Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the e-mail sign off with pronoun's?

388 replies

hehimshehertheythem · 20/01/2022 22:21

He/him and she/her at the end of an email. Margaret I know you're a woman and Jeff I know you're a man. Why are you teaching me to suck eggs. I don't get it?

I have not once never see a they/them as a sign off, so what is the actual point?

I for one will not be taking part in this madness. But would like to understand the thought behind the people that do? If there is any thought that is.

OP posts:
goodwinter · 20/01/2022 23:44

Also there are a few people in my company whose Teams status or email sig explains how their name is pronounced. I see this as a similar thing as pronouns for the unisex names mentioned above - it doesn't materially make a difference, but it's good to know that you're referring to someone properly.

(Although maybe I'm coming at this from quite a privileged perspective since I haven't experienced someone treating me differently in the workplace because I'm female - not since I worked in hospitality, anyway - so I do get why some women may prefer not to make their sex clear to clients etc)

GrandRapids · 20/01/2022 23:44

We have to do this at work. I'm a bit Hmmabout it and I mostly think it's my company's way of desperately trying to prove that they're progressive.

334bu · 20/01/2022 23:41

but it would make things easier to know.

Why?

BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 23:41

I don't get why people put both pronouns. After all, if you use "she", how likely is it that you will use "his"?

goodwinter · 20/01/2022 23:39

@Needcoffeecoffeecoffee

But if you were talking about Ashley from x company to a colleague and said she said email the information over and the colleague would surely just say "oh Ashley is male" and then you would use he next time referring to them. It wouldnt be use face to face with Ashley or in an email
That's fine if one of you knows if Ashley is a man or a woman. We have lots of offshore colleagues whom we only ever speak to via Teams/email, and none of my team know if they're male or female. Obviously not a huge deal in the grand scheme of things (we end up going for "they"), but it would make things easier to know.
DdraigGoch · 20/01/2022 23:39

[quote Enough4me]@mogkat now you're talking, if I can ID as a cat I would actually consider that. The other options don't appeal to me.[/quote]
I spend far too much time in bed and hide when I've had enough of visitors. As I have been demonstrably "living as a cat", I shall apply for a certificate to have this recognised in law.

BreadInCaptivity · 20/01/2022 23:39

It's helpful where people have first names that aren't gendered though. There's a Frankie on one team and I had no idea whether they were male or female until she put her pronouns on her sig.

Why does it matter what sex someone with whom you work is though?

Seriously.

If I'm in any doubt, I just use their name or "they". No big deal.

I care far more about them doing a good job.

My name isn't obviously female and frankly there was a noticeable shift in how people responded to me before and after they knew my sex.

I really resent the concept that by stating pronouns "gender identity" becomes important in the workplace. It isn't.

I don't want to bring my "whole self" to work, nor am I interested in anyone else doing so or being expected to validate another persons beliefs/ideology/politics etc.

I don't and won't put my pronouns in my work email because it signifies I believe something I don't (that you can change sex) and that it's remotely relevant to my or anyone else's performance in the workplace.

My experience is that it's so often driven by (predominately white male) Exec's and HR departments trying to be "relevant" and "inclusive" whilst simultaneously ignoring the far more significant lack of diversity/salary parity/seniority wrt to women and ethnicity within the workplace.

So hey - let's celebrate everyone having their pronouns on emails and our Stonewall credentials, but ignore the fact there is no BAME or female representation at a senior level.

ItsOnlyWordsInnit · 20/01/2022 23:35

@LaForza101

I have a unisex name and a non-gendered title. Take the politics out of pronouns and they are useful in emails.

I also contact a lot of people from different cultures where the gender of the name is not known to me so I appreciate it when they use pronouns as Google isn't always clear

I find it enormously useful too - my name is female in some cultures and male in others. And most of my contact with my clients - who themselves come from lots of cultures - is via email, so I don't hear or see them. Yet the formal business culture where I live dictates that it's rude to switch to first names or even Firstname Secondname too quickly, so I'm forced to choose Mr or Ms. There are any number of times I've resorted to Googling the name in the hope of finding more about it.
wherethecrawdadsare · 20/01/2022 23:34

I've wondered why you need to give two ... he/him - has anyone ever gone for she/him or he/her just to add confusion?!

bumblenbean · 20/01/2022 23:34

I have a client whose email signature includes the pronoun footer ‘she/her, but they/them is also fine’.

I mean … aside from the virtue signalling it just seems a bit …verbose? Confused

Sally872 · 20/01/2022 23:33

It is ineffective if forced to use them because it no longer shows support for others it's just following company policy. I think its a nice idea but have to be careful as .ay also push people into saying different pronouns before they are ready.

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 20/01/2022 23:31

But if you were talking about Ashley from x company to a colleague and said she said email the information over and the colleague would surely just say "oh Ashley is male" and then you would use he next time referring to them.
It wouldnt be use face to face with Ashley or in an email

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2022 23:31

@OfstedOffred

I also don't get why you need to know someone's gender to work with them.

It should make zero difference to your professional treatment of them.

Exactly. In fact it's precisely because it often makes a different to how you get treated that many women prefer to leave things ambiguous. Lets a new client get to know you before making assumptions about your ability based upon your sex.

www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-happened-when-a-man-signed-work-emails-using-a-female-name-for-a-week_n_58c2ce53e4b054a0ea6a4066

oakleaffy · 20/01/2022 23:31

@deeplyambivalent

I'm less worried about pronouns than I am about apostrophes.
I too thought the apostrophe was the issue.
MaybeHeIsMyCat · 20/01/2022 23:30

People can't even get my name right let alone if I put pronouns in

Today (not real name)
"You're through to Caroline"
"Hi there Sonia"
Confused

Delivery driver
"Mrs Smithson?"
"Well it's Miss, and you've added an extra 3 letters to the surname, none of which is on the parcel but yes..."

oakleaffy · 20/01/2022 23:28

@girljulian

I put mine in my sig because my name is Julian. I don’t like getting emails saying “Dear Mr Lastname” because I’m a woman.
I know a “ Robin” who is a young woman- Not Robyn Hence people can presume she is a man.
goodwinter · 20/01/2022 23:28

@Needcoffeecoffeecoffee

Some suggested we use our Myers Briggs letters after pronouns in work last month. Thank god that hasnt caught on. I just put name, job title and contact details and that's enough
Sweet Jesus 😂
goodwinter · 20/01/2022 23:28

@ImInStealthMode

I've been in regular email contact with an Ashley for several years. Never had need for a video or phone call. No idea if this Ashley is male or female, and makes absolutely fuck all difference to the work we collaborate on.

If I was referring to them to a colleague I'd say 'Ashley from Xcompany'

But then you end up having to say something like "I emailed Ashley about this. Ashley said we should do abc because Ashley thinks xyz"; or use "they" instead. I don't agree it should be mandated but I do think it's useful info for people with unisex names to make conversations easier.

Every time these threads come up there's always people saying "my sex/gender should make no difference to how someone treats me", and of course that's true. But there are situations like the above where knowing whether to refer to someone as he or she helps.

deeplyambivalent · 20/01/2022 23:27

I'm less worried about pronouns than I am about apostrophes.

AnnaSW1 · 20/01/2022 23:25

@DepletingDopamine I'm not cisgender. I'm a woman. Cisgender is a bollocks term in my opinion

AuntyBumBum · 20/01/2022 23:23

@Thirtytimesround

It’s a political thing. Adding your pronouns is a public statement that you agree that “transwomen are women” and biological males should have free access to women and girls spaces, male-bodied rapists should be in female prisons, male-bodies girl guide leaders allowed to supervise the girls changing room etc. It’s part of a political campaign to abolish women’s rights.

It doesn’t even make sense. Say Danny is a biological male who grew up with male privilege and never had a period or pregnancy and has male height and male body strength but now identifies as female. He sends me a work email and signs off “she/her.” When I reply to Danny, do I call him “him”, or “her”? Neither, I call Danny “you” because I am writing to Danny. So zero need for any pronoun confusion.

Or, is Danny worried that I might use the wrong pronoun in a conversation with a third person about Danny? Well (a) Danny can keep his nose out of my private conversations, (b) Danny’s email signature is not going to change what I say about him in private conversations, and (c) when I talk about Danny it isn’t the pronouns I’m using that he should most worry about.

It's quite possible that you'd use third-person pronouns in multi-person conversations including the person in question. And even if they're not present, the people who are might prefer you to respect their colleague's wishes.
Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 20/01/2022 23:22

Some suggested we use our Myers Briggs letters after pronouns in work last month.
Thank god that hasnt caught on.
I just put name, job title and contact details and that's enough

Firefliess · 20/01/2022 23:21

@ImInStealthMode

I've been in regular email contact with an Ashley for several years. Never had need for a video or phone call. No idea if this Ashley is male or female, and makes absolutely fuck all difference to the work we collaborate on.

If I was referring to them to a colleague I'd say 'Ashley from Xcompany'

I had exactly that experience with an Ashley I met in a newish job. I then completely confused a different colleague by referring to Ashley as him (which it turned out was wrong) Very useful if you have a unisex or foreign unfamiliar name, or want other people to use pronouns that don't match the gender of your name or your appearance. Pretty pointless if not. I really don't agree with this idea that it somehow makes it easier for trans people if everyone does it - they're the people who (at certain times at least, maybe before transition or early on) are the most likely to find it difficult and perhaps prefer not to say. So it does come across to me as just trying to look woke for many people.
MummyGummy · 20/01/2022 23:21

@Thirtytimesround

It’s a political thing. Adding your pronouns is a public statement that you agree that “transwomen are women” and biological males should have free access to women and girls spaces, male-bodied rapists should be in female prisons, male-bodies girl guide leaders allowed to supervise the girls changing room etc. It’s part of a political campaign to abolish women’s rights.

It doesn’t even make sense. Say Danny is a biological male who grew up with male privilege and never had a period or pregnancy and has male height and male body strength but now identifies as female. He sends me a work email and signs off “she/her.” When I reply to Danny, do I call him “him”, or “her”? Neither, I call Danny “you” because I am writing to Danny. So zero need for any pronoun confusion.

Or, is Danny worried that I might use the wrong pronoun in a conversation with a third person about Danny? Well (a) Danny can keep his nose out of my private conversations, (b) Danny’s email signature is not going to change what I say about him in private conversations, and (c) when I talk about Danny it isn’t the pronouns I’m using that he should most worry about.

Brilliant Grin
ecceromani · 20/01/2022 23:20

@OfstedOffred

I also don't get why you need to know someone's gender to work with them.

It should make zero difference to your professional treatment of them.

This^

If Sam emails me I will reply Dear Sam.
I am happy to engage with them whatever gender they are. I don't need to know in a workplace, it's not relevant to our ability to work together