Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the e-mail sign off with pronoun's?

388 replies

hehimshehertheythem · 20/01/2022 22:21

He/him and she/her at the end of an email. Margaret I know you're a woman and Jeff I know you're a man. Why are you teaching me to suck eggs. I don't get it?

I have not once never see a they/them as a sign off, so what is the actual point?

I for one will not be taking part in this madness. But would like to understand the thought behind the people that do? If there is any thought that is.

OP posts:
foxgoosefinch · 21/01/2022 01:34

[quote Ivyonafence]@foxgoosefinch

The lack of self awareness in your comment is incredible.

One of the reasons people don't feel 'comfortable' and 'confident' in asserting themselves is the resistance and pushback that is clear as day in this very thread.
[/quote]
Rubbish. I’ve spent twenty years lecturing and researching on sexuality, gender and the history of psychology and psychoanalysis, amongst other things, and this current fad for pronouns and gender identity is not only intellectually incoherent and reactionary, but completely antithetical to progressive thought in a whole host of ways. It’s faux progressive, not actually progressive; it privileges stereotypes and gender roles above reality; it’s especially damaging to women; and it’s based, fundamentally, on play acting and make believe. And as a lesbian woman who’s spent my career trying to battle against gender stereotypes to be taken seriously, I find it deeply offensive at the idea I should be putting a simpering “she/her” on my emails just to “validate” other people’s self-esteem and confirm to a bunch of sheer nonsense that a bunch of kids have made up on the internet.

Lalliella · 21/01/2022 01:32

@DepletingDopamine

Huge generalisation alert! I’m guessing that the people that have an issue with this are cisgender.
Anyone that wants to label me with the offensive term cisgender can fuck right off. I refuse to identify as that. I’m a woman, full stop. I’m not telling anyone my pronouns either. They’re obvious, they don’t need telling.
SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 01:30

@DepletingDopamine

If Margaret and Jeff add their pronouns it displays that they are an ally and won’t assume another person’s gender. It promotes inclusivity. And no, I haven’t been on a course.
Unless you are a person whose experience with gender issues has been negative, say a woman who has been incarcerated, in which case it's not inclusive to her at all.
foxgoosefinch · 21/01/2022 01:28

By which I mean too that workplace communication is not there to affirm or validate any of your sexuality, selfhood, identity or personal self esteem, and it’s rather worrying that other people just doing their jobs is somehow being co-opted into a social service for “validating” other people’s identities. That’s evidence of some very worrying psychological projection in our current culture, and not a very healthy sense of self.

How have I managed doing my job in a university for decades without having other people affirm me as a biologically female lesbian? And me affirming their identities back? Simple - it’s no one else’s business what my “identity” is and I don’t have any business with anyone else’s when I’m just going about doing my job which isn’t anything to do with my gender.

How we have spent decades trying to prove our gender and sexuality shouldn’t impact on our professional working lives, then suddenly find we’re meant to signal it all over the bloody place I don’t know.

Ivyonafence · 21/01/2022 01:26

@foxgoosefinch

The lack of self awareness in your comment is incredible.

One of the reasons people don't feel 'comfortable' and 'confident' in asserting themselves is the resistance and pushback that is clear as day in this very thread.

foxgoosefinch · 21/01/2022 01:21

Yes, exactly this, if it helps some people feel more comfortable and confident about how they express themselves then that’s fine by me. I work at a university and many of the students have said they appreciate this approach and also use the pronouns themselves.

Shouldn’t adults, including university students, be learning how to be confident and comfortable in themselves regardless of what other people’s email signatures say?

If grown people can’t be “comfortable” without being “validated” by the exact phrasing of an email from someone else in a workplace setting, then something has gone very wrong with their selfhood and resilience in life.

Migrainesbythedozen · 21/01/2022 01:12

People need to be aware of the ramifications for women in FORCING people to use pronouns on badges/email signatures. This, is the key to us stopping this nonsense.

Migrainesbythedozen · 21/01/2022 01:11

For those whose organisation is 'forcing' (is that even legal? Might want to check with your union) them to use pronouns, please email the link that DdraigGoch posted - www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-happened-when-a-man-signed-work-emails-using-a-female-name-for-a-week_n_58c2ce53e4b054a0ea6a4066

and tell them that this is the reason you are withdrawing your pronouns. CC to your union and/or HR team.

LemonSwan · 21/01/2022 01:07

I dont get it. I wouldnt put Ms. Miss or Mrs on my email signature (which is surely more relevant to addressing in emails) so unsure why I would a pronoun which would never be used.

For example my accountants admin is called Sam. To this day after numerous years of regular emails I have absolutely no idea whether its a man or a women. Does that matter? No

GrandmasCat · 21/01/2022 01:03

My boss pressed us to add our pronouns for the sake of inclusivity. I refused point blank because if all of us used the pronoun signature we will be forcing people who are not fully transitioned to lie or to reveal their new identity long before they are ready.

I don’t have any problem with people using pronouns when they have a unisex name though, although I don’t see the point of complicating things so much when signing as Ms or Mr would have done the trick in times past.

Migrainesbythedozen · 21/01/2022 01:01

@DepletingDopamine Cisgender is actually not allowed to be used on Mumsnet, and it's a deeply offensive term. Perhaps you should be more aware and less insulting to women, and less desperate to be seen to be woke.

BayesBlues · 21/01/2022 01:01

@AnnaSW1

If my employer makes it compulsory, which I doubt it will, my preferred pronoun will read, "my name is Anna, please just make you best guess."Smile. I have never had someone use the incorrect pronoun in my whole life and so I doubt it will start happening now. I am a woman. I look like a woman and I have a woman's name.
I have a male friend called Sharon. In friend's country, it's a male or a female name. If everyone was making a best guess based on his name, he'd have a lot of explaining to do (luckily for him, he lives in his own country so only an issue when he is abroad!)
ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 21/01/2022 01:00

Goodbye Sam hello Samantha
Goodbye Joe hello Joanne.
Goodbye Lew hello Louise.
From today there'll be new games
For me to play
So good luck and goodbye Sam.

AngryApple · 21/01/2022 00:53

I find myself wishing “angry fucker/sick of your bullshit” could be an option, because I definitely identify with both of those quite often. They are 100% inclusive of everyone.

DipYourPenisInMyBeaker · 21/01/2022 00:50

*trying to find the source around legality of managing this. Scratching my head as I can’t find it, so I may be mistaken. However, it may come down to a right to privacy under human rights. I do remember reading somewhere that it can’t be and shouldn’t be mandated, as I approached it this way within my workplace as a recommendation based on updated position.

Either way this is helpful - about a recommendation, but not mandating as doesn’t drive the right behaviours
Or values.

www.thehrdirector.com/business-news/diversity-and-equality-inclusion/should-employers-mandate-the-use-of-gender-pronouns-in-the-workplace/

Dreamstate · 21/01/2022 00:44

I just use peoples names, even if in their they have their pronouns. More so ebcuae this whole gender identity and erasing the word woman has pisssd me off enough that anyone who says refer as cis/they/them etc...I just use their name.

missnevermind · 21/01/2022 00:39

Years ago when doing a refresher on office etiquette and emails I was told off for signing off with just First Name Last Name so "Sally Smith " and was told I had to put Mrs or Miss in front of it. I refused and said it was nobody's business if I were married - I did say it was years ago - so was told it would be acceptable to put Ms as they would need to know how to address me.
I still refused and said they would call me Sally or Sally Smith and it would be obvious who they were addressing. It all just seems to have gone from one end of the line to the other.

DipYourPenisInMyBeaker · 21/01/2022 00:38

Technically companies can’t mandate, it’s illegal, they shouldn’t be doing it. They can recommend and explain why it could be helpful, but within my workplace there’s no heavy pressure or anything to use them. I use them to show support, but don’t judge those who don’t.

BreadInCaptivity · 21/01/2022 00:31

Yes, exactly this, if it helps some people feel more comfortable and confident about how they express themselves then that’s fine by me. I work at a university and many of the students have said they appreciate this approach and also use the pronouns themselves.

At the expense of people who find this deeply uncomfortable???

That's also fine with you? They get to suck it up?

Why do people care so much about how people refer to them when they are not even there?

It's like saying it's ok for someone to comment out of earshot "I don't think bread is a nice person" but is ok apparently "I think [wrong pronoun] is a nice person" is offensive.

You can't control how other people perceive you. It's that simple.

You can do your best to be diligent at your job and treat everyone respectfully, but you don't get to dictate the language people use to describe you or the opinions they form about you.

University students will be poorly equipped for the workplace if they are pandered to re: the expectation that the world of work will centre their linguistic and ideological "comfort" and they are badly served by academic institutions that promote this expectation.

You're not helping those who appreciate your use of pronouns any more than the students who find it deeply concerning (who won't tell you because you are so invested in this so you'll have no idea how numerous they are).

The workplace is not a "safe space" where they can expect not to be "triggered" by everyone tiptoeing around them.

That aside, it's not about making people "comfortable". It's about allowing them to control your freedom of thought and expression. It not appropriate.

I'd rather just see sex neutral language by default. Why is that so difficult?

MagnoliaMcLadyDeek · 21/01/2022 00:29

Someone at my work signs of with:

Her female name in large swirly font
Mrs Normal Font (She/Her)
Bossy Person Bossing Everyone job title in larger font and bold
Various departmental address/phone etc

Do we really need pronouns when one has already used Mrs?
What a load of crap that is.

SirVixofVixHall · 21/01/2022 00:27

@MaxNormal

I think being coerced into using them at work is akin to religious coercion.
I agree.
IamAporcupine · 21/01/2022 00:27

@AuntyBumBum

Some people also include a couple of lines saying which third-person pronouns they would like you to use to refer to them when they're not there. He/him, she/her etc. It's most important for people who's "gender identity" does not correspond to how most people would label them - eg trans men or women.

Transmen/women who what to be 'read/seen' as the opposite sex, surely chose names that are commonly used by men/women, respectively. So no need of pronouns there.

So far all the people I have seen adding pronouns to sinatures (by choice) were she/her Hmm.

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 00:21

I don't have a gender-neutral name, but have still had the odd call asking for Mr BashStreetKid. I'm not offended, in some contexts it can be very useful to wrong-foot the caller by saying "That's Ms BashStreetKid actually, how can I help you?"

FannyCann · 21/01/2022 00:20

And @Myamoth

FannyCann · 21/01/2022 00:19

As per anecdotal evidence of @dolorsit