Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate stately homes and castles now?

105 replies

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 08:55

When I was younger I would love visiting stately homes, gardens and castles with my parents - learning about all the history and the inhabitants and generally imagining myself to be a princess lol.

Now when I go to these places I just feel a bit eye rolly and bitter, thinking about how corrupt and awful the aristocratic system must have been and how I’m so happy to not be living in that time. I find myself not particularly interested in the history of it as it’s usually “very rich person gifted a large parcel of land by some other landed gentry, blah blah blah”

Like yes, I can see that in some ways as a culture we did need concentrated wealth to create these beautiful buildings in the first place, but I’m very glad that this system has been dismantled now.

Just wondering if anyone else is bothered by conflicted feelings when visiting stately homes?

OP posts:
emuloc · 21/01/2022 09:55

It is not about "slagging off the history of the Uk", but about being honest about the history, and not hiding aspects of it, that people do not want to hear.

Comedycook · 21/01/2022 09:54

I'm surprised you preferred them as a younger person to now. I found them dull as a child but absolutely love a stately home or castle now I'm older, especially if there's a lovely cafe!

astoundedgoat · 21/01/2022 09:54

Far from being dismantled, I'd say it's considerably worse now, except the billionaires upon whose whim millions of lives depend keep their money offshore and waste it on spaceships and NFTs instead of building schools, hospitals and churches.

We still have people working unholy hours in unsustainable conditions with no contract, people working two jobs and STILL needing foodbanks, slavery, indentured labour, near-slavery in the clothing trade, parents unable to feed their children, slum landlords - and that's just in the UK.

At least on a big estate your home and job were secured and in theory, the people at the top were encouraged by the system to feel a sense of responsibility for their country and people (noblesse oblige) which is a bit dubious, admittedly, but very far from the minds of any of the billionaires who steal their employees' pension funds and buy yachts with it, and inexplicably don't spend the rest of their lives in prison.

The people at the top were supposed to sit in the house of lords, contribute and participate. Now they just steal and abuse.

WomanWomenGirlsFemale · 21/01/2022 09:50

Is this just another "Let's slag off the history of the UK" post because you haven't said where you're from Allsorts1 and there isn't a country on this planet with a "clean" past Hmm

TotoAnnihiliation · 21/01/2022 09:49

I used to love stately homes, until I worked for the NT. They mould and shape the narrative of the property to suit their latest agenda and sanitise history.

Rubyupbeat · 21/01/2022 09:43

For goodness sake, its history, good or bad. The bad isn't hidden any more, so we all learn the truth on how these families were founded, houses built etc....
I love the history of our royalty, but couldn't be further from being a royalist. The history is rich, political corruption etc..... it's just fascinating.
The Egyptians would wipe all trace of any pharaohs or 'politicians ' they didn't like, or try to, that's what this country is becoming like, bloody ridiculous.

shedevill · 21/01/2022 09:38

I think the entrance fees to places like Chatsworth or national trust are often quite eye watering and unaffordable for families. But these buildings absolutely should be making money from visitors to stay afloat, for gorgeous architecture and things that last. They usually do a good balancing of showing you servants quarters and kitchens too

Lostinafield · 21/01/2022 09:35

@Scarby9

A really memorable section of a school visit to Beningbrough (everyone dressed up and spending most of the day in the Victorian laundry, doing washing) used to be when the teacher showed the children a photo of the staff team from the early 1900s. 'All these people to look after one family! What do you think?' Children suitably appalled. Then, 'One family providing employment for all these people and their families! What do you think?'
Yes.
BeMoreGoldfish · 21/01/2022 09:33

Ah thank you @Triphazards - that makes more sense Grin.

RuthTopp · 21/01/2022 09:32

I can go and enjoy them . I see them as past insights of working places , all the servants , gardeners and the surrounding small businesses that must have kept a place like them running. Yes they had the privileged living there being weighted on , but they themselves were also just part of the cog .
When I walk around the b ig rooms filled with paintings or the elaborate bedrooms , I'm glad I was not born into a life like that.

Triphazards · 21/01/2022 09:27

The robbin' is never done!

But they seem to think the name Dunrobin meant "Robert's Fort." In Gaelic.

thewhatsit · 21/01/2022 09:27

I’m the opposite in that I was dragged round that stuff constantly as a child and hated it and I do now have more interest as an adult.

Scarby9 · 21/01/2022 09:26

A really memorable section of a school visit to Beningbrough (everyone dressed up and spending most of the day in the Victorian laundry, doing washing) used to be when the teacher showed the children a photo of the staff team from the early 1900s.
'All these people to look after one family! What do you think?'
Children suitably appalled.
Then, 'One family providing employment for all these people and their families! What do you think?'

Millionairesshortbreadshort · 21/01/2022 09:25

BeMoreGoldfish

@Triphazards I’ve never heard of Dunrobin Castle and thought it was an ironic name for “done robbing”, like done robbing the poor grin.

Grin
ecoanxiety · 21/01/2022 09:24

[quote BeMoreGoldfish]@Triphazards I’ve never heard of Dunrobin Castle and thought it was an ironic name for “done robbing”, like done robbing the poor Grin.[/quote]
that's exactly what it is! I wonder if it was on purpose 🤔

Millionairesshortbreadshort · 21/01/2022 09:23

I agree OP that they make me uncomfortable and desperately sad about the slavery and hardship others were enduring. I do love looking at them though. Especially the gardens to give me inspiration.

I think there is a real opportunity to use them to illustrate the inequality at the time and about the British colonial past in reality. Also the history of aristocrats generally (basically the meanest and most selfish got all the good stuff way back in time and then set about creating a society that kept it that way - and I say this kindly, as someone who knows and loves a couple of aristocrats).

Also OP the system is still there. Just look at the current UK government!

monfuseds · 21/01/2022 09:22

I do think some are pretty, very shallow I know. What I find funny is often the landed gentry with their beat up cars & muddy trousers & dubious history re obtaining such wealth are often considered infinitely more classier then those who flaunt their wealth in designer labels.

Kitkat151 · 21/01/2022 09:20

I thought they were really boring when I was younger.....thought all history was boring.....would never go to museums or stately homes....would never take the kids....then I hit 50 and developed an interest.....my grown Up kids are The same as I was...my DD wouldn’t dream of taking my GDs to a museum....says it’s boring

ecoanxiety · 21/01/2022 09:20

@pinkpillower

Has it been dismantled though...
I think they build rockets and fast fashion empires instead
Shehasadiamondinthesky · 21/01/2022 09:18

Yes it bothers me too, my family owned a stately home in Wales back in the 1920's - lost it all in the depression. Now we're all just nobodies.
Looking back at the family tree most of it was funded on slavery so I'm glad it's gone, I'd feel sickened living in a place like that and quite honestly I'm ashamed of the family history.
I do visit occasional stately homes and castles but I really think the guides should educate themselves on issues like slavery and make it part of the tour.

CityMumma78 · 21/01/2022 09:17

Get a grip! Learn from history and respect the heritage we are lucky to have in this country. Times have changed for the better and improvement’s are ongoing.

DGRossetti · 21/01/2022 09:17

It's pretty much a given that the estates that went up - or were expanded - from about 1650 to the 1830s were paid for from and with the profits of slave trading and slave labour in the colonies.

And when slavery was abolished the slave owners were compensated (we stopped paying them in 2016 by the way) and some of that money will have gone into their stately piles of bricks.

It does change your view of things as you walk around.

ThreeFeetTall · 21/01/2022 09:16

The kitchens are often the most interesting bit.

BeMoreGoldfish · 21/01/2022 09:15

@Triphazards I’ve never heard of Dunrobin Castle and thought it was an ironic name for “done robbing”, like done robbing the poor Grin.

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 09:12

@ANameChangeAgain I do love history too, I just think perhaps the issue is that in the UK it isn’t actually fully dismantled as @pinkpillower says - eg I enjoy learning about the Incas in Mexico but that’s safely long gone.

Im not from the UK so in my childhood princesses and privilege were blissfully just historical & faraway concepts, but since moving to the UK and becoming aware of the ongoing issues here I think the stately homes and what they represent have given them a darker feeling for me and I can’t just enjoy the history as it was all so unfair.

I start feeling very “vive la revolution!!!”

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread