Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think drink driving and speeding are morally equivalent

162 replies

Highdaysandholidaze · 21/01/2022 11:03

One gets treated as unforgivable, the other as a peccadillo. The sort of thing we all do, so it can’t be that bad.

But drink driving isn’t bad in and of itself. If someone wants to down a bottle of gin and drive round a deserted island then good luck to them. Drink driving is bad because it increases the risk of hurting or killing other people.

Speeding’s the same, isn’t it? It increases your odds of hurting or killing someone.

Does it make it worse if you kill someone with your car because you’re half cut rather than if you’re over the limit?

One defence people seem to have is that their speeding wasn’t dangerous. They’ll say that the speed limit was silly in that area, or that there wasn’t anyone else on the road.

But people used to say the same sort of stuff about drink driving. And tbh Lewis Hamilton will have better reflexes after four beers than I do sober.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 21/01/2022 15:02

As someone whose 17 year old son witnessed his friend being mown down and killed by a driver doing 73mph in a 40 zone, I agree. he would not plead guilty even though there was overwhelming evidence against him and made my son and his friends have to re-live the nightmare as witnesses in court. He bleated that he wasn't drunk or on his phone etc. He got four years.

Mumofsend · 21/01/2022 14:59

I'm surprised it's not been mentioned either but doing 40 on a clear, well moving motorway is far far more dangerous than doing 80.

layladomino · 21/01/2022 14:56

It's an interesting point, but I think there is a fundamental difference.

A drink driver is by definition not in control of the car. Whether or not they speed. They aren't fully capable of responding correctly and quickly to changes in circumstances, of seeing all that's going on around them, even if they are travelling at 10mph they are dangerous.

It is possible to speed and be safe. Speed limits are manmade constructs that create a rule that people can be measured against. There are a number of studies that show that some speed limits are actually set lower than they need to be, and by increasing them you would increase safer driving.

Yes of course some speeding is dangerous. And yes, if you have an accident while speeding it is likely to be more serious.

But a drink driver isn't even in a position to know what the speed limit is, or to monitor their speed. So a drink driver may also speed, but without consideration for whether they can handle the car properly, and with impaired reflexes. They are less safe than a sober speeder.

And be careful with the stats. There are more accidents due to speed than drink. But then there are many many more people who speed than drink drive. Proportionately, if you drink drive you are more likely to have an accident. And also, those stats for speeding will include drink drivers who were speeding.

By the way, I'm no apoligist for speeding. I'm a stickler for speed limits.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 14:39

As could both my cars and my wifes car

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 14:38

@IllManneredBitch

Great, we have safer conditions here than the Isle of Man, I think we should keep it that way and not apply the rules from there to here.

Stopping distances will always be greater the faster you're going. Chances of the person you hit surviving will always reduce the faster you're going. So going faster will be more dangerous.

The pointing was making on stpping distances is I'm pretty sure (but I could be wrong) are based on old technology. Brakes have vastly improved since highway code published them. I'm almost certain my motorbike could stop in much less distance than what's quoted on the highway code
ChiefInspectorParker · 21/01/2022 14:32

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

IllManneredBitch · 21/01/2022 14:25

Great, we have safer conditions here than the Isle of Man, I think we should keep it that way and not apply the rules from there to here.

Stopping distances will always be greater the faster you're going. Chances of the person you hit surviving will always reduce the faster you're going. So going faster will be more dangerous.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 14:14

@MojoMoon

Escooters for hire in London are fitted with speed limitiers and geo fenced so the speed limit is low on some routes (shared paths) than others.

I don't understand why cars are not required to be fitted with the same speed limiting tech.

Lorries are often fitted with speed limitiers and some delivery vans are - along with black boxes recording the speed travelled and braking patterns to identify terrible drivers.

We should stop treating driving as a right and be much stricter on limiting who can do it and demand high standards.
It's the greatest threat of harm to our children (death and serious injuries)

The problem with geofencing is it's not 100% accurate if your signal gets weak the gps could think you on a road nearby where it's a 30 limit and you could be on a motorway. Next thing your being forced to slow down to 30 putting you in a very dangerous position
Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:59

Just out of interest when were the stopping distances last updated?

You have clearly never been to the isle of man. The road surfaces arent great, the standard of driving is definitely below the average over here and it can get busy over the mountain road. But I could do 150mph across it legally

RegardingMary · 21/01/2022 13:59

To me the difference is if someone goes out to a put necks 8 pints and gets in a car and drives it, they've premeditated it, they're a danger from the minute they get in the car until they get out it. It doesn't change if there on a highly built up street or outside a school.

Someone speeding may have thought, ohvits quiet here, I'll speed up. As soon as they drop their speed they're back at low risk.

I'm not excusing either.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 21/01/2022 13:57

@MojoMoon

Escooters for hire in London are fitted with speed limitiers and geo fenced so the speed limit is low on some routes (shared paths) than others.

I don't understand why cars are not required to be fitted with the same speed limiting tech.

Lorries are often fitted with speed limitiers and some delivery vans are - along with black boxes recording the speed travelled and braking patterns to identify terrible drivers.

We should stop treating driving as a right and be much stricter on limiting who can do it and demand high standards.
It's the greatest threat of harm to our children (death and serious injuries)

The problem with this would be that it's expensive and hard to retro-fit to existing vehicles. We can't effectively enforce the requirements for people to have a licence to drive, tax and MOT so this would be even harder, and the bellends who drive like bellends now would carry on.
IllManneredBitch · 21/01/2022 13:54

@Agrudge speed limits aren't 'arbitrary', no one plucks them out of the air and applies them at random. It's really clear how stopping distances are affected by speed and how the impact of a collision is intensified by speed. That's where the limits come from.

If the rules are different on the Isle of Man, perhaps that's because the conditions are different - types of road, amount of traffic etc. It doesn't mean that their rules can just be applied here.

Speeding laws are really not equivalent to a North Korean dictatorship.

People make the same excuses for drink driving as for speeding - it's the arrogant belief that they are a superior driver/know the road/trust their own judgement and so on and so on. It doesn't make it safe.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:52

@Keke94LND

Calm down. That sound dangerously like common sense

Momicrone · 21/01/2022 13:52

Purpledaisies, it means there is literally no excuse to speed because your judgment is not impaired, you're just choosing to drive dangerously

Keke94LND · 21/01/2022 13:48

[quote Highdaysandholidaze]@JuergenSchwarzwald

You may well be an excellent driver, but you’re not in control of physics.

It will take you longer to brake from 40 than from 30. If you hit someone (a daft drunk pedestrian, a feckless cyclist without lights or high vis, a child) at 40 you’re more likely to kill them than at 40.

And as I said above Lewis Hamilton will have quicker reflexes drunk than I do sober. So is it okay for him to drink and drive?[/quote]
OP I would judge someone who killed someone whilst speeding the same as I would judge someone who killed someone whilst drink driving. But if neither of those people killed anyone, I would judge the drink driver regardless, I'd only judge the speeder if they were doing ridiculous speeds in a ridiculous location (I.e if they were doing 60 in a 30 I'd judge them, if they were doing 40 in a 30 I probs wouldn't)

Dutchesss · 21/01/2022 13:44

With speeding it really depends on the speed, 10% over the speed limit while overtaking or taking your eyes off the speedo is completely different to recklessly driving way over the limit.
Also, doing 80 mph on the motorway is very different to doing 30 mph on a 20 mph outside a school for example.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:44

*this isnt North Korea

We dont need more controlling in the uk

Mumofsend · 21/01/2022 13:43

Speeding wise there is a HUGE difference between doing 80 in 70 compared to 30 in a 20 etc.

I had to do a speed course, average speed cameras for a temporary 60 stretch that was usually 70 at 2am in the morning. The police officer delivering that said along the same lines.

I'm more in control of my car at 80 in a 70 than I could ever be even slightly over the limit.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:41

@MojoMoon

Escooters for hire in London are fitted with speed limitiers and geo fenced so the speed limit is low on some routes (shared paths) than others.

I don't understand why cars are not required to be fitted with the same speed limiting tech.

Lorries are often fitted with speed limitiers and some delivery vans are - along with black boxes recording the speed travelled and braking patterns to identify terrible drivers.

We should stop treating driving as a right and be much stricter on limiting who can do it and demand high standards.
It's the greatest threat of harm to our children (death and serious injuries)

Well isnt North Korea we are free to make our own decisions right or wrong
Bucanarab · 21/01/2022 13:40

Yabu.

"Speeding" is a concept defined by arbitrary laws. Take the motorway speed limit for example, this has been the same since the 1960s and hasn't been adjusted to reflect the massive improvements in car performance, road condition (arguable I know), or volume of traffic.

Similarly, 10 years ago you could drive through Edinburgh at 30mph without a worry, now you'd be 10mph over the limit in most places in the city. It wasn't any safer to driver at 30mph back then just because that was the speed limit.

What IS as bad as drink driving, and something that I see constantly, is driving too fast for the conditions whether that involves exceeding the speed limit or not. It is far less dangerous to do 90mph on a clear, straight motorway in good conditions than it is to do 50mph on a snowy, wet, busy motorway.

Exhausteddog · 21/01/2022 13:40

Attitudes to drink driving were hugely changed by government advertising. Wish we had the same for speeding- this sort of thingwww.youtube.com/watch?v=B2rFTbvwteo

There is quite a hard hitting ad that I've seen a few times recently, about speeding, with a dad driving in a car with 2 kids.

I do agree with some pp that sometimes it depends on conditions and time. I used to regularly drive along a 3 lane road into London. The speed limit was 40mph. During the day it was so busy it was virtually impossible to do more than about 20mph. At night, if dry and good visibilty it was easy to creep over 40 on what was essentially like a motorway in a non residential area.

I'm always surprised at speed limits on narrow, country lanes. Often the speed limit is 60mph which to me seems strange on roads, with limited visibility (hedges, winding roads) where 2 cars can not pass safely at various points, and will need to slow down significantly.

Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:39

I would think they mean because of the alcohol your decision making capabilities are worse. Where if your speeding you thinking clearly

MojoMoon · 21/01/2022 13:39

Escooters for hire in London are fitted with speed limitiers and geo fenced so the speed limit is low on some routes (shared paths) than others.

I don't understand why cars are not required to be fitted with the same speed limiting tech.

Lorries are often fitted with speed limitiers and some delivery vans are - along with black boxes recording the speed travelled and braking patterns to identify terrible drivers.

We should stop treating driving as a right and be much stricter on limiting who can do it and demand high standards.
It's the greatest threat of harm to our children (death and serious injuries)

FreedomFaith · 21/01/2022 13:38

@FudgeSundae

The difference is premeditation, which is reflected in culpability for a number of criminal acts, e.g. murder - the law says murdering someone is worse if you plan it than if it is a crime of passion.

No one gets in the car intending to speed. Drink drivers get in the car over the limit intending to drink drive.

I agree if you’re the person hit you may not care which, just as if you’re the person murdered you don’t care if it’s planned or not - but it is a concept well reflected in law.

It’s also harder to prevent speeding - I literally never drink and drive, even a tiny amount, as then there’s no grey area. Therefore I totally prevent the possibility. If I could put a gadget in my car to literally prevent me being able to speed I would, but these aren’t available despite the technology being possible.

Well that's not totally true. Loads of people drive not caring if they speed or not, and some do set out to deliberately speed, whether because they don't want to drive slower or because they are late, makes no difference.
Agrudge · 21/01/2022 13:37

@etulosba

It's the way people have been conditioned

It could be generational. I am old enough to remember when there were no speed limits in the UK. Outside built areas, that is.

You see I'm not , I'm 37. But I know theres more to dangerous driving than go faster then a number in a metal circle
Swipe left for the next trending thread