Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does shone rhyme with dawn or zone?

764 replies

youdialwetile · 22/01/2022 03:16

DD has been told she's saying it wrong - may be both as used in different places?

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 22/01/2022 08:08

Once more for those at the back:

Different accents pronounce things differently. This is okay. It is normal. It is allowed. It has been the case for our entire history. There's no need to get personally affronted or baffled by it. As a Scot married to an Englishman, we have lots of differences in how we pronounce things. Neither is right or wrong.

And yes I'm Scottish and where I'm from one would never rhyme with gone, it would sound extremely odd in my accent to say it like that, like I was putting on a comedy voice. That doesn't mean it's wrong; it's just not how it's pronounced where I am. No need for Confused faces. Try listening to people from other places and walks of life; it's illuminating Grin

BertieBotts · 22/01/2022 08:08

OMG. It is absolutely nuts on these kinds of threads when people indignantly insist that certain pronunciations are 'just plain wrong' when they are simply regional.

You don't need to take it so seriously :o We do know that. It's just hyperbole for comedic effect (but it does genuinely feel like "how in the hell could you pronounce it like that??!!)

I do find it funny though how we all clearly hear a multitude of pronunciations every day and mentally transliterate it to the one that we personally use.

If you have a toddler in the house it's even funnier if you stop and think about it. You get so used to their letter/sound substitutions that their speech is completely normal to you even though someone outside the family finds it incomprehensible.

ThreeLocusts · 22/01/2022 08:08

Fascinating. I'm not a native speaker but have lived in a variety of Anglophone countries for over 20 years. I always thought it rhymed with zone. Not sure why though.

HeronLanyon · 22/01/2022 08:07

One is wun for me too. I think I have a tiny shade of won in it.
I’ve been saying it out loud with my coffee and now feel I have had a successful full rewarding day.

UtopiaMist · 22/01/2022 08:06

With gone, but I have noticed that in American podcasts they pronounce shone to with zone.

IncompleteSenten · 22/01/2022 08:04

Won is wun where I'm from.

HeronLanyon · 22/01/2022 08:04

In my accent (uk - south - old RP) shone rhymes with the way I say
Wan
Gone (approx)
Bon (bon bon bon appétit wtc)
Non
Etc

So neither of your options.

Hobbesmanc · 22/01/2022 08:04

Do people really say BBC wun?

Shone. Gone. One. Scone
Done shun fun won
Shawn born dawn quorn
Cone moan phone

BertieBotts · 22/01/2022 08:04

Won also rhymes with gone Confused Why would it be said like wun?

IncompleteSenten · 22/01/2022 08:03

One, gone, non, bon, shone.

Inertia · 22/01/2022 08:03

Shone rhymes with on (shon ) when used as the past tense of shine .

However, where we live it’s also a surname and in that case it’s pronounced with the long o sound (like shown).

Enb76 · 22/01/2022 08:02

Won and one rhyme otherwise this would not work:

1 1 was a racehorse
2 2 was 1 2
2 2 1 1 race and
1 1 1 1 2

This is a similar reason to why I know forehead rhymes with horrid.

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 08:02

OMG. It is absolutely nuts on these kinds of threads when people indignantly insist that certain pronunciations are 'just plain wrong' when they are simply regional.

OP - did I gather that you're Scottish but living in the US? In which case teachers shouldn't be trying to eradicate your child's accent by telling them it's 'wrong'. 'Shone' is definitely pronounced 'shown' in some American accents, but that doesn't mean it should be by everyone!

Fwiw I live in NW England now, but lived almost all my life in the SE (London, Home Counties). For me, shone rhymes with gone. One us pronounced 'wun'.

But seriously- what is with all you people saying regional accents are 'wrong'?! Or that you've never heard people pronounce things that way? Have you never stepped outside your region or switched on the tv or the radio?!

butterpuffed · 22/01/2022 08:00

When you count , one two three, does it sound like wun two three ?😂😂

Yes, of course

MrsMop1964 · 22/01/2022 08:00

@Monty27

Depends on the accents I guess. Even Shakespearean poetry doesn't always rhyme. It's not what poetry's about anyway. IMHO.
It possibly did in the original pronunciation. If you like that sort of thing search Shakespeare in OP or watch
LavenderAskew · 22/01/2022 08:00

Hear. Not flipping here.

LavenderAskew · 22/01/2022 08:00

I think people might here differently. To me this (dictionary) sounds like wu-on

dictionary.cambridge.org/pronunciation/english/one

So not like pun (which is puh-uh-n).

Then again my interpretation of what "wu", "on", "puh", "uh" and "n" might be different.

saraclara · 22/01/2022 07:58

I'm on childcare duty today. My DGDs favourite TV programme is Numberblocks. I'll be back!

I do wonder if the 'one' thing is partly due to selective hearing. And that it's actually most often pronounced somewhere in the middle, so we hear what we expect to hear, based on our education and regional accent.
We need a linguistics expert on that.

DancyNancy · 22/01/2022 07:57

Oh and.....the actual question from OP
To me Shone rhymes with Gone/Con/Don

Waxonwaxoff0 · 22/01/2022 07:57

I'm from the East Midlands. "Shone" rhymes with "gone" and "one". Dawn rhymes with horn/corn. Zone rhymes with own.

LemonViolet · 22/01/2022 07:56

Actually listening to The One Show theme again I think they’re singing:

“Wonnnnnn! Wunnnnn! Wannnnn! Aaaaah, Waaaaahhhhn!”

Inclusive!

DancyNancy · 22/01/2022 07:56

I'm irish so
One = Wun and doesn't rhyme with gone.

Dawn definitely doesn't rhyme with corn or horn here either.
It's funny cause the kids sometimes point it out in story book.

Idea and clear came up in a rhyming story and I was trying to explain to them that accents are different. They were like Confused haha. But then I read it out in an English/American/Australian/my accents so they could see abd they loved that!!

HunterHearstHelmsley · 22/01/2022 07:55

@MattDillonsEyebrows

This thread is twisting my melons!! 🤦‍♀️

‘One’ is rhymed with ‘gone’ in the East Midlands! But it does clear up why some of my Children’s books rhyme ‘one’ with ‘won’, I thought it was just an assonance!

Same in W. Mids. I was trying to get won and one to rhyme.

I could say won to rhyme with one, but one to rhyme with won just sounds odd to my ears!

Geamhradh · 22/01/2022 07:55

@BertieBotts

Hmmmm OK I think maybe it might be a feature of unstressed syllables actually.

If I sit here and say one one one to myself, it's won won won - clear o sound.

But if I start counting quickly and listen to that sound back, the one is not stressed, and the vowel sound used in it is more of a schwa type vowel which would be more usually phonetically written as u.

But that doesn't mean that one is pronounced wun, any more than it means twenty is pronounced twenny, even though I can clearly hear myself saying twenny-two, twenny-three, twenny-four. You know that the second t is not silent, even though it generally gets missed off pronunciation.

That's weak forms in connected speech.

If you say "And????" (as in "your point is???) you'll naturally give that "a" it's normal, English /a/ sound.

If you say "fish and chips" you'll probably use the weak form (as you say, giving the "a" a "schwa")

pinkstinks · 22/01/2022 07:55

Hahah now when Elliot says one two three in the best clip of all Time…
Ancient neanderthal voice

m.youtube.com/watch?v=o589CAu73UM