Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If we have to vote this year or the next, women who will not vote Labour due to the GRA raise your hand

670 replies

TerraNovaTwo · 20/01/2022 20:54

As above

OP posts:
AssignedNorthern · 21/01/2022 09:27

Here!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/01/2022 09:24

So that’s it’s not a “two horse race” with people put in this position of political homelessness I mean.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/01/2022 09:23

What we needed was to change the voting system when we had the chance a few years back. Ironically, that was the referendum in which working people could have re-enfranchised themselves a lot more!

eldora · 21/01/2022 09:22

@YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators

But don't just abstain if that's what you're doing, let them know why. When I left, I made it really clear why, and during each subsequent "So can you tell us why you cancelled your membership?"-call, I patiently explained myself and asked the caller to make a note of it and to paraphrase back to me what I had said. They all (4 canvassers in total) had a really good grasp of the issue and even sounded a teensy bit apologetic.
What did you say? Maybe we can use it on our emails to MPs?
Blackbird1234 · 21/01/2022 09:21

I haven't read the entire thread but I'm up to page 6 and have a question. I have never voted for anything, not because I don't want to but because I moved to a new country when I was a child and by the time I was of voting age in the UK, I was no longer eligible having lived outside of the country for more than 10 years and dont have the nationality (yet) of the country I live in now, so can't vote here either.

I've always been told that spoiling your ballot is one of the worst things you can do when voting and is a sign of massive privilege, just to prove a point that won't be proven. But some posters on this thread are saying they've spoilt it/will spoil it. Can anyone explain to me why they've done that/will do that, and what they hope it achieves, please?

senua · 21/01/2022 09:16

what exactly are you against?
Self ID. If anybody can identify as a woman then the word becomes meaningless and therefore the concept of women's rights becomes meaningless.

Alexandra2001 · 21/01/2022 09:06

@Alekto

In Labour's 2019 manifesto they committed to introduce self id:

"Labour is committed to reforming the Gender Recognition Act 2004 to introduce self-declaration for transgender people"

p.68 labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Real-Change-Labour-Manifesto-2019.pdf

Have those posters who claim we don't know Labour's policy read the manifesto or are they only here to cast aspersions?

err that was under Corbyn, the new policy has yet to be announced for the next GE... But i just read pg 68... what exactly are you against? Maybe the paragraph that commits Labour to protect LGBT+ from violence and persecution?

Here is what the Tory LGBT+ chair says... "Bunbury said: “Trans people’s rights that exist is not a topic up for discussion. If you feel disenfranchised or distant from the trans community … if you’ve forgotten the struggle that we ourselves felt, campaigning for equality, then truly that’s a shame. But it’s your choice. If you wish to ignore our shared struggle then that is on you.

“Trans people are not dangerous, they’re not scary, and they’re certainly not a threat to women and children – although the other event titles [at the conference] might think they are.”

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 21/01/2022 09:06

Yep I'll be voting Labour

deliciouschilli · 21/01/2022 09:02

Won't vote for any party that believes I don't have the right to exist.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 21/01/2022 09:01

I will vote tactically to get the Tories out. Every time.

DottyDoge · 21/01/2022 09:00

You're not "100% GC", are you because you're trying to minimise what women here are concerned about.

I'm distinguishing my GC belief (I don't think you can change sex, gender is a load of bollocks) from what many perceive to be the catastrophic implications of trans rights. So, yes, I'm 100% gender critical.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 08:57

I say that as someone who is 100% GC.

You're not "100% GC", are you because you're trying to minimise what women here are concerned about. Everyone has a line in the sand. It sounds like you don't understand why so many women feel betrayed by Labour.

Roseandgeranium · 21/01/2022 08:55

Ditched my Lib Dem membership over this.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 08:55

I imagine the self ID issue is more of a focus on here than in wider society, and in wider life people will make their voting choice in a more nuanced way.

Maybe so, but that wasn't the point being made. Women have been concerned about this issue in relation to the Labour Party since 2018 and Lily Madigan etc.

ilovesooty · 21/01/2022 08:52

[quote senua]The timing of this thread is so suspicious.
No it isn't. The feminism board have been going on about it for years. Here's a random example from Feb 2020 www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3820422--ExpelMe-trending[/quote]
I imagine the self ID issue is more of a focus on here than in wider society, and in wider life people will make their voting choice in a more nuanced way.

3peassuit · 21/01/2022 08:52

I’m a lifelong Labour voter and former party member. I spoilt my vote in the last election and will most likely do the same at the next. I will not vote for a party who seem hell bent to eradicate sex distinction.

DottyDoge · 21/01/2022 08:52

I'll be honest and say I find this stance really disheartening - it comes across petulant, short-sighted, hyperbolic and juvenile and does little to dispel the idea that the most extreme GC feminists care little about the lives of women, and I say that as someone who is 100% GC.

Broadly speaking, most parties are somewhat split on the issue. It was the Tories who put forward the proposed changes to the GRA. Most of the ire pointed at Labour is due to a few MPs who have muttered something about TWAW - I'm sure if you put some Tories under the spot, a lot would say something vaguely pro-trans rights.

I'm also of the view that the debate on trans-rights and the threats are exaggerated. The vast majority people know that women give birth, but as the same time, they want to be tolerant to people who want to transition. There are some horrible cases of women being attacked in prison by transwomen, but they're dwarfed by the numbers attacked by men in their homes or in the streets.

It honestly angers me that while I think this is an important issue, it seems to override everything to the detriment of policies that will actually improve the lives of women.

LurkerDelurking · 21/01/2022 08:47

mobile.twitter.com/pinknews/status/1402586773499244549

Direct from his own mouth, committed to supporting Self ID.

senua · 21/01/2022 08:44

The timing of this thread is so suspicious.
No it isn't. The feminism board have been going on about it for years. Here's a random example from Feb 2020 www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3820422--ExpelMe-trending

Alekto · 21/01/2022 08:40

In Labour's 2019 manifesto they committed to introduce self id:

"Labour is committed to reforming the Gender Recognition Act 2004 to introduce self-declaration for transgender people"

p.68 labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Real-Change-Labour-Manifesto-2019.pdf

Have those posters who claim we don't know Labour's policy read the manifesto or are they only here to cast aspersions?

HaroldMeeker · 21/01/2022 08:33

@Waitwhat23

And up here in Scotland, it's the left wing parties who are determinedly destroying women's rights. The likelihood of the Tories ever getting any kind of foothold here is slim to none. But yet, women's rights are being destroyed.
Precisely. The snp are twaw and those of us who find we don't like our right to single sexed spaces being stripped from us are, to quote Mhairi Black, "Jeremy Hunts".
HailAdrian · 21/01/2022 08:29

I think pp have asked but I can't see any answers, what are their actual POLICIES re gender identity and trans people?

Alexandra2001 · 21/01/2022 08:23

@Shambolicatthleast Yes agree, people seem to be just jumping on a band wagon, with no actually evidence of what Labours official position is or how Labour policy is decided.

Having a fixed position on how you will vote 2 or 3 years ahead of any GE is perhaps a little unwise, especially before seeing any actual policies.

ilovesooty · 21/01/2022 08:21

@Tinabn

If you vote Labour and they form the government you will have the right to protest about their policies, if you support the Conservatives by voting for them, not voting or spoiling your ballot paper you maintain a faction who don’t care what sex you are if you are not wealthy and a donor to the party, they will screw you over for their friends. Look at the bigger picture, women are suffering under this government, trying to support their families and juggle low incomes and prices rising all around them, zero hour contracts, NHS being brought to its knees BEFORE the pandemic, get them out, help everyone and then fight for women’s rights in a political forum that won’t use them as a dead cat to turn peoples attention away from the crap they are heaping on everyone.
Not forgetting that the Tories are removing the right to peaceful protest.
Shambolicatthleast · 21/01/2022 08:16

@Alexandra2001 absolutely. I put that same fact regarding the number of trans women in prisons to someone on a different thread and there was a deathly silence. I find it sad that so many have made their minds up yet labour haven't even released any actual policy details. I guess most people on here can afford to live comfortably under the tories and their economic policies.