Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that in the UK people don't understand 'Shared Space'.

116 replies

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 13:06

In my city we have a few areas of Shared Space. The idea is to reduce vehicle dominance. The pedestrian as just as much right to be in this space and should be accommodated by the traffic. It drives me up the wall when drivers drive too fast in the space and do not stop/slow to allow pedestrians to move about the area. We have an area along a very busy beach area. There are lots of children around and lots of ice cream parlours etc within this area that the children could be going to. You literally have to walk out in front of the cars to get them to let you move across the area. We have another area which is a big square and is shared with buses. The other day my friend and I were walking across it and a bus came up so fast to us that we were frightened.

I've seen Shared Space in the Netherlands and it works really well. It just doesn't seem to work here and I think probably the beach area they'll probably pedestrianise as some drivers make it dangerous.

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 21/01/2022 16:47

Can't cope? Don't be so patronising.

The problem with them is multitudinal. No public education, no local information, no on site signage or explanation.

If the government or any local council bothered to spend on a public information film then maybe we'd know what to do, as driver, cyclist or pedestrian. But if you look, and can actually find DoT information on it you'll find a wishy washy time about shared responsibility, common goals, community, changing landscape, etc.

Here, less than half a mile from our shared space, is an area that would greatly benefit from one, would actually be understandable by all users. But it is in a residential area, between green space and schools, not quite as sexy as just outside the historic dockyard.

We'd 'cope' just fine if they were explained, well signed and appropriately sited.

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 16:46

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

I think it sounds terrifying too.

Probably better and safer to just pedestrianise it, perhaps with a clearly marked exception for blue badge holders - but as the exception they’d be very careful, knowing it was predominantly pedestrian.

Yes, that sounds a good plan.
OP posts:
crazyjinglist · 21/01/2022 16:45

I don't remotely buy the idea that the British 'can't do it'. That's some ridiculous stereotyping. It takes time to get used to such things. Most car drivers (whatever their nationality Hmm) are used to driving cars on roads,not weaving in and out of pedestrians and road furniture. Personally I don't think spending a few years knocking toddlers over while people get used to it is worth it.

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 16:45

@Missingthesea

We now have shared space in our local high street. My SIL can no longer walk there safely with his guide dog, as there's no pavement and of course guide dogs think it's ALL pavement!
Yes, it has really not been though through for many disabled people.
OP posts:
helpfulperson · 21/01/2022 16:37

It works well in many countries but the British just don't cope with it. Like merge in turn roundabouts. A surprising amount of road design is dicated but the culture of the country and how good they are at sharing, queueing etc.

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2022 16:32

Even if a car is going slowly they wouldn't see a short toddler darting in front of them.

Theluggage15 · 21/01/2022 16:23

We had some shared space which was just confusing and has gone now, but sadly only after a toddler was knocked down and killed as the parents thought the area was pedestrianised, he was dashing about, car came round the corner and hit him. Just horrible.

It’s an everyday concept in the Netherlands, you can’t just plonk it down in the U.K. and expect people to understand it.

WhatNoRaisins · 21/01/2022 16:17

I think I'll give these a miss, sounds scary and confusing.

picklemewalnuts · 21/01/2022 16:17

I like shared space, if it means that cars can crawl through areas that they otherwise wouldn't be in. It's very practical, and avoids routing traffic away on long diversions to protect pedestrian areas.

It only works if the driver thinks like a pedestrian rather than like a driver. It's a different mindset, like electric buggies at the airport or theme park. It seems not everyone can do it- they sit in the car and automatically 'drive' in the usual way.

Ditto pedestrians see a car and move out of the way, which reinforces the problem.

crazyjinglist · 21/01/2022 16:11

I've never heard of this. Sounds like an inherently dangerous idea to me. I'm all for reducing car dominance by having more pedestrian areas, improving public transport and improving cycle lanes, having public payg bikes etc. But this shared area thing sounds terrifying unlessyou make it very hard for cars to navigate, in which case what's the point?

NightmareSlashDelightful · 21/01/2022 16:10

I don't like the concept. I think that when you've got space shared by a range of different types of motion travelling at different speeds, it's just inviting collisions really. Bikes, scooters and pedestrians can all injure each other, and cars/vans/buses can injure cyclists and pedestrians.

I also feel like it's a rather ableist concept. If you use a mobility dog, walking aids or a wheelchair, shared space isn't very user-friendly at all.

I'm all for more cycling routes, better pedestrianisation and more accessible cities and towns. I don't think shared space routes are the way to go about it.

Sirzy · 21/01/2022 16:09

I can’t think of any benefits to this. If they want to reduce traffic then make it pedestrian only don’t blur the boundaries

3scape · 21/01/2022 16:07

It's a huge problem in a city near me you just get cars ignoring the pedestrians and beeping etc. Terrifying.

GnomeDePlume · 21/01/2022 16:05

In the Netherlands generally cyclists have priority over everything (except trams, nobody has priority over trams!). Everyone starts on a cycle. So car drivers will tend to be cycle aware plus cyclists are terrifying and an omafiets (traditional Dutch bike) doesn't have brakes.

whywouldntyou · 21/01/2022 16:04

I think I live in your town! If so the bit outside Nando's is downright lethal, the drivers really don't seem to have a clue. Tempted to get run over just to be able to sue them! (Joke)(sort of)

MargaretThursday · 21/01/2022 15:59

Sounds like an accident waiting to happen.

I don't think I can see any benefit in it over pavements and roads except it may look nicer when no one's there.

The theory is nice, the reality doesn't work.

EmmaH2022 · 21/01/2022 15:40

This is the accident I'm thinking of

www.standard.co.uk/news/london/boy-one-dies-after-being-hit-by-cab-as-his-mother-pushed-him-in-buggy-a3198251.html

Pedestrians don't belong in the same space as cars and cyclists. I certainly don't want to share it - it's bad enough that cyclists seem to come flying out of nowhere in London.

I see other posters have commented re guide dogs because I wondered that too.

That beige roundabout thing sounds a total mystery. Is it meant to attract UFOs? 😂

pigsDOfly · 21/01/2022 14:59

Never heard of this either.

Why, if this is being introduced here, hasn't there been more information about on tv and in the press.

We have shared spaces where I live that involve pedestrians and cyclists.

The paths are quite narrow as it's the route of what was once a single track railway line. I used to walk my dog - always on her lead - along part of it but I gave up using it because so many of the cyclists would fly along with complete disregard for the walkers, coming up behind you without any warning and expecting you to leap out of their way despite the large signs telling cyclist to give way to pedestrians.

Frankly using it can be really stressful and scary.

Can't imagine what it's like in a similar situation but with cars; pretty terrifying I would think.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 21/01/2022 14:46

If there are to be shared spaces in the UK, there needs to be consistency of design, along with intelligent analysis & planning, enough accurate signage & lots of information put out to the general public.

In my experience, there isn't.

One example: a perfectly normal roundabout was replaced with a flat beige-on-beige circle. Vehicles still go round it, but can pedestrians also stroll across it at will? Could a driver legally go the wrong way round, or straight across? Who gives way to whom? Is it still a roundabout in the eyes of the DfT/Highway Code? Nobody knows. In practice, it functions exactly as before, so what was the point?

EmmaH2022 · 21/01/2022 14:31

I hate shared space

I don't drive at the moment so I don't have to deal with that aspect.

as a pedestrian, I try to avoid it because I don't know what it's about and the one time I had to use it, I ended up yanking another person out of the way of a cyclist who was shouting at furiously to get out of the way.

this confused me even more as I then thought "are we meant to be walking here?" There were no signs for clarity at all, but the pavement was a different colour. I found out later that cars are allowed to use it. if I was driving, I wouldn't know.

Wasn't there a cab accident in Chelsea from this kind of misunderstanding?

I don't have a problem with roads being for cars. As a bus user, the recent road changes have caused endless hold ups, but I get the impression they don't really want people using buses either!

I am moving to the very end of a Tube line - well hopefully - where things seem to be set out a bit more traditionally. I might get a car again as it would help taking my elderly mum out shopping etc, but I will be avoiding shared spaces as a driver too.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 21/01/2022 14:25

But Aberdonian Audi drivers aside (Wink), when I learned to drive in the UK, I was instructed to approach turns at a cross/intersection in second gear, roundabouts in second gear, and to ignore pedestrians standing on a street corner waiting to cross, lest I be marked down on my driving test. It's a whole culture of "the roads are for cars". You can't undo that without a lot of public re-education.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 21/01/2022 14:21

@UndertheCedartree

In my city we have a few areas of Shared Space. The idea is to reduce vehicle dominance. The pedestrian as just as much right to be in this space and should be accommodated by the traffic. It drives me up the wall when drivers drive too fast in the space and do not stop/slow to allow pedestrians to move about the area. We have an area along a very busy beach area. There are lots of children around and lots of ice cream parlours etc within this area that the children could be going to. You literally have to walk out in front of the cars to get them to let you move across the area. We have another area which is a big square and is shared with buses. The other day my friend and I were walking across it and a bus came up so fast to us that we were frightened.

I've seen Shared Space in the Netherlands and it works really well. It just doesn't seem to work here and I think probably the beach area they'll probably pedestrianise as some drivers make it dangerous.

If it's Aberdeen you're speaking about, the sense of entitlement several drivers of expensive-mobiles has is very real. Grin
CuriousaboutSamphire · 21/01/2022 14:19

In ours it's just a vast expanse of pink road, some pavements and two crossings, pelican and zebra.

Nothing else, no street furniture, no white lines, etc. It makes no sense at all.

Just10moreminutesplease · 21/01/2022 14:11

I’ve never heard of this. Does it mean there are no pavements at all?

SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 14:09

I think this only works when people understand the concept intuitively. So it would take time to develop that capacity in a new spot.

My city has one place like that which is only about 2 years old. But there are a lot of reminders for drivers - it's bricks on the ground, there are benches around, planters. It's also in an are where cars were often slower anyway.