Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the e-mail sign off with pronoun's?

388 replies

hehimshehertheythem · 20/01/2022 22:21

He/him and she/her at the end of an email. Margaret I know you're a woman and Jeff I know you're a man. Why are you teaching me to suck eggs. I don't get it?

I have not once never see a they/them as a sign off, so what is the actual point?

I for one will not be taking part in this madness. But would like to understand the thought behind the people that do? If there is any thought that is.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FannyCann · 24/01/2022 10:26

Hear hear @tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/01/2022 09:50

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?

/// I think for the person who screeches to insist we use their pronouns this is indeed true. Apart from the many reasons why, (unless I cave into having to use them because I feel under pressure and haven't the head space that day to handle the bullshit fallout of non compliance) detailed in this thread and many others for why I have a problem with pronouns, there is also this peripheral reason -

If I work with you I hope we can collaborate together to get Our Job Done. That's all work relationships are to me. With a few exceptions of colleagues who have become friends over the years I have no desire to know much more about you at all, I don't care how you identify, it's all good. But we're here to do a job. I don't need to see inside your soul to do that. Any further fuss or discussion is a distraction and bordering on attention seeking behaviour. And I say that as mum to a teenage DD Grin

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/01/2022 09:35

Aside to the equality argument, you also feel that people who identify as a different gender are delusional (not sure what you feel about people who are religious…)

Why would they necessarily feel any different? Both are faith based beliefs.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/01/2022 09:31

Do you know how hard it must be for someone who has transitioned to then be completely disregarded by people like you completely dismissing who they are? That’s not an ideology.

I don't believe in "transitioning" or any part of gender identity ideology. People cannot change sex. Sex matters. You are the sex you were born and playing along with the idea that you aren't has a negative impact for women and girls. So yes it is an ideology.

Enough4me · 24/01/2022 00:17

@DipYourPenisInMyBeaker 'women' isn't an outfit to put on, it's adult human females. Dave can call himself Danielle, can wear whatever he likes, undertake plastic surgery, can write the pronoun 'she', but Danielle is male and other males must enable him to use male loos.

What do you think happens to women when men use their spaces ? (Knowing that transwomen commit sexually motivated crimes at the same rate as men?)

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 23/01/2022 10:05

@Theeyeballsinthesky

Using pronouns you support an ideology that says men magically become women because they say they are Abd that the Category women is therefore meaningless

Say you did thibk you were being treated differently because you were a woman - how could you possibly prove it when Danielle next to you (born dave, presents male, pronouns she/her) never gets treated differently- after all they’re a woman right? They said they were

Exactly but the only important thing here is being compassionate and supportive to Dave/ Danielle. It speaks volumes about how much compassion and support some people think women are due.
Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/01/2022 09:52

Using pronouns you support an ideology that says men magically become women because they say they are Abd that the Category women is therefore meaningless

Say you did thibk you were being treated differently because you were a woman - how could you possibly prove it when Danielle next to you (born dave, presents male, pronouns she/her) never gets treated differently- after all they’re a woman right? They said they were

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 23/01/2022 09:48

@DipYourPenisInMyBeaker
You are making the mistake of thinking that only one 'side' of this toxic debate could ever need support. I am terrified of the gender ideology and the impact it is having on my, my children and all women. Yet you think that only people who identify as a different gender deserve support and compassion. Why?

DipYourPenisInMyBeaker · 23/01/2022 07:57

@Migrainesbythedozen

For me, the actual truth is, not the one you think is true (you know the suggestion I am naive, being laughed at by the community I support, made to do it and disempowered by men (earlier poster), is my friends and colleagues who have transitioned or identify as a gender different to which they were born want to be recognised as the gender they are today - I understand this is a difficult concept especially where some people have not yet transitioned or decided not - which I believe is the issue most posters are referring to.

You don’t agree that that where people identify as a different gender that others within life or the workplace should support them in feeling accepted by using their preferred pronouns when speaking to them to another person or creating an environment they feel able to be themselves by adding pronouns.

Aside to the equality argument, you also feel that people who identify as a different gender are delusional (not sure what you feel about people who are religious…)

Do you know how hard it must be for someone who has transitioned to then be completely disregarded by people like you completely dismissing who they are? That’s not an ideology.

And yes it does matter what people refer to them as when they’re not there. If you keep referring to Linda as Mike, Linda will never feel accepted and won’t be able to be herself. It’s privileged posters who say well I just go to work and never worn a mask. For people in the LGBT+ community who identify as a different gender, by not having environments where they can be themselves they may never take that mask off. For some the workplace is the only place they can be themselves.

For a lot of posters on here, I really do hope that should a loved one share with you that they want to identify as a different gender that you show them some support and compassion.

mrsdaltongrant · 23/01/2022 07:31

@Migrainesbythedozen thank you, I know sexism exists. Just like I know racism exists.
I'm happy to be known as a woman and not hide in the shadows. If i have a issue with someone not responding to me in a certain way and it turns out to be because of my gender I will address it. Ive only ever had issues with people not responding because I'm not GM, MD and a simple messages from a person of that level advising them whether need to reply and all sorted. Assume all these people having issues with pronouns are giving their children all gender neutral names so it's impossible to tell either way. You know forward thinking and all that.

Migrainesbythedozen · 23/01/2022 07:16

@mrsdaltongrant

Strange thread. I work for an global company many many different nationalities. In some cultures some names are unisex so if you've never spoken to the person it would be Impossible to tell (not that it matters). Some names like Lewis and Louise sound the same in certain accents so I My name which is similar and have been called Mr Grant before and therefore have added (Mrs) to my signature. Can't see a problem with it. We don't all have to start being gender neutral to be equal imo.
@mrsdaltongrant You might want to read this to see how women are disadvantaged over men in the workforce when men learn it's a woman. Anonymity works best for women in the workplace. www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-happened-when-a-man-signed-work-emails-using-a-female-name-for-a-week_n_58c2ce53e4b054a0ea6a4066
mrsdaltongrant · 23/01/2022 06:59

Strange thread. I work for an global company many many different nationalities. In some cultures some names are unisex so if you've never spoken to the person it would be Impossible to tell (not that it matters). Some names like Lewis and Louise sound the same in certain accents so I
My name which is similar and have been called Mr Grant before and therefore have added (Mrs) to my signature. Can't see a problem with it. We don't all have to start being gender neutral to be equal imo.

EishetChayil · 23/01/2022 06:32

I know someone who put "we/us" for their pronouns as a form of protest, resulting in someone almost getting a disciplinary as it looked like he was implicating himself in misconduct that the "we/us" person had engaged in. The person was so afraid of committing the heinous crime of misgendering that he almost lost his job. Pathetic.

hugr · 23/01/2022 05:56

@FSPea

The people saying it helps them to know if the person is a man or a woman are missing the obvious point - it doesn't tell you that - if someone writes "she/her" it could just as easily be a man who thinks he's a woman, rather than an actual woman.
Then it helps to know what pronouns to use for them.
Findwen · 23/01/2022 01:30

I think whilst many make valid points against, we do live in a time where being more inclusive is desired for the business community - you are just going to have to get with the times and state your pronouns and respect others.

I hope you will respect mine.

Kind Regards,
Findwen
2nd Assistant Junior Staffer

His Holiness/My Worshipful Master

FSPea · 23/01/2022 00:45

The people saying it helps them to know if the person is a man or a woman are missing the obvious point - it doesn't tell you that - if someone writes "she/her" it could just as easily be a man who thinks he's a woman, rather than an actual woman.

Ionlydomassiveones · 23/01/2022 00:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Migrainesbythedozen · 22/01/2022 21:57

[quote DipYourPenisInMyBeaker]@hehimshehertheythem

To show support to who? My colleagues and friends who identify as a different gender or genders (or none) and want to be recognised as such. It’s respectful.

Your company that asked you to do it? Nobody asked me to do it. My company didn’t ask me to do it. I have my own mind and it was my decision based on what I know and who I associate with.

The male dominated world that you are an agreeable female? Really?! 🥱

Who are we supporting? Please refer to my answer to your first question.

I think pronouns are good for so many reasons. My post was about it being wrong to mandate it, should be voluntarily. It’s so clear when companies or people are disingenuous with why they do things / probably why we end up with threads like these where people get their knickers in a twist!

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?[/quote]
@DipYourPenisInMyBeaker To show support to who? My colleagues and friends who identify as a different gender or genders (or none) and want to be recognised as such. It’s respectful.

You're naive if you think they appreciate it. I guarantee you that they laugh at you behind your back that you are so easy to brainwash and so naive.

I think pronouns are good for so many reasons.

Really? Name just one (1) other reason other than 'it shows support (it doesn't)'? Have you not read the links that show there is NO good reason, indeed that it hinders women? Have you not read those links that show it sets women back and penalises them? It's a backward step for equality of the sexes and only hurts and hinders, there is no upside.

And for completeness, the use of pronouns is not about sexuality or sexual orientation, it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself.

You don't get it. The point is gender 'identity' has absolutely no place in the workplace. We go to work. No to talk about our 'identity'. Gender identity has absolutely no place in the workforce.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 22/01/2022 20:36

@PiggieWiggie

I think so it's easier for colleagues who want to change their pronouns. I guess it's just being an ally for people who might be struggling and need a little support.
What about all the people who are scared of gender ideology and are therefore struggling and needing support. How are you judging who is and who is not worthy of your support?
VelvetChairGirl · 22/01/2022 09:09

I hate the word ally its so charged with ideology now, its so stonewall, it reminds of something like children of the corn or invasion of the body snatchers, like theres this sinister group urging you to be one of us, one of us, one of us, one of us.

its so cringe and such unnatural language, ally, assigned at birth, cis etc if they really dont want to be seen as a cult they should stop acting and talking like one and stop bullying and using coercion.

334bu · 21/01/2022 23:31

.* I guess it's just being an ally for people who might be struggling and need a little support.*

In what way are you being an ally to people who are struggling by demanding that everyone declares their pronouns? What of the person struggling with their gender identity? What of the women trying to conceal their sex to avoid harassment? Why are companies deliberately flouting the Yogyakarta Principles; principles laid down to ensure that the LGBT community does not suffer transphobia and homophobia in the workplace? Mandatory pronouns are transphobic!

PiggieWiggie · 21/01/2022 23:20

I think so it's easier for colleagues who want to change their pronouns. I guess it's just being an ally for people who might be struggling and need a little support.

Enough4me · 21/01/2022 22:22

@DipYourPenisInMyBeaker
"...it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?"

I can't look at a penis is a women's changing room and think that's it part of a woman. Why should I have to lie about what women are to please a man?

OnlyTheTitosaurusOfTheIceberg · 21/01/2022 20:05

Like a customer or a colleague will forward my email and say something like ‘I emailed Sam and he suggested I ask you…’ or ‘Sam is having trouble with this, could you help him?’ Yes, it’s technically possible to send those emails and avoid pronouns altogether but it very quickly becomes clunky and awkward to do so.

“I emailed Sam who suggested…”

“Sam is having trouble with this, could you help resolve the problem?”

Yeah, really awkward and clunky Hmm

This whole “if I do it, it makes it easier for others to do it” is absolute bollocks. It suggests that anyone wanting to have non-standard pronouns used about them must be timid little things without the clout or confidence to do it without an army of “allies” acting as a human shield against any comment it might generate.

To think that, you must have been under a rock if you haven’t noticed that policies at every level from national downwards have been changed to accommodate transpeople, and mostly to the disadvantage of women and girls. The Scottish Parliament’s definition of a woman is now “anyone who identifies as one”; rapists are transferred to women’s prisons if they claim a female gender identity; the police have arrested people, recorded ‘hate incidents’ against people, started to investigate people for the heinous crimes of tweeting photos of suffragette-colour ribbons, retweeting a limerick, raising concerns over a male-born Girl Guiding leader posting inappropriate images on social media; the census placed as much weight on self-described “gender identity” as it did to sex; schools will validate a pupil’s new ‘gender identity’ without informing the parents; one of the foremost women of colour campaigning against FGM was piled on for using the word “female” about it…and so on, and on, and on.

This is as far from the “most oppressed” narrative as it’s possible to get. Against that background I doubt Derek in Marketing needs you shoving a “she/her” in your email signature to feel emboldened to do the same.

Baystard · 21/01/2022 19:11

it’s about gender identity and asking people to see you as you see yourself. What’s so hard in that?

Because you are expecting others to affirm a belief you hold that many others don't. I don't expect someone with religious belief to require me to affirm their particular religious belief.

Swipe left for the next trending thread