Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another MIL one. Help me please!

146 replies

willithappen · 22/01/2022 10:25

Another MIL one to add to the huge list here on Mumsnet. I need some help/advice with how to broach this subject without it causing issues.

My daughter will be three weeks old this coming Monday. MIL stayed over not last weekend but the weekend before so quite soon after her birth. She's now coming to stay this weekend also and I was under the assumption she was staying this evening (Saturday) and leaving on Sunday. I have now just seen via her post on Facebook that she's staying at ours two nights!! So she's planning to stay both tonight and Sunday night. I have asked my partner if this was arranged directly between them two and he's said no but he also doesn't have an issue with her staying both nights and doesn't see the issue at all.

Am I BU to be annoyed that not only is this the second weekend before she's even three weeks old that MIL is staying, but also that she has changed up the plans without even asking me and I find out on Facebook instead?

How did I tell her that I'm uncomfortable with this, that she needs to ask first and to try ask for a bit of space?
How do I also make my partner understand my feelings for this? He thinks it's great as she'll watch our daughter but I don't need anyone to watch her. I'm perfectly capable of doing so myself and I don't want MIL to be here all weekend taking her away from me

Also just wondering if the hormones are taking over and I'm over exaggerating this. Don't want to hurt MILs feelings either or cause issues as we get on well, I just feel taken advantage of

OP posts:
willithappen · 22/01/2022 21:45

I did go to my mums for a bit and a walk to the shop with my mum, just for a bit of 'I have my own plans here' and I also have a friend coming to meet me tomorrow at 11.30am so no chance of staying longer through the day

OP posts:
billy1966 · 22/01/2022 21:39

Why shouldn't the OP retreat to her bedroom with her 3 week old baby if that is what she has to dobto get some peace from her thick as shit MIL who doesn't give a damn about what a new mother may want but is selfish and ignorant beyond belief.

Absolutely selfish and appallingly ill mannered to arrive at someone's home without telling them.

Some people have zero manners.

No wonder MIL's have such an awful reputation on MN, I have never heard the like of it in real life, fortunately.

JanuaryBluehoo · 22/01/2022 20:53

Granny.

If someone's feels they have to squirrel and hide in thier room, perhaps something is wrong with the entire situation.

I would in these circumstances always, favour the human who suddenly has a tiny human being relying on them. ALWAYS.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 22/01/2022 20:51

16Sunbird24

I don’t think OP was really being advised to spend time in her bedroom to punish her MIL, more that it was the only way she would get the peace and quiet she needs when her baby’s not even 3 weeks old yet

^^^

Thank you. Precisely.

Pesimistic · 22/01/2022 20:47

I think the worst part is the fact its just been thrust upon me (and you) no discussion of what would be best or even if it would be OK, my fil sounds very much like your mil.

willithappen · 22/01/2022 20:39

Oh @Pesimistic that sounds awful! So sorry, hope you can also figure out how to broach it with them.
I think some people just don't understand the need for your own space during this time

There's no way I'd have any PIL here for that length of time though, I thought the 2 days was crazy 🙈

OP posts:
Pesimistic · 22/01/2022 20:32

Oh gosh I feel your pain, I'm due baby no 3 in June and my PIL are staying 9 days before baby is born and staying for two weeks after..... they were only asked if they could come and look after our other two while I was in labour and suddenly my FIL said we are coming back to stay here xx of April and going back xx of June. Okay they live abroad but jesus christ, having to potentially be in early labour around themand then have them here for 2 weeks after baby is born is going ro be hell. I am working up the courage to tell my husband that I'm not comfortable with it but I don't want to be the bitch, as I guess you dont. It's not as easy to just come out with it is it..

willithappen · 22/01/2022 20:22

We're in Scotland yeah. No cultural differences, nothing that can explain it away anyway it's just literally how MIL is

OP posts:
ChampionOfTheSun · 22/01/2022 20:19

(But to add, I'd check with a HCP when you see one if your scar is open, I only just saw that part! Once you're a little more healed though babywearing is fantastic for keeping baby close) Flowers

ChampionOfTheSun · 22/01/2022 20:17

Sorry to jump in about the sling, you can usually wear baby after a c-section, you'll just need to make sure the waist band is higher than your scar and that the sling is comfy for you! There's lots of resources online if you search babywearing after a c-section Flowers

birdglasspen · 22/01/2022 20:17

Your c section scar is open still? Sit down, relax with your baby and tell them to look after you both so you can heal! Not by stealing baby for cuddles but by bringing you food and drinks and allowing baby to bond with mummy.

Sunbird24 · 22/01/2022 20:16

I don’t think OP was really being advised to spend time in her bedroom to punish her MIL, more that it was the only way she would get the peace and quiet she needs when her baby’s not even 3 weeks old yet

JanuaryBluehoo · 22/01/2022 20:10

Granny.

Can't you see how awful it is for new mothers having to contend with utterly selfish adults when they are recovering from a major operation and dealing with becoming a new mum?

Shouldn't they be held aloft? Like goddesses.... Protected, cooked for, cleaned for... Whilst they can concentrate on looking after this new life??

If I am lucky enough to be a grandma I will ask my dc what they want. If I am able to offer help I will.
I will buy food, clean if they want me too, do a night shift if they want me too.

If we don't get on by then I will send flowers, cards and money. I won't foist myself at the door demanding things.

Graphista · 22/01/2022 20:09

@GrannytoaUnicorn why on EARTH is that bad behaviour? Why shouldn't op have the peace and rest she needs TO HEAL at this time.

At 3 weeks her body has barely started to heal and she will be exhausted!

The MiL bashing only happens with unacceptable behaviour. There are plenty of good ones about but they obviously don't come under fire for lovely considerate behaviour.

Exactly!

How YOU (including partner and co parent) choose to feed your child is for YOU to say nothing to do with her

A key component of assertive speaking -

JADE

Do NOT

Justify, Argue Defend or Explain

Simply state your boundaries and expectations and leave it at that.

@ESGdance great minds! Grin

I think there may be cultural differences if I'm right about where op/mil are from but it's very subtle and hard to explain! If I'm right different parts of Scotland and there are cultural differences between the mainland and islanders cultures but it's not usually so extreme that may be the mils personality making it more...pronounced?

GrannytoaUnicorn · 22/01/2022 20:07

[quote CoffeeBeansGalore]@GrannytoaUnicorn No, it's the MIL's behaviour that is disgraceful. The baby is 3 weeks old and the Op has stated that MiL just comes & wants to cuddle the baby, is difficult to get the baby back to feed, expects cups of tea & to be waited on. This is not acceptable from anyone, let alone someone who has been a mother and should understand that a new mum needs to bond with her newborn.

And I believe Op doesn't want MiL to keep staying at all.

The MiL bashing only happens with unacceptable behaviour. There are plenty of good ones about but they obviously don't come under fire for lovely considerate behaviour.[/quote]
You have intentionally ignored the part of my post where I quite clearly stated that I am NOT saying MIL is right! Did you not read that?

Two wrongs do not make a right ffs! Behaving like a sulking teenager locking yourself away in your bedroom to 'punish' MIL is NOT how you handle this

Goodness me

woodhill · 22/01/2022 19:37

[quote willithappen]@rogueone I personally wouldn't take welcome anytime to mean inviting myself to stay over for an extended period of time or just anytime in general. She didn't even tell my partner she planned to stay for two days, we both found out via her Facebook post. Had I not seen that before I wouldn't have even had the chance to nip this in the bud as she'd just have never left

She's also going on about feeding DD. We are formula feeding as breastfeeding didn't work for us (as hard as we tried), so I don't have that excuse but I did just tell her that midwife advised only myself and my partner to feed DD for the first couple months as it's a bonding experience etc. she's saying she should do it as she should bond with DD also and many other cultures do this etc

She might be right, but I still think boundaries are being pushed. I shouldn't have to give reasons for not wanting something to be done or wanting to care for my newborn myself.

I 100% think you see a different side to the in laws once you bring a child into the mix

Also, she has made us food but she's left every dish and cooking utensil out and uncleaned and the kitchen not tidied up after. Usually I wouldn't mind as she cooked which is fantastic but I'd just cleaned the kitchen yesterday after weeks of a mess and I shouldn't be tidying up after my c section anyway. [/quote]
It's not for her to dictate OP.

Is she from another culture, is that why she is mentioning this?

ESGdance · 22/01/2022 18:56

I shouldn't have to give reasons for not wanting something to be done or wanting to care for my newborn myself.

100%

No is a complete sentence.

The more you JADE (justify, argue, defend or explain) the more it gives her an opportunity to wrestle a discussion which is exhausting for you.

Be blunt - she’s one of those thick skinned ones that needs straight talking to. Many people will have pushed back at her in the past because they will have had to.

Do everything that is best for you and your baby. Keep that in mind.

Shona52 · 22/01/2022 18:39

Have your mum turn up on the door step without letting you DH know and see how he reacts Wink

willithappen · 22/01/2022 18:32

@rogueone I personally wouldn't take welcome anytime to mean inviting myself to stay over for an extended period of time or just anytime in general. She didn't even tell my partner she planned to stay for two days, we both found out via her Facebook post. Had I not seen that before I wouldn't have even had the chance to nip this in the bud as she'd just have never left

She's also going on about feeding DD. We are formula feeding as breastfeeding didn't work for us (as hard as we tried), so I don't have that excuse but I did just tell her that midwife advised only myself and my partner to feed DD for the first couple months as it's a bonding experience etc. she's saying she should do it as she should bond with DD also and many other cultures do this etc

She might be right, but I still think boundaries are being pushed. I shouldn't have to give reasons for not wanting something to be done or wanting to care for my newborn myself.

I 100% think you see a different side to the in laws once you bring a child into the mix

Also, she has made us food but she's left every dish and cooking utensil out and uncleaned and the kitchen not tidied up after. Usually I wouldn't mind as she cooked which is fantastic but I'd just cleaned the kitchen yesterday after weeks of a mess and I shouldn't be tidying up after my c section anyway.

OP posts:
CoffeeBeansGalore · 22/01/2022 18:00

@GrannytoaUnicorn No, it's the MIL's behaviour that is disgraceful. The baby is 3 weeks old and the Op has stated that MiL just comes & wants to cuddle the baby, is difficult to get the baby back to feed, expects cups of tea & to be waited on. This is not acceptable from anyone, let alone someone who has been a mother and should understand that a new mum needs to bond with her newborn.

And I believe Op doesn't want MiL to keep staying at all.

The MiL bashing only happens with unacceptable behaviour. There are plenty of good ones about but they obviously don't come under fire for lovely considerate behaviour.

rogueone · 22/01/2022 17:29

I think the issue here is the OP partner has advised his mum she is welcome anytime. I have no doubt as a MIL that she assumed that welcome was agreed by his partner. I wouldnt think to have to double check with my childs partner that what he said was ok. So as much as i think its outrageous that she wants to stay for two nights and would have thought she would have checked with her son again it was ok....thus the issue is actually with your DP. ..time for a talk with him...

GrannytoaUnicorn · 22/01/2022 16:18

@CoffeeBeansGalore

She's now "only" staying one night? Keep disappearing to the bedroom for extended periods of breast feeding (pre stock with drinks & snacks and something for entertainment). Even if you & dd go for a sleep. Shut/lock the door behind you. Parting shot of I am off to feed dd. Can you just prep dinner/empty dishwasher/pop to shop/etc. Thank you so much.

Limit the time MiL can monopolize dd & she will soon get bored.
Congratulations on your baby & hope the rest of your recovery is more peaceful Flowers

😧😧😧 I've never seen such nastiness towards mothers in law as I have on these threads.... NO I do NOT condone MILs behaviour before you twist my words but telling OP - after it's gone back to the 1 night stay OP wanted - to spend extended time in the bedroom just to avoid her husband's mother???? Absolutely disgraceful behaviour.
GrannytoaUnicorn · 22/01/2022 16:14

@Iputthetrampintrampoline

Suck it up this weekend OP and on sunday go out buy her a gift and say I just wanted to thank you MIL for the kindness you have shown us these past few weeks and for all the support you gave us but I think we are ok now to forge a routine for ourselves,Its been lovely having you to rely on but we dont want to infringe on your time or your life any longer as we feel its not fair to you,,,no we wont take any argments on this we have to consider you ...we thought we might come to you for a visit in a coupe of weeks where we an fill you in on our progress on our new routine as we settle xxxx into family life,We are so grateful though for all you have done for us,i will ring you in the week to sort out our visit to you, We are going to see family and friends now to let them meet xxxx and i am sure your friends are missing you too Diplomatic,grateful,with boundaries set and no offence taken...might be the way to go?
That is hugely manipulative and disingenuous Hmm OP please don't do this and outright tell lies. Lying helps nobody
Graphista · 22/01/2022 15:44

@notthatonethisone thanks for the compliment

I don't get why woman who have had children (mil) don't get that you have a need for space to recover.

Oh they get it - they just don't care! As evidenced by numerous other mil/new mum threads their focus is on themselves as granny and their ds. It's not only mil's are like this though pp is right part of the issue is you don't have the same relationship with your mil as your mum, but it sometimes is mum.

I have a difficult relationship with my mum, when I had dd she and my dad kept trying to persuade me to let her come stay when I got home from hospital - supposedly to help - but I know mum and I know me and it wouldn't have ended well!

Mainly as mums version of "help" WOULD have been monopolising baby, criticising my parenting, complaining about the food (I'm veggie, she's a fab cook but she doesn't "get" the veggie thing) and expecting us all to fit her preferred routine.

She stayed with my sister when she had her kids but sister is mums gc and they have very similar views on most things inc parenting (eg she didn't understand my bf past 6 weeks despite before I had dd CLAIMING to be pro bf and "I bf all mine" if transpired after i had dd she had only done so for 6 weeks each time, and thought it odd and unnecessary sister ff all hers from the start which she didn't bat an eye at, I have no problem with ff it's the misleading aspect was the problem and that she had a problem with me bf for longer, she also went on about putting a bit of rusk or baby rice in a bottle from around 2 weeks! "That's what I did" she really doesn't get that knowledge and advice has massively changed since she had us. She is also a heavy smoker which I wanted around dd as little as possible. Sister is also a heavy smoker and had no such qualms, she'd stop while pregnant but be lighting up in the hospital grounds immediately after the birth!)

Brother and his 1st wife had to tell her to back off at one point as she was constantly criticising every parenting decision! Sil refused to have her visit she had her own mum nearby. They lived other end of country to mum.

Don't worry, I'm going to take all this advice on board and put my partner straight.

Good for you! Mention of islands if you're in uk makes me think you may be my neck of the woods. In which case then it is tricky in terms of transport issues around there esp this time of year but my opinion and advice still stands

ESGdance · 22/01/2022 15:42

Good for you.

This is YOUR motherhood - she’s had hers.

This time is precious and finite and is about the THREE of you laying the foundations for a calm and peaceful home - who, when and how anyone else comes through your door is at YOUR discretion once YOU have decided you have the time and the space and that their presence is enriching your new little family life.

Being assertive doesn’t have to be confrontational or cause conflict - make every decision based on what’s best for you and your baby and your new little family at this moment. Put your bonding and recovery first, front and centre. That will give you the confidence to be calmly and consistently assertive.

Sounds like your OH and his DM have poor boundaries and poor communication - you and your baby don’t need to absorb their negative bickering.

Time to put some manners on your OH.