Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the e-mail sign off with pronoun's?

388 replies

hehimshehertheythem · 20/01/2022 22:21

He/him and she/her at the end of an email. Margaret I know you're a woman and Jeff I know you're a man. Why are you teaching me to suck eggs. I don't get it?

I have not once never see a they/them as a sign off, so what is the actual point?

I for one will not be taking part in this madness. But would like to understand the thought behind the people that do? If there is any thought that is.

OP posts:
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 21/01/2022 12:14

I can't get worked up about this when there are other more pressing issues in the world

/////

It is wholly possible to want to challenge this and push back - no one here is "worked up" - whilst doing the same on numerous issues.

And if you take time to dig a bit further you'll see there are some good reasons for challenging this tosh.

FannyCann · 21/01/2022 12:14

*Interestingly some of the best research on sex bias has come from transgender people. There was a study on gender bias a few years ago on Radio 4, where they had looked at the treatment of transitioning people in the workplace.

FTM transitioners reported being treated more favourably than before, with a greater assumption of competence.

MTF reported the opposite and fared worse in their career post transition.*

Of course it is possible that some of the problems transitioners may find in relation to their careers may be less related to whichever sex they transitioned you and more related to behaviours accompanying the transition, time off sick for surgery or other treatments, demands around pronouns etc and generally being preoccupied with self rather than work.

Iloveyogurt · 21/01/2022 12:04

@Kotatsu

Interesting story. I guess I have always been fortunate that in all levels and years of work I have never been discriminated against because of my gender.

But how would you know? Part of gender (ie. the social treatment of a person according to their sex) is expectations, and it's an unconscious bias - you wouldn't know if, had you been male, you would have been considered for internal promotion, been offered a higher grade, been estimated as achieving better for your bonus assessment, or just had your CV put in the circular file as not good enough.

Because I have always been happy, felt satisfied with my achievements and been suitably paid and promoted. There are many factors when it comes to gender bias in the workplace. For example in science it is easy to get left behind your male peers if you take mat leave. Shared mat leave helps but unfortunately can't overcome some of the basics in biology in those early months.
FannyCann · 21/01/2022 11:58

Also, like@sashagabadonwas brought up that it was rude to refer to someone as 'she' in their absence so their name/they feels more polite to me!

That's nuts though. So once you've mentioned their name, you go on using the name for the rest of what you're saying, in order to avoid using the terribly rude 'she'?

'I saw Sandra today. Sandra said Sandra had just been in holiday to Mallorca. Sandra didn't like it much. Sandra said Sandra got terribly sunburnt and the locals weren't very friendly to Sandra.'

Doesn't really work, does it? It's not polite, it's bonkers and impractical! That's why we have pronouns.

@crazyjinglist

I don't think the occasions that might trigger a rebuke from Mother were ever normal conversation. It was normally in response to childish whining and complaining "She pinched me first and She spilt tea on my homework and anyway She's being really mean..."

Which could reasonably refer to three different She's hence the "Who's She?" question/rebuke.

AuntyBumBum · 21/01/2022 11:54

@crazyjinglist

Also, like@sashagabadonwas brought up that it was rude to refer to someone as 'she' in their absence so their name/they feels more polite to me!

That's nuts though. So once you've mentioned their name, you go on using the name for the rest of what you're saying, in order to avoid using the terribly rude 'she'?

'I saw Sandra today. Sandra said Sandra had just been in holiday to Mallorca. Sandra didn't like it much. Sandra said Sandra got terribly sunburnt and the locals weren't very friendly to Sandra.'

Grin Doesn't really work, does it? It's not polite, it's bonkers and impractical! That's why we have pronouns.

I can see that you don't frequent the more grim-faced threads of the feminist boards very much Grin
VelvetChairGirl · 21/01/2022 11:54

[quote girljulian]@HollowTalk actually I do have my title before my name, but my title is Dr so it doesn’t help me at all! It’s amazing how many people will see Dr Julian Lastname and reply “Dear Mr Lastname…”[/quote]
probably a blessing in disguise.

I have a very old fashioned name that many people have never heard of so sometimes I get assumed to be male, people treat you very differently if they are sexist.

best to break the ice without them instantly knowing in your profession I would have thought.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 11:49

Doesn't really work, does it? It's not polite, it's bonkers and impractical! That's why we have pronouns.

If it means I don't have to call a male person she/her or be accused of "misgendering" due to someone's power trip. I'll avoid pronouns however I can.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 21/01/2022 11:47

@YetAnotherSpartacus

Pronouns mi/ow

I'd have thought they were feed/me.

I thought Not/Dog would be more apt!
crazyjinglist · 21/01/2022 11:45

Also, like@sashagabadonwas brought up that it was rude to refer to someone as 'she' in their absence so their name/they feels more polite to me!

That's nuts though. So once you've mentioned their name, you go on using the name for the rest of what you're saying, in order to avoid using the terribly rude 'she'?

'I saw Sandra today. Sandra said Sandra had just been in holiday to Mallorca. Sandra didn't like it much. Sandra said Sandra got terribly sunburnt and the locals weren't very friendly to Sandra.'

Grin Doesn't really work, does it? It's not polite, it's bonkers and impractical! That's why we have pronouns.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 21/01/2022 11:36

@steff13

I saw a woman on Twitter (I think) who had her pronouns as she/him. Which is just confusing.
Good for him. She was obviously taking the piss Grin
IamAporcupine · 21/01/2022 11:30

@Chrysanthemum5

Someone at my work is she/her on Monday Tuesday and Friday but they/them on Wednesday and Thursday. Which always makes me wonder what if I wrote an email referring to that individual as she on a Tuesday, but it wasn't read until Wednesday when that person is now they?
I've seen this mentioned (in SM, not RL) and always wondered how bloody self-absorbed you must be to declare something like that.

I've seen others using she/they and specifying that it is not OK for people to 'just' use she. No. Both have to be used, alternatively or in similar proportions... Confused

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 11:27

Someone at my work is she/her on Monday Tuesday and Friday but they/them on Wednesday and Thursday. Which always makes me wonder what if I wrote an email referring to that individual as she on a Tuesday, but it wasn't read until Wednesday when that person is now they?

What if they take a transatlantic flight on Thursday night?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 11:25

This must surely have been a parody.

No, it wasn't just one person, it was a thing.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 21/01/2022 11:15

I'm not 'cisgender'. I'm not 'trans' either. Cisgender is made up nothingness at best and offensive at worst.

I'm a woman.

AuntyBumBum · 21/01/2022 11:14

@shrodingersvaccine

Also, like *@sashagabadon* was brought up that it was rude to refer to someone as 'she' in their absence so their name/they feels more polite to me! It's just occurred to me to wonder why we were brought up that 'she' is rude but 'he' isn't....
Hmmm, "Who's "She"? The cat's mother?".

Said my mother imperiously, at least twice a day. She was inexplicably but firmly of the view that any pronouns are an affront to the dignity of women! You're right, though, I can't remember the cat's father ever being brought into play Grin

SlapBet · 21/01/2022 11:10

If I was ever asked to include pronouns I would go with the suggestion I read on here,
“My pronouns are sex based like my oppression “

TheElementsSong · 21/01/2022 11:08

I would no more declare pronouns in my email signature than I would add my Zodiac sign or my preferred day to make sacrifice to Xipetotec.

Ormally · 21/01/2022 11:07

@Isaw3ships

‘ DepletingDopamine

Huge generalisation alert!
I’m guessing that the people that have an issue with this are cisgender.’

Nope.we had a massive discussion/argument about this in our work LGBTQ+ grp and it was divided 50/50 pretty much.

So it's ok to guess at cisgender leanings based on the absence of some words/semantics?!! Now I'm confused...
C8H10N4O2 · 21/01/2022 11:04

I guess I have always been fortunate that in all levels and years of work I have never been discriminated against because of my gender

If you are a woman and if you are in a position to even know, then yes you are extremely lucky.

If you are using pronouns because you have been told its kind or helpful to another group then you might want to read the Yogyakarta Principles linked to above. Coerced speech is never helpful, especially to those it claims to help whilst forcing them to out themselves. Its always about with power controlling those without it.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 21/01/2022 10:56

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

It’s to signify compliance with the ideology.
This and only this.
Flammkuchen · 21/01/2022 10:52

Interestingly some of the best research on sex bias has come from transgender people. There was a study on gender bias a few years ago on Radio 4, where they had looked at the treatment of transitioning people in the workplace.

FTM transitioners reported being treated more favourably than before, with a greater assumption of competence.

MTF reported the opposite and fared worse in their career post transition.

One FTM reported that one client told them that 'thank god you've replaced the women who was there before. You're so much better' without realising it was the same person.

So no, I am not going to draw attention to my sex in the workplace.

VelvetChairGirl · 21/01/2022 10:49

@MaxNormal

I think being coerced into using them at work is akin to religious coercion.
I agree, and I deliberately dont use them at all around anyone I think is a fanatical Gender ideologist.

its not worth it, altho tbf I swerve those people anyway.

Kotatsu · 21/01/2022 10:44

Interesting story. I guess I have always been fortunate that in all levels and years of work I have never been discriminated against because of my gender.

But how would you know? Part of gender (ie. the social treatment of a person according to their sex) is expectations, and it's an unconscious bias - you wouldn't know if, had you been male, you would have been considered for internal promotion, been offered a higher grade, been estimated as achieving better for your bonus assessment, or just had your CV put in the circular file as not good enough.

Everafter20 · 21/01/2022 10:41

We live in times where a business can be slated all over social media and potentially lose a lot of business or have legal action taken against them just because an employee mistakenly calls she a he or vice versa. Businesses are running scared from this topic and just trying to cover all customers. In my opinion it is utter madness but we already know that us people with a cervix, as the Scottish government have taken to addressing us are not being heard and are losing our rights more and more every day to trans rights. I believe inequality for everyone but this has gone too far now.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/01/2022 10:32

I have a dim memory of reading about someone who signals what gender they feel at that moment by wearing a wristband of a certain colour. The onus was then on those around them to notice and remember what each colour signified. This must surely have been a parody.