Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If we have to vote this year or the next, women who will not vote Labour due to the GRA raise your hand

670 replies

TerraNovaTwo · 20/01/2022 20:54

As above

OP posts:
Thoosa · 21/01/2022 13:03

Or, I just see things differently and I perceive your point of view as hyperbolic. I get the rhetorical argument (if anyone can say they're a woman, than being a woman becomes meaningless), but I just don't think things will turn out the way you think. I don't see that (in the UK) women's rights are going to be curtailed in any signficant way as a result of trans-rights, I just don't see it happening.

I would genuinely like to hear your workings out. I’d love to be able to believe something optimistic on this subject.

It’s fundamental that if you cannot legally define a term, you cannot enforce anything relating to that term, surely? How do you consider that rhetoric rather than reasoning?

Thoosa · 21/01/2022 12:56

@HyggeLykke

I want to vote but like so many I currently feel politically homeless. I recently came across the SDP website, I didn't know they were still even going. I don't think there is a candidate in my area but I found their policies an interesting read re sex based rights.

TRANSGENDER & BIOLOGICAL SEX-BASED RIGHTS
The liberal pursuit of individual autonomy and desire must be balanced by the common good. Some citizens feel at odds with the physiology and social role associated with their natal sex and can suffer distress. Transgender people should be treated with dignity and respect, in keeping with their acquired gender in most situations. However, these rights must be balanced against the need of natal females for safety and sporting fairness. Biological sex is real and politically significant. This requires an absolute stance on relevant legal definitions in some domains.
POLICY PLEDGES:
Transgender individuals wishing to change their legal sex should be allowed to do so. However, we support the continued necessity for medical gatekeeping in any legal change of sex marker. We oppose proposals that would allow someone to change their legal sex by self-identification only.
We support segregation by biological sex in sport. Fair competition is not secured if male-bodied transgender athletes are permitted to compete in women’s sport and, in the case of contact sports, the risk of injury can increase significantly.
We support segregation by biological sex in prisons and women’s refuges in order to safeguard the safety and privacy of natal females. Separate prisons or prison accommodation should be provided for transgender citizens to ensure their safety and privacy.
Healthcare spending and resources for gender dysphoric individuals, including long-term psychological intervention, should be provided at sufficient levels. Physical or drug-based medical treatments for gender dysphoria should be prohibited for anyone under 18 years of age.
We support the retention of biological sex and gender identity as distinct categories in public sector data gathering such as crime statistics, poverty metrics or public health research.
We support the use of plain English for discussions of biological sex in health and reproductive care.

Yes this is where DD has joined up, and I’m considering it, (will read the whole manifesto properly before deciding), but if they don’t field a candidate here, it doesn’t solve my voting dilemma.

It’s really exercising me.

Alcoh · 21/01/2022 12:43

@DottyDoge In the same way, there are many who think it's rather fundamental to vote for the party that on balance, will do the most for women, rather than to reject that for some imagined threat to remove sex based rights.

No party can do ANYTHING for women if we don’t have a legal definition of women. That’s the point. We need to fix this first.

Blessex · 21/01/2022 12:40

@Ereshkigalangcleg it would be catastrophic.

Artichokeleaves · 21/01/2022 12:30

Me. Politically homeless, but will vote tactically to keep out candidates most damaging to women and children's safeguarding.

Waspie · 21/01/2022 12:27

Me.
I am politically homeless.

Iggly · 21/01/2022 12:25

@Theeyeballsinthesky

I guess it depends whether you see the loss of womens only refuges, women only support groups for E.g.rape or still birth, programmes designed to increase the representation of women in politics or STEM, the loss of women only sport as a significant curtailment of womens rights

If you don’t then I guess it’s not a problem

^this

I haven’t seen anything to convince me that we would be under greater risk than the Tories, simply because they’ve actually made attempts at this. So I wouldn’t put it past them. At the end of the day, the nastiest people in the Tory party have made quite frankly awful statements to give the impression that they care about sex based rights.

But these lot are just a passing fad. The Tories will revert to vaguely competent politicians and I bet GRA will be back on the cards.

This feels like a single issue which really isn’t relevant right now when people are fucking dying because they can’t afford food. And that’s because of this government.

Sadly, the position we are in is that not voting Labour is effectively handing the Tories the keys again to number 10.

I’d rather we had a better standard of living and then I’ll think about GRA. Until then, fuck the Tories. I’ll vote for whoever kicks them out of my constituency.

FourTeaFallOut · 21/01/2022 12:24

I won't vote Labour again until they give up the misogynistic gender orthodoxy.

peachescariad · 21/01/2022 12:22

Labour....absolutely never

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 21/01/2022 12:22

Me

SmashingBIouse · 21/01/2022 12:21

Although fuck knows who I'll vote for because I'd rather eat spiders than vote Tory.

SmashingBIouse · 21/01/2022 12:20

@BreadInCaptivity

I won't be voting for them on this basis and left the party because of it.
This.
Mummyoflittledragon · 21/01/2022 12:16

@MaverickSnoopy

I've spent years saying I won't vote Labour because of this. I can't vote Tories though, I'm too aghast with them. So I need to think. I may end up voting tactically against Tories. I think if Labour get in then it will have to be protests etc to protect women's spaces and identity.
🤚

We won’t be able to do this soon either. The tories are taking our right to protest away.

I am another, who cannot vote Labour and am politically homeless. I do like the sound of the SDP though!

PrawnofthePatriarchy · 21/01/2022 12:16

I've left Labour and won't be voting for the party over this issue.

HaroldMeeker · 21/01/2022 12:14

Oh for an edit function.
Menstruator
Rape, not race.

HaroldMeeker · 21/01/2022 12:13

If you're happy bring a menstruation, a birthing person, a cervix haver, talking about your race in front of members of the male sex, stripping off in a spa besides people with penises, then yes, I see why you don't have a problem with any of it.

Lucky you, never being traumatised or frightened.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 21/01/2022 12:05

I guess it depends whether you see the loss of womens only refuges, women only support groups for E.g.rape or still birth, programmes designed to increase the representation of women in politics or STEM, the loss of women only sport as a significant curtailment of womens rights

If you don’t then I guess it’s not a problem

DottyDoge · 21/01/2022 11:52

Imaginary???? Has the poster quoted had their head under a rock for the last decade. This is the biggest threat to women's rights, safety and representation for a hundred years and the quoted poster is saying it's "imaginary". You're blind.

Or, I just see things differently and I perceive your point of view as hyperbolic. I get the rhetorical argument (if anyone can say they're a woman, than being a woman becomes meaningless), but I just don't think things will turn out the way you think. I don't see that (in the UK) women's rights are going to be curtailed in any signficant way as a result of trans-rights, I just don't see it happening.

Purpletomato · 21/01/2022 11:51

I've always voted Labour but next election my vote will go to whichever party that looks most like protecting (natal) women's rights.

I've never been a single issue voter before but this time I am.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 11:50

As I said, you can judge, and so can I. Not particularly interested.

zafferana · 21/01/2022 11:50

I'd never vote Labour and they're 3rd in my area. Thing is, I can't vote Lib Dem either, for the same reason, which leaves Con.

DottyDoge · 21/01/2022 11:48

Living in a democracy is great, isn't it? I don't owe anyone my vote, and I won't vote for anyone who thinks women's necessary sex based rights are less important than the latest identity politics bandwagon.

You're absolutely right. However, what I will say is I see a perfect reflection of the purity identity politics you're bemoaning.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/01/2022 11:45

Absolutely, I also can't vote and feel incredibly frustrated by the apathy here, including the many who say they are in a very safe seat so it makes no difference!!

Telling the truth isn’t apathy

Not voting would be apathy but ive not seen many people on here saying that (i may have missed one 😀) also saying that they don’t vote

HaroldMeeker · 21/01/2022 11:42

@Ereshkigalangcleg

some imagined threat to remove sex based rights.

It's not an "imagined threat" Confused you don't seem to be particularly aware or up to date on many of these issues despite being "GC", but I respect your right to prioritise what you think is most important and I and others will do likewise. And I'm sure you'll judge me and I'll judge you. Living in a democracy is great, isn't it? I don't owe anyone my vote, and I won't vote for anyone who thinks women's necessary sex based rights are less important than the latest identity politics bandwagon. And who hung out one of their female MPs to dry to pander to mostly male misogynists in the party so much that she couldn't even attend her party conference.

No thank you.

Imaginary???? Has the poster quoted had their head under a rock for the last decade. This is the biggest threat to women's rights, safety and representation for a hundred years and the quoted poster is saying it's "imaginary". You're blind.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/01/2022 11:38

Ugh sorry about the grammar in my last paragraph. The point stands, however. I'll use my vote as I choose, and I am completely impervious to guilt tripping, and it's time Labour fans got their head around the fact that it doesn't work, and often is counterproductive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread