Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the e-mail sign off with pronoun's?

388 replies

hehimshehertheythem · 20/01/2022 22:21

He/him and she/her at the end of an email. Margaret I know you're a woman and Jeff I know you're a man. Why are you teaching me to suck eggs. I don't get it?

I have not once never see a they/them as a sign off, so what is the actual point?

I for one will not be taking part in this madness. But would like to understand the thought behind the people that do? If there is any thought that is.

OP posts:
crazyjinglist · 21/01/2022 19:10

Myers Briggs reminds me of those personality quizzes in teen magazines. I get that adolescents feel the constant need to define and redefine themselves and loudly proclaim the tribe/type they belong to, but surely adults should really have grown out of that?

crazyjinglist · 21/01/2022 19:06

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?

You don't get to choose how others see you. You have no control over that. None of us does. Nor should we. Other people's thoughts are their own. What they see is what they see. You cannot compel people to see the world the way that fits in with your ideology, or expect people to automatically be up for validating your feelings.

Gender identity doesn't provably exist except as a bunch of personality traits and stereotypes. Why should anyone think they have the right to make other people change their view, the law and the language they use on the basis of that?

You can ask though. And people may choose to comply. But the vast majority of them still won't actually at all be seeing you the way you see yourself. They will be complying to be kind or because they're afraid they'll be flamed if they don't.

EarthSight · 21/01/2022 18:40

@VivX What an absolute waste of company time and money......and to display it publicly.....what???

I don't think the Myers Briggs is good. The big 5 personality model is simpler and I think better. Still, that's besides the point. You shouldn't have to show it publicly anywhere. There is something very intrusive about an employers asking you to the test in the first place.

HerculesMulligann · 21/01/2022 18:36

When someone asks me to see and address them as a woman despite my eyes, ears, brain and common sense telling me otherwise that is an issue. It’s gaslighting and potentially dangerous. Dulling women’s senses as to who is a man or not directly compromising women’s safety. As well as being bloody confusing and disingenuous.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 18:33

was once told in a Facebook discussion that that's fair because we're the ones in a place of privilege and basically no one cares if we don't like it

Hashtag bekind! I don't actually care what they say, but the whole concept is ideological. It's like being called a heretic, it only makes sense if you are a gender ideologue. They can't see outside their own ideology.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 21/01/2022 18:32

probably why we end up with threads like these where people get their knickers in a twist!

That is a mysogynistic statement and actually evidences why we need to continue to protect female rights and spaces. Insults when people don't see things the way you want them to are invariably referencing females in a derogatory way, like you have here.

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?

What's so hard in understanding that it's not about asking people to see you as you see yourself, it's about demanding that people change societal structures which have been set up to try to provide some level of protection and work toward some level of equality for a disadvantaged group. If the way you want to be seen creates a situation which causes significant material problems for other people then you do not necessarily have the right to be seen as you want - or to get people to pretend that if they don't really see you like you want (you don't actually get to police's other's perceptions).

ArabellaScott · 21/01/2022 18:14

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?

I don't choose to identify with stereotypes applied to my sex.

DipYourPenisInMyBeaker · 21/01/2022 18:05

@hehimshehertheythem

To show support to who? My colleagues and friends who identify as a different gender or genders (or none) and want to be recognised as such. It’s respectful.

Your company that asked you to do it? Nobody asked me to do it. My company didn’t ask me to do it. I have my own mind and it was my decision based on what I know and who I associate with.

The male dominated world that you are an agreeable female? Really?! 🥱

Who are we supporting? Please refer to my answer to your first question.

I think pronouns are good for so many reasons. My post was about it being wrong to mandate it, should be voluntarily. It’s so clear when companies or people are disingenuous with why they do things / probably why we end up with threads like these where people get their knickers in a twist!

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?

DepletingDopamine · 21/01/2022 18:05

I sincerely apologise to anyone who may have been offended by my previous comment. If I had known that it was such a controversial word I would never have used it. I have reported my own comment as I said previously and mnhq are going to review it. I have read all the comments responding and realise that I was wrong. Please take comfort in knowing that your responses have helped to educate me and I will never use the term again.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 21/01/2022 18:05

Pronouns are a signal that someone is either being coerced or supports an extreme and potentially dangerous ideology

Or haven’t thought about it beyond ‘be kind’ or ‘it’s fashionable’..

JollyHostess · 21/01/2022 17:59

@Baystard

Interesting that it apparently causes unacceptable distress to refer to a trans person by anything other than the name of their chosen gender, and yet simultaneously it's fine to call women 'cisgender' against their wishes.
I was once told in a Facebook discussion that that's fair because we're the ones in a place of privilege and basically no one cares if we don't like it 🤷🏻‍♀️
ArabellaScott · 21/01/2022 16:32

Yes, well, quite. Almost like women are lesser, isn't it?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 16:31

Interesting that it apparently causes unacceptable distress to refer to a trans person by anything other than the name of their chosen gender, and yet simultaneously it's fine to call women 'cisgender' against their wishes.

Isn't it.

Baystard · 21/01/2022 16:02

Interesting that it apparently causes unacceptable distress to refer to a trans person by anything other than the name of their chosen gender, and yet simultaneously it's fine to call women 'cisgender' against their wishes.

AuntyBumBum · 21/01/2022 15:55

@ArabellaScott

YANBU, OP.

Pronouns are a signal that someone is either being coerced or supports an extreme and potentially dangerous ideology.

Bloody hell, there's a lot more to Brenda in Accounts than I realised.
VelvetChairGirl · 21/01/2022 15:38

@patritus

get so fed up with filling out application forms that ask for my gender, I am so tempted to tick "prefer not to say" if they have a box to write your own I make it clear I am female sex and I dont believe in gender. but so few forms actually have a box to type in.

But surely true equality is for age/race/religion/gender/sex/whether you have dependents etc blind applications.
A candidate should be hired for their ability to do the job and nothing else.
And once they are in post others are only entitled to know enough personal details required to work with them and nothing else

When I first started looking for work we were told how to write our CVs and things.

never include a photo unless your a model, its none of their business, dont write your age/DOB again its none of their business and discrimination if they actually hire based on age, same apples for for your sexual orientation and so on.

they also said never write miss, mr whatever on your CV just your name, contact details, experience, education, key skills and maybe a bit about hobbies if you feel they are relevant to the position your applying for, your personal information is none of their business and nothing to do with the job.

now we are having to write all the things they told us not to write to avoid discrimination, seemingly to show inclusivity its bollocks, at best a totally incompetent will be employed because they tick all the diversity boxes thus being discriminatory towards the none gay and black or whatever applicants, but I'm sure 9.9 times out of 10 its used to discriminate people on age, sex and marital status.

patritus · 21/01/2022 15:00

get so fed up with filling out application forms that ask for my gender, I am so tempted to tick "prefer not to say" if they have a box to write your own I make it clear I am female sex and I dont believe in gender. but so few forms actually have a box to type in.

But surely true equality is for age/race/religion/gender/sex/whether you have dependents etc blind applications.
A candidate should be hired for their ability to do the job and nothing else.
And once they are in post others are only entitled to know enough personal details required to work with them and nothing else

notanothertakeaway · 21/01/2022 14:52

My experience is that it's so often driven by (predominately white male) Exec's and HR departments trying to be "relevant" and "inclusive" whilst simultaneously ignoring the far more significant lack of diversity/salary parity/seniority wrt to women and ethnicity within the workplace

So hey - let's celebrate everyone having their pronouns on emails and our Stonewall credentials, but ignore the fact there is no BAME or female representation at a senior level

So true @BreadInCaptivity It's a no-cost "hey look at us, we're so inclusive" that does nothing to address the inequalities that already exist in the work place

ArabellaScott · 21/01/2022 14:49

YANBU, OP.

Pronouns are a signal that someone is either being coerced or supports an extreme and potentially dangerous ideology.

VelvetChairGirl · 21/01/2022 14:43

@EishetChayil

Political propaganda.

I recruit, and automatically discount CVs from anyone with pronouns in their signature. I don't want to work with someone who jumps on bandwagons.

I want to work for your company!

I get so fed up with filling out application forms that ask for my gender, I am so tempted to tick "prefer not to say" if they have a box to write your own I make it clear I am female sex and I dont believe in gender. but so few forms actually have a box to type in.

I have given up on applications entirely if they are absolutely full of the gender woo woo, pages and pages as I dont want to work for any company like that, I used to get pissed of at applications that asked if your single or married or if you are straight or gay I dont think thats anyone's business and as a woman I always think its the male management checking to see if your available so its a red flag for sexual harassment to me, now its just getting worse and worse.

Igloo71 · 21/01/2022 14:15

I started a thread earlier about being requested to do exactly this in my new job (sorry OP, didn't realise one already existed!)

Reading the comments are really interesting and helpful for me, thank you!

VelvetChairGirl · 21/01/2022 12:54

@TheBeardedVulture

Oh and for people saying pronoun announcement promotes inclusivity- how would you feel if a colleague decided to announce their religious affiliation in their professional email signature?

Because that is how I regard email pronouns. I don’t believe in gender identity and seeing colleagues put their ( obvious) pronouns in their sigs is fucking weird.

This^

I dont care about your religion, I am a christian and I am in no doubt you dont care about mine, I will not talk to you about god and will keep it to myself and you will not talk to me about gender woo woo and keep it to yourself.

that is what being in a tolerant society means.

purpleboy · 21/01/2022 12:48

I will never put my pronouns on my email, as soon as I encounter someone who does its a great signifier that, that person is either dim (to put it politely) or virtue signaling.
No place for it in work. Your there to do your job, not to compel others into an ideology that actively harms women and girls.
Seriously how narcissistic do you have to be to force others to refer to you in a certain way when your not even there?

randomsabreuse · 21/01/2022 12:40

I'm female, happily female and massively prefer not to make my gender clear in any communication where it is not either evident or essential. Especially when I was a city lawyer... so much less rubbish happens if people assume you're male.

crazyjinglist · 21/01/2022 12:23

I can't get worked up about this when there are other more pressing issues in the world

I happen to think it's part of an extremely pressing issue. Besides, I have plenty of room in my brain to get 'worked up' an enormous variety of things Grin.

If it means I don't have to call a male person she/her or be accused of "misgendering" due to someone's power trip. I'll avoid pronouns however I can

Oh yes, I'm with you there. I would very happily (and pointedly) repeat ad infinitum the name of, for example, a TW rapist or abuser of women in order to avoid either calling them 'she' or getting in trouble for 'misgendering' (i.e. correctly sexing) them.