Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if I live in one of the most restricted nations on earth - Covid related *title edited by MNHQ*

135 replies

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 08:07

NC as this is outing. AIBU to think that I live in the most restricted nation in the world (well, maybe after North Korea)?

So, I’m a Brit living in Perth, Western Australia (WA). I think it is widely known that Australia basically closed to everyone at the start of the pandemic leaving tens of thousands of citizens and residents overseas. Towards the end of 2021, the individual states all started to open allowing quarantine free travel to approved vaccinated travellers. Except WA. We have continued to live with closed borders – both internal to other states and international (we can leave but due to stringent caps and hotel quarantine, it is almost impossible to return). Our state Premier announced prior to Christmas that the state would open on Feb 5th. Thousands made plans to reunite with family, return home etc. Last night he performed a u-turn and our border is staying shut due to the threat of Omicron. He has not set a future date so we are all essentially in limbo. The rest of Australia is now learning to live with covid and can travel freely. WA has only had around 1400 cases of Covid since the pandemic began with 9 deaths. We have had a few short lockdowns. Whilst I appreciate that this is excellent, striving for zero covid is not a strategy the Premier can keep up with forever. He is delaying the inevitable.

We have an 89% fully vaxxed rate in the over 12s (96% single vaxxed) but this is apparently not good enough, despite being one of the highest rates in the world. We have a mask mandate that covers any indoor premise that isn’t a private residence.

75% of our work force has been mandated to get the vaccine. This is everyone from health care workers and police to supermarket workers and builders – the list is pretty much endless. As you can imagine, there has been a lot of discontent regarding this.

The rules state that as of 31st Jan, we have to show a vaccine certificate to attend – off licenses, restaurants, bars, zoo, theatres museums, hospitals (as a visitor), sporting stadiums, arenas, casino, play centres, gyms, night clubs, music venues and cinemas. I’m pretty sure it won’t stop there. The unvaxxed soon won’t have anywhere to go. Despite being pro-vax and being triple vaxxed myself, I believe that this has gone too far.

This is a state with a significant number of expats. Many of us haven’t seen family for 2-3 years now. I know people will just say that we should leave but it isn’t easy to just leave when we have jobs, lives, homes and mortgages here.

I would love to hear outsider (or fellow WA residents) thoughts on the restrictions we are living with.

OP posts:
DifficultBloodyWoman · 21/01/2022 10:12

I live (elsewhere) in Aus and I am ready for all borders (domestic and international) to be open.

I recognize that quarantining the rest of the world was initially effective but that was prior to vaccination.

Australia cannot live in isolation forever.

We need an end date. And possibly a change of government.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2022 10:12

Do you have a new date?

I don’t know what is meant to change for you to open up

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 10:10

Exactly @eurochick

The relative freedoms we have had over the past 2 years aren't lost on me @Drywhitefruitycidergin. I fully understand that we have been incredibly lucky. However, I haven't seem any family for over 2 years and my mental health is declining. I know this sounds selfish but I know of a lot of others who feel the same as I do. I have had close family go through difficult medical diagnoses and treatment. We have been dangled a carrot of a date and it has now been taken away. What are we waiting for? We have had 2 years to prepare.

OP posts:
Anotherdayanotheropinon · 21/01/2022 10:10

You need to get a grip @FreedomforWA

Clearly someone who doesn’t have a clue about what living in an actual restricted nation is like - typical overprivileged western view.

Asking you honestly here - would you prefer to live in Afghanistan? Would you genuinely move there as it’s less restrictive than Australia? I mean if you’re living in the most restricted nation in the world after North Korea then those places must be far better options for you?

whatsthpoint · 21/01/2022 10:09

You all need to get vaccinated! And then think about who you vote for in the next election.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2022 10:08

I haven’t rtft but it’s interesting as my family is in another previously zero Covid state that has opened up.

It’s a bit bumpy but they should be more free to travel than before

shiningcuckoo · 21/01/2022 10:08

Oh and I don't think that the handling of the Novak Djokovic thing is at all embarrassing. It would have been more embarrassing to let him in when others in a similar position would have been refused entry. Aus sees itself a the lucky country because there is this belief that everyone gets a fair shot. Whilst clearly this isn't true, allowing Djokovic in would have been in blatant of the rules that have set for everyone and so depriving others of that fair shot. It's not about him being a vocal anti vaxxer, rather it's about him trying to side step a requirement on the basis of his status and the Aussies going 'no way mate. You're not special"

nojudgementhere · 21/01/2022 10:07

@LakieLady - Sadly it sounds like they can't do anything 'freely' within the state or elsewhere at the moment. Coercing people to have vaccines in order to work/partake in society and banning them from leaving a designated area is not freedom in my opinion.

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 21/01/2022 10:06

It's a difficult one. I've got family in WA who were due to travel to UK summer 2020 for the first time in about 10 years and now have no idea when they will be able to rearrange. My aunt is desperate to get over to see her grandkids and that seems further and further away.
I also fear that you can't stay closed forever & at some point you will be hit with a massive wave, vaccination immunity will have waned, no natural immunity.

Otoh - compared to UK you've been so free/normal life for the last 2 years - no homeschool, cancelling of kids activities etc. 9 deaths vs 175000. It's not all bad....

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 10:04

@Kiwiinparis – yes, NZ has been super isolated too. I think it is the not knowing when we will open which is the hard part.

@OperationRinka Covid will take off here when we open but what else are we waiting for? Covid isn’t going away. We can’t stay shut forever. We have a 89% double dose rate – if we wait much longer, immunity will be waning. I’m pretty sure once we open, whenever that is, restrictions will be put in place. We get a mask mandate every time we have a single case.

@Migrainesbythedozen – but QLD couldn’t stay shut forever and neither can any other state. Covid will never go away. It is here to stay in one variant or another. Palachook stayed closed long enough to get vax rates up.

@echt I do clearly understand the division of state and federal thank you. I think you are clearly missing the tone of my post.

@MananaTomorrow – I never stated that it felt like a totalitarian state, that was another poster. I am pointing out the restrictions that we are being forced to live with. I have been reading that approx 10% of NHS staff are unhappy with the vax mandate. Well here, 75% of everyone working is mandated to get the vaccine. Whilst I’m pro vax, I feel that this is a breach of government power.

@Kokeshi123 – I know. Don’t get me wrong as clearly nobody wants to have covid but we are going to have to live with it at some point so why not now….I know of a few people who are hoping for that cluster to grow.

OP posts:
eurochick · 21/01/2022 10:02

It seems kind of silly not to seize the opportunity with a highly vaccinated population and a mild variant to let it in. If they don't now, then when? And we know vaccine protection seems to wane quickly - will people keep having vaccines at such a rate if they are not being exposed to the thing they are vaccinated against, and if not then there may be less vaccine protection when they do eventually open the doors.

shiningcuckoo · 21/01/2022 10:01

I think that if you're looking at the situation in Aus and NZ from a UK perspective , you're actually looking at it from a UK media perspective. Which is giving you one tiny piece of the story. In NZ there is not really a sense of compliance, more a sense of protecting our communities and for some people that is actually wearing very thin now. There is objection to the vax mandates but of the people for whom vaccination is required, the proportion of people objecting and not getting vaxxed is actually quite small. You have to remember that culturally NZ, Aus and the UK are really different. And the nature of our respective diversity is different too. So I do take some objection to dismissing Aus and NZ as 'compliant' when actually the population at large is reacting to their governments handling of things in a way that reflects their cultural priorities. And for the record, there is a general feeling here that unvaxxed medical staff and teaching staff are putting others at greater risk when there is no need. It seems to be a fairly cut and dried opinion amongst a majority.

OperationRinka · 21/01/2022 09:56

Well the major restriction that they've had had been immigration controls, and that's not really something where you have a choice of whether to be compliant or not - you can hardly force your way onto a plane. And the people most affected and inclined to protest and riot are by definition not in Australia.

LakieLady · 21/01/2022 09:54

[quote nojudgementhere]@FreedomforWA - I agree - it must be like being in prison and it makes me feel claustrophobic thinking about it. 💐 to you and anyone else out in WA who's struggling. If it were me I'd be on the first flight home.[/quote]
Can WA residents not travel freely within the state?

I thought they could, so apologies if I'm wrong, but if I'm right it's nothing to feel claustrophobic about. WA is huge - several times bigger than the whole of the UK.

Mosaic123 · 21/01/2022 09:53

My WA resident cousin is delighted that they are not now opening up as planned. We hope to visit eventually.

HerculesMulligann · 21/01/2022 09:47

From my UK perspective I’ve been amazed at how compliant it seems the Australia and NZ population have been as a whole during the pandemic. Seemingly willing to endure massively harsh restrictions when covid rates haven’t been that high. And when everyone knew that at some point covid was impossible to keep out indefinitely anyway.

And the treatment of Novak Djokovic has been ridiculous, I’d be embarrassed if I was part of the Aus govt. They’ve outright admitted that him being in Aus is a negligible health risk but that his “free thinking”
could have a negative impact on vaccination rates. The idea that a democratic country with supposedly free speech can feel so threatened by one bloke who hasn’t been vaccinated is both scary and laughable. It’s not even as though Djokovic has been preaching any anti-vac rhetoric, all he’s done is to decide not to be vaccinated.

TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 21/01/2022 09:45

"AIBU to ask if I live in one of the most restricted nations on earth"

The above was your opening question @FreedomforWA

to which I voted that you are being unreasonable, as I am answering that question, which does not seem to be Covid related, not your fuller question just below that one. You actually did suggest later that maybe WA might not be quite as bad as North Korea, so I didn't think that you were mainly talking about NK's Covid problems.

My negative vote was because if you are a woman (and the likelihood is that you are), I believe that in nearly every country run by Muslims, the females from birth to death (but particularly from their school days to their menopause) live a much more restricted life than most of us could ever imagine. I think that the females in NK may come close to that restrictiveness, but by the very nature of NK it is hard to know exactly how bad it is to live there (certainly much, much worse than either WA or the UK) for all of it's citizens, compared to the females in Muslim run countries.

If you are only asking in respect of the pandemic, and what your state restrictions have been, I don't think that you are being unreasonable, with regards to the free world. I don't have much idea what it is like in any of the Communist countries.

LankylegsFromOz · 21/01/2022 09:42

@Lacaola

YANBU. I have been horrified at the scenes coming out of Australia and the totalitarianism and cruelty that has been enforced. I am sorry you are going through this. It has made me not want to visit, ever.
Yeah, it's been horrible trying to decide whether to holiday in Noosa or Malloolaba 🙄
Migrainesbythedozen · 21/01/2022 09:40

[quote Ginandplatonic]@Lacaola that’s just the teensiest bit hyperbolic perhaps. Thanks for your sympathy but let me assure you that looking at the number of deaths in the UK, no one in Aus is wishing we’d handled it more like they did[/quote]
Right on! I wouldn't choose to be in the UK if you offered me 50 million dollars! I'm proud of the way the Premiers have handle this (until QLD etc caved) and am proud of Australia's lockdowns. Poll after poll after poll after poll even now still show most Australians support the lockdowns. It's only the noisy minority of troublemakers who don't.

Kokeshi123 · 21/01/2022 09:39

Sounds like a tough situation, OP. But I'd give it a while before making any big decisions. They've just found a few "mystery" omicron cases in Perth; I don't think they can keep the virus out much longer.

MananaTomorrow · 21/01/2022 09:37

Btw in case there is any confusion, I mention if the OP FEELS like it’s a totalitarian state, not that it is!

echt · 21/01/2022 09:36

[quote FreedomforWA]@echt I already covered that it isn't a nation. However for those of us living here it may as well be. We are cut off from the rest of Australia. It is the Nation of McGowan.[/quote]
No it isn't, and your use of it as metaphor undermines understanding of how Australia works politically, ie. the division of state and federal.

Nation of McGowan my arse, you sound like the Dictator Dan crew in Victoria.

MananaTomorrow · 21/01/2022 09:36

I’d leave sorry.
If leaving there makes you feel like you are in a totalitarian country, if you strongly disagree with the rules there, then you leave.

At least, you have somewhere else to go to (even though with much higher death rate).

Migrainesbythedozen · 21/01/2022 09:36

*You don't know what totalitarianism is, do you?

Do WA a favour and stay away.*

Totally agree @echt . That poster was not just ignorant but very offensive.

Migrainesbythedozen · 21/01/2022 09:33

I am in Queensland and envy you. Our Premier backed down and opened the borders - BAD DECISION. My fucken oath was it a baaaddddd decision!! In the small rural community I live in there has already been 300 cases. Before the borders opened? Not one single case in the entire pandemic. I want Qld to slam shut again and close the borders for good - for the foreseeable future. If I may be honest I think you're being ungrateful and I would trade places with you in 2 seconds. We may be the 'most restricted' nation (or state regarding WA), but we are the most sensible nation. If the UK and US followed Australia, they wouldn't have such the disastrous fatalities they do now.
So, #proudly a resident of the most restricted nation on earth, and long may it be that way! Get McGowan to talk to Annastacia and get her to do the same.

Swipe left for the next trending thread