Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that most people are not aware of the dire staffing crisis in social care.

82 replies

TravellingSpoon · 21/01/2022 22:14

I work in social care and have amazing colleagues across a range of services, however every single one without fail is short staffed, some dangerously so and they are not able to recruit staff to fill the tens of thousands of vacancies across the whole sector.

Its a perfect storm of staff burnout, low wages, covid, mandatory vaccinations and brexit.

I work in the community and our team is covering care provider handbacks as well as our normal caseload. These are cases that care providers just can't cover due to staffing issues.

Another concern is that some companies are becoming so desperate they are employing people who are not fit for the job. They don't have the skills or the right attitude for the job.

I love the job I do and couldn't imagine working in another sector, but to me it feels like its on the brink, and it never gets the same sort of love that the NHS gets, the handwringing and the campaigning.

OP posts:
dannydyerismydad · 22/01/2022 11:55

I think people are aware, but don't give it headspace unless it affects them.

Care work is vastly underpaid and undervalued.

LakieLady · 22/01/2022 11:54

@bloodywhitecat and @tophonetheGP, I'm so sorry you're going through this. Flowers

And to every MN'er who voted for this shite, I hope you're pleased with yourselves. This is down to you. Own it.

LakieLady · 22/01/2022 11:46

@YeOldeTrout

Staffing crisis in social care has been in the news a lot in last 10 years, and was a talking point in 2016 referendum... people just don't pay attention or want to remember.
Or they did pay attention, but fell for the Brexit lies about "Project Fear" and are embarrassed to admit it.
Topbird29 · 22/01/2022 11:28

I guess they need to pay regular staff a decent wage, get enough to cover shifts and retain them. The job just isn't attractive enough to make people want to start / stay. I know agency/ bank staff costs are higher - surely by having better pay for your staff generally, you could cut down the times you need the agency cover (and those higher costs). And having no care spaces (due to lack of staff), then also impacts on nhs costs as people in hospital can't leave, so block the beds, costing the nhs ££ too. The government really need to see it all as part of the same problem to be fixed and give proper money and thought towards this. But they won't as they don't care enough about it.

Nat6999 · 22/01/2022 10:55

Social care was in a mess before Covid, my ex husband has carers 4 times a day, he should have a 1 hour call in a morning for shower, dressing, meds, breakfast, 2 × 20 minutes calls for lunch + meds & tea + meds & a 30 minute call for meds + undress +bed. He has been lucky to get showered once a week because the carers were too busy, they sometimes don't turn up for his breakfast call until 11.00am which messes his meds up & would turn up at 6.00pm to put him to bed. He needs to be showered every day because he has a suprapubic catheter & the site needs to be kept super clean, he has been admitted to hospital 5 times during the pandemic for infections.

The biggest problem with social care is that councils are only prepared to pay nmw for home social care so a lot of the carers just aren't up to the job. They contract the care out to private providers who don't train the carers properly, it should be brought back in house to councils.

Lex345 · 22/01/2022 10:45

It is a massive problem. The problem started quite some time ago-LA rates for care were below the actual cost of providing care to the person, so homes were forced to charge more for private residents to balance the books. The profit margin in a home actually providing good care was razor thin even a couple of years ago. Small enough in fact that even an extra agency staff bill could wipe it out. Retention has always been a problem and if you are properly recruiting and training people for probabionary periods (and using this properly to assess suitably and inevitably letting some go) there are costs attached to this too. Then Brexit caused more vacancies to recruit into. Then COVID decimated the sector, for 2 reasons-1) Staffing and additional costs and 2) Increased vacancies in homes

This was ignored whilst everyone was out clapping. At the worst, our agency bill for a small independent home for one month was £50,000 to keep everyone safe and the amount spent on masks (when no one could get them via pandemic stock) was £5,000 a month. Our occupancy at that stage was 21 residents, paying approx £760/week-mostly less than this. That means after the agency bill and masks (not even other PPE),there was £8840 to pay regular staff, food, bills etc etc.

It is chronically under funded and was always one crisis away from this. I am deeply worried for my colleagues still in the sector.

Lampzade · 22/01/2022 10:44

My niece works in a care home. She is at university so only works twelve hours a week. On her days off she is often harassed by the care home managers who want her to do overtime which is impossible as she is a full time student.
She is a lovely caring young lady but has told her parents that she does not want to work in the care home as there have been a number of occasions whereby she has been left to care for up to fifteen service users by herself. This includes providing personal care, feeding etc. The service users all have dementia .
This is a care home which cost £1350+ a week. My niece earns under £9
an hour.
She is looking for a job in a supermarket.

tophonetheGP · 22/01/2022 10:43

YANBU - had a meeting for DM two weeks ago, 15 people agree she needs 24/7 care - then social worker shrugged and said, it doesn’t exist .

She’s now living with her mother, 82, (who also needs care to be honest) - a carer comes round for 90 mins a day to make sure mum gets a wash at least .

Sister 28 is in supported living (autism, epilepsy, ID and mental health), they can’t get carers for her either so they’re now doing pyjamas and bedtime routine before dinner as no time otherwise - and can’t leave the house often at all as need 1:1 staff for that . What makes it worse is all of sister’s day services were stoped in March 2020 and council are saying are if they restart them they can no longer afford to run them except for the most profoundly disabled . So she’s spending her days doing nothing but watching TV indoors .

betwixtlives · 22/01/2022 10:42

Yanbu it’s scary

bloodywhitecat · 22/01/2022 10:32

I am more than aware. In the past I worked in paediatric complex care, we provided care in the family home and we were always running below full staffing capacity even then. Now I am living it as DH needs care and we are forever struggling as his carers are over worked and under staffed. Living the care crisis is hell and it will forever taint my memories of his last months of life. I know things won't get better and he is slowly dying and every day I feel I have failed him a little bit more.

Mickarooni · 22/01/2022 10:32

Some people are aware but they seem not to care. The only quality of care isn’t even on the radar for many people.

JanuaryBluehoo · 22/01/2022 10:28

Oh and the bigger scandal issue forcing incredibly ill miserable terminally ill people to live long after they should have been allowed to die peaceful and in dignity.

JanuaryBluehoo · 22/01/2022 10:26

Yes lots of places seem to be run by faceless unaccounble companies who have no inclination or business in care?
They are allowed to cut every cost and treat staff like crap etc.

I don't know what the answer is without opening it all up and making it as transparent as possible with trip advisor style feedback.
Min rates of pay in care, on going training and innovation etc.

ChakaFridaMendips · 22/01/2022 10:22

It’s a massive scandal.

We tried to engage carers privately for a terminally ill patient and there was nothing (nice area with great transport etc). I was utterly shocked. We did manage to get some care through a hospice and they were different every day and has less than 30m to get in and do everything- I have no idea how people alone cope. It used to be a job students would do the odd overnight shift (mainly sleeping and then morning duties when I knew people that did it) so it’s obviously either changed or students are not interested.

We’ve also looked for residential care for a relative with Autism/ vulnerable needs and it’s also impossible.

Socialcarenope · 22/01/2022 10:09

@ThisIsStartingToBoreMe

Blame the greedy grasping money obsessed homecare company owners for taking on more clients than they can accommodate with the staff they've got.

The staff numbers aren't goi g to increase so the only thing to do is decrease the client numbers.

To be fair to them, we (local authorities) put massive pressure on them to pick up packages of care because if they don't, then we as the LA aren't fulfilling our statutory duty (the law is clear that lack of available provision is not an excuse not to provide support).

Where I work we have over 100 people waiting for care. These people sometimes have a bit of paid for care but need more, others have no care at all and are waiting weeks and weeks for care.

People are being discharged from hospital with no care because we can't provide it.

Care agencies with better rates of pay are not in a better position. We are currently utilising ALL cqc registered agencies, including those which charge almost double our usual rate, but they are are also struggling to find staff.

The amount of safeguarding referrals for inadequate care in care homes is increasing and the number of people being evicted from a care home because they "can't meet their needs" is also increasing, because of staffing issues.

I want out of social work because I can't see it getting better and people are already dying.

maggienolia · 22/01/2022 10:03

Agree 1000%.
8 years in home care here, nvq 3 qualified.

In a month I will be leaving the sector.
It's the poor pay, calls being packed tighter and tighter with no time to give clients the time they need. Add to that inadequate travel time, 15 minutes to do a 25 minute drive, and asked why you're late when you get there.
It's the wear on your car, and on you too. It's all that and more.
My new job is days only. And boy am I ready for it.
Until carers are paid a decent wage and treated like humans not spaces on a rota to be crammed in this will only get worse.

CorpusCallosum · 22/01/2022 10:00

It's awful. I work with young disabled adults and have always been proud of the care & support opportunities in our area. Now, even the basics aren't available most of the time.

Families are under enormous strain, begging for support and there just isn't any. So many good providers are short staffed & some haven't been open to new referrals for years.

The social workers are on their knees, care providers are doing their best, young people and their families are being failed. 😢

Toomanypeople · 22/01/2022 09:43

The company I work for has cut people's visit times to allow the staff to go to more people in a shift. It's awful as anyone who has done the job knows you never get enough tike with each person as it is. Losing staff due to burnout as well as those who are off sick or isolating. I've worked in care for 20 years and seen many staff shortages but never as bad as now

Pasdelacasa · 22/01/2022 09:26

I witnessed this myself for the first time last year when a loved one was at the end of his life (cancer). In the last weeks of his life he couldn’t be discharged from hospital for several weeks because there was a shortage of carers, so he spent much of his last weeks of life on a busy ward, with very little care and mostly alone due to strict visiting hours.

When he was finally discharged, the carers who turned up were newly recruited, had zero experience and hadn’t been briefed on his needs. It was a disaster. I felt sorry for them, to be honest, as they obviously just needed a job and had no idea what they were turning up to - a very, very sick man who couldn’t stand, feed himself, wash himself etc. They were like rabbits in a headlight and didn’t turn up after Day 2 Sad.

He finally got a place in a hospice and died a few days later, thankfully well cared for and with loved ones close. But his last few weeks haunt me. The care just wasn’t there.

awesomekilick · 22/01/2022 09:24

Shouldn't have left the EU. Shouldn't have voted Tory. What the absolute fuck did people think was going to happen to care homes? We're going back 100 years as a country to survival only if you have money, and/or connections, and tough luck on the rest.

It's absolutely disgraceful and must be horrendous for individuals working in and reliant on care. But we as a nation asked for this. Particularly the old, and white men, who interestingly enough form the majority of Brexit voters www.statista.com/statistics/56 and Tory voters. yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/

Doobydoo · 22/01/2022 09:14

Completely agree op. I have worked in Nursing Homes for years..lots of different ones and they have all been run with the bare minimum of staff. Now it is horrendous.I now work in NHS and trying to get care packages for people to go home is a nitemare..we are a rural county as well.Then when a package is availabĺe we have had referrals back in because carers have not arrived.

TheGoogleMum · 22/01/2022 09:12

I knew there were shortages but perhaps underestimated how bad. We definitely need to be paying carers more to make the job more attractive. It's a difficult and important job worthy of more than minimum wage

Change123today · 22/01/2022 09:10

^they live to far away not get away Blush

Change123today · 22/01/2022 09:08

My grandad requires careers. It was surprising to see the process, private companies providing a ‘service’ unable to even provide a simple rough time in advance for when they are arriving - he has four a day.
I really feel for the carers unsociable hours , driving trying to then find parking! And the pay is shockingly low for the service they provide. To then deal with families expectations- we quite aware of what can be provided but didn’t stop my interfering Aunt deciding to criticise them and being just plain rude to the carers causing them to cancel the contract with my grandparents :(

It’s so hard as all my aunts & uncles still work full time jobs & have caring responsibility for grandchildren and/or live to get away. Then Grandad wouldn’t want any of them to provide the type of care that he now needs. Granny doesn’t want him to go into a home.

I didn’t realise (naively) how carers worked - I stupidly thought they were employed by NHS and was a pool of carers. Finding our it’s in fact a selection of private companies that can close and reopen with a new name. Especially if they have bad reviews! It doesn’t make sense and unless you are aware of it you don’t realise what’s going on.

twominutesmore · 22/01/2022 09:08

To make conditions acceptable to staff in care homes they'd have to charge residents more I guess.