Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Sorry the colour doesn’t suit my baby’

491 replies

Laughingstock91 · 21/01/2022 12:07

Sent a friend with a new baby some clothes - one thing was a really pale pink and the other thing was a really pale yellow. It was like a T-shirt and joggers set thing that I got in a small independent shop.

No Thankyou - just a comment that the colours weren’t right. The baby is 3 months old.

Aibu to think I would never have dreamed of making such a comment. I had some really unusual colours but I smiled, said Thankyou & the kids wore them as I was grateful to receive gifts.

I feel really offended- they weren’t cheap either 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 22/01/2022 06:43

@Laughingstock91

Does anyone really care that the colour doesn’t suit a 3 month old? Maybe it’s just me!
Our first was a little jaundiced and really didn't suit the outfit I'd picked out for her to go home in. I don't remember it being a problem with the others. So I think it's possible it didn't suit, but it's not something I'd ever say.
Laughingstock91 · 22/01/2022 06:20

“I get the feeling OP would have been naffed off anyway tbh even if effusive thanks... But.

OP?”

@CheeseMmmm I’m sorry but I have no idea what you mean here? You don’t know me at all so why do you ‘get the feeling’ about me?

I was hacked off because my friend was rude. I was literally just trying to buy her kid a nice present!

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 22/01/2022 01:12

weasily

For sure. Hand knitted is different though.

The thought, care, time, effort and essentially love that goes in is for me the actual gift.

MIL was a knitter. She died kids too young to remember her. Those clothes she gave are obv huge emotional value.

Not same as baby tops from shop from 'friend'!

goawaystormy · 22/01/2022 01:11

Presents are for the person. They're supposed to like them. That's the whole point!

I'm inclined to agree with this but I guess it does depend on your relationship with the person.

In my family/close group of friends it's standard to say if you don't like it I've got the gift recipes for any kind of personal taste gifts (clothes, jewellery etc) because we don't want things to sit unused in the back of cupboards for years and eventually end up unused in a charity shop - we love the person and want them to enjoy the gift.

However if I got a gift from my boyfriends parents you bet I'd be graciously saying thank you and then just never using it - I don't have the relationship with them where I'd want to risk rocking the boat or making it awkward.

I do disagree with you 'I'll put the baby in it anyway because I'm grateful they thought to buy me a gift' - I can be grateful for the thought and still dislike something enough that I won't use it because I have other options I lie more.

I also disagree with all the 'put baby in it for a picture and send it to them' people - as if new mums, sleep deprived and all, have time to be putting on and taking off multiple outfits from a baby for a photo op, not to mention remembering specifically who got exactly what whilst also having baby brain. A simple thank you upon reception is fine.

So I guess what I'm saying is whether your friend was rude depends how much of a friend she really is. If it was my close friend I'd be fine with it because I want them to enjoy the gift, if it's more of an acquaintance and you have a more formal relationship maybe it's different for you. I agree it's worded funny but maybe she just wrote it clumsily. Either way I don't think it's worth dropping a whole, otherwise good, friendship over. If you're not that good friends in the first place then fine but then I'd question why you're buying baby gifts and taking such offence at someone having personal style.

AhNowTed · 22/01/2022 00:56

Well this thread took a turn.

OP your friend is a rude entitled cow who has no manners.

Even my kids from a very young age knew to say thank you and look grateful regardless.

Some of these responses are wild.

whynotwhatknot · 22/01/2022 00:54

Its rude to return a gift you just say thankyou very much even if she never used it

my aunt has always bought me really random things-this year i got a giant toy miaowingcat something kids would get i just said thanks its lovely

Sunsetmom · 22/01/2022 00:24

Your friend does sound like she came across as ungrateful/ rude however I don’t dress my DD in certain colours because I don’t like them or they just don’t suit! Im not going to dress her in just anything to please other people! (My MIL bought Dd Who is only 5MO a black dress for Xmas, she is far too young to wear black!!!) depending on who bought the clothing I would either swap and tell them or keep in the back of the wardrobe!

It’s not what she’s said it’s more how she’s put it I think, I would much rather be told and asked for receipt than whatever I bought end up in the back of a wardrobe which is a massive waste of money!

NoRaceInThisHorse · 22/01/2022 00:07

Lol, the baby is 3 months. They wear what is put on them, and who cares, as long as it's suitable for the weather.

SquirrelG · 21/01/2022 23:51

Is there a full moon at the moment? There have been some extremely strange people mentioned on MN lately.

She's a rude brat OP, and yes, ask for them to be returned so you can either get a refund, or gift them in the future to a regular person.

As for this "friend" - she would be dropped forthwith if she were in my circle!

WeasilyPleased · 21/01/2022 23:50

My mil has knitted the most hideous cardigans in gooseberry green and apricot...with matching hats.
I said thanks very much and baby will wear them when she sees mil. She'll grow out of them quickly enough and I've pre-empted any more by buying some wool (saying I couldn't resist it and please may I have cardis next size up)
I think your friend is extremely rude and ungrateful.

Blossomtoes · 21/01/2022 23:48

They certainly are.

Enough4me · 21/01/2022 23:48

@CheeseMmmm I know you are genuine as have seen you post on other threads, but your posting style is unusual, hence the comments on here.

The issue for OP is the unnecessary abruptness and lack of manners from the gift recipient.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/01/2022 23:47

@CheeseMmmm

Yes that's fair.

I get the feeling OP would have been naffed off anyway tbh even if effusive thanks... But.

OP?

Incidentally again different people different ways. Different norms.

Eg I always text next day thank you if friend cooks for me, or has some kind party. Say thanks for X, had great time/lush food. Was lovely to see you/ fab party etc.

I do that stuff I don't know literally anyone who says thanks.

Except my parents... So. That's where I got it from then!

They don't do what I do. Because they're rude and whatever? Terrible people?

I did wonder in 20s why no thanks. Then I thought. Well I know they're nice people who like me. Prob just not a thing they do.

So I still say thanks and they don't and that's cool.

And it goes both ways. They don't get the hump that I don't do cards.

What's important? When it comes to friends, it's them, the relationship. If you know that care about you and vice versa. Changing view of them based on (in the scheme of things) trivial stuff. Feels missing the point to me.

Someone's on the 🍷 tonight!
youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/01/2022 23:45

@Laughingstock91

Thing is- it wasn’t even a horrible set- the closest I can find is this pic from next which is similar
I want this in grown up size!!
CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 23:45

Interesting that rather than actually responding to content of posts about my personal view of nature of friendship, point of present is to give something make recipient happy...

Rather. I'm-

Drunk
Found caps lock
Or an MP!!!

Anyone fancy saying yes would be vv grateful for the boobs babygro? Parents preferences when comes baby when comes baby clothes irrelevant?

Or. Why they prefer to have insincere thanks, and present given away/ back wardrobe. Than thanks soz can I exchange. So they get something they like?

And, if a friend. Who you like and likes you. Have good time with. Etc. Would change entire view of them based on a couple words?

Crap friends in first place surely. To think grabby rude awful person over something like this. When otherwise you close etc.

Don't get it. At all.

AlwaysLatte · 21/01/2022 23:35
  • Yes that's fair. I get the feeling OP would have been naffed off anyway tbh even if effusive thanks... But. OP? Incidentally again different people different ways. Different norms. Eg I always text next day thank you if friend cooks for me, or has some kind party. Say thanks for X, had great time/lush food. Was lovely to see you/ fab party etc. I do that stuff I don't know literally anyone who says thanks. Except my parents... So. That's where I got it from then! They don't do what I do. Because they're rude and whatever? Terrible people? I did wonder in 20s why no thanks. Then I thought. Well I know they're nice people who like me. Prob just not a thing they do. So I still say thanks and they don't and that's cool. And it goes both ways. They don't get the hump that I don't do cards. What's important? When it comes to friends, it's them, the relationship. If you know that care about you and vice versa. Changing view of them based on (in the scheme of things) trivial stuff. Feels missing the point to me.*

Are you an MP? Completely forgotten what the original question was.

Tsuni · 21/01/2022 23:35

@Mylittlepotofjoy

One of my sons was given a tartan snow suit with lace on ! I wasn’t impressed as it was obvious meant for a girl but I got the lace off after buyer saw him in it . Everyone happy Grin
Uh oh, you can’t say that on mn. Everybody here dresses their sons in lace (and glitter and sequins and pink.)
AlwaysLatte · 21/01/2022 23:31

YABU if the newborn had been to have their colours done in a top department store and you had known the outcome. Otherwise you sound like a lovely friend. Is your friend ok? Not baby blues?

Mylittlepotofjoy · 21/01/2022 23:26

One of my sons was given a tartan snow suit with lace on ! I wasn’t impressed as it was obvious meant for a girl but I got the lace off after buyer saw him in it . Everyone happy Grin

CallMeNutribullet · 21/01/2022 23:26

Clearly you should have spent some time on colour analysis and understood her 3 month old is more of a cool winter

Blossomtoes · 21/01/2022 23:26

Are you drunk @CheeseMmmm?

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 23:25

Yes that's fair.

I get the feeling OP would have been naffed off anyway tbh even if effusive thanks... But.

OP?

Incidentally again different people different ways. Different norms.

Eg I always text next day thank you if friend cooks for me, or has some kind party. Say thanks for X, had great time/lush food. Was lovely to see you/ fab party etc.

I do that stuff I don't know literally anyone who says thanks.

Except my parents... So. That's where I got it from then!

They don't do what I do. Because they're rude and whatever? Terrible people?

I did wonder in 20s why no thanks. Then I thought. Well I know they're nice people who like me. Prob just not a thing they do.

So I still say thanks and they don't and that's cool.

And it goes both ways. They don't get the hump that I don't do cards.

What's important? When it comes to friends, it's them, the relationship. If you know that care about you and vice versa. Changing view of them based on (in the scheme of things) trivial stuff. Feels missing the point to me.

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 23:16

Thank you so much! Haha brilliant.

Lucky it's summer! Will put on baby when we go lunch tomorrow. Ps my parents are going to drop in say hello while we there! You're the best xxx

‘Sorry the colour doesn’t suit my baby’
CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 23:11

[quote Somethingsnappy]@CheeseMmmm, well perhaps if the baby had received the dress you described, the responses here would indeed be rather different... Grin[/quote]
Lolol Grin

In fact... Good point. There's some really nasty baby stuff with sexual innuendo out in the wild. Get threads on here about how awful sometimes...

Somethingsnappy · 21/01/2022 23:09

@CheeseMmmm, I think the main issue was the lack of manners. The friend didn't even thank the OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread