Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate stately homes and castles now?

105 replies

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 08:55

When I was younger I would love visiting stately homes, gardens and castles with my parents - learning about all the history and the inhabitants and generally imagining myself to be a princess lol.

Now when I go to these places I just feel a bit eye rolly and bitter, thinking about how corrupt and awful the aristocratic system must have been and how I’m so happy to not be living in that time. I find myself not particularly interested in the history of it as it’s usually “very rich person gifted a large parcel of land by some other landed gentry, blah blah blah”

Like yes, I can see that in some ways as a culture we did need concentrated wealth to create these beautiful buildings in the first place, but I’m very glad that this system has been dismantled now.

Just wondering if anyone else is bothered by conflicted feelings when visiting stately homes?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JanuaryBluehoo · 23/01/2022 08:13

No

I've always known how stately homes became.
It's a huge system with lots of people living there?
Did you think they were altruistic communes Grin

latetothefisting · 22/01/2022 19:34

@Knockon

I know what you mean *@Allsorts1* I went to chatsworth last summer, and I felt an awe for the beautiful architecture and landscape, but ended up feeling a bit sick at the magnitude of wealth. Especially at the end whereby it said the family couldn’t pay their taxes, so donated some tapestries to HMRC, which still hang in the house for visitors to see after they’ve paid their entrance fee to pay for the upkeep of the property because its too much for one family to pay.

I do however agree that usually the way historical houses have been set up, it’s hard to imagine the owners’ lives - with multiple bedrooms and dressing rooms and card rooms and retiring rooms, but much easier to go to the scullery and kitchens and feel the history come alive!

In fairness those tapestries (the Devonshire Hunting tapestries) are usually kept at the V&A for everyone to see, they are only back at Chatsworth for a short period. When valuable items are donated in lieu of tax it's with the caveat they have to be available for public access, so they would usually go to a suitable museum or archive, but can occasionally stay in the actual home - with the caveat they can't hide it away in the 'private' side of the house, and the museum/archive that technically now 'owns it' can ask for it occasionally for exhibitions. While I can kind of see the point of it (keeps national treasures in the UK and available to the public rather than going overseas/to a private collector) it is a bit of a fiddle! But if they didn't allow it as an option most of these houses would be gone in a generation because the inheritance tax bill would be unaffordable.
entropynow · 21/01/2022 17:24

@DGRossetti

It's pretty much a given that the estates that went up - or were expanded - from about 1650 to the 1830s were paid for from and with the profits of slave trading and slave labour in the colonies.

And when slavery was abolished the slave owners were compensated (we stopped paying them in 2016 by the way) and some of that money will have gone into their stately piles of bricks.

It does change your view of things as you walk around.

No it isn't. Some, yes. Many are the result of simply owning vast tracts of land for a long time and/or finding coal on said land.

We should talk about the legacy of slavery. We shouldn't however assume it was universal.

DGRossetti · 21/01/2022 16:35

how we started drug running opium on massive scale.

Are you usually so understated Grin ?

It went further than that. Remember we basically threatened to burn China to the ground (a serious threat to people who build in wood and paper) unless they let us in to peddle opium.

Calennig · 21/01/2022 14:09

@DGRossetti

All the big Norman castles (especially in Wales) are also huge demonstrations of oppression. Not the nice fluffy oppression we have these days. But the OG style where the North of England was almost wiped out.
Absolutely - the churches are made in stone for similar reasons we are here were staying.

I have to admit my schooling left me with vauge impression reason we were so wealthy as a country was mainly because we had the industrial revolution - it's only since I've realised how much we asset striped India and how much we profited from slavery and how we started drug running opium on massive scale.

CatrinVennastin · 21/01/2022 14:06

My parents are obsessed with visiting stately homes and dragged us along with them as kids and I was bored witless then and wouldn't choose to go and visit one now as an adult.

My DM has done lots of research on our family history and has found that lots of her ancestors were tenant farmers who were turfed off the land and into poverty by Sir Bufton Fucking Tufton. That's put a bit of a different spin on things for her.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 21/01/2022 14:00

I bloody love a good castle because I'm a bloodthirsty bastard, but I find stately homes are often lacking in decent, nuanced history in favour of the Upstairs Downstairs vibe.

Mostly I'm just more interested in longbows and military tactics than posh furniture Grin

Echobelly · 21/01/2022 13:25

I'm not, but I guess OP is entitled to feel that way. Certainly there's a degree of unease underlying seats of privilege, but I guess that's the case with everything in history with so much stuff happening that was awful and unacceptable now.

I'd say it's better not to let that overwhelm you otherwise it's kind of fitting this narrative that people 'can't cope' with negative stories from history and that discomfort is enough reason to shut things away, whereas talking about it and making it visible is exactly what we have to do.

emuloc · 21/01/2022 13:20

It is good that the National Trust is looking to address the history of colonialism and slavery with regards to their stately homes.

DGRossetti · 21/01/2022 13:19

[quote Calennig]eu.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/06/30/fact-check-u-k-paid-off-debts-slave-owning-families-2015/3283908001/

taxjustice.net/2020/06/09/slavery-compensation-uk-questions/[/quote]
Oh, yes, forgot to mention - as taxpayers you and I were compensating the descendants of the poor slave owning families who lost their property.

DGRossetti · 21/01/2022 13:17

All the big Norman castles (especially in Wales) are also huge demonstrations of oppression. Not the nice fluffy oppression we have these days. But the OG style where the North of England was almost wiped out.

caringcarer · 21/01/2022 13:08

No I don't feel that way at all. I often go and wonder around castles or stately homes and enjoy doing so. They usually have lovely gardens too. Often a nice cafe with good coffee and cake.

MoiraNotRuby · 21/01/2022 12:51

I agree with you OP. If it was properly in the past, maybe I could appreciate them more. But until the patriarchy, racism and capitalist bastards all fuck off, I do struggle.

singlenamestar · 21/01/2022 12:46

@DGRossetti

It's pretty much a given that the estates that went up - or were expanded - from about 1650 to the 1830s were paid for from and with the profits of slave trading and slave labour in the colonies.

And when slavery was abolished the slave owners were compensated (we stopped paying them in 2016 by the way) and some of that money will have gone into their stately piles of bricks.

It does change your view of things as you walk around.

2016!!!!! How was this compensated?! Omg I am shocked
GrendelsGrandma · 21/01/2022 12:41

If plebs like us don't go to these places, they'll be sold off to Russian oligarchs. I like the ones where you can see the behind the scenes bits too. I always look houses up to get the warts and all history, it can be quite eye opening compared to the official presentation!

I mainly like the gardens, flowers are nice anywhere right?

Calennig · 21/01/2022 12:40

Castles often seem to have very different histories and are often good for dragging more obscure areas of English history to light.

My childhood covered more working class museums as well as castles - argicultural/industial museums. School visits to a stately home we reacted English civil war with pikes and lot of talk of priest hole house was famous for.

We have not really done stately homes with our kids - not driving does mean they are hard to get to. When we have been to castles, we’ve often been lucky enough to see re-enactors and they often talk of washing, cooking weapons, clothes – more everyday experiences

I grew up watching BBC Victorian Kitchen garden and later Victorian Kitchen – you tube these days has Mrs Crocombe’s Victorian cookery – more the things some of my ancestors were up to and I think these days there’s more emphasis on all classes than there once was.

Surprising thing to me BBC history program have taught me is that slave compensation went into British Museum but also funded railways – my ancestors worked the railways and they still get us around today. There is a statue in Manchester that commemorates the hardship of mill workers of the refusing to take southern states cotton in US civil war – the mill workers also suffered when India started to refuse to buy the cloth that before us they used to make themselves and get profit with – wealth creation via slavery and colonialism benefits are surprisingly more widespread than just the big houses.

The few stautely houses we have been round - we're already aware of where money came from - so haven't been hyper focused on that.

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 12:36

@PattyPan that’s true! I guess the bitterness gives me the energy to be interested in topics of inequality today and reminds me not to buy too many groceries from Daylesford 🤣

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 21/01/2022 12:28

@pinkpillower

Has it been dismantled though...
Has it fuck. Sir Bufton Fucking Tufton and his corrupt mates are still in charge.
PattyPan · 21/01/2022 12:25

The thing is, what good does it do to feel bitter and annoyed? If you're at a National Trust property (as opposed to one still family-owned) it's not like the aristocracy suffers from you grumping about or history changes, you're just ruining the visit for yourself.

raspberrymuffin · 21/01/2022 12:24

@Farrandau you're spot on. When we consume this fictional benign version of the past we risk creating a sort of nostalgia for a simpler, better time that never actually existed, which is how we've ended up in this current bizarre political situation where we're all surprised that members of a group that consider themselves the ruling class act like it.

My grandma left school at 14 and went into service. She loved learning and art and music but instead of doing any of that she had to work long days scrubbing floors etc in a boys' private boarding school and didn't get to live for herself, as she described it, until she was middle aged. They weren't doing her a favour by giving her a job, they were profiting from a situation in which she, a child, had effectively no choice. We can't fall back into thinking that way of living is normal.

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 12:12

@Farrandau I think you’ve hit the nail on the head there!

OP posts:
Notjustanymum · 21/01/2022 12:11

We can’t change the past, but we should remember it and learn from it.
IMO feeling sad about past inequality and injustice is fine, as long as that feeling shapes how you live your life going forward.
My feeling is that nowadays, it is largely celebrity and huge wealth, that creates issues similar to those that the “underdogs” of society experienced up to the 1930’s and beyond, in some cases. Revelations about Hollywood stars and Uber-rich Dubai residents paying minimum, or less-than-minimum wages to their staff right now, are the issues we should be concentrating on, rather than directing our ire against people long-dead!

Allsorts1 · 21/01/2022 12:11

@Thirtytimesround I do support causes that campaign for change on a range of issues - as a rounded human being I can consider a multitude of topics without being fixated on any particular one!

OP posts:
EdithStourton · 21/01/2022 12:09

@monfuseds

I wonder if the elites tried to hide the extent of their wealth from the plebs by looking rough and 'the look' gradually became the uniform that's been passed down from generation to generation.

Good point, placate the plebs!

Nope, I don't think so. Our local gentry dress as they do because they drive tractors, run livery yards and litter-pick their own hedges.

The last time I saw someone who I know is descended from Henry VII, he was wearing filthy jeans and a reflective jacket - almost 70 and still out there farming every day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread