Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about war

191 replies

Ciaram55 · 21/01/2022 11:33

The stand off between Russia and the west over Ukraine. I can't see either side backing down. I'm just so worried now. I know that worrying doesn't help but it seems to be a very tense time right now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notimagain · 26/01/2022 16:49

@C152

Agree with that, I am certainly not calling for an end to NATO…

However we also need to understand how something’s are perceived in Russia, or at least some in that country.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 26/01/2022 16:09

Make no mistake, war will come. It has to, because it always does

No it doesn’t.

Cuban Missile Crisis
Russia invaded Afghanistan
Gadaffi lobbed some missile in the 80’s
Conflict between India and Pakistan in early 00’s

C152 · 26/01/2022 15:52

[quote Alexandra2001]@notimagain Its not possible to write a thesis on the rights n wrongs of Russian and Western foreign policy in the ME on here.

I was original replying to poster who put the blame on the Russia the Aggressor.... and its simply not true, the west is/has been mired in terrible wars and equally terrible decisions.

To be clear Putin needs to be stood up to and the 'west is weak, FFS he shot down an airliner and we did nothing, nothing at all, he has poisoned critics here in the UK, our response was to allow more Russian money to fund the Tory party, you couldn't make it up!

Yesterday Raab tells the Russians that no UK troops will be used in Ukraine, should there be an invasion - why not give a Green light to Putin Mr Raab?

BUT to avoid war we also have to respect and understand Russian fears, NATO was set up to counteract the Soviets, USSR has long gone and there is no reason to have NATO member states on the borders of Russia.[/quote]
There is ABSOLUTELY a need for NATO to still be in place. I would call Russia's continued incursion into independent states and open threats to invade the Baltics again because he never wanted to let them go a very clear reason for those states to band together in defence. Maybe if Russia stopped invading and threatening to invade independent states, the threat of war would recede?

Ciaram55 · 26/01/2022 15:46

We weren't directly fighting the Russians in any of those wars though.

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 26/01/2022 15:32

But in the past there were conventional wars. We can't afford to have another big war because of the nuclear threat? Mutual Assured Destruction will surely prevail.

Didn't stop Vietnam.
Or invasion of Afghanistan
Or Gulf war 1991
Or Gulf War 2003

notimagain · 26/01/2022 15:28

It “still applies”, yes, but you need to understand when it might still apply.

We are (thankfully) not in the really grim old days of what was known as “tripwire” when the stated NATO response to any Soviet incursion into West Germany was an all out release of nuclear weapons, and we’ve even moved on (thankfully) from the only slightly less grim old days of a policy called flexible response where nuclear weapons might have been released if NATO forces and as a result entire NATO nations/their capital cities were in danger of being overrun by Warsaw Pact Forces.

Ciaram55 · 26/01/2022 15:17

MAD still applies. The fact there'll be no winners is still just as relevant today.

OP posts:
Postdatedpandemic · 26/01/2022 15:12

Nobody is going back to MAD like we had in the early eighties.
There's just not enough profit in it.

Ciaram55 · 26/01/2022 15:12

The biggest worry would be if it escalated though, where it might get past the point of no return?

OP posts:
notimagain · 26/01/2022 15:09

@Ciaram55

Make no mistake, war will come. It has to, because it always does

But in the past there were conventional wars. We can't afford to have another big war because of the nuclear threat? Mutual Assured Destruction will surely prevail.

FWIW a conventional war/invasion on the far eastern side of Europe, whilst definitely not a good thing, would not in itself inevitably lead to the release of nuclear weapons….MAD would not surely prevail.
fizzypop100 · 26/01/2022 14:58

We are going from one crock of shite to another

Ciaram55 · 26/01/2022 14:57

Make no mistake, war will come. It has to, because it always does

But in the past there were conventional wars. We can't afford to have another big war because of the nuclear threat? Mutual Assured Destruction will surely prevail.

OP posts:
Curiousmouse · 24/01/2022 21:08

@AutomaticMoon I know. Today the guardian says it'll go up beyond that, to stratospheric, if there is a war.

AutomaticMoon · 24/01/2022 20:50

@Curiousmouse Putin said months ago it was the end of cheap gas and wheat, for export.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 24/01/2022 20:44

@AM2476

Why would Russia want to ‘turn off’ their lucrative gas supply to a very big customer ? Especially when economically Russia isn’t particularly stable and hasn’t been for a while. Nothing will happen with the U.K. most likely.
It's a seller's market.
Postdatedpandemic · 24/01/2022 20:12

We've been here and a lot closer many times

sst1234 · 24/01/2022 19:27

@MorningStarling

As Machiavelli wrote, "there is no avoiding war; it can only be postponed to the advantage of others."

The west is getting to the point where we will regret having allowed Putin and China to have expanded their influence in the way they have. I'm not sure if it was ignorance or arrogance that has led successive world leaders to ignore what was happening in those countries since the early to mid 90s. Perhaps it was just wishful thinking. It's too late to prevent war now, it's an inevitability, it's just a shame we didn't take pre-emptive action when our advantage was at its greatest - or, perhaps, our disadvantage was at its lowest.

Make no mistake, war will come. It has to, because it always does.

They’re proxy wars and they have never stopped. Syria for example.
Alexandra2001 · 24/01/2022 13:45

@MorningStarling

Disagree, war isn't inevitable at all, the demands of Putin are not unrealistic and if we focused on trade and diplomatic efforts as much as we do talking up war, we could still turn this around.

China especially has a huge pop. and struggles to control it, war could split China into pieces.
Russia needs trade and foreign investment but it also, like the West, needs an enemy.

But completely agree, cuts in our military has been a disaster, many bases have been turned into housing and delays in procurement has meant advantages we had in equipment has gone.

notimagain · 24/01/2022 12:31

@MorningStarling

The west is getting to the point where we will regret having allowed Putin and China to have expanded their influence in the way they have. I'm not sure if it was ignorance or arrogance that has led successive world leaders to ignore what was happening in those countries since the early to mid 90s. Perhaps it was just wishful thinking.

Yep..that wall came down, Warsaw Pact dissolved, everybody loved that nice Mr Gorbachev and lo and behold lots of talk of peace dividends and turning guns into ploughshares, etc…

Result - Cuts in Defence spending left, right and centre…and TBH all very understandable at the time (early 1990s).

Fast forward to about ten years ago and it was obvious to anybody paying attention that the Russians and Chinese were massively improving their conventional forces and they had “hard” men as leaders and they had global aspirations.

Trouble was a lot of people weren’t paying attention… many continued to disagree with defence spending on political and ethical grounds and as a result some politicians saw talking about potential threats and spending more on defence, or even maintaining current levels of spending as a vote loser…

I’m not sure I’d agree with defence spending on a U.S. level but the low level of spending by Europe (and I include the UK in that) has certainly helped encourage the despots.

Curiousmouse · 24/01/2022 12:14

The Times today says that Russia has threatened to weaponise gas, and ministers say that it will push gas prices to an even higher, much higher peak.

MorningStarling · 24/01/2022 12:04

As Machiavelli wrote, "there is no avoiding war; it can only be postponed to the advantage of others."

The west is getting to the point where we will regret having allowed Putin and China to have expanded their influence in the way they have. I'm not sure if it was ignorance or arrogance that has led successive world leaders to ignore what was happening in those countries since the early to mid 90s. Perhaps it was just wishful thinking. It's too late to prevent war now, it's an inevitability, it's just a shame we didn't take pre-emptive action when our advantage was at its greatest - or, perhaps, our disadvantage was at its lowest.

Make no mistake, war will come. It has to, because it always does.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 24/01/2022 11:33

Russia vs Ukraine would be an absolute bloodbath for the Ukraine, however Russia vs Nato the odds are very much not in Russias favour. I can't understand those who say that Russia and China have come out of nowhere, its been blindingly obvious for years that they are the two we need to worry about. The middle east and North Korea are just minor diversions.

notimagain · 24/01/2022 11:27

For the benefit of those seeing the sky falling in whilst a conflict in the Ukraine is not a happy thought options other than WW3 are possible/much more likely.

Putin is a pragmatist and many think an incursion as far as the Dnieper River, perhaps control of the coast to the west of the Dnieper estuary and a neutral government in Kiev would give him what he wants….

Go west of the Dnieper, especially towards Kiev itself and for all sorts - of reasons (logistics, demographics at a regional level) it gets much more difficult for the Russian Army and long term they could face trying to control an insurgency..and even the Russians learnt some lessons in Afghanistan.

forinborin · 24/01/2022 09:51

@Ciaram55

I just don't think we should be in that area. Surely it's understandable that Russia feels threatened. We should get out and defuse the situation.i hate the worry of all this.
You are not in that area. There isn't a single NATO base in Ukraine.
Postdatedpandemic · 24/01/2022 09:49

@AM2476

Why would Russia want to ‘turn off’ their lucrative gas supply to a very big customer ? Especially when economically Russia isn’t particularly stable and hasn’t been for a while. Nothing will happen with the U.K. most likely.
Because gas is a limited resource. They can sell it now and make money or sell it later and make more money or save it for their own use later.