Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about war

191 replies

Ciaram55 · 21/01/2022 11:33

The stand off between Russia and the west over Ukraine. I can't see either side backing down. I'm just so worried now. I know that worrying doesn't help but it seems to be a very tense time right now.

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 24/01/2022 09:49

it feels like China and Russia have come out of no where

What planet have you been on for the past 60 years ?

Wilburisagirl · 24/01/2022 09:45

@Lockedoorsopen

Same here, it feels like China and Russia have come out of no where and every one is like ...'whats for dinner tonight then'

I have been watching whats been going on with China, Taiwan and US and now Russia doing this to the Ukraine and U.K getting involved and it is making me wonder if this is the start of WW3

Agreed. I've been feeling like WW3 was on the horizon for a while now. It's a scary thought.
AM2476 · 24/01/2022 09:44

Why would Russia want to ‘turn off’ their lucrative gas supply to a very big customer ? Especially when economically Russia isn’t particularly stable and hasn’t been for a while. Nothing will happen with the U.K. most likely.

Postdatedpandemic · 24/01/2022 09:41

Russia has a lot of infrastructure in Ukraine, so likes to keep it. Gas, pipelines, ports and other resources are critical.
It is almost like we are reaching the limits of growrh.

To be worried about war
DGRossetti · 24/01/2022 09:16

Exactly. We have fuck all control over anything so best to ignore and just enjoy the parts of our lives that we can exert influence over

I imagine my grandparents saying that in 1939 and my great grandparents saying it in 1914.

Lilifer · 24/01/2022 09:06

@Cheekypeach

I have to be honest and say the last 5 years has left me numb to even shocking world events. I try to avoid the news now, there’s nothing I can do to influence it & I want to enjoy life in the meantime.
Exactly. We have fuck all control over anything so best to ignore and just enjoy the parts of our lives that we can exert influence over 🤷‍♀️
DGRossetti · 24/01/2022 08:54

Here's a useful aid to picturing how big countries are. Notice how small China is compared to Africa. Now remember how for all our lives the US, USSR and EU have done absolutely nothing towards a pan-African union. In fact, quite the reverse.

I can't recommend this book highly enough

Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps That Tell You Everything You Need to Know About Global Politics

By Tim Marshall

it goes some way towards explaining Russias nervousness about Ukraine.

It also says that if you live in the US you basically got a golden ticket in life. And if you live in Africa you got the wooden spoon.

And from a geographical perspective, if we Europeans could just stop fighting for a second, we'd have had it all too. Luckily there was never any danger of that. Can you imagine having had it easy ? Phew. Thank goodness for xenophobia, nationalism, and flags.

www.visualcapitalist.com/map-true-size-of-africa/

To be worried about war
Alexandra2001 · 24/01/2022 08:42

@notimagain Thats why we have diplomates and wise heads of state... or should have!!!

I very much feel that allowing the possibility of Ukraine to join NATO is provocation, equally Putin cannot be allowed to use military might and gas supplies to blackmail the 'west into giving in & allowing Ukraine to go the same way as Belarus.

I hope, as reported in the press last week, the Americans will take membership off the table in return for troop withdrawals, with the promise of far greater military presence should he not comply.

Hard to believe 14000 troops have died in fighting on the Ukraine over the 8 years, yet we ve all been pre occupied with Brexit, Putin did indeed pull a master stroke there didn't he.

notimagain · 24/01/2022 08:17

BUT to avoid war we also have to respect and understand Russian fears,

Absolutely agree…I remember many many years ago (late 70s) being shown a map drawn/using a projection which showed the world from the Russian/Soviet POV which depicted all the threats had faced over the years and continued to face at that time.

Their need to have buffer States is understandable, the problem is what to do if that independent State actually doesn’t want to be a buffer???

We need wise heads to prevail.

Alexandra2001 · 24/01/2022 07:10

@notimagain Its not possible to write a thesis on the rights n wrongs of Russian and Western foreign policy in the ME on here.

I was original replying to poster who put the blame on the Russia the Aggressor.... and its simply not true, the west is/has been mired in terrible wars and equally terrible decisions.

To be clear Putin needs to be stood up to and the 'west is weak, FFS he shot down an airliner and we did nothing, nothing at all, he has poisoned critics here in the UK, our response was to allow more Russian money to fund the Tory party, you couldn't make it up!

Yesterday Raab tells the Russians that no UK troops will be used in Ukraine, should there be an invasion - why not give a Green light to Putin Mr Raab?

BUT to avoid war we also have to respect and understand Russian fears, NATO was set up to counteract the Soviets, USSR has long gone and there is no reason to have NATO member states on the borders of Russia.

notimagain · 23/01/2022 23:01

@Alexandra2001

Ah i see, that means its ok to launch genocide on the Houthis (by denying them food, water, medicines and shelter plus trying to kill as many as possible) and arm the Saudis with the latest British weapons.

Care to give us the whole story about which countries are up to their ears in fueling that war?

For example who is supplying the Houthis with weaponry such as the Scud derivatives (remind me again where the Scud originated BTW), the ones fired in the direction of Riyadh? Any thoughts on how they were provisioned and who shipped them into country?

I do think it’s fair enough for you to point out the Uk have supplied some weapons, OTOH it’s not at all reasonable/fair to try and paint a picture that presents the UK (and presumably by association) other western powers as being the only ones involved in the arms trade to both sides in that conflict

AutomaticMoon · 23/01/2022 21:31

@Alexandra2001 Even in China there’s power shortages leading to factories only opening part time, yet we’re all held ransom because we cannot/will not manufacture anything here.

ParsleySageRosemary · 23/01/2022 21:31

Are you honestly claiming Russia has no involvement in that region?? And then using it to justify moves on East Europe in the name of a false united people??

AutomaticMoon · 23/01/2022 21:29

@Alexandra2001 And the way Taiwan is treated in the politics media is vile, I’ve seen someone from WHO apologise for calling Taiwan a country and all sorts of CCP submissive behaviour. The CCP is a vile organisation and they’re destroying that whole continent with the hatred they indoctrinate.

AutomaticMoon · 23/01/2022 21:25

@MrsTerryPratchett The revolution in Romania was televised, it’s on youtube if anyone’s interested! It was Christmas time and as a Christmas gift, the army lynched Ceausescu and Elena in the street like dogs and it was shown on tv and children celebrated.

Alexandra2001 · 23/01/2022 21:23

@AutomaticMoon

I’m worried about China too. Their president has been cracking down in recent times, some think he’s preparing for war.
Agree, whole cultures destroyed/re educated but we will still off shore manufacturing and send an Olympics team there.
AutomaticMoon · 23/01/2022 21:21

Sorry, I said president but he’s really a dictator!

Alexandra2001 · 23/01/2022 21:20

@ParsleySageRosemary

Britain isn’t the US. The EU isn’t the US. As DGRossetti says, in Britain Blair is not popular over Iraq.

I’d suggest you look up the origins of the Saudi-Yemen conflict and what the Houthis got up to, and grasp the religious differences and rivalries in the region.

Ah i see, that means its ok to launch genocide on the Houthis (by denying them food, water, medicines and shelter plus trying to kill as many as possible) and arm the Saudis with the latest British weapons.

Its a barbaric war, which the UK is fostering by its full support for SA... why? to sell more weapons to them.

AutomaticMoon · 23/01/2022 21:20

I’m worried about China too. Their president has been cracking down in recent times, some think he’s preparing for war.

Alexandra2001 · 23/01/2022 21:15

@ParsleySageRosemary

You are smashing together an awful lot of different times and places Alexandra. Why?
Pointing out that when a poster says Russia is involved in some pretty nasty wars and is the aggressor and has nothing to fear from the west... that he/she is simply wrong. The wars we have got ourselves into over the last 50 years dwarfs anything China and Russia have done combined.

Germany said it would never invade Russia and even signed a peace treaty with them... less than a year later Operation Barbarosssa was launched, this is within many peoples life times, now that might be inconsequential to you but it feeds a mistrust of the west within Russia.

BTW how do you think the UK would feel if Russia formed a "defence" pact with Germany & France... would that make us feel at ease with the world?

Gas price increases aren't down only to Putin or CV but because Europe didn't invest in alternative energy sources, relied on oil, hurriedly switched to gas and didn't consider alternatives.

ParsleySageRosemary · 23/01/2022 21:10

Britain isn’t the US. The EU isn’t the US. As DGRossetti says, in Britain Blair is not popular over Iraq.

I’d suggest you look up the origins of the Saudi-Yemen conflict and what the Houthis got up to, and grasp the religious differences and rivalries in the region.

DoctorTwo · 23/01/2022 20:49

Because Parsley the US has been at war just about all the time since 1950ish. Russia invaded Afghanistan in 1979 and that's it, so the US armed the Mujahideen which evolved into the Taliban, they also invaded Afghanistan to stop the Taliban (anyone know how that's going?), Iraq, they supply arms to Saudi Arabia, they supplied arms to Libyans to destabilise their country and Russia are the bad guys? Wow...

Though Russia spends a fair bit more than the US on their military, the country is barely in a good economic position to fund a war and faces many economic challenges post Covid.

Sorry to disabuse you of your fact @AuntMasha but the US spends more on defence than China, Russia, UK, Turkey and Greece combined, and their income in dollars from exportation of oil and gas to the west has left them with a massive war chest. They're also buying loads of gold, possibly to back the ruble against a crash in the dollar, which, as it's only backed by trust is almost inevitable.

bottleofbeer · 23/01/2022 19:17

Chill, Putin is a baaaadddd man but he's very far from stupid.

DGRossetti · 23/01/2022 19:05

Nothing I’d trust in the MSM

And we have a history where a serving PM went on national TV and lied to drag the UK into a war.

I'll be honest. At this distance, my trust is in very short supply.

notimagain · 23/01/2022 19:02

@ParsleySageRosemary

You are smashing together an awful lot of different times and places Alexandra. Why?
Fair question, if the suggested timescale starts with Vietnam then in addition to all the proxy wars that had Soviet “advisors” fingerprints, and more, all over them there is just the little issue of the Soviet-Afghan war, 1979-1989…

Of course for a while after that the Russian economy wasn’t in a particularly good position to support too many foreign ventures but objectively it’s Forces have certainly seen significant re equipment over the last few years.

I do think overall, looking at history, it’s understandable why Russia is more than slightly uncomfortable with NATO members on it’s borders but it’s disingenuous at the very least to somehow suggest the Soviets/Russians are squeaky clean when it comes to being involved in foreign walls…

Swipe left for the next trending thread