Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does shone rhyme with dawn or zone?

764 replies

youdialwetile · 22/01/2022 03:16

DD has been told she's saying it wrong - may be both as used in different places?

OP posts:
cafedesreves · 22/01/2022 15:39

Rhymes with don, gone, con, John

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 15:38

I'm sure I've heard that British English has a very very wide range of accent variation for the size of country. Eg we have as much variation within a country a third the size of Texas & a quarter the population, as they do in the US.

That's very interesting! I'm guessing that's because English developed over a much longer time from Anglo Saxon and other languages and dialects in the British Isles, whereas English and other languages spoken in the US were 'imported' fully-formed much later? Maybe.

aSofaNearYou · 22/01/2022 15:37

@crazyjinglist

Yes, but you could say the same in reverse and all the "wun" lot have been hearing people say it the other way for years! It isn't spelt that way, that's for sure...

I agree, the reverse is true. The spelling is pretty much irrelevant though. I mean - how do you pronounce the 'o' in woman, women, won etc? Besides, if you pronounced 'one' how it's spelled, why wouldn't it be just as likely to rhyme with phone?

On the subject of whether it's more to do with how we're hearing it, can anyone tell me if they hear this as wun?

dictionary.cambridge.org/pronunciation/english/one

Because this sounds like how I say it and it definitely rhymes with gone to me.

That 100% rhymes with 'sun' to me. In fact even more so than most examples I've heard!

Yes I agree spelling can be somewhat moot, but given there's no decisive answer to which is the "right" way, it does tip the favour a little to me. It's quite bizarre for that letter to have anything to do with an "u" sound.

Interesting that you hear that as rhyming with sun, definitely shows that it is in the hearing that people are getting different answers.

Pemba · 22/01/2022 15:35

@aSofaNearYou yes on that clip I hear the speaker saying 'one' to rhyme with 'gone'. And she has a fairly posh Southern accent. Do other people hear something different?

Plantstrees · 22/01/2022 15:35

Shone, one, gone, won and scone all rhyme for me on the English south coast with what is usually considered a posh accent.

nevergoesaway · 22/01/2022 15:34

My brain not Brian.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2022 15:34

@crazyjinglist

Wun two three? wun two three???

Yes, wun two three! Perfectly normal!

Oh btw how do you pronounce 'won' - as in 'he won a prize'? Grin

He w-un a prize for being number w-on
nevergoesaway · 22/01/2022 15:34

@crazyjinglist

I’ve only ever rhymed one with gone and can’t imagine saying it as ‘wun’ unless I was putting on an accent!*

But surely the fact that you would say 'wun' if you were putting on an accent means that you are aware that it's pronounced 'wun' in different accents? Confused

In the interest of research, I just watched the beginning of Chesney Hawkes singing 'The One and Only' and he definitely sings 'wun'. Like most pop stars he sings in a vaguely American accent anyway, and no American I've ever heard rhymes 'one' with 'gone'!

Yes I’m aware of other accents very much so, but it would be a very affected, posh accent if I said it like that. Not like anyone I know or my experience of tv and films. However like I say, I’m thinking maybe my hearing is messed up, or more accurately my Brian is skewed and biased and is interpreting it in a different way to how it’s been said!!

I listened again to Chesney, and it sometimes sounds like ‘wOn’ and sometimes like ‘wUn’ Grin

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 15:33

Yes, but you could say the same in reverse and all the "wun" lot have been hearing people say it the other way for years! It isn't spelt that way, that's for sure...

I agree, the reverse is true. The spelling is pretty much irrelevant though. I mean - how do you pronounce the 'o' in woman, women, won etc? Besides, if you pronounced 'one' how it's spelled, why wouldn't it be just as likely to rhyme with phone?

On the subject of whether it's more to do with how we're hearing it, can anyone tell me if they hear this as wun?

dictionary.cambridge.org/pronunciation/english/one

Because this sounds like how I say it and it definitely rhymes with gone to me.

That 100% rhymes with 'sun' to me. In fact even more so than most examples I've heard!

OfstedOffred · 22/01/2022 15:31

I'm sure I've heard that British English has a very very wide range of accent variation for the size of country. Eg we have as much variation within a country a third the size of Texas & a quarter the population, as they do in the US

OfstedOffred · 22/01/2022 15:29

My friend from derby wouldnt rhyme one and gone.

"One" would be a very short "wun", "gone" would be a longer sound, almost approaching "garn".

aSofaNearYou · 22/01/2022 15:25

But if you're thinking it's something to do with how people are hearing it, you probably have heard people say 'wun', you just haven't heard it as 'wun'!

Yes, but you could say the same in reverse and all the "wun" lot have been hearing people say it the other way for years! It isn't spelt that way, that's for sure...

stripeyflowers · 22/01/2022 15:25

Shone, gone, one.

Yes - one! Only ever rhymed one with gone. Never rhymed it with sun. Confused

Am from West Midland if that helps.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 22/01/2022 15:25

@Toothsil

I'm so confused by the people saying "one" rhymes with gone!
But they do rhyme! Confused
aSofaNearYou · 22/01/2022 15:24

On the subject of whether it's more to do with how we're hearing it, can anyone tell me if they hear this as wun?

dictionary.cambridge.org/pronunciation/english/one

Because this sounds like how I say it and it definitely rhymes with gone to me.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 22/01/2022 15:21

@SleepingStandingUp

Neither.

Dawn, Horn, Lawn
Zone, Phone, Moan
Shone, Gone, One,

This
crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 15:21

I think it could be something do to with how people are hearing it. I also wondered if it could be somewhat of a generational thing, maybe "wun" used to be more common and I'm of a younger demographic than the people from my area who say it, because I've honestly never heard anyone say that.

But if you're thinking it's something to do with how people are hearing it, you probably have heard people say 'wun', you just haven't heard it as 'wun'!

I don't think it's a generational thing. I'm a teacher, so I hear a lot of young people talking too much.

SpinsForGin · 22/01/2022 15:20

@Toothsil

I'm so confused by the people saying "one" rhymes with gone!
Have never you met a someone from Manchester?
SpinsForGin · 22/01/2022 15:19

@Phrowzunn

😂 I can’t cope with people thinking ‘horn’ and ‘corn’ rhyme with ‘dawn’..?! Also, in what universe does ‘one’ rhyme with ‘gone’?!
In my northern universe! One and gone rhyme for me!
Toothsil · 22/01/2022 15:17

I'm so confused by the people saying "one" rhymes with gone!

aSofaNearYou · 22/01/2022 15:16

@crazyjinglist

One: Rhymes with bun/Dun/Sun down here in the SE!

It doesn't in Oxfordshire.

It did when I lived in Oxfordshire (for 16 years).

The only possible explanation is that people are hearing it differently, since people are giving exactly the same examples (e.g. specific songs) and sone think it sounds one way and some the other.

I just asked my teen dc (originally southerners, but have lived in the NW for 7 years) without giving them my opinionor any background to the question. They both said 'wun' of course and looked baffled that anyone would think otherwise!

Well your own kids aren't the best people to ask as they likely say it the same as you, I asked my dad and he said it like gone, same as me.

I think it could be something do to with how people are hearing it. I also wondered if it could be somewhat of a generational thing, maybe "wun" used to be more common and I'm of a younger demographic than the people from my area who say it, because I've honestly never heard anyone say that.

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 15:15

So you’re not weird but maybe have a better ear?

Hmm maybe. I'm a language teacher, which probably helps! It might also make me a bit more tolerant and less insistent about things only being correct when they're pronounced in one particular way, I guess. I spend my time hearing people talk in languages they don't speak very well Grin, which contain sounds that don't even exist in their native language!

Plus of course, when you're teaching a foreign language - e.g. Spanish - what regional 'flavour' of Spanish do you teach? I say 'gracias' with a 'th' in the middle, but how can I tell my students it's wrong to say it with a 's' if gazillions of Spanish speakers say it that way?

QueBarbaridad · 22/01/2022 15:10

@tcjotm

So you’re not weird but maybe have a better ear?
Yes, if everyone could do it perfectly there would be no such thing as hypercorrection.
FredtheCatsMum · 22/01/2022 15:09

Nope, rhymes with gone (New Zealander, lived in London a long time)

crazyjinglist · 22/01/2022 15:07

One: Rhymes with bun/Dun/Sun down here in the SE!

It doesn't in Oxfordshire.

It did when I lived in Oxfordshire (for 16 years).

The only possible explanation is that people are hearing it differently, since people are giving exactly the same examples (e.g. specific songs) and sone think it sounds one way and some the other.

I just asked my teen dc (originally southerners, but have lived in the NW for 7 years) without giving them my opinionor any background to the question. They both said 'wun' of course and looked baffled that anyone would think otherwise!