Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit worried my year 12 DS doesn’t know what degree/job he wants to do?

112 replies

Billfortune · 21/01/2022 17:33

Is it normal for them to not really know what career they want at this stage of year 12. DS is 17 and not sure but also doesn’t really want to talk about or explore options. He’s doing A’levels and wants to go to university so doesn’t he need to be thinking about this now? Feel like I’m being a bit pushy asking him about it when he’s clearly not keen to discuss it at the moment.

OP posts:
Iamnotamermaid · 21/01/2022 23:04

My career did not exist when I was at uni. I had one vague and unrealistic plan - realised it would never happen and sort of fell into my current one.

Go for a general degree - maybe one of the STEM subjects.

blueshoes · 21/01/2022 22:54

How about choosing a well paid career and then working backwards to see what degrees offer entry into it and then see what his interests and skills are and the most suitable degree for him. That should point him in the right direction

This is what I did for law, accountancy and engineering. These days, I would add computer science in the mix. I chose law in the end. Never looked back. Gave me lots of options and the high pay gives my dcs even more options. Who loves their job? If it pays the bills and some, you are already winning.

TheMoth · 21/01/2022 21:39

I wish I'd known it was ok not to know what to want to do in yr12.
I wish I'd known you don't have to rush in to a career in your 20s because the starting salary seems high, but all your mates end up earning more long term
I wish I'd known that office jobs don't have to mean staring at a computer screen all day and that p5 on a rainy Thursday I would kill to be staring ata computer instead of a stand off with some random kids who's popped in to disturb my lesson
I wish someone had told me to go for the money jobs.

RagzRebooted · 21/01/2022 21:25

My year 11 wants to work on politics and my year 10 wants to a police officer. Year 7 did want to be a teacher but realised not liking children (or most people) was a downside and now wants to be a police dog handler! The older two have been set on theirs for years, but I fully expect them to end up doing something completely different.
At 17 I nearly joined the army. Then nearly trained to be a medical herbalist.
Then had DC1 at 20 and didn't decide to go into nursing until my late 20s. Benefit of nursing is so many different jobs within it, so if/when I get bored there's always a completely different path to take.

I like having discussions with my DCs about uni or work or plans for the future, and am always enthusiastic about their plans, but I don't expect them to stick.

Eldest definitely wants to go University, but plans to have a gap year and work for a bit first. May well completely change plans in that time.

NoRaceInThisHorse · 21/01/2022 21:17

I had it all planned out at 17... and then it went very wrong, and I never even finished uni!
He has a while to decide. And uni isn't everything. Sure, if he has a set career path and needs the degree, then go, but I wouldn't recommend just going for the sake of it.

FlyingPandas · 21/01/2022 21:04

At 17 I absolutely KNEW what I was going to do: primary ed. All my work experience was geared to it, my A levels were geared to it, my degree choice and university choices were totally completely and utterly geared to it.

Within 12 months I had crashed and burned. Nearly had a breakdown and ended up changing my degree to a non-vocational academic one, where I had bugger all idea of what I wanted to do, but enjoyed the course content. Subsequently went into a non-graduate but enjoyable job and worked my way up from there.

Now I have a 17yo DS in Y13 who has picked his degree based on a subject he feels he will really enjoy, but he doesn't really have a clear idea as to where that will lead. Frankly, after my own experience I suspect his is the healthier approach.

Weenurse · 21/01/2022 21:04

Another who’s DC benefited from a gap year.
Both DC started degrees in what they thought they might be interested in ( no strong conviction).
Both finished first year ( to get credits), then took a gap year.
DC1 has gone from science based degree to humanities, DC2 went from music industry to business. Both much clearer on what they want to do.
Suggest keeping subjects very broad.
Good luck

TeenTraumaTrials · 21/01/2022 20:58

That's not unusual at all. I had no idea what I wanted to do. Went to Uni and did a degree is the subject I enjoyed the most. Started a postgraduate diploma in something a bit random but left half way through. Found job in related subject and did PhD through that. Then realised I wanted to do something totally different, joined the civil service at fairly low grade and have worked my way up over past 20 years. Absolutely no way I would have seen myself here 30 years ago when I was his age.

Gigipixiz · 21/01/2022 20:57

Super common! I teach A levels at a college. We recently delivered a personal development day for our AS students. Which was career focussed each session was delivered by subject specialists internal and external focussed on what career paths their subjects could lead to. Students signed up for whatever interested them.
I led an alternative session called ‘What to do when you don’t know what to do’
it was so popular I had to run it twice!

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 21/01/2022 20:52

My DD was the same. She looked at several universities and thought of primary teaching then she found a very niche course that interested her even though she wasn't 100% convinced that she would do the job it qualified it for her. This year she will start her 10th year in the job.

Mossstitch · 21/01/2022 20:38

Relax, 3 sons and none knew what they wanted to do at 17. Don't push please. If they don't know what they want let them take a gap year, get a job, whatever. My youngest said didn't want uni, took a gap year then a job in a call centre, then independently decided to go to uni at 24 and is now a nurse. Both of his brothers ended up in something different to their degrees. 17 is often too young for them to know what they want to do but if you are just supportive in the background they will sort themselves out👍

AngelinaFibres · 21/01/2022 20:21

@miltonj

Wow! He's 12!! He'll be fine.
I read it like that too , but he's year 12 so 17SmileSmile
PermanentTemporary · 21/01/2022 20:14

Looking back I'd also say, leaving school aside, what does he actually like doing when it's up to him?

For my ds you could say gym, athletics, certain types of gaming, piano, obsession with modern architecture. What they all share is that they're quite solitary and the way he does them is quite maths based - at the gym and on the track he thinks about percentages of improvement a lot. He is uninterested in narrative, only watches films with other people to have something in common with them. Its not surprising he's landed on computer science as his area for career development.

HP87 · 21/01/2022 20:09

I wish I didn't know at 17/18, wouldn't have wasted time on a degree I now don't use the academic side of.

BunnyRuddington · 21/01/2022 20:06

And another vote for driving to a Uni and just wondering around and having a coffee.

Don't think DS really got motivated until we did this. You could almost see him imagining his new life at Uni as he walked around.

UpintNorth · 21/01/2022 20:06

*geography

UpintNorth · 21/01/2022 20:05

Work in a careers related field.
It’s 100% normal not to know, in fact I’d say only a very small percentage of 17-18 year old have a clear commitment to one career idea. Portfolio careers (moving from one field to another) are increasingly the norm too.
That said, Degrees in arts/humanities/pure subjects like maths, history and georgia physics are useful for many careers and the university experience can really benefit in other ways. BUT if a young person shows an interest in a vocational degree - say law, engineering, etc then the new degree apprenticeships are well worth exploring - get paid work experience and the degree paid for simultaneously.
I also think there is a lot of value in structured gap years, schemes such as BUNAC, etc,

Good luck to you and your boy. With your support I’m sure he will find a way forward.

wineandsunshine · 21/01/2022 20:00

Mine doesn't either - well he's 19 now and started on a law degree (decided after a year he didn't like that). Switched to fashion marketing and still doesn't know what he wants out of it!

I have another son in Y11 who also doesn't know what he wants to study 🤣

It's a common theme in our house!

DrDreReturns · 21/01/2022 19:54

Wtf. I didn't know what I wanted to do until I got offered my first job!

BunnyRuddington · 21/01/2022 19:53

My DF's DS has applied to Keele for exactly that reason @SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius. He quite likes the idea of a Campus Uni too.

Mummadeze · 21/01/2022 19:50

I did a psychology degree with no idea what I wanted to do. I didn’t want to be a psychologist. I took an admin type job after Uni and then looked around to see what else I wanted to do. I tried PR and knew I didn’t want to do that quite quickly. So I then went for some jobs in TV and that ended up being my career path. I don’t think it is unusual to be in his shoes.

DillDanding · 21/01/2022 19:37

Perfectly normal. My sons at uni and still has no idea. His older brother was the same, as was I.

I did my degree in English with absolutely no idea what I wanted to do. Ended up then doing another degree in a completely unrelated subject for my job.

SometimesMaybe · 21/01/2022 19:35

If he’s not sure why he wants to “be” then I would be encouraging him to do at uni what he is good at/enjoys the best. That will give a good foundation and if it doesn’t lead directly to a job then can do further study.

hivemindneeded · 21/01/2022 19:33

Don't pressurise him. He'll probably benefit from a gap year. So fw of them have any clue at this age, let alone having lacked social and academic stimulus of actually going to school for the past two years!

Me to Yr 13 DS2 during lockdown: Are you sure you don't want to have a gap year? You could do an art foundation for free. You love art.
DS2: No! I want to go straight to uni.
DS2 yesterday (now in 2nd year of uni): When I finish uni I am going to do an art foundation.
Me: Oh?
DS2: yeah. If I'd done it in a gap year after school it would have been free.
Me: Really? Hmm

They just have to discover what they want at their own pace.

brogueish · 21/01/2022 19:30

Sorry but how on earth would a 17year old know what they want to do for a career when they have no real experience of work and are still becoming an adult. Fair play to the few that pick medicine or law or whatever and run with it but most people just aren’t like that. It’s fine, OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread