Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it better to save for retirement or enjoy life now?

103 replies

malificent7 · 21/01/2022 06:56

Starting out on new career so dont earn loads nut low mortgage...i'm 43. I am aware that i need to prep for retirement and will enrol on another pension scheme ( i did have some as a teacher).
However, as a health are worker I am aware that life is short and i want to spend the money I earn now on holidays etc.My mum died at 58 before she took retirement.
Aibu to think only high earners can both save and enjoy life now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
blyn72 · 23/01/2022 14:16

It's not greedy to shore yourself up a bit. I must say I never did it, I was always very much a live in the moment person but I appreciate the fact my late husband did - a bit - as it means I don't have to worry and our son is provided for. We are not rich but comfortable - what is wrong with that?

Somanyquestions1984 · 23/01/2022 14:09

Wombat I agree with most of what you say. I do have a rather privileged set of friends all paying into NHS whilst also squirrelling away into other private pensions and some who own multiple buy to let’s with no mortgage!

I understand these are the privileged few and unusual but I see it as a bit greedy as once mortgage is paid I can’t imagine I’d need that much money for retirement but then who knows?

WombatChocolate · 23/01/2022 13:32

Somanyqiestions, by paying into your very good occupational NHS pension, you are in fact saving or preparing for retirement. Several hundred pounds from your salary will be going into that every month.

The thing is, some people opt out of pensions or with defined contribution pensions, pay in the minimum of a couple of percent and only have employers who pay the minimum too - their provision will be very small.

Most people’s provision for retirement is via pensions. Some people have some other provision too via ISAs or other investments if perhaps Buy to Let, or other savings, but for most people it’s pensions. If people have looked into what income they need in retirement and their pension contributions will provide that, then they are prepared.

People who aren’t prepared are either those who have never actually looked into what they are likely to need (the Which? Website gives useful info for what income might be needed for a single person or couple for basic, moderate and comfortable retirement) and considered if what they are paying in will provide it, or who have looked into it and are put contributing nearly enough.

This stuff about no-one knows when they will die so they want to enjoy the cash now is foolish head in the sand stuff. Yes, some people die in their 50s, 60s, but the vast majority don’t. Absolutely, we need to live now. We need housing and to help our kids and to enjoy holidays too, but a key expense also needs to be providing for old age. For most of us it will happen, and no-one wants to be poor.

Most people assume they will get a full state pension. But most people don’t know how much that is or that you need 35 years of contributions to to get it - it’s not automatic. Many people, especially women won’t get to the full 35 years. And most people don’t have any idea if what they will need in retirement or what their current pension will provide per year. It’s the equivalent of having zero idea what income you will have next year and just hoping you’ll have a job but not doing anything to make it happen.

Most people don’t have enough income to have absolutely everything they want now and a good, comfortable retirement. Most people have to make some choices, but choices require information. People need to know the consequences for today and the future if putting £300 per month into their pension or £600 per month into their pension, and the consequences of having a new sofa or not having one for today and tomorrow.

This general principle which is quite vague of living for today (whatever that means) and saving a bit for future (with tiny oension contributions or none) is just sleep walking into an old age of poverty.

For some people old age poverty is pretty much unavoidable as their income levels currently are so low. But for lots of people, they will be in old age poverty, when actually it could have been avoided by different choices when they were younger. Even a couple of hours digging around in the internet or accessing pension records or state pension forecast online can give someone the info they need to make informed choices. It’s vital!

Somanyquestions1984 · 23/01/2022 12:11

I’m paying into NHS pension which is enough for me as you can’t draw until 67 currently. I choose enjoy life and reduce stressful work responsibility after 55 for me.

Snailhaterz2 · 23/01/2022 12:02

I'm in my early 60s, won't get my state pension until I'm 67 and frankly am a bit knackered. I'm also very bad at boundarying my work - I'm a bit of a workaholic, which isn't great when you're self-employed. I have a pension pot which my financial adviser has confirmed that I can take some money out of without affecting the size of the overall pot - eg on average it won't get any bigger but it won't get any smaller. So, my plan is to take some money out every year until the state pension kicks in, and use that to reduce the amount I have to work. I will then use that extra time to do nice things, and hopefully feel a lot less pressured. So, a sort of middle ground! I really don't want to wait until I'm 67 before doing anything.

CaptainMerica · 23/01/2022 11:46

I think it's important to think about what "saving for retirement" might actually mean. It's not necessarily about trips to the seaside and lunch out, etc. Most of us will be much older than our parents were when we retire.

For a lot of people, it's about paying a cleaner, when you are unable to manage on your own. The quality of ready meals delivered, if you are too infirm to cook. The heating on constantly, if you can't move from your chair. The things that enable you to stay in your own home, if that is your preference, or give you more choice of care options if not.

Drunkpanda · 23/01/2022 11:46

Thank you, @PaintYourDreams I will register for that today Flowers

blyn72 · 23/01/2022 11:18

I have to say I never saved for retirement but I do have a small occupational pension and have inherited my late husband's pension which is quite sufficient.

NotEnoughTime · 23/01/2022 11:11

I agree with the PP's that say do both if you can.

Personally though I like to enjoy my life now (within reason!) and 'make memories' with my DC. Yes, I know that many people find that a sickly phrase and yes, I also know that you do not HAVE to spend lots of money to make memories but I have found that as the DC are getting older most things that they are interested in cost £££.

My parents died at 62 and 65 so in the back of my mind I have a feeling that I won't make 'old bones'-daft perhaps but I would hate to save for a future that might never happen.

Whilst I'm fit and healthy (ish!) then I will carry on treating my DC and enjoying life as best I can :)

rooarsome · 22/01/2022 16:11

Do both! My dad is 63, retired last year. Diagnosed with stage 4 cancer a month after he retired. We are now rapidly approaching end of life care and he hasn't done even half the things he wanted to do with my mum when retired.

PaintYourDreams · 22/01/2022 16:08

drunkpanda you can check your NI contributions via the Government Gateway and it will show exactly how many years of contributions you have. Also, there is a Pension Forecast you can look up, again accessed through the Government Gateway.

StEval · 22/01/2022 14:58

@BashfulClam

It’s difficult as both my dad and fil died before reaching retirement. Fil was desperate to retire and was just a few years away, I always feel he was robbed.
If either DH or I died before retiring the other gets their lump sum paid out. If either dies after retiring the other gets half each month.
BashfulClam · 22/01/2022 14:53

It’s difficult as both my dad and fil died before reaching retirement. Fil was desperate to retire and was just a few years away, I always feel he was robbed.

Drunkpanda · 22/01/2022 14:45

That's a really helpful explanation, thank you @FourTeaFallOut

FourTeaFallOut · 22/01/2022 13:42

@Drunkpanda

So is it 35 years of full time work you need to get the full state pension? Are maternity leave taken out and is part time work pro rata'd then?
No. You don't have to work full time. If I understand it right, you need to make a minimum ni contribution equivalent to a lower earning limit. So, say in the year 2019-20 - the lower earnings limit was just £118 per week which means if you earnt more that just over £6k that year and paid in contributions on that income, regardless of hours per week or which months you worked, then you qualify for a full year's worth of ni contributions.
monfuseds · 22/01/2022 12:33

Don't do what I did & I paid the missing contributions when I was on mat leave. I've paid NI since I was 17 & through uni & my retirement age is 67 so that's 50 years of contributions

Drunkpanda · 22/01/2022 12:17

So is it 35 years of full time work you need to get the full state pension? Are maternity leave taken out and is part time work pro rata'd then?

Guacamole001 · 22/01/2022 12:12

Yes not everybody has 35 years in the state pension pot. Luckily I am nearly at that level. Not that it is enough to live on!

Jmaho · 22/01/2022 12:04

@cptartapp

Well don't fall into the trap of saving for retirement/a rainy day and then when you get there refuse to spend it. PIL continue to live thriftily despite being very well off, with no one seemingly enjoying it. Money just piling up whilst they sit in the cold and do everything on the cheap. If DH is lucky enough to inherit then he'll damn well spend it on enjoying life rather then repeating the miserable process. That I don't get.
I agree with this. My parents neighbour died a few years ago at 90. He had lived in his house for 60 odd years having inherited from his parents so was mortgage free pretty much his whole life. He had quite a senior role for Royal Mail and took early redundancy when he was 60 and got a huge payout and very good pension. The house was falling apart. Damp and cold. He never put the heating on. He used to dry teabags on the washing line and reuse them and used to spend his later years walking round the streets looking for skips and would help himself to all sorts of junk. He died and left his house (worth £300k) plus over & £1 million to his distant nephew that he rarely saw. Absolute madness
Drunkpanda · 22/01/2022 11:52

@fedup078

I also hate the thought of squirrelling money away and then if like my mother I die single with no dependents my pensions will just go back to the government/ pension company
Not the state one but a private pension can have anyone you want for a beneficiary - pretty sure you could leave it to a charity of your choice (not a pensions expert so don't take my word for it)
AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 22/01/2022 11:52

I pay into my NHS pension every month so use my wages and to enjoy life and squirrel a bit away for emergencies

GnomeDePlume · 22/01/2022 11:36

@Guacamole001 only if you have 35 years of contributions.

Guacamole001 · 22/01/2022 11:28

The state pension is just over 9k. Most definitely NOT 3k!

JamMakingWannaBe · 22/01/2022 10:55

The state pension of £3k/year is not that far off my annual Council Tax bill - plus, gas, elec, TV etc. People who are not saving privately are going to have a big shock and/or life adjustment.

Houseplantmad · 22/01/2022 10:05

I'm a middle way person too. I'm looking to plan the next few years til retirement now in terms of reducing hours etc. so I can do other things I'm interested in.
I have two good work pensions and full state. I save to travel now with my family while the DCs are at home (uni age) but do have other savings. We do a big trip every few years and holiday modestly but well in the meantime.
My family seem to die in their late 70s and that's frighteningly close so I want to enjoy as much now as possible!

Swipe left for the next trending thread