Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that in the UK people don't understand 'Shared Space'.

116 replies

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 13:06

In my city we have a few areas of Shared Space. The idea is to reduce vehicle dominance. The pedestrian as just as much right to be in this space and should be accommodated by the traffic. It drives me up the wall when drivers drive too fast in the space and do not stop/slow to allow pedestrians to move about the area. We have an area along a very busy beach area. There are lots of children around and lots of ice cream parlours etc within this area that the children could be going to. You literally have to walk out in front of the cars to get them to let you move across the area. We have another area which is a big square and is shared with buses. The other day my friend and I were walking across it and a bus came up so fast to us that we were frightened.

I've seen Shared Space in the Netherlands and it works really well. It just doesn't seem to work here and I think probably the beach area they'll probably pedestrianise as some drivers make it dangerous.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 21/01/2022 19:02

I meant housing and leisure, of course, not retail and leisure!

user1497207191 · 21/01/2022 19:00

@sanbeiji

The best would be if we could make all the shops etc in one place, and ban cars from there (except for the disabled). Then people can use cars for the necessary part of the journey, but not needed in high foot traffic areas.

I've often thought there's merit in that kind of idea. Especially now that so many shops have closed down, both in town centres and precincts etc, they're just too spread out with either vacant/empty shops inbetween or conversions into residential, breaking up the retail areas.

I do think council's should explore the possibilities of concentrating retail into smaller areas (by incentives or compulsory purchase if necessary), and re-purpose the surrounding areas into retail, leisure, etc.

sanbeiji · 21/01/2022 18:59

@user1497207191

I've seen Shared Space in the Netherlands and it works really well.

I'd disagree with that, especially in Amsterdam. There are cyclists everywhere who don't give a toss about pedestrians. I got taken out by a very fast cyclist (who didn't stop) and I ended up having to get stitches in my leg and arm.

Cyclists behaviour towards pedestrians in Amsterdam is just like motorists behaviour in the UK - they ain't going to stop and it's up to you to get out of their way.

There are a LOT of cycling accidents in the Netherlands. However because they’re usually not serious enough to be reported they aren’t counted.

I remember being yelled at and almost knocked down multiple times as a tourist, that , unfriendly locals and charging for packets of sauce is why Am’s my least favourite city.

Thé Zuid-Kennemerland National Park though that’s a piece of heaven, lovely place and welcoming folk
** sorry to digress

JuergenSchwarzwald · 21/01/2022 18:58

@Momicrone

Drivers are a very entitled lot, it takes time to change behaviours
I agree. Look how outraged people were on here over the changes to the Highway Code.
user1497207191 · 21/01/2022 18:55

I've seen Shared Space in the Netherlands and it works really well.

I'd disagree with that, especially in Amsterdam. There are cyclists everywhere who don't give a toss about pedestrians. I got taken out by a very fast cyclist (who didn't stop) and I ended up having to get stitches in my leg and arm.

Cyclists behaviour towards pedestrians in Amsterdam is just like motorists behaviour in the UK - they ain't going to stop and it's up to you to get out of their way.

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:54

@SickAndTiredAgain

This sounds like a pain in the arse for everyone involved. Just make the areas pedestrian only.
To be honest I've thought for years they should pedestrianise the central beach area. I suppose this is a compromise but we've had it for many years now and I think someone needs to admit it doesn't work!
OP posts:
sanbeiji · 21/01/2022 18:53

*sorru eealised I repeated my point but am on second glass of wine already… you know what I mean tho…

sanbeiji · 21/01/2022 18:52

@Deliaskis

There is one near us that I think works quite well. Possibly because it was previously a road with very slow moving traffic (lined with shops and cafes etc, leading up to some traffic lights) and so people aren't used to driving quickly on it. I suppose it also helps that it isn't a through route to anywhere important so it's mostly locals that use it so we know how it works. I use it in a car and on foot and it seems to be fine. Perhaps the circumstances need to be right for it to work safely.
Thing is - what’s wrong with putting zebra crossings, or pedestrian lights? Why does an area have to be ‘shared’ e.g have people go wherever they like? In OP’s example are there no crossings?

The reason isn’t to give way to cars but that it’s easier for everyone to know what to do and where to stop.

There are a couple of areas near me that I guess aren’t an ‘official’ shared space but similar to you has shops, school buses with kids crossing everywhere so people are quite careful around 3 p.m even if the road is wide. Fair enough.

But others..busy road with people randomly crossing, it’s a wide stretch and suddenly there’s a row of shops on either side. Bit unexpected.

In the OP’s examples U.K. wondering why aren’t there are other crossings, is weaving in and out of cars the only option ?

The best would be if we could make all the shops etc in one place, and ban cars from there (except for the disabled). Then people can use cars for the necessary part of the journey, but not needed in high foot traffic areas.

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:51

@FlatCheese

Let's make a safe space for pedestrians to move about in.

Now let's add cars. Brilliant.

Yeah, doesn't sound great when you put it like that! Grin
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:50

@sanbeiji - I find most motorists polite around here too. But the point of Shared Space is there are no crossings.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:47

@EmmaH2022 - our council uses bus stops and billboards as well as leaflets through doors. Never had anything about Shared Space.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:41

@DerAlteMann

"Shared Space" is a concept that has never been properly explained to the public. As a result, I think that YANBU and, until such time as there is a national, as opposed to local, publicity campaign to explain what they are about, they are damn dangerous and should done away with. I have never encountered one when driving and have no idea of what I should be doing if and when I do.
There wasn't even been a local publicity campaign when they came in. But yes, good point - it should be national. We have a lot of visitors here, especially at the beach - it's no wonder many don't have any idea how to use the Shared Space.
OP posts:
Deliaskis · 21/01/2022 18:15

There is one near us that I think works quite well. Possibly because it was previously a road with very slow moving traffic (lined with shops and cafes etc, leading up to some traffic lights) and so people aren't used to driving quickly on it. I suppose it also helps that it isn't a through route to anywhere important so it's mostly locals that use it so we know how it works. I use it in a car and on foot and it seems to be fine. Perhaps the circumstances need to be right for it to work safely.

EmmaH2022 · 21/01/2022 18:14

[quote sanbeiji]@EmmaH2022 I guess ‘local’ means putting leaflets through people’s doors, or signs in local shops.

There are loads of other things that could be done though, a scannable QR code / memorable link people can visit to find information.[/quote]
Yes, I'd look a leaflet.

A QR code, I wouldn't even notice. Local shops - a lot of commuters don't use them and again, I'd not notice anything in a shop.

With something as drastic as shared spaces, where toddlers have died, I think at the minimum there should be one design, advertising campaigns as well as leaflets, and everyone on the council list notified.

That said, I'd prefer pedestrian only areas. Much safer and I think more disability friendly.

FruitToast · 21/01/2022 18:11

I suspect it's a bit like when they plonked the first roundabout in one of Kentucky's counties recently. Everyone was going around it the wrong way, didn't know where to go or what to do. To us it's hilarious as roundabouts are an everyday thing but as no one knew what they were doing because no one had told them what to do at the roundabout it was absolute chaos! You really can't just take road concepts that are well established in other places and dump them somewhere with no education of the population. I'm fairly sure people in Kentucky can use roundabouts just as people in the UK can use shared space. Someone might need to explain the concept first though! I did think however that pedestrians have always had right of way (even when I did my theory test). I'm fairly sure you've never been able to just run people over for fun?

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:08

@sanbeiji

YANBU. Also the Netherlands is designed around not needing a car, yes people bike everywhere but everything’s concentrated and it’s flat.

It’s not just about culture, or a single street but how wider facilities are designed

Yes, good point.
OP posts:
SickAndTiredAgain · 21/01/2022 18:07

This sounds like a pain in the arse for everyone involved. Just make the areas pedestrian only.

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:06

@Rosebel

I've never heard of this either but agree it sounds terrifying and dangerous. Why not just make the area for pedestrians? Does it work better in the Netherlands because less people drive, maybe?
I think it is for lots of reasons. Firstly, people understand how they work, secondly cars aren't as dominant anyway and thirdly they put them in the right places.
OP posts:
sanbeiji · 21/01/2022 18:06

@EmmaH2022 I guess ‘local’ means putting leaflets through people’s doors, or signs in local shops.

There are loads of other things that could be done though, a scannable QR code / memorable link people can visit to find information.

EmmaH2022 · 21/01/2022 18:04

@DerAlteMann

"Shared Space" is a concept that has never been properly explained to the public. As a result, I think that YANBU and, until such time as there is a national, as opposed to local, publicity campaign to explain what they are about, they are damn dangerous and should done away with. I have never encountered one when driving and have no idea of what I should be doing if and when I do.
Also, how do local publicity things work now? I don't get a local paper. I'm on the council list for developments but many people won't be. The local library is now open for collection only.

I think there might be a shared place in the works a couple of roads away but I won't know until I walk into it. Argh.

And much worse for drivers.

UndertheCedartree · 21/01/2022 18:02

@CuriousaboutSamphire

Can't cope? Don't be so patronising.

The problem with them is multitudinal. No public education, no local information, no on site signage or explanation.

If the government or any local council bothered to spend on a public information film then maybe we'd know what to do, as driver, cyclist or pedestrian. But if you look, and can actually find DoT information on it you'll find a wishy washy time about shared responsibility, common goals, community, changing landscape, etc.

Here, less than half a mile from our shared space, is an area that would greatly benefit from one, would actually be understandable by all users. But it is in a residential area, between green space and schools, not quite as sexy as just outside the historic dockyard.

We'd 'cope' just fine if they were explained, well signed and appropriately sited.

Yes, definitely.
OP posts:
FlatCheese · 21/01/2022 18:02

Let's make a safe space for pedestrians to move about in.

Now let's add cars. Brilliant.

sanbeiji · 21/01/2022 18:02

Also to add we have a lot of cycle lanes the majority of drivers will also have been cyclists/pedestrians at some point…

EmmaH2022 · 21/01/2022 18:01

@crazyjinglist

I don't remotely buy the idea that the British 'can't do it'. That's some ridiculous stereotyping. It takes time to get used to such things. Most car drivers (whatever their nationality Hmm) are used to driving cars on roads,not weaving in and out of pedestrians and road furniture. Personally I don't think spending a few years knocking toddlers over while people get used to it is worth it.
Agree.

Pp have mentioned a new hierarchy, which I'm only vaguely aware of because of MN, but I cross at crossings anyway. Hopefully it doesn't mean more pedestrians being mown down by cyclists? Scooters are a real menace in London too.

Clear road markings and uses seem like a benefit for all. Big changes should have big awareness campaigns.

I think it's just government officials giving taxes to their cronies. There's a bit in my part of town that's about 5 shop fronts wide. It got a £3million grant so it was re-concreted and had benches put on it. Now people sit on the benches and feed pigeons who poop everywhere.

sanbeiji · 21/01/2022 18:01

@crazyjinglist

but many people just don't have the mindset of putting pedestrians above cars here.

Well it's pretty hard to have the mindset of something in a country where most people have never heard of it or seen it!

I don’t know if I’m just lucky, but cars in my area are very polite. They don’t zoom past pedestrian crossings, stop at junctions to allow pedestrians to cross etc.

The main bad behaviour is from cyclists