them know what happened. I'd ask for compensation for the stress and worry. I hope it goes smoothly from now.

BruceAndNosh · 25/01/2022 15:12

[quote Iamthedom]@PegasusReturns
I am naturally a relaxed person and while I'm angry at what he did he’s ultimately screwed the buyers over as while I would have been up to negotiating for stuff they couldn’t physically see like the roof and floorboards as far as I’m concerned that survey is worthless as he’s a liar and untrustworthy

Yeah people lie all the time . I’m not above lying myself when I need to 😂 but I still would ask the owners permission to do what the surveyor did
Probably did me a favour as the prices have gone up since last year[/quote]
My worry would be that the surveyor would exaggerate / invent problems found to "justify" the damage.
ie "It's just as well I pulled up that floor because blah blah"

Hopefully the buyers will be so embarrassed about the whole thing, they'll just exchange ASAP with no haggling.
But if I were them, I wouldn't be paying him for that survey. He's proved that he would lie his way out of a paper bag, plus his behaviour has possibly put their purchase in jeopardy by really pissing off the vendor

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 25/01/2022 15:04

Our did the same, it was our house we were getting assessed to charge the previous tennant we ended up having to replaster walls that didn't need doing because he'd taken chunks out the plaster, relaminate because he'd broken the laminate and get floorboards replaced. We got a third of what he valued it at and it took months because he didn't whether to charge vat?!

Ellowyn · 25/01/2022 14:59

@Pluvia

No one's going to pay for the damage because whoever buys the house is going to have to rip off the skirtings, sort the damp problem out and dispose of the floor. This is a house being sold for total renovation/ makeover. The purchasers are buying it for location, size, potential, not for its beautiful interiors.

I'm taking it you've never developed a dilapidated house that needs major works?

"No one's going to pay for the damage because whoever buys the house is going to have to rip off the skirtings, sort the damp problem out and dispose of the floor"

The keys words are WHOEVER BUYS THE HOUSE. The bit you haven't been able to figure out is, it was not their property to change/ remodel. You can't take a hammer to someone else's property because you don't like it. There are actually laws in place against vandalism.

WhenTheyComeForYou · 25/01/2022 14:56

[quote Iamthedom]@WhenTheyComeForYou
They are aren’t attractive to you but they are still a feature of my late parents property and it’s my property .
And even if the buyers rip it out they had no right to do that without my permission.

It’s not their property to damage as they haven’t paid for it .
Would you go around damaging stuff and say well I’m going to rip it out anyway before you have paid for if .
I don’t care if they replace it or rip it out
They shouldn’t be doing that till the house is theirs they can do what the fuck they want when they have bought it .

@Speakuptomakeyourselfheard
I will update as soon as I hear anything[/quote]
As I said, I understand the issue and why you're annoyed.

But you seem really quite angry over a bit of damage to a doer upper. I know it's your parents home, but if it's a doer upper, then really I'd advise to take a step back and relax about it.

If it has damp then can you blame them for wanting to know the extent? Do you really expect them to just accept your word for it or a very superficial glance and put probably hundreds of thousands of pounds into it? Of course they want to find out the extent to the damp etc.

A lot of buyers would ask you, the seller, to pay for an inspection on it. At least you aren't paying.

Don't shoot yourself in the foot and be difficult, if you lose your buyers you may regret it

Soontobe60 · 25/01/2022 14:50

You’ve said that the whole house needs renovating, so why are you getting so fixated on things being done that will not have devalued the house, nor prevent it being sold for whatever price it’s already being sold for? You’re being petty. But hey, feel free to spend money on taking the surveyors to court.
Also, nobody in their right mind would want to keep those awful porch tiles!

PrincessPaws · 25/01/2022 14:34

@Pluvia

Just managed to read on to the end. If the house was in good condition and wasn't due for complete refurbishment you'd have a point, but as you know the whole place is going to be stripped out I think you ABU. Presumably the purchasers told the surveyor that they were going to take up that laminate and the original tiles and they wanted to know what was going on under the floors. In these circumstances I can see how it happened.

You need to remove emotion from the situation which is hard when it's your family home. They've offered more than you wanted for the property. If they start messing you about you can put it back on the market and expect to get a similar offer because from the sound of it the location is good and, whatever its condition, the house will appeal to another buyer.

I had to sell my mother's house and it was an upsetting experience. I can see how tempting it could be to channel difficult feelings into retribution against the surveyor but it's really not worth it. Sell quickly, put this behind you, enjoy the proceeds, remember good things about you parents, get on with your lives.

But the fact is not their house yet. So it doesn't matter one iota what they may or may not plan to do, the house has been priced for its condition and even if they have specifically asked their surveyor to pull up floorboards he should not be doing so without the owners permission
Iamthedom · 25/01/2022 14:30

@PegasusReturns
I am naturally a relaxed person and while I'm angry at what he did he’s ultimately screwed the buyers over as while I would have been up to negotiating for stuff they couldn’t physically see like the roof and floorboards as far as I’m concerned that survey is worthless as he’s a liar and untrustworthy

Yeah people lie all the time . I’m not above lying myself when I need to 😂 but I still would ask the owners permission to do what the surveyor did
Probably did me a favour as the prices have gone up since last year

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 25/01/2022 14:16

Pluvia you keep going on about rot. From experience of older houses including renovation, rot is normal as the house will have gone through its life without benefit of Central Heating. As is woodworm (they tend to go together). They can be treated if the wood is still sound. If not joists, floorboards etc can be replaced or sistered.

PegasusReturns · 25/01/2022 14:12

Appalling behaviour from the surveyor and from a minority on this thread.

@Iamthedom I’d be raging but you’re showing remarkable tolerance

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 14:10

It’s not the damage as such , it’s the surveyor lying to me afterwards his attitude .and the fact that he didn’t ask me if he could do this

Bad news. People lie and bend the rules all the time. And if you were buying a dilapidated property you'd want someone poking around trying to discover the worst so that you weren't hit with unpleasant surprises that could leave you £10k+ worse off.

Pluvia · 25/01/2022 14:06

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius

Maybe *@Pluvia isn't necessarily saying @Iamthedom*'s has to replace the tile, but is simply pointing out that there are places where a replacement tile should be available, so she can insist on the surveyor getting an authentic replacement?
Or doing nothing at all, because the damage to that tile and the laminate won't have affected the value of the house. Feel annoyed for a while and then forget it.

We're stuck in a woods and trees situation, aren't we? I see the bigger picture from a renovator's pov. The OP is focussing on 'shoulds' and 'oughts' and 'rights'. I'm saying that in the real world, with old and dilapidated properties, things are more grey. This has happened, he shouldn't have done it but I can understand why he did and if I'd commissioned him I'd have wanted him to do the same. The important thing is that it won't have affected the value of property in any way and as the OP isn't living there it's not affecting her.

I obviously wouldn't say that if the house was pristine and purchasers were paying a premium for finish and fittings, but that's not the case here. Basically, no harm done. I hope there's no sign of rot, OP.

GnomeDePlume · 25/01/2022 14:03

I am appalled by what the surveyor has done. The floor is one thing but to destroy an original tile then try to lie his way out of it is something else altogether.

What on earth did he think he was going to find behind the tile? Lord Lucan?

Of course it is possible it was broken by accident taking a ladder through but in which case surely there's insurance for that. Of course this may not be the first time he has been stupid in which case he may soon find himself out on his ear and deservedly so.

Iamthedom · 25/01/2022 13:55

@Pluvia ha ha I wouldn’t touch the laminate I might break a nail 😂😂

I can’t even change a lightbulb
Honestly I have nothing to hide
I’ve not stopped the buyers having as many visits as they want along with builders - a lot of sellers wouldn’t allow this I know .
.
I know Im selling an old property and I have no interest in hiding stuff from anyone
They can look at whatever they want - just not do any more damage

OP posts:
Iamthedom · 25/01/2022 13:51

@Pluvia
It’s not the damage as such , it’s the surveyor lying to me afterwards his attitude .and the fact that he didn’t ask me if he could do this
He was in the house for under 2hrs as thr neighbour told me .

I feel sorry for the buyers because they have spent a lot of money on this survey and I would have been willing to take into account anything they weren’t able to see properly like the joists or the roof but I certainly won’t now - because he lied to me . If he told me one lie what else has he lied about . The survey as far as I’m concerned isn’t credible .

Because the house had not been valued for over 50 years it was an in person valuation
The mortgage company agreed it was worth the mortgage so no issues with there mortgage
Buyers have a mortgage in place

As I posted earlier I don’t care if they buy it or not
I can put it back on the market at the original price I asked for and as the prices have probably gone up it will sell within a week
But I’m not going to negotiate anything on the basis of that survey

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread