Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think drink driving and speeding are morally equivalent

162 replies

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:03

One gets treated as unforgivable, the other as a peccadillo. The sort of thing we all do, so it can’t be that bad.

But drink driving isn’t bad in and of itself. If someone wants to down a bottle of gin and drive round a deserted island then good luck to them. Drink driving is bad because it increases the risk of hurting or killing other people.

Speeding’s the same, isn’t it? It increases your odds of hurting or killing someone.

Does it make it worse if you kill someone with your car because you’re half cut rather than if you’re over the limit?

One defence people seem to have is that their speeding wasn’t dangerous. They’ll say that the speed limit was silly in that area, or that there wasn’t anyone else on the road.

But people used to say the same sort of stuff about drink driving. And tbh Lewis Hamilton will have better reflexes after four beers than I do sober.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
GunsNShips · 21/01/2022 11:37

[quote Highdaysandholidaze]@GunsNShips, but I don’t think I care whether someone kills me because they’ve made a choice to speed or because they’ve made a choice to have an extra beer.[/quote]
That’s not what I meant. When people speed they don’t choose to veer from lane to lane as well. When people drink drive they don’t choose to do that either and yet they doo

JuergenSchwarzwald · 21/01/2022 11:36

My mind was blown when I started thinking about it during the speed awareness course. If I hit someone and killed them doing 35 in a 30 they wouldn't be less dead than if I I'd hit them at 30 having had 5 pints. If someone hit and killed my child doing 35 in a 30, I wouldn't grieve less because 'at least they weren't drunk

I think the difference is that if I am doing 35 in a 30 limit it is possible a child could run out in front of me. But I am still alert, I will still see cyclists and be aware of what's going on. The chances of me killing someone are tiny.

If on the other hand I am drunk, I may be going even faster, not aware of what's going on at all and go through a red light and kill someone crossing the road who I had ample chance to see.

There is a massive difference in risk profile for me.

FacebookPhotos · 21/01/2022 11:35

Do you have a link for your stats? I've had a quick google and can't find the right thing. The previous ones I've seen (which were similar) where for a pedestrian actually hit at the speed (ie the vehicle hasn't slowed down at all), which means they only apply to situations where the driver isn't paying attention (texting perhaps) or is too slow to react (drunk).

That said, I don't have a lot of patience with speeders. I would like to see a shift in cultural attitudes around driving. Drink driving used to be pretty much accepted and isn't anymore. I'd like to see the same happen with regards to speeding and mobile phone use.

3luckystars · 21/01/2022 11:33

I don’t agree at all. At all. At all.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 21/01/2022 11:32

Speeding isn't automatically as serious as drink (or increasingly) drug driving.

But there is a similarity in that they are both subject to artificial limits.

It's arguable that any alcohol is too much.

People virtue signalling about not breaking speed limits aren't automatically safe - just legal.

Sirzy · 21/01/2022 11:32

I think if your comparing drink driving with the 120mph type speeders then you have a point.

But on the whole speeding is more of a short term lapse in concentration which is bad and is dangerous but it’s not the same as making a decision to purposely drive when not fit to do so.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 21/01/2022 11:31

Lewis Hamilton will have quicker reflexes drunk than I do sober. So is it okay for him to drink and drive

It's not ok for anyone to drink and drive.

Iheartmysmart · 21/01/2022 11:31

I don’t think they are comparable at all. Personally I’d rather not drink anything if I’m driving. Sometimes I can have a glass of wine and feel fine, other times the same amount will make me feel lightheaded so it’s not worth the risk. I do however accidentally creep over the speed limit on occasions. Especially when our local council change the limit overnight which seems to happen on a regular basis.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 21/01/2022 11:31

@PurpleDaisies

Isn’t is quite likely someone who is drink driving is also speeding?
I'd agree with that.

It’s scary that speeding is so normalised that even good people, people with a strong sense of social responsibility, think it’s kind of ok

I agree that it should not be normalised and that people who think they are law abiding speed and think it's ok. But I do think there's a context where the risks are very low. Doing 80 on a motorway in dry weather - not so bad (although it kind of pushes everyone else along at that speed - I would like to see average speed cameras on all motorways). Doing it in fog - crazy and you should have the book thrown at you. Penalties should depend on context.

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:31

@JuergenSchwarzwald

You may well be an excellent driver, but you’re not in control of physics.

It will take you longer to brake from 40 than from 30. If you hit someone (a daft drunk pedestrian, a feckless cyclist without lights or high vis, a child) at 40 you’re more likely to kill them than at 40.

And as I said above Lewis Hamilton will have quicker reflexes drunk than I do sober. So is it okay for him to drink and drive?

OP posts:
gymbummy · 21/01/2022 11:30

I went on a speed awareness course thinking that it would be a complete waste of time and was just something to do to avoid 3 points on my licence. I'd always thought of speeding as something everybody does to some degree (I'm not talking about flying through a town centre at 80mph, just 35 in a 30 now and again). I'd also always thought of drink driving as the ultimate despicable and selfish behaviour, I would NEVER drink and drive.

My mind was blown when I started thinking about it during the speed awareness course. If I hit someone and killed them doing 35 in a 30 they wouldn't be less dead than if I I'd hit them at 30 having had 5 pints. If someone hit and killed my child doing 35 in a 30, I wouldn't grieve less because 'at least they weren't drunk'.

I had genuinely never thought about it like that before. I don't think this is just because I am really thick....

LavenderAskew · 21/01/2022 11:29

I think it's because so many more people know there's a chance they might speed.

Also speeding can be corrected, In the sense you might go over the limit unintentionally, notice and decrease your speed.

I do agree that drivers who drive over the speed limit, remain over and make manoeuvres at that speed are as reckless and dangerous as people driving over the limit.

Also, with speeding many, many people feel speeding isn't bad because they do it. Believing they are such good drivers they have control.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 11:28

Not the same .

You can (and I do) drive fast and be in complete control of a vehicle.

Hope that helps

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:27

@GunsNShips, but I don’t think I care whether someone kills me because they’ve made a choice to speed or because they’ve made a choice to have an extra beer.

OP posts:
JuergenSchwarzwald · 21/01/2022 11:26

They are not remotely comparable.

If you drink alcohol and drive, you know you are not in control of the car.

I can easily do 40 in a 30 limit and be in perfect control of the car and certainly at night, be no risk to anyone.

Of course doing something like 100 on a motorway is unacceptable, or 50 past a school where loads of kids are coming out, but that is a different point. Context matters (from a moral if not legal perspective).

When drinking and driving, there is no such thing as an acceptable context.

SoupDragon · 21/01/2022 11:26

I think it's because drink driving is a deliberate choice on the part of the driver.

The end result can be the same but "accidental" speeding can be corrected (eg you notice it's crept up and immediately slow down or realise the limit has changed). With drunk driving you are a risk for the entire journey, there is no opportunity to correct it.

.

PurpleDaisies · 21/01/2022 11:26

Isn’t is quite likely someone who is drink driving is also speeding?

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 21/01/2022 11:26

The courts do make a distinction in the level of alcohol. Slightly over the limit is treated very different to completely bladdered.

(People do commit drink driving without realising it...Next day driving. More people aware of it now obviously, but not long ago many wouldn't think twice about it!)

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:25

@Ikona,

But by creeping up to 35 you’re significantly increasing your risk of hurting or killing someone - stats below from Federation of Traffic Safety in US.

What’s interesting is that - from your post - you seem a responsible, cautious person with a strong sense of social responsibility. It’s scary that speeding is so normalised that even good people, people with a strong sense of social responsibility, think it’s kind of ok.

‘The average risk of severe injury for a pedestrian struck by a vehicle reaches 10% at an impact speed of 16 mph, 25% at 23 mph, 50% at 31 mph, 75% at 39 mph, and 90% at 46 mph. The average risk of death for a pedestrian reaches 10% at an impact speed of 23 mph, 25% at 32 mph, 50% at 42 mph, 75% at 50 mph, and 90% at 58 mph.’

OP posts:
solbunny · 21/01/2022 11:24

If someone accidentally creeps slightly over the limit and then corrects it quickly, fair enough. I'm sure literally everyone has done that. But people who knowingly speed, even if it's only a little over the limit, are immoral and pretty stupid imo.

I will never understand how people can justify speeding and not feel embarrassed, it makes you look so foolish, selfish, and arrogant.

GunsNShips · 21/01/2022 11:23

YABU.

With drunk driving you are taking choice away. Choice to slow down, choice to stop at the light, choice to stay in your own lane, choice not to mount a pavement. It doesn’t just make your reaction times slower, it impairs your whole decision making process.

MindyStClaire · 21/01/2022 11:22

I think there are degrees of seriousness for speeding - couldn't get worked up about 75 on the motorway, or not noticing a temporarary limit, not slowing quickly enough downhill etc. Whereas drink driving is open and shut for me, regardless of the level someone is over.

DropYourSword · 21/01/2022 11:22

@Highdaysandholidaze

But why aren’t they the same? I get that the law treats them differently - but legal difference isn’t the same as moral difference.

I get that people can be only slightly speeding, but then people can be only slightly over the alcohol limit too.

They're not the same because you can have a momentary lapse of concentration and be a couple of miles over the speed limit and then rectify it immediately.

If you have alcohol in your system you can't immediately rectify it.

I agree that excessive speeding is very dangerous, but your general argument seems to be oversimplification of lots of shades of nuance!

Ikona · 21/01/2022 11:21

@Highdaysandholidaze

But why aren’t they the same? I get that the law treats them differently - but legal difference isn’t the same as moral difference.

I get that people can be only slightly speeding, but then people can be only slightly over the alcohol limit too.

When someone is genuinely slightly speeding, notices and slows down, they've corrected the error they didn't notice they were making at first. If I've been drinking alcohol and drive while over the limit, I'm well aware I've been drinking and there's a chance I'm over the limit. In my case, I can drink so I'm under the limit and still be drunk. I'd be extremely unsafe behind the wheel, but my blood alcohol levels would be legal, so I avoid alcohol before driving completely.
Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:20

@PurpleDaisies

So does drunk driving. Half a beer over the limit is different from a bottle of Jack Daniel’s over the limit.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread