Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Passengers not wearing masks on a flight, should I make a complaint?

88 replies

RopeyRuby · 20/01/2022 21:33

Flew on a long haul flight last week with a major UK airline. As far as I was aware masks are mandatory on a flight.

Two men got ion the plane and sat two rows in front of us with their masks around their neck. The flight attendant asked them to put them on but they said they were exempt Hmm which beggars the question of why they had them at all? Shortly after takeoff another man took his mask off and spent the rest of the flight standing chatting to a passenger across from us with no mask on for the rest of the flight. I was not aware of him being asked to put it back on. Meanwhile we’re struggling with keeping our masks on for 7 hours!

On the flight back yesterday, my mask slipped down my nose so it wasn’t covered when I was trying to find space for my cabin bag as the lockers were all full. I got the attention of a flight attendant to ask him where I could put my stuff but he said very patronisingly ‘put your mask on properly then I’ll answer your question’. He then walked straight past a passenger with his mask around his neck and didn’t say anything to him. There was a different flight attendant with his mask only over his mouth not his nose the whole flight!

I’ve just read about a woman being removed from a flight for refusing to wear a mask.

WIBU to make a complaint about this to the airline?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notimagain · 22/01/2022 09:06

Yes they are dicks not wearing masks and yes I would complain mainly so the AIRLINE makes it more clear rather than the individual employees having to be the only ones enforcing. And they might empower their workers to issue penalties or something

Enforce what exactly? At the risk of repeating myself in general terms the UK regs allow people to fly mask less and those that do so do not need to provide any proof of their reason for doing so….

I suspect in the last couple of years more than one cabin crew member at a UK airline has had a conversation with a passenger along the lines of:

“Sir will you please put a mask on”
“No, I have an exemption and I don’t need to show you proof”
“Err…OK”

The only justifiable complaint I can see the OP may have is the manner in which she was handled by the cabin crew member.

Onthedowns · 22/01/2022 07:37

@fmpc

The thing that really gets me about reading posts about all these 'Exempt' people, is that over the last few months, I've been travelling between 4 EU countries and I just don't see this huge number of mask wearing exemptions in any of them

The only place/nationality that I hear/read about regular exemptions from mask wearers is here on mumsnet or on UK news

What is it about UK nationals that make them more prone to mask exemptions than other countries?

Or are EU countries just full of Super Mask Wearers who are actually capable of wearing them?

Asking for a friend

So true
NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 22/01/2022 07:06

@fmpc

The thing that really gets me about reading posts about all these 'Exempt' people, is that over the last few months, I've been travelling between 4 EU countries and I just don't see this huge number of mask wearing exemptions in any of them

The only place/nationality that I hear/read about regular exemptions from mask wearers is here on mumsnet or on UK news

What is it about UK nationals that make them more prone to mask exemptions than other countries?

Or are EU countries just full of Super Mask Wearers who are actually capable of wearing them?

Asking for a friend

This! I live in the Netherlands and only come across one "exempt" person, meanwhile every time I come back to Scotland there seems to be tonnes of exempt people, weirdly enough they all appear to be heavy smokers. My GP brother told me that the exempt thing is a nonsense, the NHS do not support it at all.
takemetomars · 21/01/2022 21:38

@Ickle37

I am a fully mask wearing advocate. However if mask wearing and washing your hands every 10 minutes worked, it would have worked. It doesn't work tbh. You were in a space where every traveller had tested negative. Dont fly if you want to police people.
Seems to have worked for me as a frontline worker
Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/01/2022 21:37

@Ickle37

I am a fully mask wearing advocate. However if mask wearing and washing your hands every 10 minutes worked, it would have worked. It doesn't work tbh. You were in a space where every traveller had tested negative. Dont fly if you want to police people.
No necessarily. My sister, husband and her 3 children recently had a holiday in Turkey. 3 children under 10. They all tested before they came back, drove straight home from the airport without stopping, did a pcr when they got home. Husband and 2 of the children tested positive
Mrbob · 21/01/2022 21:27

@Bringmeadog

You’re breathing all the recycled air for hours….. masks will make zero difference. It’s just for appearances.
It’s filtered. This is why people should understand the basics this long into a pandemic because they might actually get why rules exist

Yes they are dicks not wearing masks and yes I would complain mainly so the AIRLINE makes it more clear rather than the individual employees having to be the only ones enforcing. And they might empower their workers to issue penalties or something

This kind of mask bullshit gives me the rage. We also don’t have exemptions here interestingly. And yes I know a number of people with breathing difficulties etc who still manage to go to the shops in a mask. If they are in hospital and acutely unwell and short of breath a few remove them but that’s a different matter

lljkk · 21/01/2022 21:21

What was the basis of OP's complaint?

About the 2 guys who didn't wear masks --
About the flight attendant who told her to wear mask --
That flight attendant's tone was rude? --
That the rules shouldn't exist if they aren't enforced perfectly --
That she wasn't a lucky soul on flight 38 that got turned around (I was on that same service 3 weeks ago, I would have felt nuclear towards the mask shunning passenger!!)

I'm voting YABVU since I think OP just wants to complain, about anything will do.

Pinkrose1111 · 21/01/2022 20:57

I'm sorry but if they're exempt. Then they're exempt. You don't know what their medical history is like and it's none of your business. If you're uncomfortable with it then just don't fly. You're all sharing the same recycled air anyway.

notimagain · 21/01/2022 19:49

@TheHoptimist

There is no government exemption list- so BAs statement is pointless.
Is it the terminology you are concerned about rather than the substance?

Whatever you call it the link BA provide leads to this Government website:

www.gov.uk/government/publications/face-coverings-when-to-wear-one-and-how-to-make-your-own

Quite a lot of detail from the government there beyond details of mask making…including details/examples of situations in which people may not be able to wear face coverings and also the subject of exemptions….

TheHoptimist · 21/01/2022 18:33

There is no government exemption list- so BAs statement is pointless.

notimagain · 21/01/2022 18:30

@RopeyRuby

It was a BA flight. I didn’t even think you could claim an ‘exemption’ on a flight. I understood it as wear a mask or don’t fly.

To some extent it is route dependent and there are exemptions in certain circumstances….long story short people can quite legitimately be flying without masks.

www.britishairways.com/en-fr/information/the-ba-experience/welcome-onboard-faqs#mask

“ When you travel with us, you will need to wear a face mask at all times, in the airport and on board, unless you qualify for the government exemption list.”

TBH I think it’s unlikely you’ll get any traction with the airline with regard to the issue other passengers not wearing masks, whether you will get any response to any complaint about the cabin crew member’s behavior you’ll have to wait and see.

Topseyt · 21/01/2022 17:41

@XenoBitch

Surely everyone on the flight would have had PCRs done before boarding anyway. Can't spread Covid if you don't have it.
It wasn't required when we flew to Malta last October. Not on the outbound flight or the return one.

We did have to complete Passenger Locator Forms and do a day 2 PCR test after returning. Vaccination certificates were also required.

TheHoptimist · 21/01/2022 17:38

@VelvetChairGirl

to those saying if they were wearing masks they cant be exempt.

my son wears a mask on public transport and in shops, but he is exempt in school and has a lanyard to prove his exemption, its fine in school because they know so no ones going to bother him about it and theres a big difference between sitting on the tube for 10 mins and being in a school for 7 hours.

Same here

My OH has throat cancer
He cant wear a mask for 14 hours on a plane/ through an airport as he doesnt make saliva and he has a rather large lump

He can wear one for short periods such as moving through an airport. He tries very hard to wear a mask for everyday stuff such as popping into the corner shop or seeing the consultant but cant sustain a mask on a flight as it is a very dry atmosphere.

Should he be denied flying?

Giraffesandbottoms · 21/01/2022 17:31

Also how can you not have noticed your mask slipped down? It feels very hypocritical to complain about these men but then say you weren’t wearing your mask properly but you shouldn’t have been in trouble for that?! Mouth maskers are the most irritating of all. Wear one or don’t wear one, but it’s so stupid keeping your chin warm.

Giraffesandbottoms · 21/01/2022 17:29

You can claim an exemption on a flight, yes. I had hyperemesis gravidarum and a note from a doctor. I had to travel for a funeral but I really, really could not sit with a mask on my face as it exacerbated my symptoms. The air stewards were fine with it as a I had a medical note. I got some looks from passengers and it infuriated me - it’s not for other people to police this shit. For what it’s worth, I did still have a mask because I tried to wear it where possible but when it became too much I took it off. So these men having a mask doesn’t mean much/mean they weren’t exempt.

GreenWheat · 21/01/2022 17:24

The moment has passed. The time to complain was during the flight, to the flight attendant concerned. What do you expect them to do about it now?

RopeyRuby · 21/01/2022 17:18

And yes, wearing a mask protects others from your exhalations not you from theirs!

OP posts:
RopeyRuby · 21/01/2022 17:17

It was a BA flight.

I didn’t even think you could claim an ‘exemption’ on a flight. I understood it as wear a mask or don’t fly. I wasn’t scared of getting Covid either. I’ve had it.

It was more the enforcing rules for some but not for others and being rude with it. I have complained. The fact both flights were delayed and we had to wait in the airport for almost 8 hours in our masks (in addition to the flight) on the way back made it even worse. I didn’t notice anyone in the airport without a mask on. We were in the US and they were constantly saying over the tannoy that you MUST keep your mask on.

Let’s see what they say.

OP posts:
user1471447863 · 21/01/2022 16:55

@Isaw3ships

By wearing YOUR mask you were protecting yourself - by not wearing theirs they were putting themselves more at risk. Also - why complain so far after the factX did it loss you off that much? Move on…
Really? Nearly 2 years in and you are still getting it the wrong way round? Are you doing it deliberately or are you incredibly hard of thinking?

Mask wearing protects others from you more than it protects you from others. Wearing one is a courtesy to others and works best when everyone participates.

notimagain · 21/01/2022 13:47

Plan B is I assume a UK “thing”, so I doubt the turn back would have happened on a UK registered flight, simply because everybody seems to have the “exemption” get out.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/01/2022 13:42

I would certainly expect the company/FA to back up the captain’s decision

So would I, but considering the diversity of views over masks, the money airlines have already lost through Covid and the ever changing rules, I'd be surprised if there wasn't some pushback - especially if this keeps happening when the "Plan B" restrictions end

notimagain · 21/01/2022 13:34

Just for info this is the rule the US based crew would have been trying to enforce:

“ U.S. federal law requires that you wear a face covering at all times while indoors at the airport and on board your flight, regardless of vaccination status. If you refuse to wear one, you may be denied boarding and future travel on American. You may also face penalties under federal law.”

There are some exemptions, but if you want to claim exemption you need to give the airline 72 hours notice….rocking up on the day and claiming exemption won’t work…

www.aa.com/i18n/travel-info/coronavirus-updates.jsp

notimagain · 21/01/2022 13:27

The OP claims they were on a UK airline, the turn back case that has been in the news was a US one with a very different rule set, especially when it comes to exemptions from mask wearing.

The Flight attendants on the US flight would have been required to operate iaw with FAA rules and would have been required/expected by many passengers to enforce those rules…

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 13:04

@notimagain and yet somehow the flight the OP was on didn’t descend into some riot between anti maskers and those wearing masks…

notimagain · 21/01/2022 12:53

@Isaw3ships

Personally I’d rather the plane kept on going and I wore my mask and washed my hands etc than have the flight diverted because one or two people out of the hundreds onboard didn’t wear masks for the journey.
Problem with that approach that some people who initially were wearing masks reluctantly. start to notice the mask rules aren’t being enforced…so don’t bother either…There’s then a danger of the situation degenerating especially if everybody thinks they know their rights….

There’s a potential for it getting very ugly and you maybe end up diverting to somewhere you’d rather not go.

Easiest answer, especially v early in a flight is to return to the start point and let authorities on the ground sort it out.