Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does shone rhyme with dawn or zone?

764 replies

youdialwetile · 22/01/2022 03:16

DD has been told she's saying it wrong - may be both as used in different places?

OP posts:
MinglingFlamingo · 22/01/2022 22:35

Shown even

MinglingFlamingo · 22/01/2022 22:34

The sun shone rhymes with one

I was shone the way to the park rhymes with zone

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 22:34

When people say that "shorn" and "dawn" rhyme, it feels as odd as if someone insisted that "three" and "France" start with the same sound. I mean, I know that some people pronounce them the same, but it's jarring to think that they don't even have a mental concept of the difference.

Presumably a lot of people who pronounce it the opposite way find it similarly jarring. And then there's the rest of us... who have heard rhotic and non-rhotic accents a gazillion times and are totally at ease with their differences. Actually, all those other people have heard rhotic and non-rhotic accents a gazillion times too, they just don't bloody listen!

I mean... all that this: When people say that "shorn" and "dawn" rhyme, it feels as odd as if someone insisted that "three" and "France" start with the same sound. means is "I am Irish/Scottish/American and have failed to notice that other people's spoken English doesn't sound like mine". Just like "Wtf of course shorn and dawn rhyme" means "I am an English speaker who's not Irish/Scottish/American and I have failed to notice that other people's spoken English doesn't sound like mine".

TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 22/01/2022 22:31

[quote GaryLurcher19]@TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek

Sorry but "a 'sh" makes more sense than "an 'sh"

I certainly don't pronounce 'sh' with an 'e' sound first. That's a feature of Spanish, not English.

Saying "an 'sh" is awkward and requires a guttural stop and start between the 'n' and the 's'. That guttural stop could even be the 'e' sound you're imagining.

Saying "a 'sh" is easier and more natural. It requires no 'e' insert.[/quote]
Lol, sorry @GaryLurcher19. I didn't explain myself very well at all! You are completely right that the "sh" sound should always be preceeded by an "a", which I think I tried to explain later on when I gave examples of words like "a squirrel" "a shoe" "a shop"
"a street map" etc.
I don't know if I can explain myself any clearer this time, but I will give it a go...

I was just trying to explain to a pp that I had put "an" "s" rather than the required "a" "s" of "sh", because when I say "s" to myself, I pronounce it as "es" eg to spell shop I would pronounce the letters "es" "aitch" "oh" "pee", so that would be: an es, an aitch, an oh, and a pee. So when I was trying to explain it before, I should have said an (e)s (gap) h, which put together of course make "a sh" sound - never
"an sh" sound.
I have no idea if I have explained it any better this time, I wish that I had never highlighted the fact that I said "an ess" rather than "a es", especially as it had nothing to do with the point I was trying to make - it just made it even more confusing ☺ so apologies again GaryLurcher19!

Grendel90 · 22/01/2022 22:28

I am from South Yorkshire and I pronounce one to rhyme with gone. My partner is from London/Surrey and we have been together for over 10 years, and I have never noticed a difference in the way we pronounce the word one, although I’ve obviously noticed plenty of other differences in the way we pronounce things over the years.

Prompted by this thread I asked him to say ‘one and gone’ to test if they rhymed in his accent and it turns out they don’t, he pronounces one more like ‘wun’ as many on this thread do.

When I was actively listening out for the difference, I could hear it, but I have never noticed it before in the whole time we’ve been together, so to all those who are really shocked to discover the other way of pronouncing one to theirs(on either side of the debate), you’ve probably heard people pronounce it the other way loads of times and just never actually noticed it because the difference is actually a lot less stark when said out loud than when you see it written down like on this thread

HaveringWavering · 22/01/2022 22:12

All this talk of people saying that “gone” is like “one with a g in front” just put me in mind of Mrs Doyle “Have a cup of tea father- gwan, gwan, gwan, gwan!”

HaveringWavering · 22/01/2022 22:08

In my accent (Scottish)

Dawn, Lawn, Gone, Shone
Zone, Phone, Moan
One, Won, Sun, Bun

PugInTheHouse · 22/01/2022 21:53

In the US shone and dawn would rhyme, also maybe one and gone depending on the accent.

For me (Southern UK) shone rhymes with on. Zone rhymes with cone/home. One does not rhyme with gone, for me it rhymes with gun!

cafedesreves · 22/01/2022 21:46

www.wordreference.com/enfr/shorn

Here you can find "shorn" in loads of different pronunciations (drop down menu at the top).

www.wordreference.com/enfr/shone

And here is "shone".

www.wordreference.com/enfr/one

And here is one!

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2022 21:32

@DaisyWaldron

When people say that "shorn" and "dawn" rhyme, it feels as odd as if someone insisted that "three" and "France" start with the same sound. I mean, I know that some people pronounce them the same, but it's jarring to think that they don't even have a mental concept of the difference.
can you do the phonics for them?
etulosba · 22/01/2022 20:36

I have lived in the South, the Midlands and now the North.

Where on earth do these shone/one rhymers live

In all the areas that you have mentioned. I have lived in them too.

singlenamestar · 22/01/2022 20:31

@SleepingStandingUp

Neither.

Dawn, Horn, Lawn
Zone, Phone, Moan
Shone, Gone, One,

Yes this
stockpilingallthecheese · 22/01/2022 20:29

@Phrowzunn

😂 I can’t cope with people thinking ‘horn’ and ‘corn’ rhyme with ‘dawn’..?! Also, in what universe does ‘one’ rhyme with ‘gone’?!
Where are you from? In the SE England, or at least for every person I know here, that's exactly how we speak Grin
DaisyWaldron · 22/01/2022 20:19

When people say that "shorn" and "dawn" rhyme, it feels as odd as if someone insisted that "three" and "France" start with the same sound. I mean, I know that some people pronounce them the same, but it's jarring to think that they don't even have a mental concept of the difference.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 22/01/2022 20:18

@crazyjinglist

I’ve only ever rhymed one with gone and can’t imagine saying it as ‘wun’ unless I was putting on an accent!*

But surely the fact that you would say 'wun' if you were putting on an accent means that you are aware that it's pronounced 'wun' in different accents? Confused

In the interest of research, I just watched the beginning of Chesney Hawkes singing 'The One and Only' and he definitely sings 'wun'. Like most pop stars he sings in a vaguely American accent anyway, and no American I've ever heard rhymes 'one' with 'gone'!

I've just gone to listen to this, I love it and listen to it a lot anyway Grin

To me, he's 💯 saying one to rhyme with gone. It's not that mind blowing that people say things differently but it is mind blowing that we're each using the same thing as evidence of different things.

Also interesting that you say he sings with a vaguely American accent. I particularly like it because he pronounces can't properly. Ha.

lavender2022 · 22/01/2022 20:18

@Thethingswedoforlove

Neither/ it rhymes with gone
This
FlaviaAlbiaWantsLangClegBack · 22/01/2022 20:17

Hang on, I think I worded my post badly
I don't mean one, fun, gone, scone and shone all rhyme with each other, I mean in sets. So the same as crazy
one and fun rhyme
gone, shone and scone rhyme

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2022 20:00

@NiceTwin

How the hell does shone and one rhyme?

This is fascinating how people must hear things differently as I have never heard shone pronounced as one would be. I have lived in the South, the Midlands and now the North.

Where on earth do these shone/one rhymers live?

I'm West Midlands

sh-on (shone)
w-on (one)
g-on (gone)

b-oh-n (bone)
ph-oh-n (phone)
l-oh-n (lone)
sc-oh-n (scone)

FlaviaAlbiaWantsLangClegBack · 22/01/2022 19:52

It's funny that you and LizBennet rhyme it with different ones catswhisky Smile keeps things interesting.

We can take this outside crazy except that I have to wrestle DS2 into bed now and he and DS1 are hiding out with nerf guns to avoid this fate. I may be some time.

Thelittleweasel · 22/01/2022 19:47

Dawn = shorn! [Sorry]

Catswhisky · 22/01/2022 19:46

*your

Catswhisky · 22/01/2022 19:45

[quote FlaviaAlbiaWantsLangClegBack]Im baffled @Catswhisky, here’s my Shawn and shorn voca.ro/17CDdCFIhLbS[/quote]
Both of mine sound like you’re second one.

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 19:39

Ok I took a break from this and am now a glass or two of wine to the good. So I was thinking of settling back into the thread with a relaxed attitude....

And then @FlaviaAlbiaWantsLangClegBack ( - hi Flavia) has to go and bring scones into the mix Shock . That's fighting talk. Scones always cause trouble.

You rhyme shone, one and gone and I rhyme shone and scone and one and fun

I don't even know where to start with that...

gone, scone and shone rhyme (with don)
one and fun rhyme

LizBennet · 22/01/2022 19:33

[quote FlaviaAlbiaWantsLangClegBack]Im baffled @Catswhisky, here’s my Shawn and shorn voca.ro/17CDdCFIhLbS[/quote]
I pronounce both Shawn and Shorn like the first example in that clip.

HappyDays40 · 22/01/2022 19:30

Neither of those it rhymes with 'don'