Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If we have to vote this year or the next, women who will not vote Labour due to the GRA raise your hand

670 replies

TerraNovaTwo · 20/01/2022 20:54

As above

OP posts:
MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor · 21/01/2022 17:58

@Theeyeballsinthesky

Wait wait I need to get my bingo card!

We can tick them off together Grin

HaroldMeeker · 21/01/2022 17:57

@MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor

Imagine being so filled with hate you drag the rest of the country down with you

Another one from the TRA cheat sheet.

Oooo ooooh Ooooooh I know this one!!!

WE'RE TALKING ABOUT WOMEN'S RIGHTS

And as for the laughable attempt at emotional manipulation, you lot have went too far....we don't CARE any more about the finger pointing and name calling and attempts to shame us into "being kind" and allowing our rights to be trampled on. Go ahead. Call me terf.

Terf has now self ID'd as a new acronym, didn't you know. Tired of Explaining Reality to Feckwits.

Consider yourself educated.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 21/01/2022 17:57

Wait wait I need to get my bingo card!

GrolliffetheDragon · 21/01/2022 17:55

I sympathize with people feeling this way, but from my pov there is nobody else to vote for and I can't help the Tories - though I'm fairly sure our year of a Tory MP will get voted in again. Can't stand the man for a number of reasons, so even if he's willing to say he knows what a woman is, that doesn't outweigh his stance on just about every other important issue. I've checked his voting record, we disagree on pretty much all of them.

MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor · 21/01/2022 17:46

Imagine being so filled with hate you drag the rest of the country down with you

Another one from the TRA cheat sheet.

Skeumorph · 21/01/2022 17:44

Me. And I'm a party member!!!!

I can't see how they can come back to a point where I feel safe voting for them tbh. It's as much the willingness to kowtow tbh, I doubt many of them believe what they're parrotting for a moment.

TearifficTaz · 21/01/2022 17:44

This site really has gone to the pits

Imagine being so filled with hate you drag the rest of the country down with you

delurkasaurus · 21/01/2022 17:43

*Every politician invited on MN for any party has run a mile from any questions on this issue

They don’t want to answer the question because you know deep down none of them really believe men can become women either and they know exactly which sex gives birth & which doesn’t*

True. Doesn't mean MN can't ask again though.

MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor · 21/01/2022 17:40

@Goldshelfie

I was a labour member and quit over this issue, there is no way they will get my vote if they carry on like this. I am really pissed off that all left wing parties are pro self id, I have always been on the left and I'm at a loss now.

The realisation that women's rights matter so little to so many people in power has been quite sobering and depressing.

Same. Labour have really let women down. They won't get my vote again.
JanuaryBluehoo · 21/01/2022 17:39

Op, many people don't know what gra is.
You shouldn't assume people know.

But I won't be voting Labour because of this.

Goldshelfie · 21/01/2022 17:39

I was a labour member and quit over this issue, there is no way they will get my vote if they carry on like this. I am really pissed off that all left wing parties are pro self id, I have always been on the left and I'm at a loss now.

The realisation that women's rights matter so little to so many people in power has been quite sobering and depressing.

MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor · 21/01/2022 17:39

@senua

you just can't bear the idea that trans people exist? You are misunderstanding (and misrepresenting) us. Have you not bothered to read the thread?
Straight from the TRA prompt sheet. Deliberately don't bother to read what is actually said. Replace considered responses with tropes such as you don't want tran people to exist. Or bigot. Really it's not even worth debating with responses like this. They're not here to learn anything new. They're here for one purpose only.
ScreamingMeMe · 21/01/2022 17:37

I wouldn't trust them to answer honestly either.

iguanadonna · 21/01/2022 17:37

Left the party because not allowed to say that the female sex exists. Obliged to pretend that humans can change sex. That humans don't have two distinct reproductive sexes.

No-one else to vote for, though. And some excellent feminist Labour MPs.

But fundamentally not a party that accepts female leadership - or even female existence.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 21/01/2022 17:33

@crosstalk

Can Mumsnet (without stepping out of their apolitical stance) not ask all political parties what their stances are?

Or answer mediated questions on a live feed?

I agree that there are more urgent and immediate issues - housing, increased cost of living, homelesssness, NHS, schooling, environment including water companies polluting our rivers and sea.

HOWEVER GRA is a major long term consequence. What gives if one party puts more money into women's refuges, rape crisis centres, prisons and the NHS, if women have to tolerate policies that mean they will come across TW or men self IDing as women?

Every politician invited on MN for any party has run a mile from any questions on this issue

They don’t want to answer the question because you know deep down none of them really believe men can become women either and they know exactly which sex gives birth & which doesn’t

Theeyeballsinthesky · 21/01/2022 17:30

Ah mr/ms/mx “you just can’t beat that trans people exist” has arrived. Come in we were expecting you!

Now can you explain how it benefits women tk open up their single sex spaces to men?

delurkasaurus · 21/01/2022 17:21

*pay GAP reporting

senua · 21/01/2022 17:20

you just can't bear the idea that trans people exist?
You are misunderstanding (and misrepresenting) us. Have you not bothered to read the thread?

delurkasaurus · 21/01/2022 17:19

@crosstalk

Can Mumsnet (without stepping out of their apolitical stance) not ask all political parties what their stances are?

Or answer mediated questions on a live feed?

I agree that there are more urgent and immediate issues - housing, increased cost of living, homelesssness, NHS, schooling, environment including water companies polluting our rivers and sea.

HOWEVER GRA is a major long term consequence. What gives if one party puts more money into women's refuges, rape crisis centres, prisons and the NHS, if women have to tolerate policies that mean they will come across TW or men self IDing as women?

This would be a good idea. They could also ask if any of the parties supports post-legislative scrutiny of the GRA.

I don't agree self-ID is a single issue. It impacts almost every area of all our lives.

  1. Toilets - thereby impacting our participation in public life
  2. Changing rooms - impacting our fitness. Bone strength is important for women so access to being fit is important to us
  3. Schools - single sex, sports in schools, trips away etc
  4. Employment law - if men can self-ID as women then pay gay reporting becomes a skewed nonsense
  5. Service provision. You need to know how many women of what age live in your area so you can plan maternity care, cancer care etc. Target campaigns at them to get help early. Provide breastfeeding groups FOR WOMEN
  6. Refuges
  7. Rape counselling and evidence collection
  8. Who does gynaecological services for you
  9. Who does your intimate care, who does it for your elderly mum and dad
10. What we tell children about their bodies. Facts. Facts matter if children are abused but they can't name body parts, will a case progress to court? 11. (cont from 10) If not then that also impacts justice and lets predators walk free 12. Groups that girls used to be able to go to, for girls only, are becoming mixed sex by stealth. 13. Crime stats are a mess and unreliable. So we now seem to have a situation with an "increase" in female sex offending. But do we? Or do we have crap data and we don't know what the real position is because of self-ID by stealth? 14. Evidence given in court. If compelled to use female terminology for the male who raped you, how good is your evidence going to be under what are already incredibly pressing circumstances? 15. Impact on female police officers and prison officers compelled to search male bodies. Are they not put at risk by self-ID? 16. Impact on young lesbians and gay males of being fed by social media, narratives about their bodies and themselves that make them think they're trans. We have emerging evidence of detransitioners which is devastating to read.

I'm sure that's not an exhaustive list but I'd like to understand parties' views on what they think will and will not change under self-ID and the above.

EeeICouldRipATissue · 21/01/2022 17:19

@entropynow

Translation: how many of you will allow the Tory party to fuck over the entire country once again because you just can't bear the idea that trans people exist?

WHY does MN allow this tripe?

Yep, that's about the crux of it!
Shambolicatthleast · 21/01/2022 17:18

Love @MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor 's certainty. How do you know they are worse or 'unviable'. The tories
aren't looking so morally viable either.
How come 40 years ago the electorate were quite happy to punish an incompetent administration, hence Major, Heath all lost GEs ? What has happened to us as a nation ? It's just rewarding immorality.

entropynow · 21/01/2022 17:17

Translation: how many of you will allow the Tory party to fuck over the entire country once again because you just can't bear the idea that trans people exist?

WHY does MN allow this tripe?

ScreamingMeMe · 21/01/2022 17:12

Well that should surely include a party that votes against misogyny being defined as a hate crime.

As you've mentioned this 3 times now*...

Yes, we know

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4456705-Lords-Misogyny-Amendment

Dominic Raab thinks men can be victims of misogyny

Many Labour MPs think men can be women. What's the difference?

crosstalk · 21/01/2022 16:46

Can Mumsnet (without stepping out of their apolitical stance) not ask all political parties what their stances are?

Or answer mediated questions on a live feed?

I agree that there are more urgent and immediate issues - housing, increased cost of living, homelesssness, NHS, schooling, environment including water companies polluting our rivers and sea.

HOWEVER GRA is a major long term consequence. What gives if one party puts more money into women's refuges, rape crisis centres, prisons and the NHS, if women have to tolerate policies that mean they will come across TW or men self IDing as women?

MrBlobbyLivesNextDoor · 21/01/2022 16:44

@DottyDoge

How many, exactly, are needed before it becomes a problem? 5? 50? 100? For me, personally, one woman being forced away from support aimed at females because a male's feelings trumps her trauma is too many. How many do you need?

One woman feeling uncomfortable at a rape therapy session hosted by a charity is a bad thing. But I'd need more than that to convince me that women's services were now "unusable", or that the Labour Party represented such a threat to Women's Rights.

Most women would feel uncomfortable discussing their trauma from male violence and sexual assault, in front of men. Men have no place in these groups set up for women. And seeing as the labour party don't know what a woman is, the problem would get far worse, not better. Not that anyone needs to convince you anyway. Enough people know the erosion of women's rights and safeguards is wrong. And labour won't be getting in for a long long time. The Tory party may be crap. But labour is far worse. It's not a viable alternative. And that will be reflected in how people vote.