Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if I live in one of the most restricted nations on earth - Covid related *title edited by MNHQ*

135 replies

FreedomforWA · 21/01/2022 08:07

NC as this is outing. AIBU to think that I live in the most restricted nation in the world (well, maybe after North Korea)?

So, I’m a Brit living in Perth, Western Australia (WA). I think it is widely known that Australia basically closed to everyone at the start of the pandemic leaving tens of thousands of citizens and residents overseas. Towards the end of 2021, the individual states all started to open allowing quarantine free travel to approved vaccinated travellers. Except WA. We have continued to live with closed borders – both internal to other states and international (we can leave but due to stringent caps and hotel quarantine, it is almost impossible to return). Our state Premier announced prior to Christmas that the state would open on Feb 5th. Thousands made plans to reunite with family, return home etc. Last night he performed a u-turn and our border is staying shut due to the threat of Omicron. He has not set a future date so we are all essentially in limbo. The rest of Australia is now learning to live with covid and can travel freely. WA has only had around 1400 cases of Covid since the pandemic began with 9 deaths. We have had a few short lockdowns. Whilst I appreciate that this is excellent, striving for zero covid is not a strategy the Premier can keep up with forever. He is delaying the inevitable.

We have an 89% fully vaxxed rate in the over 12s (96% single vaxxed) but this is apparently not good enough, despite being one of the highest rates in the world. We have a mask mandate that covers any indoor premise that isn’t a private residence.

75% of our work force has been mandated to get the vaccine. This is everyone from health care workers and police to supermarket workers and builders – the list is pretty much endless. As you can imagine, there has been a lot of discontent regarding this.

The rules state that as of 31st Jan, we have to show a vaccine certificate to attend – off licenses, restaurants, bars, zoo, theatres museums, hospitals (as a visitor), sporting stadiums, arenas, casino, play centres, gyms, night clubs, music venues and cinemas. I’m pretty sure it won’t stop there. The unvaxxed soon won’t have anywhere to go. Despite being pro-vax and being triple vaxxed myself, I believe that this has gone too far.

This is a state with a significant number of expats. Many of us haven’t seen family for 2-3 years now. I know people will just say that we should leave but it isn’t easy to just leave when we have jobs, lives, homes and mortgages here.

I would love to hear outsider (or fellow WA residents) thoughts on the restrictions we are living with.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nolongersurprised · 22/01/2022 10:01

I’m in another part of Australia and I think it’s delaying the inevitable. How bad things are depend on who you talk to, I think.

If you’re trying to get a rapid antigen test and can’t, then that’s terrible. If you went to the supermarket and there’s not as much food then that’s also terrible. If you’re waiting on an elective procedure that’s been deferred then that’s awful as well. If you wanted to never get COVID then the whole thing is terrifying

On the other hand, restaurants, cinemas, coffee shops are open. The vaccinations seem to work, people are dying but not in huge numbers. (Although 60-70/day of mainly elderly people with co-morbidities is tragic and too many for some). There is strain on the hospital system but GPs are still working, where I am hospital outpatients is still happening.

Most people I know have either had it, or accept that it’s coming. Most people are triple vaccinated, 12-15 year olds double vaccinated and a reasonable chunk of 5-11 years had had their first vaccine.

Waiting for the population to be be vaccinated before opening up has seemingly reduced the number of people dying, no one I personally know wants to stay locked up forevermore.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 22/01/2022 09:33

On reflection, I think there is a very good case to make that there s a breach of Article 13 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

I do think that, under the circumstances, it is understandable that it might be temporarily suspended but it has gone on for too long and without an end date in sight

That said, I am sure someone one must have challenged it on these grounds before and lost as I am certainly not the cleverest person in the room.

Perhaps it is time for another challenge as the situation has evolved further? I’m not a lawyer and I have tried not to dwell on this so I acknowledge I don’t have all the facts. But I am desperate to leave the country again and deal with outstanding personal matters overseas. Not to mention just take a holiday.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 22/01/2022 09:30

I think that you are correct OP.
If you can’t unlock travel restrictions now when everyone who will be vaccinated has been vaccinated, then will be the time ever right?
I thought that measures in the UK went too far at times - like when the Mayor of Middlesbrough locked all of the parks during lockdown for instance- it does seem to bring out the worst in some officials.

RantyAunty · 22/01/2022 09:17

expat/immigrant in oz victoria

One thing I don't think many outside were aware of that we were not allowed to leave the country. Even having citizenship in another country I wasn't allowed to leave. You had to apply for a special exemption and by the time you had your statutory declaration and evidence of why you should be allowed to leave, it was 15 - 20 pages.

It's been terrible. It hasn't helped being mocked and shamed by fellow Australians for saying it's been bad.

My mental health has awful. I've come close to ending it a few times.

It's easy to say it's all good when you live here and all your family and friends are here.

When all your family lives overseas, it isn't good.

I'm in the process of leaving here. I don't think I'll ever return.

Go ahead and shame and mock someone suffering with PTSD and severe depression.

Queuing4Fergs · 22/01/2022 08:46

OP I think you are being perfectly rational and drawing comparisons with some countries not known for their Liberal human rights when yours is a country that has always had such rights, is perfectly understandable. Posters saying "are you really saying you have it worse than women in Afghanistan" are obviously, and probably intentionally, missing the point.

What you are describing is awful. To have no idea when things might change, is frankly, cruel. I would be angry too.

I am angry actually. I'm a NZ'er who had a big trip booked in Dec 2020 to see my elderly father. I haven't been able to get back since that trip was cancelled. Initially I hadn't wanted to take my children out of school as they had missed so much and I thought this madness couldn't last for much longer.

But I've given up caring about that now, as it's far more important that they get to see their 85 year old grandfather one last time, as far as I'm concerned. Except I can't get a managed isolation place on the lottery. The closet I've been is something like 11,000th in line. So I'm being locked out of my own country and like you, I have no idea when this will change.

My fear is that NZ govt will react strongly against the new UK policy of just getting on with it and living with it. Jacinda has managed to create such a climate of fear in NZ that the public are going to support any policy that will make it hard for me to visit my own country, as I must be 'riddled with covid'. It"s going to be a huge adjustment for the NZ public to accept that the time has come to live freely, and where necessary cautiously - that PP from Queensland makes this point perfectly. And because of that, I think it could be yet another year before I'm able to go home.

Aussies and Kiwis have always had a "she'll be right" "get on with it" attitude and I despair that we've been turned into nations of bed wetters, scared of our own shadows. Covid kills, for sure. But we're so far gone that we're afraid to live.

YeOldeTrout · 22/01/2022 08:29

Podcast you may like, OP. Other places struggling to find a Plan B away from Zero Covid.

BlancheB · 22/01/2022 08:24

@EatYourVegetables

How overdramatic.

This week a young woman in Pakistan has been sentenced to death for some Whatsapp messages she sent. But no, YOU live in the most restricted nation on Earth, because your government didn’t allow loads of old and vulnerable folk to die for your convenience.

FFS.

Well why not start your own thread to discuss that if you haven't already?

The OP is not being dramatic. It's utterly chilling to read what has been going in WA and elsewhere and also reading some of the responses on here.

Marchmount · 22/01/2022 08:14

We’ve all been told here that vaccine protection reduces and is ineffective after several months. Surely the best time for the population to be exposed is when people have just been vaccinated? If WA delays opening up, are they not just making the problem worse when the inevitable wave does hit?

ineedsun · 22/01/2022 08:13

@BrightYellowDaffodil

Good. One less

One less what?

I don’t think @echt is feeling great about people who aren’t keen on and don’t want to visit Australia 😂
echt · 22/01/2022 08:12

One less person who doesn't want to come here anyway.

They pitch up threads about Australia all the time.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 22/01/2022 08:01

Good. One less

One less what?

echt · 22/01/2022 07:56

@BrightYellowDaffodil

YANBU, OP. I've been staggered by the behaviour of some parts of Australia over Covid; not only draconian legislation for citizens but a shocking legal approach to those coming in from outside. It seems that the laws are far-reaching and as flexible as those using them wish them to be to suit their purpose.

I love travel, the further flung the better generally, but Australia has never been somewhere I've hugely wanted to go. I definitely don't want to now.

Good. One less.
TwentyFirstCenturyTricoteuse · 22/01/2022 07:54

Well, other places have long-standing vaccine mandates and passes, so you are not alone in that. The quarantine rules seem unduly strict, but then you are not facing a fine of several thousand euros if you refuse the jab as in Austria. So, same as some places on some points, worse on some, and better on others.

Loopytiles · 22/01/2022 06:19

YANBU to be angry about the measures taken.

YABU on the North Korea comparison.

Migrainesbythedozen · 22/01/2022 06:12

My gut feeling is that he is waiting for Omicron to peak in the Eastern states before he opens up. I can see logic in that. But I do agree that opening up before winter hits would be best.

Notanotheruser111 · 21/01/2022 21:10

I work in a hospital in the eastern states. I don’t work with COVID patients. The nurses on my ward are exhausted doing double shifts, working short staffed which is incredibly dangerous on this ward. They’ve had to shut beds because of staffing issues which means the EDs are badly affected. Covid effects every part of the health system. I can understand why he doesn’t want to open up.

Anecdotally the mental health of my colleagues seems to be worse now then in lockdown

mjf981 · 21/01/2022 20:54

I think it’s madness. I’d be so angry if I lived in WA.

I’m in Sydney. I recently had COVID, as have a lot of people I know. For every single person it was mild URT cold symptoms for a few days. That’s it. Omnicron is much milder than the other strains. To keep the whole state isolated when your vaccination rate is so high is madness. Scare mongering. Open up and get on with it like the rest of the country. Herd immunity for the win.

EngTech · 21/01/2022 20:45

I have family in WA so I know how you feel not being able to physically see them 😔

All the politicians are doing, is putting off the inevitable

Once WA opens up its borders to everyone, CV19 is going to spread big time but hopefully if most people are jabbed up, it should mitigate hopefully, the hospitals being over loaded and just be like a bad dose of flu for a few days!

Time will tell on that one

Talking to our son via video link, modern tech is wonderful, they are having trouble getting people to actually do work due to borders being closed so companies are getting big engineering work orders but are unable to start them 😳

WA can’t keep its borders closed indefinitely? Or can it?

If they keep borders closed, what is the long term cost, fallout?

Election year this year, May?

Will ScoMo get re-elected?

Voters have a habit of showing their disapproval 👍

StartupRepair · 21/01/2022 20:30

@Sarahschild what evidence do you have for all the premiers being corrupt? (apart from Gladys where we have heard the evidence).

Bambooshoot · 21/01/2022 15:10

“One of”, definitely, but not the worst. You’ve had the opportunity to pause and be kept safe until vaccines and treatment have been found. Your children have not had schools closed and been confined to their home, with huge developmental impacts on the youngest and mental health impacts on the oldest. The rate of job loss will have been lower, the health services coping well, all of these are good things. Yes, Covid is shit, but its shit for everyone across the planet, in different ways, and having lived in both a Covid-struck and Covid-free country during these times, the feeling of not knowing in the early days whether you’d be one of the unlucky ones and not be able to survive to look after your child long enough that they’d actually remember you is definitely not to be envied.

And at least you needn’t fear being carted into quarantine just by being a close contact - and you’re not a hamster!!

merryhouse · 21/01/2022 14:54

We can't live like this indefinitely.

...well, you could, you know...

150 years ago if you went to Australia that was it. You were in Australia now.

Even 50 years ago, my aunt and her family didn't expect to see us more than once a decade.

I'm not saying you should put up and shut up, but it's entirely possible to live your whole life in the same country. (I haven't left England since 1999.) You just don't want to.

InWalksBarberalla · 21/01/2022 14:45

I think McGowan has made the right call to delay a little. If the planning they have done is anything like the other states - based on delta not omicron it makes sense to wait a little and get the vulnerable boostered and testing ready to go. It's been a shitstorm over in the east - impossible to get tests, medical care non existent, supermarket shelves almost empty. We've spent the summer school holidays either with covid ( first half) or with nothing to do because so many things are shut due to covid or with nobody to see because they have covid. Now are bins aren't even being collected due to lack or drivers because of tcovid.

But those are really just minor inconvenience compared to the vulnerable people I know that rely on carers and the stress involved in that care being continued. IVF being cancelled. 'Elective' surgery being cancelled.
I'd swap this summer with someone in WA in a heartbeat, in fact I'd swap the last 2 years. We've spent heaps of that time separated from family who live in the same state due to restrictions anyway.

Distant01 · 21/01/2022 14:41

Take heart OP. YANBU
Most of the voters agree you're not being unreasonable.
Of course the tragedies and oppression taking part in other countries are terrible, but you are entitled to your feelings too.
We see what's happening in Australia and if people here think battering people protesting and pepper spraying them is acceptable, then they'd fit right in living in North Korea.
Your leaders have become unhinged despots.

SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 14:38

No matter where you are, if we're talking about western democratic countries, covid measures raise a lot of questions about compatibility with basic citizenship rights, and the basic liberal democratic rights that underpin liberal democracy.

There is a tendency to handwave those away, but it's worth noticing that ij npretty much every country the civil liberties organisations have been really concerned about the inroads being made. Legal, but also psychological.

In my province, our legislature didn't sit for over a year after emergency measures were invoked. Many people were back to work, supermarkets had never shut down, but apparently our political representatives could not meet to govern us. We were being governed by the premier. Even the media wasn't really challenging their pronouncements.

That kind of thing is very worrying. Not letting in your own citizens who are abroad, that is very worrying, close to making people stateless. Given permanent extraordinary powers to the health minister, as in Aus. - very worrying.

What are the implications for this stuff as time goes on? Now that it's seen how easily these populations have accepted these measures?

Then the other thing is - what they heck are they thinking they will achive by not opening now? There may have been relative freedom (within rather strict bounds) till now - but everyone knows once they open up, there will be waves of illness. Probably several even if they are starting with omicron, because the building up of natural immunity also seems to be playing a part in making the population more resilient.

They've painted themselves into a corner with 0 covid thinking.

ittakes2 · 21/01/2022 14:25

West Australian living in the UK - I have watched my family and friends lead a normal life during the pandemic - and been relieved they have been safe. It does feel now though that after promising to open up he is changing his mind - he could have done a mini quaranteen like 48hrs or even five days instead of a ridiculous 14 dayer.
I said to my mum its going to be months now - with min community transmission if he suddenly opens up he will get in future what he is saying the reason for keeping closed now - pressure on hospitals. There is always going to be new variants.
We have flights and accomodation for April - looks like we need to review!