Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think drink driving and speeding are morally equivalent

162 replies

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:03

One gets treated as unforgivable, the other as a peccadillo. The sort of thing we all do, so it can’t be that bad.

But drink driving isn’t bad in and of itself. If someone wants to down a bottle of gin and drive round a deserted island then good luck to them. Drink driving is bad because it increases the risk of hurting or killing other people.

Speeding’s the same, isn’t it? It increases your odds of hurting or killing someone.

Does it make it worse if you kill someone with your car because you’re half cut rather than if you’re over the limit?

One defence people seem to have is that their speeding wasn’t dangerous. They’ll say that the speed limit was silly in that area, or that there wasn’t anyone else on the road.

But people used to say the same sort of stuff about drink driving. And tbh Lewis Hamilton will have better reflexes after four beers than I do sober.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Wnkingawalrus · 21/01/2022 12:38

@JuergenSchwarzwald

They are not remotely comparable.

If you drink alcohol and drive, you know you are not in control of the car.

I can easily do 40 in a 30 limit and be in perfect control of the car and certainly at night, be no risk to anyone.

Of course doing something like 100 on a motorway is unacceptable, or 50 past a school where loads of kids are coming out, but that is a different point. Context matters (from a moral if not legal perspective).

When drinking and driving, there is no such thing as an acceptable context.

This.

And context is everything. I don’t believe for a second that I pose as much danger doing 75 on a quiet motorway during a dry day as I do if I’m driving over the limit.

Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 12:37

I’ve already explained I set the limit 2mph below the speed limit.

Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 12:37

You literally press a button to turn it off.

I’ve never felt in danger from it ever.

But if it’s not something you feel you would be happy to have, you don’t need to use it.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 21/01/2022 12:36

@Ovenaffray

You can do both. I have the speed front and. I have routine of watching the road, flicking eyes to speed briefly (it’s right in front of me it takes milliseconds). Back to watching road.

I have a max speed limiter thing on my car. I use it. What’s wrong with that? Why wouldn’t I use a system designed to help me not break the law?

What have you set the limiter to?Grin 5mph.
Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 12:35

It’s easy to turn off

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 12:35

[quote girlmom21]@Agrudge with a speed limiter you set the speed limit and your car just won't go any faster no matter how much you press the accelerator [/quote]
To me that can also be dangerous. What if you need the extra speed to get out of a situation

Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 12:35

No it’s an actual limit I set on my car @Agrudge. In a 30 I set it to 28, for example, and even if I sink the boot to the floor the car will not go past 28.

girlmom21 · 21/01/2022 12:33

@Agrudge with a speed limiter you set the speed limit and your car just won't go any faster no matter how much you press the accelerator

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 12:32

@Ovenaffray

You can do both. I have the speed front and. I have routine of watching the road, flicking eyes to speed briefly (it’s right in front of me it takes milliseconds). Back to watching road.

I have a max speed limiter thing on my car. I use it. What’s wrong with that? Why wouldn’t I use a system designed to help me not break the law?

Just curious how does that work? I havent driven a car with a limiter on it. It's like the new gps based system that new cars have ?
IllManneredBitch · 21/01/2022 12:30

I find phrases like 'completely in control' and 'perfectly safe' indicative of a very arrogant attitude that puts everyone on the road at risk. You aren't ever in control of all the variables and the slower you drive, the more time you have to react and the shorter your stopping distance. (Obviously I understand that driving too slowly for the conditions is also dangerous so I'm not advocating staying significantly under the limit in normal conditions either).

Driving is dangerous, a lot of people are killed and injured every day on the roads. Good, careful drivers can still make a mistake. It's never just your own life you're gambling. I take my responsibilities really seriously when it comes to being in charge of a car and I try never to lose sight of the terrible consequences a little lapse could have. I don't want to endanger anyone, go to prison, be fined or jeopardise my licence. I agree speeding deliberately is as bad as drink driving. I don't think anyone is immune to a slight drift or missing a sign occasionally and that isn't as bad as drink driving.

Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 12:27

You can do both. I have the speed front and. I have routine of watching the road, flicking eyes to speed briefly (it’s right in front of me it takes milliseconds). Back to watching road.

I have a max speed limiter thing on my car. I use it. What’s wrong with that? Why wouldn’t I use a system designed to help me not break the law?

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 12:24

@Ovenaffray

I got slaughtered on a thread yesterday for saying I am law abiding and don’t break the speed limit and if I do I’m mortified and ashamed.

For me, they’re the same. As is any law. And I obey the law.

I have an eye on my speed all the time and stay 2mph under the limit as much as I can. If I see my speed creep to the limit I immediately correct myself.

I can’t, of course, say I have never gone a mile or two over - yes, very occasionally for a very short period of time of a few seconds. But I correct it as soon as I can.

I never drive if I’ve had any alcohol at all. Every drink increase your risk of crashing.

I feel its safer to focus more on the road(and surroundings) instead of monitoring your speed constantly.

But that's me

SoupDragon · 21/01/2022 12:23

@Agrudge

Not the same .

You can (and I do) drive fast and be in complete control of a vehicle.

Hope that helps

How do you magically stop at 40 in the same time/distance it would take at 30? What is your secret? Or do you simply not give a shit?
Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 12:16

I got slaughtered on a thread yesterday for saying I am law abiding and don’t break the speed limit and if I do I’m mortified and ashamed.

For me, they’re the same. As is any law. And I obey the law.

I have an eye on my speed all the time and stay 2mph under the limit as much as I can. If I see my speed creep to the limit I immediately correct myself.

I can’t, of course, say I have never gone a mile or two over - yes, very occasionally for a very short period of time of a few seconds. But I correct it as soon as I can.

I never drive if I’ve had any alcohol at all. Every drink increase your risk of crashing.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 12:08

@etulosba

but I don’t think I care whether someone kills me because they’ve made a choice to speed or because they’ve made a choice to have an extra beer.

It’s unlikely to happen though. Millions of people speed every day and nothing bad happens at all.

Exactly this . For the most most part speeding is a victimless crime
GrolliffetheDragon · 21/01/2022 12:08

I don't think they're the same. If you're over the limit you shouldn't be driving at all - and if I drove I wouldn't after drinking any alcohol. Someone accidentally drifting a few mph over the limit and then correcting, or temporarily speeding up to avoid a hazard is not really comparable.

The problem is that speeding is not seen as socially unacceptable, so is done routinely and deliberately rather than as an exception - like the person who was driving at 80mph (according to the electronic sign) on a residential street with a school on it, and no room for two cars to pass because of parking on both sides of the road.

whosaidtha · 21/01/2022 12:06

I don't think there is a single person who drives that has never been 5+mph above the speed limit by accident. You creep up without noticing, you think the road is 40 when it's 30, someone is up your arse so you speed up a little to get distance. Lots of things happen. If you OP claim to never have sped I won't believe you.

girlmom21 · 21/01/2022 11:49

If you're speeding you can slow down in a millisecond. If you're drunk you can't sober up in a millisecond.

Lots of accidents caused by drunk drivers happen because they're drunk and speeding.

Nidan2Sandan · 21/01/2022 11:46

Whilst I agree that I wouldnt care if my kid was killed by someone who accidentally went over the speed limit, drove drunk, or purposefully went over the speed limit, the law does see it differently and does allow for human nature as it rightfully should.

In modern cars these days, its really easy to not notice your speed creep up to 35mph. Not an excuse, but it is what it is. That person has not made a conscious choice to drive in a manner that could be dangerous and i'm sure as soon as they notice they reduce their speed. They should probably have been keeping an eye on the speedo better, but more than likely were just trying to get from A to B. Are they a bad person, a criminal, no, they're not. Could they hurt or even kill someone, absolutely they could.

If you're drving at 50 in a 30, well, obviously you CAN notice that and that means you chose to drive like a twat and have a very good chance of killing someone.

If you've had alcohol (and I believe the limit should be zero not 35mg) then you choose to put yourself and others at risk and should take the blame for that. No one accidentally drinks alcohol.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 11:46

I agree using a phone while driving is more like drink driving.

But you'll never convince me doing 90mph on a motorway in average or under traffic is dangerous.

I think we need the isle of man approach. Where your judge by how you drive rather than how fast you drive. I've driving there at 90mph on what is similar to an open country road over here. Perfectly safe

NightmareSlashDelightful · 21/01/2022 11:45

I mean at one level, how you rank things morally is up to you. If you see them as the same, you see them as the same.

To me, they're not the same. Although both are bad and dangerous, just at different levels and in different ways. And I think one big difference is that with speeding, you can correct whilst behind the wheel, and slow down almost instantly. You can't do that with drinking -- it takes hours for the alcohol to be worked out of your system.

Plus drink-driving is to a degree pre-meditated -- you know when you sink that pint, or order that large glass of wine, and you also know an hour later when you walk out to your car and get in the driver's seat. It's a series of very deliberate advance decisions. Whereas speeding is more either poor judgement, ignorance, or a behavioural failing.

I'd also like to throw in poor car maintenance. I have a personal angle on this -- my schoolfriend was killed by a woman who didn't realise that her bald tyres were dangerous and that they wouldn't stop her in time. She wasn't speeding and she wasn't drunk, but she still killed a young girl with her car. I think people who ignorantly fail to maintain their cars and then go on to hurt or kill somebody should be punished more severely.

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 11:45

Define "speeding". Is, say, driving at 22 in a 20 zone as dangerous as drink driving?

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 21/01/2022 11:43

Focusing on speed means statistically a driver is less likely to seriously main or kill if you hit a person.
It's an easy winner for the authorities.
If you drive at 31 in a 30 there aren't suddenly going to be people to hit appearing.🤣🤣🤣🤣

Drunk driving negatively impacts a broader set of skills needed to drive. Speeding is a narrow parameter.

etulosba · 21/01/2022 11:42

but I don’t think I care whether someone kills me because they’ve made a choice to speed or because they’ve made a choice to have an extra beer.

It’s unlikely to happen though. Millions of people speed every day and nothing bad happens at all.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 21/01/2022 11:38

That said, I don't have a lot of patience with speeders. I would like to see a shift in cultural attitudes around driving. Drink driving used to be pretty much accepted and isn't anymore. I'd like to see the same happen with regards to speeding and mobile phone use

I do think mobile phone use should become as socially unacceptable as drink driving. However, when car manufacturers are putting screens on dashboards that are as distracting I am not sure what the answer to that is other than governments imposing tough regulation on car standards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread