Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does shone rhyme with dawn or zone?

764 replies

youdialwetile · 22/01/2022 03:16

DD has been told she's saying it wrong - may be both as used in different places?

OP posts:
horseymum · 22/01/2022 14:20

People still don't seem to get that accents vary. In many Scottish accents lawn and corn/horn don't rhyme at all. Spelling in English is also not a reliable indicator of pronunciation. One is on the tricky word list because it is not phonetically regular. If it was, you would saw it 'own'.
We also say poor, paw and pour differently- shocker!

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 22/01/2022 14:20

@Thethingswedoforlove

Neither/ it rhymes with gone
Yes!
tcjotm · 22/01/2022 14:18

@Lightstoobright

They're completely different sounds OP.

Zone: own / cone / known / tone / flown

Shone: one / con / on / don /

Dawn: yawn / fawn / horn / corn

I agree with these except ‘one’ is the odd one out in that line. It’s a different sound to on/con/don

My first thought was shone and John

Grilledaubergines · 22/01/2022 14:09

[quote HaveringWavering]@Grilledaubergines
@aSofaNearYou

I’ve lost track of who is saying what because of all the quoting.

Let me get this straight.

  1. You are both from the South of England and have lived there all your lives. However this still covers a massive area.
  1. GA says that she has never in her life heard “one” and “gone” pronounced (by a fellow local) in a way that rhymes.
  1. ASNY says that everyone around her rhymes them, and that you hear it all over the BBC as well.

So, three things could be happening here:

A. Each of these posters is hearing different sounds local to them ie there is more regional variation than they thought.

B. They are both hearing the same thing but their brains are processing it differently.

C. They are confusing each other with the way they are trying to represent sounds in writing (“won” “wun” etc) and they actually agree. Possibly it’s the way they say/hear “gone” that is more variable than “one”?

Can we resolve it like this? Can each of you find a clip(s) of someone saying “one” and “gone” that sounds like you hear them?

I’ll declare my bias- in my Scottish accent “gone” does not rhyme with “gun”, but “one” does rhyme with “gun”. In my accent “gone” rhymes with “on”.[/quote]
Grin I think you’ve summed it up very well!

I’m really not trying to be difficult about it but genuinely don’t hear it any other way. If I visit family or friends much further north then obviously it is noticeable that there are differences in pronunciation but neither is right or wrong. If we have different accents then words will sound different. It’s simple(ish!)

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2022 14:09

I hear one Andy only to rhyme with gone and only so I think it's that thing of your brain translating

FlaviaAlbiaWantsLangClegBack · 22/01/2022 14:07

@Catswhisky

Mind blown.

Shone, one, gone here. They’re spelt the same so find it weird they wouldn’t be said the same. Having said that one and won are the same sound to me.

Also struggling to make Shaun and shorn sound different.

Fascinating stuff.

I’m fascinated, since I’m the opposite and can’t make them sound the same, do you reckon we pronounce any of them the same or would my Shawn not sound like either your Shawn or shorn? Thereby making it even more complicated Grin
Pedalpushers · 22/01/2022 14:06

My mind is blown re. 'One'. I'm a goner and yes I am Northern. However, I am also very keen to point out that Northern English is historically more 'correct' than RP in that it came first.

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 13:55

I’ve only ever rhymed one with gone and can’t imagine saying it as ‘wun’ unless I was putting on an accent!*

But surely the fact that you would say 'wun' if you were putting on an accent means that you are aware that it's pronounced 'wun' in different accents? Confused

In the interest of research, I just watched the beginning of Chesney Hawkes singing 'The One and Only' and he definitely sings 'wun'. Like most pop stars he sings in a vaguely American accent anyway, and no American I've ever heard rhymes 'one' with 'gone'!

SweetPotatoDumpling · 22/01/2022 13:48

Well my name is Dawn and I can ASSURE YOU ALL that it absolutely DOES rhyme with corn, horn, worn, lawn, prawn...I mean I've put up with Horny Dawnie and Dawn The Prawn for bloody years, so 🤷‍♀️🤣

nevergoesaway · 22/01/2022 13:38

This thread has been a revelation, I’ve only ever rhymed one with gone and can’t imagine saying it as ‘wun’ unless I was putting on an accent! Where I’m from it’s a very noticeable ‘o’ sound in it.

Also, bizarrely I feel like I’ve only ever heard others say “BBC ONE” on tv the same as I do but I’m wondering if I’ve heard it differently to others. And to my ears, Chesney Hawkes is definitely singing “the ONE and only” to rhyme with gone not won!

Catswhisky · 22/01/2022 12:32

Mind blown.

Shone, one, gone here. They’re spelt the same so find it weird they wouldn’t be said the same. Having said that one and won are the same sound to me.

Also struggling to make Shaun and shorn sound different.

Fascinating stuff.

LapinR0se · 22/01/2022 12:19

I would be here for hours transcribing regional pronunciations of one…

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2022 11:50

@pinkstripeycat Love the posters who are saying one and gone rhyme. They must be from the north

@HunterHearstHelmsley Depends where in the Midlands! I'm black country and one and gone rhyme for me and a lot of people I know

Agree Hunter. Me too. The "Midlands" is a huge area with a vast variety of pronunciations. Even in the West Midlands there's a huge mix. Just like the North.

When our kids are taught to read one at school they'll be taught to sight read it as it doesn't work with phonics and it rhymes with gone. If somewhere else pronounces it differently, it isn't wrong, it's just part of our rich cultural diversity. Who invaded who and who won (rhymes with Bun) etc.

Those who have never heard any word pronounced differently to how they say it must have very sheltered lives. Here's a shocker. In some areas, poorly rhymes with Julie

saraclara · 22/01/2022 11:44

@ShowOfHands the exact same word had me mocked (fortunately not bullied) when I left Derby!

I had to learn to to say tung instead of tong pretty quickly.
When I had kids down here in the south, it felt so weird to me that I had children that said grahss and bahth!

LucyFox · 22/01/2022 11:41

teacher says it's like zone...cone ...phone

Are you sure she means shone rhymes with zone/cone/phone?
Shown (past tense of show - she was shown to her room, he was shown a green china vase) definitely rhymes with zone/cone/phone but shone is a different word that relates to light (the sun shone, she shone the torch/flashlight 🔦 round the dark room) and DEFINITELY rhymes with con

LizBennet · 22/01/2022 11:34

Ah sorry ShowOfHands, I can see you did make it clear why you were linking the video.

BertieBotts · 22/01/2022 11:30

English vowels in general are nuts aren't they.

BertieBotts · 22/01/2022 11:29

The idea that "he won a prize" and won-ton have different pronunciations of won is really tickling me as it is confusing so many of the won/one/wun explanations :o

Somebody is going to come out in a minute and claim that son and sun are not homophones. (Surely won is not pronounced wun in the same way that son is pronounced sun?)

ShowOfHands · 22/01/2022 11:26

I only linked Claire Foy on GN as an example of somebody who - in their native accent - rhymes one with gone for all those people who claim they're completely unfamiliar with the concept. We all know the queen's accent is remarkable.

I was born in the Midlands and my parents moved when I was still little. They worked hard to make sure I didn't have the accent they did because my brother (school age when we moved) was being teased mercilessly and finding it unbearable. My accent is pretty much RP except for a couple of notable exceptions. One rhymes with gone is one of them. I also had to actively work to undo my pronunciation of tongue after the school bully punched me square in the stomach aged 7 and threatened to do so every time I said it in my faint South Derbys accent.

inheritancetrack · 22/01/2022 11:24

It rhymes with gone

aSofaNearYou · 22/01/2022 11:21

@RandomLondoner

I’ve never heard anyone say one to rhyme with gone/don. In fact I just played the beginning of the One Show and Rylan clearly says ‘welcome to the wun Show on BBC wun’ So, ‘one’ rhyming with sun and fun.^

In response to this I've just listened to the exact same thing, and what he says does not rhyme with sun and fun. it's much closer to gone. (Though he is speaking quickly so it's not the best example for resolving this. We need someone speaking more slowly and deliberately. Though ultimately it won't prove anything, as clearly there is more than one pronunciation, dependent on accent.)

For me. shone, one and gone all have the same sound.

I have tried a couple of pronuciation guides, and the only time "one" sounded like "wun" was in the american pronunciation on one site. (Though I can believe it does, in some British accents.)

Yes I had the same experience. Though also Rylan does not have an RP accent so he isn't the best example.

But yes I definitely find all teaching guides and people speaking with RP accents on TV do support one = gone. Doesn't surprise me some say it differently but it does surprise me how adamant they are that that is standard.

Sparkl · 22/01/2022 11:14

I love these threads!

Especially the ‘I’ve never heard it Any Other Way’ comments Grin

I guess you’ve never left the village then!

thegreylady · 22/01/2022 11:10

Sun does not rhyme with dawn or don.
It rhymes with bun.

thegreylady · 22/01/2022 11:08

Shone gone
Dawn lawn
Zone phone
There are other examples of course but these are the simplest.

ScrollingLeaves · 22/01/2022 11:05

I meant ‘shone’ rhymes with ‘Don’

Swipe left for the next trending thread