Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if I live in one of the most restricted nations on earth - Covid related *title edited by MNHQ*

135 replies

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 08:07

NC as this is outing. AIBU to think that I live in the most restricted nation in the world (well, maybe after North Korea)?

So, I’m a Brit living in Perth, Western Australia (WA). I think it is widely known that Australia basically closed to everyone at the start of the pandemic leaving tens of thousands of citizens and residents overseas. Towards the end of 2021, the individual states all started to open allowing quarantine free travel to approved vaccinated travellers. Except WA. We have continued to live with closed borders – both internal to other states and international (we can leave but due to stringent caps and hotel quarantine, it is almost impossible to return). Our state Premier announced prior to Christmas that the state would open on Feb 5th. Thousands made plans to reunite with family, return home etc. Last night he performed a u-turn and our border is staying shut due to the threat of Omicron. He has not set a future date so we are all essentially in limbo. The rest of Australia is now learning to live with covid and can travel freely. WA has only had around 1400 cases of Covid since the pandemic began with 9 deaths. We have had a few short lockdowns. Whilst I appreciate that this is excellent, striving for zero covid is not a strategy the Premier can keep up with forever. He is delaying the inevitable.

We have an 89% fully vaxxed rate in the over 12s (96% single vaxxed) but this is apparently not good enough, despite being one of the highest rates in the world. We have a mask mandate that covers any indoor premise that isn’t a private residence.

75% of our work force has been mandated to get the vaccine. This is everyone from health care workers and police to supermarket workers and builders – the list is pretty much endless. As you can imagine, there has been a lot of discontent regarding this.

The rules state that as of 31st Jan, we have to show a vaccine certificate to attend – off licenses, restaurants, bars, zoo, theatres museums, hospitals (as a visitor), sporting stadiums, arenas, casino, play centres, gyms, night clubs, music venues and cinemas. I’m pretty sure it won’t stop there. The unvaxxed soon won’t have anywhere to go. Despite being pro-vax and being triple vaxxed myself, I believe that this has gone too far.

This is a state with a significant number of expats. Many of us haven’t seen family for 2-3 years now. I know people will just say that we should leave but it isn’t easy to just leave when we have jobs, lives, homes and mortgages here.

I would love to hear outsider (or fellow WA residents) thoughts on the restrictions we are living with.

OP posts:
SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 14:16

Yes, OP, I agree. I have friends living under these restrictions in WA and they are horrified. They said a lot of people they know are trying to move. They've also been told recently trying to order some overseas items that they will no longer deliver to Australia due to the problems it was causing the company, which doesn't bode well.

The powers being granted to the health authorities are also quite worrying from a democratic systems POV.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/01/2022 14:06

YANBU, OP. I've been staggered by the behaviour of some parts of Australia over Covid; not only draconian legislation for citizens but a shocking legal approach to those coming in from outside. It seems that the laws are far-reaching and as flexible as those using them wish them to be to suit their purpose.

I love travel, the further flung the better generally, but Australia has never been somewhere I've hugely wanted to go. I definitely don't want to now.

DetMcNulty · 21/01/2022 14:00

The low take up in the aboriginal communities is a concern for sure, and it's unfair I think to say they've been offered so should have taken it up given the history here. The federal government are responsible for this, and there is understandable reluctance and distrust . There's also been some evangelical groups who have got in and sowed rather extreme anti vax sentiment which has definitely not helped. These communities are served by same remote hubs as many mines, so not that simple to restrict travel either, and I do think their safety should come above expat wish to travel.

How we get over this I don't know, still pretty sure it's spreading and mark's hand will be forced sooner than later. I'm in south west on holiday at moment, there's back packers everywhere, which is the community the current cases came from and not really any restrictions being followed in the vans and campsites.

whinetime89 · 21/01/2022 13:34

I am also in Perth and originally from here so cannot imagine the heart ache of not seeing my rellies for so long.
I still cannot believe Marky back flipped and the overall feel of everyone is frustration. We can't run and hide from covid forever.
We were very lucky to not feel the pain of lock down like over east has done for so long however now with Vax rates so high he needs to put something in place soon.

55Jumbo · 21/01/2022 13:20

Sounds insane, OP. I really feel for you.

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 13:15

@sunshineandlollypops remote aboriginal communities have had ample opportunities to get vaccinated. There has been teams going in to offer vaccinations. If their low rates is a concern then McGowan should restrict travel to those specific areas as per his previous plan. The mining issue won't go away in a few weeks, months or years. All FIFO workers will be vaccinated by now as per the mandate. We have done what was asked of us....90% double vaxxed. He needs to open now.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2022 13:13

[quote sunshineandlollypops]@MarshaBradyo Sorry, if I phrased that incorrectly. I would like it to open for purely selfish personal reasons. However, because of the issues I have listed, I am happy to keep the borders closed until the numbers for the vaxxed Aboriginals are up and until more people are triple vaxxed. We are now at approximately 25% triple vaxxed in the general population.[/quote]
No worries Smile

Is it going up quite quickly? For general and Aboriginal population

I’m guessing the FI / FO issue won’t stop borders opening when vaccination is higher - As that won’t change and the issue will always be there, so it’s just rates?

Sarahschild · 21/01/2022 13:08

FFS everyone stop jumping in the OP.
She has every right to complain about the Australian government that most of you have absolutely no knowledge of. Comparing it with women in Pakistan is ridiculous, it’s like not enjoying a meal because there are kids hungry somewhere else in the world.
Australia is up shit creek and it’s getting worse. But typical MN just jumps all over people and slams them for having an opinion.
I honestly don’t know why I read these posts.
Our premiers are all corrupt and everyone just blindly follows bull shit directions
As fior you echt calm down and go back to obeying your master Dan Andrews. You’re a big fan.

sunshineandlollypops · 21/01/2022 13:04

@MarshaBradyo Sorry, if I phrased that incorrectly. I would like it to open for purely selfish personal reasons. However, because of the issues I have listed, I am happy to keep the borders closed until the numbers for the vaxxed Aboriginals are up and until more people are triple vaxxed. We are now at approximately 25% triple vaxxed in the general population.

Porcupineintherough · 21/01/2022 12:46

if you swap COVID for the word flu that shows how dumb it is

Yeah and if you swap COVID for lemons we can all make lemonade. If we swap COVID for verucca then my, we've all overreacted!

"Living with covid" isnt the same as "pretending covid is flu" just yet.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2022 12:43

@sunshineandlollypops

I have read the thread. No one has mentioned how Perth and most of WA is so heavily reliant on resources. The resource sector (Mining) has kept the WA economy afloat for the last two years. (Many locals would argue that is has kept the country's economy afloat). Not sure if the rest of the world is aware, but most of the mining workforce are Fly In/ Fly Out. Workers will stay at the mine sites for periods of 1 week to several weeks. If these sites become infected, hundreds of workers could potentially be infected. Resulting in the mines shutting down.

No one has mentioned that a high number of Aboriginal population has not been vaxxed. Many of these communities are remote and if there is an outbreak I don't know how they would cope.

I hope the state opens up soon. Like many, most of my family lives overseas, but there is too much at stake at the moment.

If you’d like it to open up soon won’t those issues still be there?
sunshineandlollypops · 21/01/2022 12:41

I have read the thread. No one has mentioned how Perth and most of WA is so heavily reliant on resources. The resource sector (Mining) has kept the WA economy afloat for the last two years. (Many locals would argue that is has kept the country's economy afloat). Not sure if the rest of the world is aware, but most of the mining workforce are Fly In/ Fly Out. Workers will stay at the mine sites for periods of 1 week to several weeks. If these sites become infected, hundreds of workers could potentially be infected. Resulting in the mines shutting down.

No one has mentioned that a high number of Aboriginal population has not been vaxxed. Many of these communities are remote and if there is an outbreak I don't know how they would cope.

I hope the state opens up soon. Like many, most of my family lives overseas, but there is too much at stake at the moment.

HerculesMulligann · 21/01/2022 12:39

Epidemiologists across the world have been pretty clear from Feb/March 2020 that now covid exists it will spread worldwide. Government and media narratives that the virus will go away if we all just complied nicely with lockdowns were always wishful thinking at best, and downright lying at worst. (I’m not against lockdowns per se - the first UK lockdown was needed to buy us time to learn about the virus and to give NHS time to prepare for example).

What I don’t quite get is why some countries and individuals seem to be unable to accept this. It seems that two years on some in Australia - and elsewhere - are in complete denial. And so are making policy for the world they’d like to exist, rather than the world as it actually is. Which helps no one.

I’m no fan of the UK govt in general, but at least they have grasped the fact that the challenge is not whether covid is widespread in society, but is rather how to manage and live with covid going forward.

VelvetChairGirl · 21/01/2022 12:09

I feel sorry for you OP, if you swap Covid with the word flu that shows how dumb it is, covid isnt going away, its changing everyone will catch it eventually and the whole world is going to have to live with it, just like the spanish flu just changed and flu can change to be more deadly anytime.

tcjotm · 21/01/2022 11:46

OP I do agree that it’s better to do it over the summer. I think end of a Feb would be a better compromise. I do think NSW was too fast dropping all the restrictions just as omicron came in. Another couple of weeks would’ve made a big difference to numbers. But our premier was brand new and buying our love.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2022 11:42

@StartupRepair

I wouldn't open up in Feb if I was Magowan either.
Why not February and when would you?

Out of interest

Anotherdayanotheropinon · 21/01/2022 11:41

@nojudgementhere maybe you should actually read the OP where OP said AIBU to think that I live in the most restricted nation in the world (well, maybe after North Korea)?

@FreedomforWA I haven’t heard much about the covid restrictions in North Korea - what are they?

workworkworkugh · 21/01/2022 11:36

@FreedomforWA I'm in Victoria and have no close links to WA but I'm so irrationally angry at his decision. As you said, he's just delaying the inevitable.

Also, the fact you have to be triple vaxxed and then still do a 14 day quarantine Confused completely ridiculous if you ask me.
Can't see how that's going to work for the allowed travellers who are trying to get in to see a loved one who is terminally ill or palliative care, life doesn't give you a 14 day warning for these things.
Mark McGowan seems to be getting a lot of support from West Australians though from what I read, go figure 🤷🏻‍♀️

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 11:33

@alwayscrashinginthesamecar1

I'm in Perth too and think Magowan made the right decison. It isn't the right time to open with Omicron raging over east. A little more time to see how it pans out is a good idea. As for being trapped or living in a totalitarian regime, what bullshit! My life for the last few years has been mostly mask free and unrestricted, albeit sans overseas travel.. Compared to practically everywhere else we have had it easy. I know my UK and Irish friends and family have had a bloody awful time compared to here, and much as I miss them all I feel extremely lucky to live here.
But we know how it is going to pan out. Cases rise, they peak and then over the coming weeks and months, they steadily fall. Unfortunately a very tiny percentage of those will lose their life. The health system will be put under pressure. But wouldn't it be better doing that in summer without the added impact of winter illnesses and with the current high level of vaccine immunity. We have seen what happens with this virus across the world and we have been in a privileged position to wait for high vaccination levels, new drugs to treat it with etc. Waiting to see how things pan out over east won't change the fact that it will come here one day, it is just delaying the inevitable.

And once again, I didn't say that it was a totalitarian regimen, that was another poster. I can't leave the state though as there is a very significant chance that I won't be allowed back in. I have friends that have had their G2G passes rejected and are now living in limbo. I would call that trapped.

OP posts:
StartupRepair · 21/01/2022 11:29

I wouldn't open up in Feb if I was Magowan either.

nojudgementhere · 21/01/2022 11:27

@EatYourVegetables

How overdramatic.

This week a young woman in Pakistan has been sentenced to death for some Whatsapp messages she sent. But no, YOU live in the most restricted nation on Earth, because your government didn’t allow loads of old and vulnerable folk to die for your convenience.

FFS.

And you're calling the OP dramatic? How ironic! Nobody is saying the government should have let loads of old and vulnerable folk die. They're saying that now WA have vaccinated a large percentage of their population and Omicron is proving to be much less dangerous they should be allowed to travel freely again. There is a difference.
tcjotm · 21/01/2022 11:23

[quote Blinkingbatshit]Actually @Ginandplatonic
architectureau.com/articles/australian-cities-among-the-largest-and-least-densely-settled-in-the-world/[/quote]
We have huge sprawling suburbs on the outskirts of all big cities. Those are barely part of the city (it’s a looooong drive to get to the CBD). Totally agreee those are way more spacious than what you’d generally get in the UK. But look at inner city Sydney on Google maps. It’s pretty crowded. Not Hong Kong or New Delhi density, but we aren’t all living on spacious estates. I grew up in inner city Sydney in tiny Victorian terraces, much more crowded than my street in London. We squash on to crowded public transport too.

Porcupineintherough · 21/01/2022 11:17

You forgot China.

EatYourVegetables · 21/01/2022 11:16

How overdramatic.

This week a young woman in Pakistan has been sentenced to death for some Whatsapp messages she sent. But no, YOU live in the most restricted nation on Earth, because your government didn’t allow loads of old and vulnerable folk to die for your convenience.

FFS.

tcjotm · 21/01/2022 11:15

[quote Ginandplatonic]@Lilifer Same here. I dont ever want to visit Australia now because of the way they have treated their citizens during the pandemic

FFS what on earth do you people think went on here that was so vastly different from the UK?? Come or don’t come I don’t care but trust me we don’t need or want your weirdly patronising “sympathy”.[/quote]
I know right? We’ve actually had a pretty decent 2 years all things considering. Nothing like the horrors I read about in the UK!

OP I’m in NSW and you have my sympathies. But WA has always been weird so your kind of being unreasonable. The Premier is catering to a population that have long flirted with the idea of seceding and seem to have little interest in the rest of Australia. None of this surprises the rest of us.

To a PP, yes WA is very big and they can travel around it but it’s also pretty bloody empty. So it’s probably a weird combo of claustrophobia and agoraphobia.

Australians are outward looking. We want to travel. We don’t do the short beach holiday/ city weekends abroad that you guys can do in the UK but we are a nation of immigrants and usually travel regularly overseas to see families. Our young people are usually found backpacking all over the world.

But closing international borders until we were vaccinated made sense. We’ve had a tiny fraction of deaths. @Blinkingbatshit yeah but those figures dont take into account that most of Australia is uninhabitable. The population is mostly in a narrow edge around the coast. We have crowded cities too!

Swipe left for the next trending thread