Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate stately homes and castles now?

105 replies

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 08:55

When I was younger I would love visiting stately homes, gardens and castles with my parents - learning about all the history and the inhabitants and generally imagining myself to be a princess lol.

Now when I go to these places I just feel a bit eye rolly and bitter, thinking about how corrupt and awful the aristocratic system must have been and how I’m so happy to not be living in that time. I find myself not particularly interested in the history of it as it’s usually “very rich person gifted a large parcel of land by some other landed gentry, blah blah blah”

Like yes, I can see that in some ways as a culture we did need concentrated wealth to create these beautiful buildings in the first place, but I’m very glad that this system has been dismantled now.

Just wondering if anyone else is bothered by conflicted feelings when visiting stately homes?

OP posts:
Farrandau · 21/01/2022 12:08

@Thirtytimesround

I hear what you’re saying OP but it’s an odd thing to fixate on. You might as well walk through London stressing about the quality of life suffered by most of the Victorian labourers who built it in toxic smog with no pensions or health pay, while feeling guilty about the abducted Uyghurs who made your clothes in some Chinese forced-labour camp, and staring at your feet as they walk along in shoes made from the leather of a bull-calf shot at birth because males can’t be used for milk…

Don’t mean to be quite so depressing but misery inequality and exploitation are everywhere and stately homes at least have transformed into public-access beauty spots. Enjoy them and if you want to think about ethics get involved in campaigning or donating for some of the charities fighting horrible things going on today.

I think that the difference is that no one is presenting walking down a London street to work or wearing Chinese sweatshop clothes as some kind of artificially benign 'heritage leisure' experience.

(And with the advent of more use of sexed semen, mass culling of excess bull calves in dairy herds is slowing right down, because they're no longer being born in such numbers...)

CaptainMyCaptain · 21/01/2022 12:07

My grandmother was 'in service' in a big house. I am always most interested in the below stairs areas. One family may have lived in the best part of the house but these places supported whole communities. I'm not defending that but it's the way it was and sometimes still is e.g. Chatsworth.

ladycarlotta · 21/01/2022 12:04

I think a lot of people feel that way and the National Trust (for example) is working really hard to showcase the stories of other people who lived and worked in those places (servants, enslaved people etc) as well as be frank about the dodgy ways stately homes were paid for and the uncomfortable truths about what their owners contributed to history.

This is often derided as 'wokeness' in a bad way. I think it's fine to be 'woke' in its true sense, as in aware of how the status quo privileges one set of people to the tragic detriment of others. I have worked in museums and stately homes and I love them, but this is a genuine part of their history and we need to acknowledge it.

Thirtytimesround · 21/01/2022 11:58

I hear what you’re saying OP but it’s an odd thing to fixate on. You might as well walk through London stressing about the quality of life suffered by most of the Victorian labourers who built it in toxic smog with no pensions or health pay, while feeling guilty about the abducted Uyghurs who made your clothes in some Chinese forced-labour camp, and staring at your feet as they walk along in shoes made from the leather of a bull-calf shot at birth because males can’t be used for milk…

Don’t mean to be quite so depressing but misery inequality and exploitation are everywhere and stately homes at least have transformed into public-access beauty spots. Enjoy them and if you want to think about ethics get involved in campaigning or donating for some of the charities fighting horrible things going on today.

PartyOnKale · 21/01/2022 11:54

They are pretty awful looking in a lot of cases.

Yants · 21/01/2022 11:53

I'm a real history buff but I have virtually no interest at all in stately homes, mansions etc I'm much more interested in the lives and lifestyles of ordinary people in historic times than the aristocracy, give me the Jorvik Centre or Beamish over Chatsworth House any day.

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 11:46

@Latara that’s horrendous! How unethical.

@raspberrymuffin yes exactly, providing employment to your servants isn’t altruistic. Being kind to the general population who heavily outnumber you and if they were disgruntled and organised enough would realise they could just lop off your head is also not altruistic.

And for everyone who says the UK has managed to come through with gradual changes and avoid wars - fantastic! When is the end date to the now pointless aristocracy then?

Ironically, democracy has worked out for whomever was holding the titles back then - as they’ve not had to fight or strategise to keep their lands and title beyond not completely running out of money/not having a male heir - the peace forged by democracy has ingrained their position forever. At least the kings of old had to worry about long lost cousins and Spanish princes making power grabs.

Slightly detailing the point of my own thread but these are the thoughts that trouble me on the grounds of stately homes!

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 21/01/2022 11:30

@Latara

My uncle lives in a village where a lot of the cottages still belong to the 'lord of the manor' (who lives in a beautiful stately home) and are rented to local families.

But the old aristocrat just died & the new Lord has seen other villages where cottages have become air bnb or been sold as second homes for a fortune.

So he's not repairing his tenants' cottages and keeps increasing rents in the hope that he can force them out. Its so cruel and means that locals have to leave the villages they've lived in for generations.

So yes I'm also looking at stately homes a little differently!

Prince Charles ?
SlidingInto2022sDMs · 21/01/2022 11:30

I'm not really interested in hearing about how the lower scullery maid was just so grateful to be allowed a whole half day a month off to visit her elderly impoverished mother and what a splendid employer the Earl of Whatever was for allowing it.

Yep. Be grateful for any scrap from the overlords. Afterall, they're sent by god.

Farrandau · 21/01/2022 11:30

@Wandawide, not really. Ireland before the Norman invasion wasn’t ruled as any form of unitary state, but as a collection of provincial kingdoms (between five and nine, at various stages) which were themselves subdivided into smaller kingdoms (tuatha) — the High Kingship was mostly titular, and pretty much never absolute.

godmum56 · 21/01/2022 11:27

people who don't like them needn't visit?

raspberrymuffin · 21/01/2022 11:15

The big houses were the "lifeblood of the local economy" because the local economy was designed around providing for the owners of the big houses so that they could spend their time fighting and doing politics rather than having to mess around with cabbages. To ascribe some sort of benevolent motive to the situation is naive at best.

I enjoy visiting these places when you get a full history of what happened there and how everyone involved lived; the National Trust is usually very good at this. I don't feel comfortable in the ones that are privately owned as I feel like I'm handing over money to suppprt people who just happen to own a lot of land just the same as my ancestors did, and the history presented is usually embarrassingly incomplete. I'm not really interested in hearing about how the lower scullery maid was just so grateful to be allowed a whole half day a month off to visit her elderly impoverished mother and what a splendid employer the Earl of Whatever was for allowing it.

Latara · 21/01/2022 11:13

My uncle lives in a village where a lot of the cottages still belong to the 'lord of the manor' (who lives in a beautiful stately home) and are rented to local families.

But the old aristocrat just died & the new Lord has seen other villages where cottages have become air bnb or been sold as second homes for a fortune.

So he's not repairing his tenants' cottages and keeps increasing rents in the hope that he can force them out. Its so cruel and means that locals have to leave the villages they've lived in for generations.

So yes I'm also looking at stately homes a little differently!

Wandawide · 21/01/2022 11:08

@DGRossetti

England has only ever had one civil war.

I know you really meant "Britain" Grin

England had two civil wars. Matilda v Stephen referred to as the years God and his angels slept, 18years of misery and desolation. Then we had King v Cromwell.
Scotland had Kings and Queens and nobles murdered for Religion. The kings of North Wales fought anybody who argued and at one time there were 3 kings in Ireland (I think that is correct).
Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 11:08

@Trainbear sounds perfect 😂

OP posts:
Trainbear · 21/01/2022 11:00

There a National trust place in Glasgow which was built from the profits of a plantation with slaves, but the fortune was lost in the American civil war. Its got a lovely garden. So if you want to feel schadenfreude over the loss of the house and families wealth AND enjoy the grounds have a visit.

FreshHeaven · 21/01/2022 10:59

Usually I can disconnect sufficiently. However my sister and I were looking into family history and found the estate one person was working in as a boy was now open to visitors to stay in! We thought about it for about two seconds and then both went ,"Ugh no way!"

twilightermummy · 21/01/2022 10:59

I’ve been thinking precisely this over the last couple of years. I love history too but I’m so sick of the royals and those in power right now, that the whole system makes me feel queasy.

SlidingInto2022sDMs · 21/01/2022 10:54

British history is very complex and the intrinsic classism is something we must address. Whilst visiting these beautiful places of grandeur I’m finding there is increasingly more attention to the under classes who ran it. Kitchens are being restaged, exhibitions are more staff centric.

I think this is a good thing. Though I wonder if the re-focus is due to people having conversations like the OP, hence the attention is seen to be better placed on 'Look at what the 'lower class' had to go through - poverty-tourism' as opposed to 'Look and wonder at the magnificent wealth and opulence of those better than you. Something you'll never have'.

I'm sure there's an audience for both though.

monfuseds · 21/01/2022 10:54

I wonder if the elites tried to hide the extent of their wealth from the plebs by looking rough and 'the look' gradually became the uniform that's been passed down from generation to generation.

Good point, placate the plebs!

reluctantbrit · 21/01/2022 10:53

I think it's a two sided sword.

Yes, most stately home do have some story behind them with money coming from slavery connected income. Even if they didn't own planations themselves or were in shipping hugely, they were connected one way or the other.

But, these homes also give us artwork we admire and study. Without them, lots of artisans wouldn't have made it to the fame they have now. They also provided employment, badly paid, but for lots of areas, they were the only source for jobs. Big ones like Chatsworth still are a large employer.

We love going to stately homes and castles, be it in the UK or abroad. For me it is a matter of learning about a period in time better than just reading a book. Acknowledging how the wealth was accumulated is important but also is how the people living there shaped the region or even the country.

Wandawide · 21/01/2022 10:53

The more history of the UK you read you will see that those people were in a minority and from about 1200 we gave much more freedom and respect to our poorer classes than did other continental countries. There were freemen, not tied or owned by anyone.

The castles did not come from the same sort of people as 'stately homes'. There has been a steady development of 'rights' toward democracy. It did not take a revolution or Civil War as in France or United States. Our Civil War had comparatively few casualties.
France lost over an inch from the average height of the nation in revolution and Napoleonic times. US lost more in 1860s than inWW2

TabbyM · 21/01/2022 10:50

As a child I enjoyed proper ruined castles, bonus if they had jousting or other re-enactments but found stately homes boring. Now I still enjoy a good ruin but quite like the grounds and gardens of NT etc, also the café if they have good scones. My ancestors were in domestic service so I have no illusions about that sort of life.

Trainbear · 21/01/2022 10:50

If you read of the Sutherland's and the Highland clearances you will see how right you are!

Farrandau · 21/01/2022 10:49

@TheLovelinessOfDemons

I mostly visit them to re-enact battles.
You lot are wild. I once accidentally wandered into the Battle of Tewkesbury looking for DS and DH, who’d wandered off on a rest stop on the way home from Wales (and discovered them around a bonfire with some mildly inebriated Lancastrians). Grin

To be honest, I find the assumption that giant estates are a thing of the past far more sinister than the sanitised NT ‘Here is a bed Eliz I slept in on one of her progresses’ version of history. I found Downton Abbey (written by tone-deaf professional posho Julian Fellowes) incredibly pernicious in exploiting the weirdly widespread tendency of a significant percentage of British people to forelock-tugging and normalise social inequality.

I gather there are moves afoot to include more of the slave trading history of NT properties in displays, and that this is causing much huffing and puffing among the types who just want to ooh and aah at the swag someone brought home from their Grand Tour and head for the tearoom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread