Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think drink driving and speeding are morally equivalent

162 replies

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:03

One gets treated as unforgivable, the other as a peccadillo. The sort of thing we all do, so it can’t be that bad.

But drink driving isn’t bad in and of itself. If someone wants to down a bottle of gin and drive round a deserted island then good luck to them. Drink driving is bad because it increases the risk of hurting or killing other people.

Speeding’s the same, isn’t it? It increases your odds of hurting or killing someone.

Does it make it worse if you kill someone with your car because you’re half cut rather than if you’re over the limit?

One defence people seem to have is that their speeding wasn’t dangerous. They’ll say that the speed limit was silly in that area, or that there wasn’t anyone else on the road.

But people used to say the same sort of stuff about drink driving. And tbh Lewis Hamilton will have better reflexes after four beers than I do sober.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Keke94LND · 21/01/2022 13:36

I think speeding it depends, where's drink driving there's no excuse other than you are a dick. Ofcourse, you can be a dick if you speed, but for example, I got caught speeding on a 30 going 37, because the road used to be a 40 and I hadn't realised it was now a 30

PurpleDaisies · 21/01/2022 13:36

@PattyPan

I actually think speeding is worse - at least with drink driving the alcohol has impaired your judgment.
Sorry, “at least the alcohol has impaired your judgement”? What does that even mean?
PattyPan · 21/01/2022 13:34

I actually think speeding is worse - at least with drink driving the alcohol has impaired your judgment.

Thinkbiglittleone · 21/01/2022 13:34

If I could put a gadget in my car to literally prevent me being able to speed I would, but these aren’t available despite the technology being possible.

You have eyes. If you cannot monitor and be aware of your own speed, you really should not be driving a car if your concentration can not be such that it keeps you and others safe.

solbunny · 21/01/2022 13:32

@Ifailed

50 years ago, drink driving (amongst men) was routine, and getting caught was seen to be 'bad luck'. Since then things have moved on, helped by government campaigns, to the point that most people would see it as reprehensible (although I know several men in the late 60s/70s who still persist). Speeding is routine by many drivers, men and women, and getting caught is seen as 'bad luck', with speed cameras labelled as unfair and a 'tax' on drivers. Plenty of people think themselves above the law, and believe their driving skills are so superior that they can ignore speed limits. Is it going to take another government campaign to change this?
Completely agree
Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 13:31

If I could put a gadget in my car to literally prevent me being able to speed I would, but these aren’t available despite the technology being possible.

That’s literally what my speed limiter does.

(I really do need to step away from this thread)

Thinkbiglittleone · 21/01/2022 13:30

No one gets in the car intending to speed. Drink drivers get in the car over the limit intending to drink drive.

I disagree, if someone is running late, they know they are going to be speeding to get where they need to be on time.
Some people just like driving fast and it's the norm to do 80/90 on the motorway that's not an accident.
Cars have sensors now that you can set to alarm you when you go over a certain speed
Cars have cruise control that you can set.

A lot of drink divers are caught the next day, adamant they are fine. Some jump in the car after eating out, working out how long they have been there so it's fine to have 2 pints and they have miscalculated it, not all drink drivers are on mad nights out, stumbling around, some it's a mistake and they are just over.

FudgeSundae · 21/01/2022 13:21

The difference is premeditation, which is reflected in culpability for a number of criminal acts, e.g. murder - the law says murdering someone is worse if you plan it than if it is a crime of passion.

No one gets in the car intending to speed. Drink drivers get in the car over the limit intending to drink drive.

I agree if you’re the person hit you may not care which, just as if you’re the person murdered you don’t care if it’s planned or not - but it is a concept well reflected in law.

It’s also harder to prevent speeding - I literally never drink and drive, even a tiny amount, as then there’s no grey area. Therefore I totally prevent the possibility. If I could put a gadget in my car to literally prevent me being able to speed I would, but these aren’t available despite the technology being possible.

Thinkbiglittleone · 21/01/2022 13:19

Yes, it is the same.

You are responsible for a vehicle and you should use that accordingly and stay on full safe, control of that car to prevent it being used as a weapon.

Do I ever speed, yes I do.
Is it right, no it's absolutely not but I can own the mistakes I make and don't try to defend them, I do try to be more compliant though.

BadLad · 21/01/2022 13:19

@PurpleDaisies

I read things, and sometimes remember them.

You can understand why that doesn’t seem like a very reliable source of information.

Your question was how I know it.
Duchess379 · 21/01/2022 13:18

The major difference between the 2 is that drink/drug driving impairs your judgement so you are much slower to recognise danger & react to it. Speeding, although still an offence doesn't impair your judgement but does cut down your reaction time when faced with danger. Doing 37 in a 30 is still an offence but you'll probably still be able to react & stop in time. Doing 25 in a 30 whilst drunk or drugged up, you're less likely to see someone cross the road & run them over!

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:15

It's on the police programs . Is one of the signs of a possible drink driver

PurpleDaisies · 21/01/2022 13:14

I read things, and sometimes remember them.

You can understand why that doesn’t seem like a very reliable source of information.

FreedomFaith · 21/01/2022 13:14

Any kind of driving where you aren't in full control of the vehicle and can cause an accident is bad in my view. This includes drink driving, speeding consistently, driving while tired, driving when not confident, driving while using a phone etc.

I know people will think driving while not confident isn't a big deal, but the only non confident people on the road should be learners. If you've passed your test, you should be able to drive confidently in all types of situations and if you can't, don't drive. You're likely to panic way more easily and cause a crash.

BadLad · 21/01/2022 13:13

@PurpleDaisies

Actually a lot of drink drivers drive well below the speed limit. They're way over the limit but they still have some awareness that they shouldn't be driving, so they slow right down, thinking it will compensate. You know this how?
I read things, and sometimes remember them.
MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 21/01/2022 13:12

For me, speeding is as bad if it's in a built up area where children and people might be crossing roads, playing out etc. doing over 30 in a residential area is intolerable.

Doing 85 on the motorway I can't get so worked up about.

Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 13:12

Anyway. I’m definitely bowing out now.

Thanks again for starting this op.

etulosba · 21/01/2022 13:11

You know this how?

Well, I know it from watching police reality programmes on the telly.

Ovenaffray · 21/01/2022 13:10

I researched and the average over read in my car is between 2mph and 3mph over - hence setting it 2mph below.

PurpleDaisies · 21/01/2022 13:10

Actually a lot of drink drivers drive well below the speed limit. They're way over the limit but they still have some awareness that they shouldn't be driving, so they slow right down, thinking it will compensate.
You know this how?

BadLad · 21/01/2022 13:09

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Surely being drunk behind the wheel increases the likelihood that someone will speed - either because they don't care what speed they are doing or because they can't control it due to the alcohol.

So speeding - bad
Drink driving - unforgiveable

Actually a lot of drink drivers drive well below the speed limit. They're way over the limit but they still have some awareness that they shouldn't be driving, so they slow right down, thinking it will compensate.
etulosba · 21/01/2022 13:09

Built up areas

etulosba · 21/01/2022 13:09

It's the way people have been conditioned

It could be generational. I am old enough to remember when there were no speed limits in the UK. Outside built areas, that is.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:08

@Ovenaffray

I understand that sentencing gives degrees, but morally to me both are the same. Breaking the law.

Anyway I’m not quite sure I’m not being made fun of so I’m going to bow out.

Interesting discussion op. Thanks for starting it. It certainly made me think.

I dont blame you. The way you got treated in the thread yesterday was horrible. Me and you Cleary have opposite views on this subject but I respect you opinion
YouokHun · 21/01/2022 13:07

@Tay17

Yep I also know someone who will consistently speed everywhere (full of the ‘it’s an empty road’ ‘there’s no houses’ excuses etc etc yet is in uproar when someone speeds pasts their house! Hypocritical much.
In my village we have a very active speed watch group who collect data on speeds in the 30 or 40 mph limits and are rightly vocal about some of the dangerous driving they see. One of them overtook me yesterday coming into my village on a 40 mph stretch having sat on my tail and must have hurtled into the 30mph zone at well over 50 mph, right past the spot she stands in to discourage other speeders Confused We all make mistakes and realise we are going too fast sometimes but this was quite aggressive and very much ignoring the signs.

I agree about the “it’s an empty road” or “it’s fine I know this stretch” logic and I have experience of this logic being applied: When I was 15 a very close family member popped out to fill his car up with petrol. It was 20 minute job. When he wasn’t back after an hour we started to get concerned (this is well before we had mobiles). After two hours we were getting quietly frantic and trying to reassure each other. Not much later two police officers came to the door and told us that he had been killed in a head on crash. It transpired that the woman who killed him was over the alcohol limit and had been going at a good 20 mph over the speed limit on a piece of road “she knew really well”, she was “just nipping home” from the pub so didn’t think being a bit over the limit would be a problem. Her selfish decisions that day took a 47 year old man’s life, left a widow and three devastated young teens who I don’t think have ever really recovered. I’ll never forget that day and every time I get in my car I think “why not me?” and all I can do is moderate my own driving behaviour and hope others are doing the same.

Anyone who doesn’t accept their own fallibility and doesn’t accept that the driving rules are there for a reason and also apply to them is a concern. Whether their speed kills someone or their alcohol level the outcome is the same for their victim. I guess speed is more of an every day slip up whereas drinking and driving seems to be a more pre meditated act. Certainly the drink drivers I have known have been habitual.

Swipe left for the next trending thread