Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...NOT to get a dog?

206 replies

LizLemonsGlasses · 21/01/2022 09:14

Yet another family we know has got a puppy - it genuinely feels like we're the only ones of our peer group not to have a dog!

My working circumstances have changed in a way which makes it much more doable for us, plus we live in a rural area, we like to walk and get outside, and I know that if we were to do it, it feels like now or never - DDs are 15 and 12 - and we would get the most of it as a family before we blink and the kids are off to uni or work or whatever.

I appreciate the benefits from a family and relationships perspective and all the wellbeing aspects of having a dog - for mental and physical health etc... but I still balk at the commitment and the extra layer of daily work and general organisation involved. There are times when I already find work/life balance difficult so adding a dog into the mix doesn't seem like a great idea. But then I read about how people do it and the dog can slot in and feels like they've always had it etc. etc.

I heard Gretchen Rubin on a podcast advocating for getting a dog - she did it as a way of 'choosing the bigger life' and while I love that idea, I just don't know if it's right for us - and then I feel a bit guilty, am I denying us a 'bigger life'??

This is technically all still hypothetical as DH remains less convinced than I am by that argument and we'd obviously have to be in agreement. And the solution can't be: get a cat - I am 100% a cat person and would love one but DH is definitely not (I could write a whole other thread about this Sad)

DD1 begs for a dog on an almost daily basis - especially now most of her friends have got one! - and it's getting harder to say no convincingly and without wondering if we really are missing out.

Are we doing the right thing NOT to get a dog?? Are we saying no to something that would really enhance our family life, and will we regret not giving ourselves and the DDs this life experience? Tell me we're not the only ones who still don't have a dog?!

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 24/01/2022 10:55

XelaM
Cats only barely tolerate humans and spend most of their time roaming outside like wild beasts. Plus litter trays are disgusting. Whereas no one will be happier to see you coming home than your dog“

You haven’t met our cats!
One is pretty much as you describe, 3 are firmly fair weather outdoor cats and enjoy our company, 1 is pretty much glued to me if I sit still for more than 30 seconds.

nalabae · 23/01/2022 19:43

@XelaM

Cats only barely tolerate humans and spend most of their time roaming outside like wild beasts. Plus litter trays are disgusting. Whereas no one will be happier to see you coming home than your dog
this is soooooooo untrue i have had cats my whole life
nalabae · 23/01/2022 19:42

as someone with two dogs (forced into this) and a cat, do not get a dog

they are hard work, i would never give up my pets but i wouldnt get another dog if my dogs passed

steppemum · 23/01/2022 19:19

@XelaM

Cats only barely tolerate humans and spend most of their time roaming outside like wild beasts. Plus litter trays are disgusting. Whereas no one will be happier to see you coming home than your dog
my cats always meet me at home. In fatc I went through a phase of driving different cars. It took the cat about 3 days each time to recognise the new car and then he would come running as I arrived home.

They comes and ask for cuddles, affection and before I got married I would always wake up with a cat asleep on my bed.

I don't use a litter tray, and cats never make the house smell unlike my dog.

I have both, but I don't recognise your description of a cat

BeMoreGoldfish · 22/01/2022 18:43

@XelaM you’ve been unlucky with your cats Smile

XelaM · 22/01/2022 18:07

Cats only barely tolerate humans and spend most of their time roaming outside like wild beasts. Plus litter trays are disgusting. Whereas no one will be happier to see you coming home than your dog

LizLemonsGlasses · 22/01/2022 17:50

@steppemum

I know not everyone likes cats, but honestly as someone who has both, I get about 80% of the things a dog brings also from my cat.

The one big thing I don't get is walking, and I love walking my dog, even on rainy cold days. Good boots and coat and it is fab being out in the weather.

The cat gives, cuddles affection, company, entertainment, etc etc.
But zero ties and very low commitment.
I think they are also massively less likely to need expensive treatment.

Just a whole other league.

Totally agree with you on this @steppemum, including the walking thing! I love to be outside. Agree a cat gives you the rest of the household pet experience though, without some of the main downsides of dog ownership. Just wish I could convince DH of this Sad I suppose it's the reason I've put myself in the position of considering a dog - because it's the only household pet I think he might tolerate.

He's not really an animal person but does like dogs. He's not very keen for us to get one either tbh but does occasionally show vague interest - whereas he won't even entertain the idea of a cat. Ironically, the reasons he gives for not getting one are: they smell, are bitey and damage your stuff - all the main downsides I think you would usually associate with having a dog!

I must admit it makes me really sad that I won't be a cat owner for the foreseeable future, or may never be. I love cats and I'm confident that owning one would most likely enrich my life and family life in a way that I'm now pretty sure having a dog would not...

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 22/01/2022 12:55

I love dogs, and would like one, but they are huge commitment so I wouldn’t.

Extra jobs on top of extra jobs can kill ya. Get a dog later in life when your commitments are less. If your DDs have friends with dogs, they can hang out with those.

Nothing against Gretchen Rubin, but that’s just a meaningless sound bite, not having a dog could equally lead to a bigger life if it meant you could travel more, do whatever more.

steppemum · 22/01/2022 12:06

I know not everyone likes cats, but honestly as someone who has both, I get about 80% of the things a dog brings also from my cat.

The one big thing I don't get is walking, and I love walking my dog, even on rainy cold days. Good boots and coat and it is fab being out in the weather.

The cat gives, cuddles affection, company, entertainment, etc etc.
But zero ties and very low commitment.
I think they are also massively less likely to need expensive treatment.

Just a whole other league.

feedthepeony · 22/01/2022 10:32

Last year we chose a pup. It was from a reputable rescue company, passed all the checks etc. he was only very young, we chose a name, paid a deposit and did a LOT of research into it. Hours and hours of reading.

A week before he was ready I got cold feet. And I knew and always said to myself if I had any doubts before picking him up, no matter how big or small, not to do it. We had to be 100% both sure as it's a huuuuge commitment.

We didn't get the puppy. And I'm super glad we didn't as Dd1 is only 1, we ended up moving home and life three in lots of obstacles, health reasons etc etc what seemed like the perfect time on paper, really turned into the worst time in reality.
I don't have any regrets, I didn't want to go in blinded and be one of those owners who ends up rehoming the poor thing because I didn't have the mental or physical time to put my all into this puppy, which is what each dog deserves.

We will get one, one day. But it will be years down the line when DD is no longer a toddler and we have a bigger garden.

We ended up buying a house bunny. Still a little of work and commitment, any animal is. But what it came down to, is we wanted a furry friend but in all honesty we weren't ready for the work she commitment for the puppy with the events that came up.

We have a happy house buns who is very well looked after, a happy home and zero regrets about not picking up that dog.

Long story short, unless you are ALL 100% ready to the commitment, hours of training, appointments, jabs, insurance, sleepless nights, noisy nights, daily whatever the weather walks, the fact that the pup may have a total different temperament to what you expect, health complications, chewing everything, please please don't.

Wait until you're both ready. Until you WANT to do all those things above, as well as all the good stuff that comes with a pup.

Frazzled2207 · 22/01/2022 09:36

Oh and once we got the dog and she didn’t like the kennels, that was basically the death knell for family holidays.

Frazzled2207 · 22/01/2022 09:34

Yanbu.
We are having a dog conversation right now and while I think we will get one we have agreed that everyone needs to be 100% on board. With older kids that would mean taking responsibility for walking etc

I pestered my parents for a dog and we got one when I was about 10. I loved her to pieces but my mum ended up doing 90% of the “dog work”(excuse the pun). Tread very carefully.

Karenetta · 22/01/2022 09:31

I know loads of people who got lockdown dogs and all of them moan about their pets. Think for a lot of people it was a mistake they now regret. Unsurprising as dogs are pretty inconvenient. Like a pp I think dog owners have smaller lives than other people because they can't do as much and they have less money to spare.

PupInAPram · 22/01/2022 09:10

@catwomando

Oh, and the 'bigger life' is just social media wankery Grin
@catwomando a truer word never was spoken.
PinkSyCo · 22/01/2022 08:16

The trick is to get an "easy" breed and not to go for popular high energy dogs like Labradors, Spaniels, Poodles and Poodle mixes etc.

We got a pug and he is the easiest, cuddliest, laziest, friendliest dog ever. As long as he is fed, he sleeps almost all day on the sofa (usually on the electric blanket). He was extended easy to potty train as well.

Nothing wrong with a Labrador. Pugs however, thanks to rigorous selective breeding, are in a permanent state of respiratory distress, which is probably why yours spends all it’s time sleeping. Sad

speakout · 22/01/2022 06:37

Pugs and many others are examples of cruel breeding.
Vets call them "anatomical disasters" many suffering a lifetime of breathing difficulties and eye problems.
They have been deformed by mankind, and I would like to see the breed banned.
www.boredpanda.com/pugs-malformed-inbred-animals-not-cute-tumblr-thread/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=organic

catwomando · 22/01/2022 06:23

Oh, and the 'bigger life' is just social media wankery Grin

catwomando · 22/01/2022 06:17

I think all of our friends have dogs. They are cute but such a tie. Visiting us for weekends is a problem (we have cats) so the dogs need sitting. Even going out for dinner "we can't leave the dog too long as he gets lonely". And the mess and poo cleaning. And overseas holidays require so much planning and expense.

Dogs are very sweet (mostly) and I like quite a few of the ones I know, but unless you are ready to do all of,the work and make all of,the sacrifices I'd say no.

onedayoranother · 22/01/2022 06:16

I have two and they are a big commitment. If you got one you will be the main dog walker - I have yet to see a family where the kids do the walking (unless they are going to do it before school, and it's not reasonable to expect them too, plus the dog will need walking again before they are back).
My friend got a dog - too big and powerful for her. Her kids and husband did the majority of that, but now they've grown up moved out and she's also getting a divorce and is 'stuck' with a dog she can barely cope with.
Going away you either bring dog or be prepared for expensive kennelling/dog sitter. When I go away for two weeks at Xmas (so no friends willing to take them on then) it's £650 plus.
Everyone needs to be 100% on board with it.

Chasingaftermidnight · 22/01/2022 05:16

YANBU not to get a dog when you don’t want one. And YANBU not to want one.

I got bullied persuaded into getting a dog. I’ll be honest - it’s one of the few decisions I’ve made in my life that I really regret. He’s turned out to be a very anxious and challenging dog, which is very stressful and isolating (can’t have friends over to our house etc), but I don’t think I’d enjoy being a dog owner even if he were laidback and loving.

PupInAPram · 22/01/2022 04:47

I've wanted a dog my whole life, but never felt in a position where I could 'do right by one' (working, single parenting). In my 60s now I plan to get a rescue when I retire. I love walking and live alone, so will be able to devote time and energy to it. I walk to work and frequently pass a dog walker with a puppy and an elderly dog in a pram, hence my username.
I can't waitSmile

XelaM · 22/01/2022 03:52

But then I really dislike cats, so I cannot understand the thinking of a "cat person" Wink

XelaM · 22/01/2022 03:46

extremely easy*

XelaM · 22/01/2022 03:46

The trick is to get an "easy" breed and not to go for popular high energy dogs like Labradors, Spaniels, Poodles and Poodle mixes etc.

We got a pug and he is the easiest, cuddliest, laziest, friendliest dog ever. As long as he is fed, he sleeps almost all day on the sofa (usually on the electric blanket). He was extended easy to potty train as well.

greenteafiend · 22/01/2022 03:05

*If you are not all on board then definitely don't do it.

DH and I both work full time and have generally busy lives. He wanted a puppy, I didn't. He found a breeder - I wavered, still said no. He bought the puppy anyway. I hate the mess, the smell, the disruption, the expense, the poo and holes dug in the garden, the fact that dog walkers let themselves in when we're both at work, being stared at when I'm cooking and eating, the fact that we can't be spontaneous...the list goes on. it's definitely affected my marriage as I gave all these reasons before the puppy arrived and I was ignored.

Who knows though - often you hear about a partner who didn't want a dog and now they wouldn't be without it.*

Oh my goodness.
That puppy would have been plopped straight into its carrier and taken back to the breeder in my case. And my husband would have been sleeping in the porch for the next... year?

Your husband is an absolute twat. You don't get a dog unless everyone in the family wants it.