Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that most people are not aware of the dire staffing crisis in social care.

82 replies

TravellingSpoon · 21/01/2022 22:14

I work in social care and have amazing colleagues across a range of services, however every single one without fail is short staffed, some dangerously so and they are not able to recruit staff to fill the tens of thousands of vacancies across the whole sector.

Its a perfect storm of staff burnout, low wages, covid, mandatory vaccinations and brexit.

I work in the community and our team is covering care provider handbacks as well as our normal caseload. These are cases that care providers just can't cover due to staffing issues.

Another concern is that some companies are becoming so desperate they are employing people who are not fit for the job. They don't have the skills or the right attitude for the job.

I love the job I do and couldn't imagine working in another sector, but to me it feels like its on the brink, and it never gets the same sort of love that the NHS gets, the handwringing and the campaigning.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LaBelleSauvage123 · 09/08/2022 09:29

We have a son with autism who has just left school. We were making plans with a support agency to provide respite which will gradually increase to become supported living in 2-3 years time. A team from the agency visited him at home and school to get to know him and all was going well. Yesterday I found out that the team have been relocated to other clients because of a massive staff exodus, so all this preparation time ( and money!) has been wasted and we have to start again.
Meanwhile my dad has just moved into a nursing home. His own home isn’t suitable for someone who can’t walk. The regular staff are great but every weekend they have a skeleton agency staff on and it’s frankly dangerous. They have a number of confused residents ( including my dad) who are regularly trying to get up and walk and most of the time there’s not even anyone in the lounge keeping an eye on them - they’re just passing through. Because they’re so stretched and don’t know the residents, there’s no warmth or compassion there. It’s dire.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 25/07/2022 21:52

The Tory's NI rise was heralded (by Johnson) as "solving social care once and for all". The first thing Liz Truss will do is reverse it.
Shameful excuse for a government.

lastminutedotcom22 · 25/07/2022 21:09

I work for the nhs in a hospital and a lot of the housekeepers, nursing assistants and healthcare support workers are ex care home staff.

Although the NHS is also on its knees if you join the bank in a hospital it's better money per hour with enhanced rates for evenings and weekends, good holiday allowance and the nhs pension and although staffing is stretched there are more benefits to be had.

My friend worked in a nursing home until recently. It was minimum wage day or night and they were so shorted staffed it was dangerous - buzzers all going off and 2 members of staff trying to help 12-15 patients all with dementia. She left in the end it just became un-manageable and she reported them to the quality care commission.

It's a terrible situation and I really feel sorry for people working in this sector

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 25/07/2022 14:46

Huge shortages in my area to the point where they are now ‘working together’ and district nursing teams are now taking on care packages in the interim (I use this term loosely as as soon as they hear DN team are going in they don’t bother sourcing a care package). This is to the detriment of end of life patients, Of which we are seeing a lot more since the pandemic, who can now not get their wish of dying at home as we do not have the capacity due to taking on these care packages

safetyfreak · 25/07/2022 14:42

Can you blame people? care work is so much responsibility and stress for rubbish pay and benefits. Many home carers are on zero hour contracts and leave the sector for more secure work and better pay. It is a shame, as many people do enjoy care work but its just not worth it at the moment.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 22/01/2022 23:10

I used to work in care homes as a nurse, but the conditions just became worse and worse. It's even harder for care staff.

A care home near me has just closed its nursing beds because they can't recruit RNs. They're blaming the agencies because they pay more and you can set your own work pattern.

SweetFelicityArkright · 22/01/2022 22:28

@Saz12

Care work is never going to suit someone who’s in it for the £££. A decent pay rate, a fair contract (hours, overtime, days off, length of shifts, training entitlements, sick pay, pension, holiday entitlement, compassionate leave, maternity, sabbaticals...) all needed. But the biggest is to have enough time to do the job properly- to encourage independence, help with diet/lifestyle, social contact etc. That’s what good carers want to do - not to nip in, haul someone out /in to bed, throw some good at them and ram medication in, sort out incontinence accidents, with a weekly shower if lucky.
This, absolutely this. And recognition that the reason for a lot of bad care is due to lack of resources, not lack of will or bad attitude from the majority of carers. At the moment 9 times out of 10 the care staff take the blame for poor care after being put in impossible positions, they take the flack from the service users, the families and then management and providers when complaints are made. They are written off as unskilled and poorly educated and therefore their concerns aren't listened to, they're blamed for systematic failures, painted as inadequate when most of the time it's the system, lack of resources and lack of time that have led to poor care being delivered.
Saz12 · 22/01/2022 21:58

Care work is never going to suit someone who’s in it for the £££.
A decent pay rate, a fair contract (hours, overtime, days off, length of shifts, training entitlements, sick pay, pension, holiday entitlement, compassionate leave, maternity, sabbaticals...) all needed. But the biggest is to have enough time to do the job properly- to encourage independence, help with diet/lifestyle, social contact etc. That’s what good carers want to do - not to nip in, haul someone out /in to bed, throw some good at them and ram medication in, sort out incontinence accidents, with a weekly shower if lucky.

aramox1 · 22/01/2022 21:44

I think all of us with folk needing care are aware. Sadly that doesn't include the government. Stop voting Tory!

Doobydoo · 22/01/2022 21:39

@Galapie. I would be really interested to know which company you work in. I have worked for a fair few Nursing/ Care home big names( and small ones) over the years as an agency nurse and as non agency nurse. They have all been pretty dire.

TravellingSpoon · 22/01/2022 16:19

@Dustyplumber

Pay rates just need to go up, so care jobs become an attractive career, that's all.
But that is much, much easier said than done.
OP posts:
Dustyplumber · 22/01/2022 15:04

Pay rates just need to go up, so care jobs become an attractive career, that's all.

SweetFelicityArkright · 22/01/2022 14:46

@GalaPie

Do you think part of the reason could be the societal attitude towards the care industry? Many people I talk to about my job say "I couldn't or wouldn't do/put up with that!" The job comes with certain attitudes of not being able to do better, being a low skilled worker because you can't/can't be bothered to 'better' yourself, the stigma that always comes with being a low earner who doesn't need a university education to do it.

Also every employer I've gone to says those things, not one I've worked for has actually delivered in real terms, I pretty much discount those promises in adverts and interviews and focus on the hourly rate and what I see at an interview at that time, I've almost in a way been institutionalised by my experiences in social care as a worker, and until you're in an organisation you don't see if they deliver or not on their promises.

Plus, I found a really good job opportunity with values like your organisation, values I want to be able to uphold in delivering care - they wouldn't give more than 20 hour contracts but said overtime is 'always available' - as much as I would have loved to vote with my feet as an experienced and good carer and work somewhere better, I can't live on 20 hours a week and the uncertainty that I might, one month, have to if overtime is unavailable.

Do you also offer training? Considering the dire state of training in social care, it's unsurprising to me that many people are deemed unsuitable for a role in a place where standards are so much higher than the average, they're likely trained on a shoe string via DVDs and online day courses and in some cases, pay for that themselves.

Places like yours should be the norm, not the exception shouldn't they? Unfortunately they're not though and you're maybe looking for people that don't exist, if they've been trained elsewhere they're unlikely to meet your standards as they've been trained to a much lower expectation.

GalaPie · 22/01/2022 14:12

I have to say that within my organisation budgets are not the issue - and staffing levels won't be dropped if it looks like we are 'coping' on fewer staff. We have a clear vision of what life should look like for our people and how many staff that takes and it wasn't never an issue till about 4 months ago.
We pay well above NLW with regular cash and in kind bonuses, good leave allowance, clear and accountable management structure. Still we cannot recruit new staff. Those interviewed are clearly not right for the job. We have arrangements with 4 local agencies and often none of those can cover shifts.

CHIRIBAYA · 22/01/2022 14:07

There are wider issues here concerning how care homes are structured, namely, often by private equity companies looking for returns on their investments. It is not in their interests to 'care' for residents or to treat their staff as anything other than a statistic on a balance sheet. They have complex company structures often with headquarters in tax havens like the Bahamas. A significant portion of the fees paid by self-funders goes on servicing debts, not on their own care. There are some places where we should have never allowed free markets to run unchecked and this sector is one of them; somebody's basic human needs should not be another's cash cow. How can a society claim to be civilized when it treats care workers and those who rely on them like we do?

Weredone · 22/01/2022 13:28

Over 10 years of a conservative government has led us to this!

OneMoreTimeThen · 22/01/2022 13:25

I managed a residential home for young adults for years, worked my way up from the bottom and loved my job and providing really high standards of care to the people who lived there. We had a brilliant staff team and low staff turnover.
I left in the end because over the years the budget for staffing went down and down gradually, until we couldn't afford to cover sickness and annual leave and the people who lived there weren't getting the person cantered care they deserved. It was always at safe levels (because I would cover) , but just for the basics of them existing. There were not high enough staff ratios for them to go out individually or in small groups. I was covering shifts and popping in to be an extra body so they could go out . As manager I couldn't claim any overtime for this.
I sobbed when I left, but I wasn't willing to do it anymore ,and it was only a matter of time before sickness or an emergency , when I physically couldn't go in to support, meant it was unsafe. I was the Registered Manager and I felt really vulnerable.
I got an office job on not much less than I was on as manager, with M-F 9-5 working . This was over ten years ago, so god knows how it is now.

Socialcarenope · 22/01/2022 13:19

@GalaPie

I work in a supported living setting and we are struggling by shift by shift. I can't remember the last time we were fully staffed for the morning shift. We are a very close knit group and so oftentimes the night staff are waiting on till others can get in for a few hours, staff who live close by are whizzing in to cover meds rounds and meds checks, some are coming in for a couple of hours to cook dinner etc. obviously it's stressful for staff but what saddens us more is the limits it puts into the people we support in terms of what they can do and where they can go. Lots of karaoke parties going on in-house at the moment, and hot dog nights!!
And the problem is that if you continue to meet need at reduced staffing levels management start to think the extra staff are superfluous. But the alternative of actually not meeting need is just unthinkable.
Akire · 22/01/2022 13:04

I keep wondering when the Big Crunch will
Happen. I’be used many carer agency’s for myself over the years pay and conditions also been dreadful. They never wanted employ part time staff say a student on 6-10pm shift it was also some poor sod working 7-7 and getting worn out and you being out bed at 6pm because that’s latest they can do. Business up down country can staff evening shifts but care agency’s can’t.

I used direct payments when we told pay carers £10.50 say 15y ago which was decent ish amount when mim Wage was £5 but that hasn’t gone up at all. Now it’s what 50p over mim wage?

I know many people struggling get home private care to as EU rules mean many just aren’t moving and working here.

Really sad for care homes when pay £1500 month and lucky if get shower once a week it’s criminal. We need take out profit and run as NHS facilities and if fees still don’t cover then Gov pays extra. If they do bring their max lifetime costs in and start pouring money in still can’t see staff getting paid proper wage.

All those HGV drivers suddenly had pick
Of jobs and pay wonder if care sector even get like that? But I’ve been hoping last 20y!

GalaPie · 22/01/2022 12:51

I work in a supported living setting and we are struggling by shift by shift. I can't remember the last time we were fully staffed for the morning shift. We are a very close knit group and so oftentimes the night staff are waiting on till others can get in for a few hours, staff who live close by are whizzing in to cover meds rounds and meds checks, some are coming in for a couple of hours to cook dinner etc.

obviously it's stressful for staff but what saddens us more is the limits it puts into the people we support in terms of what they can do and where they can go. Lots of karaoke parties going on in-house at the moment, and hot dog nights!!

LaBelleSauvage123 · 22/01/2022 12:13

We are in the process of planning our 19 year olds transition to supported living and this terrifies me.

LakieLady · 22/01/2022 12:04

@Nat6999

Social care was in a mess before Covid, my ex husband has carers 4 times a day, he should have a 1 hour call in a morning for shower, dressing, meds, breakfast, 2 × 20 minutes calls for lunch + meds & tea + meds & a 30 minute call for meds + undress +bed. He has been lucky to get showered once a week because the carers were too busy, they sometimes don't turn up for his breakfast call until 11.00am which messes his meds up & would turn up at 6.00pm to put him to bed. He needs to be showered every day because he has a suprapubic catheter & the site needs to be kept super clean, he has been admitted to hospital 5 times during the pandemic for infections.

The biggest problem with social care is that councils are only prepared to pay nmw for home social care so a lot of the carers just aren't up to the job. They contract the care out to private providers who don't train the carers properly, it should be brought back in house to councils.

It's not what councils are prepared to pay, it's what they can afford. And the law requires them to award contracts to the lowest bidder. Bringing it back in-house would require a change to local government procurement rules.

This is, of course, perfectly possible post-Brexit, but I can't somehow see this govt taking advantage of it if that means an increase in public spending.

I'd love to see services brought back into the public sector, but I'm not even sure Starmer's NuLabour would go for that, the Tories never will.

All these things come back to political decisions in the end.

LakieLady · 22/01/2022 11:57

@Topbird29

I guess they need to pay regular staff a decent wage, get enough to cover shifts and retain them. The job just isn't attractive enough to make people want to start / stay. I know agency/ bank staff costs are higher - surely by having better pay for your staff generally, you could cut down the times you need the agency cover (and those higher costs). And having no care spaces (due to lack of staff), then also impacts on nhs costs as people in hospital can't leave, so block the beds, costing the nhs ££ too. The government really need to see it all as part of the same problem to be fixed and give proper money and thought towards this. But they won't as they don't care enough about it.
That might work for private care, where people are self-funding their placements.

But when the cost of care is met by councils, the amount they can pay is restricted and simply not enough to permit homes to pay more.